Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bully XLs - if breed-specific legislation isn't the answer, what is?

144 replies

Middlelanehogger · 16/09/2023 22:03

Upfront - I'm glad bully XLs will be banned. There have been way too many attacks and if we're going to have a banned breeds list then they definitely belong on it!

But I do agree a bit with people who say BSL is a bit pointless because backyard breeders will just create another one and then there will be a few years of muddled statistics before the govt realises this is the new killer breed and then has to take months and months to define it etc

So what should the rule be... ideally one that is predictive in advance and not just waiting for the dogs to kill first... Size/weight? Zero tolerance for "minor" bites? Dog licences for all? Make owners & breeders criminally responsible for murders their dogs commit?

YANBU = yes this is a serious issue
YABU = my velvet hippo would never hurt a fly

OP posts:
JuliusWho · 16/09/2023 23:54

Dog breeding through licensed breeders only. Legal changes to make it easier to sue for dog bite injuries. Mandatory dog licenses, for all dogs, with associated insurance.

Good for reducing attacks, good for victims of attacks and especially good for the welfare of dogs.

echt · 16/09/2023 23:53

While the following is about importing dogs into Australia, it raises interesting possibilities. Along with a short list of banned breeds there is the proviso to include crosses and anything that has any of the characteristics of a banned breed. Obviously the numbers of dogs up for import is far smaller than the number of problematic dogs in the UK, but Australia bins off the DNA route straight off.

Yes to dog licensing. If it can be done in Australia, it can be done in the UK. What's needed is the political will to do so. Where I live, the licence has to be renewed annually and unsexed animal licences cost more. The licence, a disc, has to be on the dog's collar at all times outside the home.

HauntingSecrets · 16/09/2023 23:53

Treat all dogs as weapons?
Anyone can own a dog (where the breed standard is) under 20kg, over that must be registered and over X weight needs a license?

JaneIntheBox · 16/09/2023 23:52

YANBU there's only one way.
Jail and fine owners for their dogs' actions. Even the smallest bite.
It should be the same sentence as if the owner personally caused the injury, not the dog.
The less dogs we have in the world the better anyway. I'm a dog lover but so many unsuitable people have them now.

parameciumparty · 16/09/2023 23:50

Frequency · 16/09/2023 22:11

Education on canine welfare and behaviour from a young age coupled with reduced cost neutering, a focus on responsible dog ownership, and more accessible enclosed dog parks which could be funded via licensing and fines.

And tighter controls around the breeding and sale of all companion animals.

And you think the type of people who keep these dogs will respond to such requirements? They keep these animals to look hard or to do organised fighting. They're generally not very intelligent and care only about street cred. They don't want lil Buster's balls removing 'cos they want him to look hard and to be used for breeding purposes.

Middlelanehogger · 16/09/2023 23:48

@HauntingSecrets oh don't get me wrong, I actually don't have a problem with banning breeds. And we should keep that on the books until/unless a better suggestion comes along.

I just don't want backyard breeders taking some Killer Kimbo descendent, crossing it with a rottweiler and calling it a totally separate breed. Probably with an equally stupid name like "Rotty KK"

OP posts:
Middlelanehogger · 16/09/2023 23:43

Really helpful @ntmdino @Frequency and others... do you have a sense of how easy it would be to change the law for these suggestions? E.g. are there any orgs which have proposals for what might be a sensible set of rules for genetic tests?

OP posts:
Hawkins0009 · 16/09/2023 23:41

humans need to have license's to eg drive a car, why not a license to have a dog etc ?

MartinChuzzlewit · 16/09/2023 23:36

If I’m being 100% honest (and I’m prepared to be flamed) I’d personally be fine if all dog ownership was banned tomorrow. I think there’s too many dogs and way too many bad owners, it’s immoral on every level, and the UK population has proven itself to be too stupid to own pets properly.

But given that is unlikely, I think it IS the only answer - to define what an XL Bully is and ban them. They can go in homes and take them away for all I care - I’m sick of seeing news of children dying and being injured, in sick of thickos defending them and deluding themselves that biology is irrelevant and I’m REALLY sick of going to public places and trying to dodge all the people - lets face it it’s a certain kind of person who owns on me of these awful beasts (always ‘hard man’ type blokes) who often don’t even have them on leads, as they try and follow my children or sniff my crotch.

Dogsarebetterthanpeopl · 16/09/2023 23:36

@ntmdino I like all your suggestions wholeheartedly. I have a different point of view on not banning certain breeds but I think you offer some real practical solutions that would work in the real world

HauntingSecrets · 16/09/2023 23:35

But… the breeds we “blamed” in the past are now not a problem so clearly it DOES work, I have small dogs, if one of them went rabid and attacked to kill you’d get stitches and a bad bruise. They literally couldn’t kill unless it was a freak accident.

A bull breed’s jaws brings a gun to a knife fight.

Dogsarebetterthanpeopl · 16/09/2023 23:31

I have a big breed dog that needs alot of exercise.

I meet alot of bam dog owners who seem clueless. It shocks me how lazy some owners are.

Mandatory theory and practical dog licence for owners. Good citizen test mandatory for off leash dogs. Like a licence for cars different catalegories for dog ownership so extra testing done for bigger or higher prey drive dogs etc

Some breeds aren't Good pets and would be best neutered with a breeding ban

bravotango · 16/09/2023 23:24

LizzieSiddal · 16/09/2023 22:14

All dogs to be muzzled in public and kept on a lead unless in a designated area for dogs.

This, I think this is the solution

TheWayTheLightFalls · 16/09/2023 23:14

Deal with the criminal lowlife who like having these animals. The drug dealers, the pimps, the antisocial scum who blight certain neighbourhoods.

This. That’s the underlying issue, not whether flavour of the week is rotties, staffies, mastiffs, knives, machetes or whatever else.

Johnnylewis · 16/09/2023 23:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I'm not stupid thanks. I said it was my dream scenario, I'm well aware it would never happen.

smooththecat · 16/09/2023 23:07

There was a guy on the radio who had originally written the DDA legislation. He also seemed to be of the opinion that dogs bred for fighting have no place in society.

hattie43 · 16/09/2023 23:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

hattie43 · 16/09/2023 23:05

drinkuptheezider · 16/09/2023 22:32

Deal with the criminal lowlife who like having these animals. The drug dealers, the pimps, the antisocial scum who blight certain neighbourhoods.
If they are leant on daily, rather than police standing by whilst they make money through fear and intimidation, their dopey 'partners' constantly under SS scrutiny, DC removed, make life so uncomfortable the last thing they want is grief over their choice of dog.
Banning the dogs is a sticking plaster on an open wound.

I so agree with this . This feral underclass need sorting for the misery they cause .

ntmdino · 16/09/2023 22:59

The problem begins long before the owners get their dogs. The current BSL is useless, because it pays no attention to the actual heritage of the dog, so even if you believe that breed = behaviour, our current laws are insufficient to fix the problem (unless, of course, you think that a dog's dimensions determine its behaviour) and adding more breeds to the list won't change that.

It's actually really simple to fix this whole thing, conceptually, and make all the dog enthusiasts happy at the same time.

  • Keep the spirit of the Dangerous Dogs act - any dog that has proven to be a danger should be subject to restrictions.
  • Make all owners responsible for the behaviour of their dogs as though they themselves committed the crime.
  • Define dog breeds by genetics in the law, instead of using the Kennel Club's abusive breed standards.
  • Make all dog breeding illegal without a licence, which should be prohibitively expensive for the average person, and make it contingent on welfare inspections. Massive fines for anybody whose dog has even one litter; breeding should only be done by people who actually know what they're doing. Don't want a fine? Neuter your dog.
  • Prohibit the breeding and import of dog breeds on the banned list - as defined by the aforementioned genetic heritage testing (including 50% genetic content - the point being not to continue lines that were banned).
  • Require all breeders to produce at least 40% of litters as unrelated crossbreeds, and must be able to prove minimal inbreeding for every litter.
  • All dogs subject to restrictions under the DDA should be neutered (ie never allow a dangerous dog to reproduce).

There you go. All banned breeds disappear from the gene pool, dog welfare increases, uninformed idiots can't breed dogs to make some cash on the side, the Kennel Club no longer has ever-more-abusive control of breed standards, shitty owners go to jail if they can't keep their dogs under control, and everybody's happy.

This, of course, is hard work compared to adding another breed to a list that's already as useful as a chocolate teapot, and sadly won't placate the "SOMETHING MUST BE DONE!" crowd or grab headlines and votes.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 16/09/2023 22:57

This is what the British Veterinary Association had to say.

Bully XLs - if breed-specific legislation isn't the answer, what is?
Frequency · 16/09/2023 22:57

ps: how is having a dog licence any different from having the animal micochipped?

Licensing could be used to fund other control measures.

My ideal solution would be to focus on education and to totally overhaul the DDA.

I would educate children of primary school aged and older in canine welfare and behaviour. 80% of dog attacks can be attributed to human error/environmental factors. Education is the only thing that could reduce this.

On top of that, I would bring in dog licensing and on-the-spot fines for dogs viewed to be breaking the laws of the new DDA.

The new laws would include;

  1. all dogs to be licensed. 2)All dogs are to be spayed or neutered by the age of 2 unless registered for breeding or otherwise advised by a qualified behaviorist that it would be detrimental to the dog's welfare to neuter. I would also put into place a nationwide reduced-cost scheme for low-income families to neuter and spay (paid for by licensing and fines)
  2. Dog wardens with the power to issue on-the-spot fines to patrol parks and other dog hotspots (paid for via licensing and fines)
  3. Fines issued for any dog witnessed to be out of control in public - out of control in public would include but not be limited to lack of recall and chasing or jumping on members of the public. Fines can be lowered if the dog owner attends a "dog awareness" class which would aim to teach owners how to train and control their dog using scientifically backed training methods.
  4. Incentivise training by allowing reduced-cost licenses for dogs who have passed their canine good citizen awards.
  5. Incentivise licensing by working with businesses to give discounts on pet products for license holders.

I would then look at breeding and the sale of companion animals and create new laws around that. All breeding animals must be registered and to be registered they must pass stringent health and temperament tests. No animal born from unregistered parents can be sold for profit. They must instead be rehomed via a registered rescue. I would ban the sale of live animals on social media platforms and only allow websites to advertise animals for sale if they took measures to check the parents of the advertised animals were properly registered. All breeders must do home checks to ensure the suitability of the new owners.

I wouldn't ban any breed as breed is not a reliable predictor for aggression.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 16/09/2023 22:54

borogovia · 16/09/2023 22:28

If its not possible to ban the breed, would it be possible to ban dogs of a certain bite strength or just a certain size and power?

Well, it seems Anatolian shepherds have the biggest bite force.

Johnnylewis · 16/09/2023 22:48

My dream scenario would be to ban ALL dogs as pets. Police/assistance dogs only.

Whilst current pets are still alive, all to be muzzled in public.

Ponoka7 · 16/09/2023 22:39

Universitynewbie · 16/09/2023 22:27

The muzzle and leads don't tackle dog attacks in the home, you are right. They do tackle them outside the home though and would save lives- not sure what there is to be argued against really?

This change in law seems to have been triggered by the death of Ian Price, the dogs jumped out of the window to get him. Other child deaths and attacks have been in the house/garden. Two other adults were killed by dogs jumping over hedges/fences. That's beside the dogs/other pets that have been killed by these dogs getting out of their back gardens. It's a sticking plaster on a gaping wound.

lljkk · 16/09/2023 22:34

My feeling is around a lot more regulation about who can legally breed animals (or import semen, I guess). This would be no bad thing at all. I'm foreign so I want them all neutered, anyway.

Someone I know suggested that owner could be charged with the crime the animal did. Ie, dog bites a person = owner charged with assault.

Would that penalty influence people who like having a violet dog, or would they still not care? I dunno.

ps: how is having a dog licence any different from having the animal micochipped?