Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bully XLs - if breed-specific legislation isn't the answer, what is?

144 replies

Middlelanehogger · 16/09/2023 22:03

Upfront - I'm glad bully XLs will be banned. There have been way too many attacks and if we're going to have a banned breeds list then they definitely belong on it!

But I do agree a bit with people who say BSL is a bit pointless because backyard breeders will just create another one and then there will be a few years of muddled statistics before the govt realises this is the new killer breed and then has to take months and months to define it etc

So what should the rule be... ideally one that is predictive in advance and not just waiting for the dogs to kill first... Size/weight? Zero tolerance for "minor" bites? Dog licences for all? Make owners & breeders criminally responsible for murders their dogs commit?

YANBU = yes this is a serious issue
YABU = my velvet hippo would never hurt a fly

OP posts:
brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 17/09/2023 01:20

An average adult woman fights every breed of dog, smallest to biggest. Ban anything she can’t defeat.

Afterrain · 17/09/2023 00:58

I think the ban and the DDA need to stay and be improved by genetic testing. Any dog type that has been bred in the past for fighting should be neutered and the type/breed allowed to die out. In the meantime muzzle in private garden and public.
Licence for All dogs
People to go preparation classes before getting a dog and the compulsory training and socialisation classes.
Stop the inbreeding and silly rules of the KC.
Stop importing dogs and cats for breeding
Stop importing cats and dogs from rescues overseas. This is a lucrative business (some are bred specifically for the UK rescue market) and there are plenty of strays here that need rehomed.

STOP treating dogs as fur babies. They are not toys they are intelligent sociable animals.

Little dogs can bite and do damage too.

Ban dogs from the school gates. Not all children like dogs.

Supermarkets, shopping malls are not a dog park. Only properly trained and licensed support dogs should be allowed in these places.

I am a dog owner.

parameciumparty · 17/09/2023 00:38

ntmdino · 17/09/2023 00:33

I once had occasion to contact them to ask for help - we were desperate, and after £10k of vet bills our other two dogs fell ill and we were broke. They told me (in order):

  • That they needed our address and the address of our vet in order to help.
  • They're a marketing and litigation organisation only, and will never take direct action to help pet owners.
  • They'd be contacting our vet in a few days, and if we hadn't taken the dogs in for treatment they'd be commencing criminal action against us for animal cruelty (they actually did this, and our vet of 10 years told them to get fked).
That was their response to us asking them in a last-ditch attempt to try to get the money together to treat our dogs.

They don't give a damn. They'll never be anywhere near this other than making a few soundbites so people remember they exist and holding out their grubby paws for cash.

Bloody shocking that!

They wouldn't come out to rescue an eagle owl (non native bird) that landed in my friend's garden. It was sitting there for hours.

parameciumparty · 17/09/2023 00:36

slugHell · 17/09/2023 00:29

What would you do with the dogs that didn't meet the standard for police work or medical assistance, though? Lots of guide dogs for example don't meet the grade and end up in pet homes.

Euthanasia I suppose. Unfortunate, but we all pay the price for today's lovely feral thuglife society.

parameciumparty · 17/09/2023 00:33

Alstroemeria123 · 17/09/2023 00:24

Oh, I agree with that. But I’d prefer if there were no aggressive large or small dogs - so if there was some way of going by temperament that would be better.

Could reduce the selection even further by allowing Cavalier King Charles spaniels for instance, but not Jack Russells? Reintroduce and allow better temperament small breeds and mongrels.

Of course the Kennel Club wouldn't allow such legislation because money always wins, but it's a logical step in my opinion.

ntmdino · 17/09/2023 00:33

parameciumparty · 17/09/2023 00:05

The RSPCA seem to exist to raise money and that's it. Like many large charities, they bypass their initial aims to chase the cash now.

I once had occasion to contact them to ask for help - we were desperate, and after £10k of vet bills our other two dogs fell ill and we were broke. They told me (in order):

  • That they needed our address and the address of our vet in order to help.
  • They're a marketing and litigation organisation only, and will never take direct action to help pet owners.
  • They'd be contacting our vet in a few days, and if we hadn't taken the dogs in for treatment they'd be commencing criminal action against us for animal cruelty (they actually did this, and our vet of 10 years told them to get fked).
That was their response to us asking them in a last-ditch attempt to try to get the money together to treat our dogs.

They don't give a damn. They'll never be anywhere near this other than making a few soundbites so people remember they exist and holding out their grubby paws for cash.

slugHell · 17/09/2023 00:30

Sorry was trying to reply to @Johnnylewis

slugHell · 17/09/2023 00:29

What would you do with the dogs that didn't meet the standard for police work or medical assistance, though? Lots of guide dogs for example don't meet the grade and end up in pet homes.

Alstroemeria123 · 17/09/2023 00:24

parameciumparty · 17/09/2023 00:09

I'd rather be locked in a room with a pissed off jack russel than a pissed off rottweiler though.

Larger dogs with naturally good temperaments would be natural casualties of a size reduction scheme. Just one of those things. It would prevent thuglife from moving on to cane corsos. We all have to suffer thanks to plod not controlling thuglife. Just the way of the world now.

Oh, I agree with that. But I’d prefer if there were no aggressive large or small dogs - so if there was some way of going by temperament that would be better.

crumblingschools · 17/09/2023 00:14

What do other countries do?

parameciumparty · 17/09/2023 00:11

bengalcat · 17/09/2023 00:11

As a bare minimum dog breeders should be licensed .

And how do you control backstreet breeders?

bengalcat · 17/09/2023 00:11

As a bare minimum dog breeders should be licensed .

parameciumparty · 17/09/2023 00:09

Alstroemeria123 · 17/09/2023 00:04

It’s temperament as much as size, though.

I feel far safer around a St Bernard than a Jack Russell (for instance)

I'd rather be locked in a room with a pissed off jack russel than a pissed off rottweiler though.

Larger dogs with naturally good temperaments would be natural casualties of a size reduction scheme. Just one of those things. It would prevent thuglife from moving on to cane corsos. We all have to suffer thanks to plod not controlling thuglife. Just the way of the world now.

Brrrrrrrrrrrr · 17/09/2023 00:08

Destroy all non compliant dogs, they’re too much of a risk. Jail sentence for anyone found breeding or owning one after the ban.

JaneIntheBox · 17/09/2023 00:06

MartinChuzzlewit · 16/09/2023 23:56

That doesn’t stop these dogs killing though. Prevention is better than cure

That's great in theory, but as PP have said it's impossible to enforce.
Banning one dog breed will just lead to another one being created, in addition many irresponsible owners aren't the type to pay attention to the law anyway.
Who's going to enforce it?
But if there's a fine, or a law that the owner must pay compensation and these people are CAUGHT then it's a deterrent,

Of course, all these things can be implemented together but banning breeds on their own with no impact to the owener other than dog PTS will not work. 100%.

parameciumparty · 17/09/2023 00:05

The RSPCA seem to exist to raise money and that's it. Like many large charities, they bypass their initial aims to chase the cash now.

Alstroemeria123 · 17/09/2023 00:04

It’s temperament as much as size, though.

I feel far safer around a St Bernard than a Jack Russell (for instance)

KingOfThieves · 17/09/2023 00:03

LizzieSiddal · 16/09/2023 22:14

All dogs to be muzzled in public and kept on a lead unless in a designated area for dogs.

Entirely pointless considering the dogs that cause issues are not owned by responsible pet owners. They wouldn’t abide by such rules anyway

ToBeOrNotToBee · 17/09/2023 00:02

Something needs to be done.
We have a situation where dogs weighing more than some healthy human adults are routinely out of control, are being bred with unstable genetics, with terrible upbringings, poor socialisation and then passed around homes, each worse than the last.
Dogs that have had their ears cropped as pups without anaesthetic, their first few weeks of live will be pain and suffering, that does not make healthy well-rounded adults.
Breeding for increased body mass has resulted in dogs with severe hip and elbow issues, again, dogs in pain. Dogs in pain are not happy campers, they bite, often unpredictably.
It's a disaster waiting to happen and I don't want anyone else getting hurt.
The answer isn't more BSL, imo it's dog wardens coming down hard on shit owners, breeding restrictions being introduced, and a huge public safety awareness of how to approach and look after dogs.
Also, where the feck has the RSPCA been for the last few years, this has been a dog welfare issue for years with pups having their ears cropped, poor breeding practices, dogs kept in crates and outside before being passed onto homes with small kids. And they've been nowhere.

parameciumparty · 17/09/2023 00:00

Bearing in mind that there is now no chance of ever doing anything about the feral underclass, perhaps it's time to put a limit on what size dog people can own. Allow only the smaller breeds which have no particular power and which can be overpowered by pretty much anyone (baring the frail elderly or very small children) in the event of biting. Small dogs can be snappy and yappy, but don't kill people. Cat owners are happy owning domestic cats and don't expect to own pet pumas or tigers, so why not reduce the size of pet dogs to something manageable which can be kept in today's overcrowded and urbanised society?

echt · 17/09/2023 00:00

unsexed animal licences cost more I meant to write un desexed. Is that even a.word?

ntmdino · 16/09/2023 23:57

Middlelanehogger · 16/09/2023 23:43

Really helpful @ntmdino @Frequency and others... do you have a sense of how easy it would be to change the law for these suggestions? E.g. are there any orgs which have proposals for what might be a sensible set of rules for genetic tests?

Oh, my suggestion wouldn't be easy at all. Aside from the usual process of defining laws without loopholes (if humans in groups love to do one thing, it's gaming the system), there would be intense lobbying against the key part - making breed a function of genetics by law. The Kennel Club would pile tons of cash into lobbying to prevent that happening, because being the sole arbiters of breed standards is core to their business model. Similarly, breeders would huck all the money they can spare into preventing the large licence fees and mandatory inspections from ever coming into law, while simultaneously supporting the backyard breeder provisions.

The trouble is that unless it's all implemented, it's useless. If one part is neutered or weakened, none of the rest of it works.

MartinChuzzlewit · 16/09/2023 23:56

JaneIntheBox · 16/09/2023 23:52

YANBU there's only one way.
Jail and fine owners for their dogs' actions. Even the smallest bite.
It should be the same sentence as if the owner personally caused the injury, not the dog.
The less dogs we have in the world the better anyway. I'm a dog lover but so many unsuitable people have them now.

Edited

That doesn’t stop these dogs killing though. Prevention is better than cure

MartinChuzzlewit · 16/09/2023 23:55

parameciumparty · 16/09/2023 23:50

And you think the type of people who keep these dogs will respond to such requirements? They keep these animals to look hard or to do organised fighting. They're generally not very intelligent and care only about street cred. They don't want lil Buster's balls removing 'cos they want him to look hard and to be used for breeding purposes.

Exactly.

These suggestion are good ones in an ideal world. But in the real world, thugs get these poor dog’s ears clipped to make them look hard - they’re never gonna muzzle them and turn up to puppy classes are they

HauntingSecrets · 16/09/2023 23:54

I mean you only have to watch Bluey to know Australia have got it right.

Swipe left for the next trending thread