Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone else find 'just relax' unhelpful advice when TTC

39 replies

TTCalittlebaby · 17/09/2023 05:04

I've been TTC for a few months now and feeling so so depressed every month when I start getting my BFNs at 11, 12 dpo... Does anyone else find that "just relax" is the most unhelpful advice? Thank you, didn't think of that, I was choosing to be stressed! Did anyone conceive whilst not being "relaxed"?

(Written whilst crying at a BFN at 5am...)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Totalwasteofpaper · 18/09/2023 06:27

Curiosity101 · 17/09/2023 08:23

As a PP said, stress won't stop you conceiving.

And knowing exactly when you're ovulating/likely to ovulate will help you conceive.

So in terms of TTC "Just relax" is the most ridiculous advice.

There is a problem with the mental health aspect of putting all the effort in and then not getting the results though. It can and has caused the breakdown of people and relationships, for those people they really should have changed their approach as they lost sight of the bigger picture.

The mental health impact is probably greater of you tracked ovulation through all the methods, make all the lifestyle changes and have sex at all the right times and you still don't succeed. Cause you don't just get a BFN, you also get the disappointment of failing at all the things you did to fix the problem. The answer isn't to tell people to "Just relax" though. It needs to be more specific than that.

What if "just relax" means go with the flow and then you're always having sex significantly before, immediately after ovulation? You literally only have around 5 days per cycle where you can realistically aim to get pregnant. Of those only 3 days give a reasonable chance and the day before ovulation is actually the best day. Having said that, having sex every other day unless on your period gives almost the same chance of getting pregnant as tracking all the things (but that's not feasible for everyone and when there are additional fertility issues to consider then it muddies the water).

The point around mental health i strongly agree with.

I say this as someone who has been there... crying on the floor with a bin full of ovulation strips crying that I had "no eggs!" 🙄 I insisted on fertility testing at month 5 as I was so worked up. We never got the sperm analysis back and I didn't get to do the second blood test... as I was pregnant!
I then had an early scan as I was convinced I had a blighted ovvum 🙄🙄🙄 what?why?
the sonographer nicely told me to unclench and calm down. I Didn't at all. In fact it ramped up and I was anxious the entire pregnancy I only realised how badly now I am pregnant with no 2.

Some times science CAN be counterproductive and in the case of ovulation strips and early pregnancy tests I firmly believe this is the case for 99% women.

You say it's been "a few months" that doesn't at this point indicate actual fertility issues.

I think you should try and find techniques to calm down and stay calm... for you. Crying all Sunday night is no good for anyone.

I really recommend buying the super cheap pregnancy strips and not testing early. Also once you have establish you actually ovulate bin the strips.
It's feels good to test in the short term but long term is not great.

whatamess100 · 18/09/2023 06:23

I ttc my second for 2yrs in hindsight, i was flipping mental by the end. EVERYONE said relax and honestly, i could have smashed them all in the face!

I stopped ttc as i couldn't take it anymore, and then i found out my dirty dog stbxh was having a long-term affair, so that put an end to that. I grieved the child I'd never have, made peace with that.
I met someone else and 12 months later with one "try" i got pregnant. Currently 34 weeks. Xx

My advice would be, dont let it consume you.
track your periods so you know when your due on but dont ovualtion test. Ttc absolutely stipped me bare. I won't say relax because it will be on your mind but just try and keep an open mind and have a drink, keep the sex fun and think what will be will be!

My friend also stoped " trying" then got pregnant so i do think there is a little something in it.

roro87 · 18/09/2023 06:01

I really hated when anyone said that to me, it used to set me on edge like how the hell can I relax when all I see are pregnant people and I'm left wondering why me. But I will say that I was 22 months trying for my son and finally admitted something was wrong and went to the doctor to be referred and got pregnant that month. This time I was trying for 23m, failed ivf, multiple failed ovulation inductions. But in late June I decided I'm stopping trying for a while I'm going to focus on me, I looked up the best vitamins to deal with my thyroid and pcos, i lost weight (as no hormone injections) I gave up gluten and I walked. I did not do ovulation testing I only bd twice the whole month and I'm 9 weeks now. But that being said I had to get there on my own had someone said to me relax and do this a year ago I'd gave lost it with them. I now get the just relax and enjoy it pregnancy comments off those two people I've told which also drives me mad.

Puffinsandcreeks · 18/09/2023 05:37

"Just relax"
"Your time will come"
"Juat stop thinking about it"
Things said by people pushing out toxic positivity and are unable to empathise.

stuggling5939 · 17/09/2023 23:41

@Matildahoney we had a very similar situation. We had been trying for two years at this point and had also experienced the just relax comments. The month we were moving house I actually thought just have a month off it's too much. Well that was the month we conceived. I do think as much I hate to say it because you often can't just relax but it may have helped. My cycles are definitely effected by stress and that month I tested positive on day 28. For the previous 2 years my cycles ranged between 35 to 40 days so I must have had a shorter cycle the month I conceived.

TheBirdintheCave · 17/09/2023 18:23

@Matildahoney Yep it is hard to do. I couldn't relax at all but I still got pregnant eventually because, whilst relaxing has no effect on sperm motility, taking vitamins can help.

Noname112 · 17/09/2023 17:52

I would definitely never say it as I remember now awful it was to feel like it would never happen. I did stop testing especially early it didn’t help and made me feel so much worse. I still had hope every cycle but was easier to wait for my period to turn up than torture myself with tests in the end. I did also fall pregnant the month we had private fertility testing almost 21 months after we started trying and I do wonder if not really trying or worrying about it that cycle helped or the knowledge that there was other things we would look at/do to get us there. So I do sometimes get where it may come from. Hope it works out for you soon.

Curiosity101 · 17/09/2023 17:45

@Matildahoney it doesn't matter that it's the only thing you did differently. We have next to no influence over the vast majority of the fertility cycle. Relaxing makes no statistically significant difference to whether you will get a BFP or not.

Things that need to happen for a successful pregnancy:
Healthy egg is released and guided into the fallopian tube (hormone driven, but requires luck)
Egg is fertilised by 1 healthy sperm within the right time frame (mostly luck / timing)
The egg then develops correctly as it travels down (largely genetic)
The fertilised egg implants successfully in the correct place (again, mostly genetic and luck)
The fertilised egg continues to develop successfully (genetics/luck. Most early miscarriages are expected to be due to genetics and the embryo simply not being viable)

In practically every case where people 'relaxed' and then conceived it's correlation not causation.

You mentioned intra uterine scar tissue? Perhaps there is very little surface area that is suitable for implantation 🤷. Perhaps you'd conceived many times but the embryo had never luckily hit the right part of your lining at the right time to be able to implant. But then this time luck was on your side.

So many things have to go right to result in a pregnancy. If that wasn't true then IVF would have spectacular success rates. As it stands the only bit we have any proper control over tends to be ensuring sperm meets egg at the right time. Maybe some lifestyle changes that help regulate hormone/menstrual cycle. But there's so so much more that has to go right to result in successful conception/pregnancy.

And apologies for picking on you, it's not actually aimed at you really. Just playing devil's advocate.

KimberleyClark · 17/09/2023 13:39

As someone who never got a BFP yes it is stupid and dismissive advice.

Mummyblob · 17/09/2023 13:36

Just relax and all the other unhelpful stuff is often said because people don't know what to say.

So sorry to hear you got the BFN this month it's so hard and such a roller coaster of emotions. After a couple of years ttc we got lucky and I know I wasn't relaxed, I was still doing crazy stuff like eating pineapple cause I heard it helped ovulation and that egg white mucus stuff LOL also doing ovulation tests to know when to get into action with DH.

Hope you gey your positive soon!

Matildahoney · 17/09/2023 13:27

@TheBirdintheCave it was the only thing we did differently! We were waiting on a hycosy because I hadn't fallen pregnant & the consultant had no idea why from our results. It works for lots of people! But as I said I appreciate it's not easy to do.

jane1956 · 17/09/2023 12:52

had this back in late 70s and early 80s have to say the thing that worked and I guess made me relax was my best friend asked me to be godmother to her new baby. There is 9 months between our two boys (men now) good luck

TheBirdintheCave · 17/09/2023 12:13

@Matildahoney It's not true though 🤷🏻‍♀️ Surely it was just chance it happened that month for you as you'd been trying for a while and odds are most couples will get pregnant by two years of trying.

fairyfluf · 17/09/2023 10:39

It's also the one thing guaranteed to make me not relax. It's the same when I go for a flu jab.

MsFrost · 17/09/2023 10:39

MillenialAvocado · 17/09/2023 10:21

Very unhelpful, especially since the reason we couldn't conceive naturally was because DH had a 0% sperm count. Even after we found that out, I still had people giving advice. It's like, what part of 0% sperm count do you not understand? 🙄 All the best with your TTC journey OP - it took us years and I remember how hard it was.

Similar situation here. Also, so many people have told me stories about miracle births where people suddenly conceived naturally despite having had IVF etc and it's like... yep that's great for them isn't it, but it's not helpful for me 🙄

People really struggle with the idea that it's not going to work and seem to think you're being pessimistic when actually it's just science.

Frustrating.

MsFrost · 17/09/2023 10:35

I think 'just relax' is a pretty rubbish thing to say to anyone who is stressed in any circumstance really. Almost as bad as 'calm down'.

Matildahoney · 17/09/2023 10:33

It is, and I totally get it, we were tracking ovulation & temps for over a year, smep-ing & nothing. We were crazy busy one month, between houses, not tracking anything, and I'm now 24 weeks pregnant! I also had a negative that month at 14dpo, didn't get my bfp until 4 days after af was due! So I guess it is true, but when it's all you want you can't relax about it! Lots of people say go on holiday when you're trying!

Amotherlife · 17/09/2023 10:24

It's a long time ago that I was trying to conceive but yes, being told to 'relax' just makes it worse as you just can't when something means so much to you.

A friend of mine was into alternative medicine then and tried to suggest things I could try to help conception. I had to completely ignore those suggestions as, despite not actually believing they would have any benefit, it just stressed me out even more to consider I might not be doing all I could.

AffableApple · 17/09/2023 10:21

I too was wound up by this bollocks. But to the outside eye all the testing etc if you've never had to do it, seems crazy. People are dickheads when you sound enthused/het up up about something they've not experienced. Most of the time I think it's just something reassuring to say, though hugely inappropriate. It's meant well. I learned not to say anything in the end. Ironically that did make things a bit more relaxing 🙃 Of course you can't "relax". Carry on actually living alongside your testing, and keep up the good work. All the luck and best wishes in the world for you Xxx

MillenialAvocado · 17/09/2023 10:21

Very unhelpful, especially since the reason we couldn't conceive naturally was because DH had a 0% sperm count. Even after we found that out, I still had people giving advice. It's like, what part of 0% sperm count do you not understand? 🙄 All the best with your TTC journey OP - it took us years and I remember how hard it was.

FiddleLeaf · 17/09/2023 10:20

Hah same… it’s always people who are already parents and then you spend time trying to convince them & yourself that you’re not stressed.

Such a stupid thing to say.

BertieBotts · 17/09/2023 10:19

I agree it's silly, unhelpful advice - and likely to be counterproductive because then you're just feeling guilty that you're feeling stressed which is more stress FFS!

Stress is unlikely to have a significant effect on biology. We know it affects it a bit but it's not likely to make huge difference either way. It certainly isn't going to cause a fertility issue where there isn't one, and relaxing isn't going to fix a biological issue.

But, I do think that TTC can be a very stressful experience if you're expecting it to happen straight away, seeing every negative test as some kind of sign of failure, testing so early that you're likely to see negatives (especially if that's compounded by the above). What can help is reframing experiences - expect it to take up to about 8 months for a start, and try (I know!!) not to test too early, although some people do get positives at 11dpo, it's quite unlikely. 13dpo is really the earliest that you should be testing, but a negative is more likely (4x more likely!) than a positive every month even if you're doing everything right! So having that realistic expectation can really help.

Something that I found helpful was saying that I wouldn't test early unless I had an actual reason to, so if I wanted to drink I'd test, if I thought there were multiple symptoms I'd test, I tested early once because my mum was visiting and I wanted to tell her in person if it was positive. But other than this I tried not to.

It can also help to have little treats lined up for every month that you're not pregnant, that you'd have to cancel if you were pregnant, like something involving alcohol, fairground, hot tub, forbidden pregnancy foods, whatever. That way you have something good happening either way and it's not just crushing disappointment every time.

TheBirdintheCave · 17/09/2023 10:04

DuchyCazalet · 17/09/2023 09:50

Hate it. It implies that it's your own fault for not getting pregnant - you're stressing about it so that's why it's not happening. I had a friend who used to say it - just feels so dismissive and ignoring the fact that many people need intervention to get pregnant.
Good luck with your journey

Yes this is what annoys me the most about it. It puts all the blame on the person struggling.

Whataretheodds · 17/09/2023 09:54

"Just relax" is deeply unhelpful. But making sure that you are both taking active steps to distress regularly is important for feeling able to DTD (!and to orgasm), and to keep your sanity!

Have you looked at what you're both eating/drinking etc?

DuchyCazalet · 17/09/2023 09:50

Hate it. It implies that it's your own fault for not getting pregnant - you're stressing about it so that's why it's not happening. I had a friend who used to say it - just feels so dismissive and ignoring the fact that many people need intervention to get pregnant.
Good luck with your journey