Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bully XLs - if breed-specific legislation isn't the answer, what is?

144 replies

Middlelanehogger · 16/09/2023 22:03

Upfront - I'm glad bully XLs will be banned. There have been way too many attacks and if we're going to have a banned breeds list then they definitely belong on it!

But I do agree a bit with people who say BSL is a bit pointless because backyard breeders will just create another one and then there will be a few years of muddled statistics before the govt realises this is the new killer breed and then has to take months and months to define it etc

So what should the rule be... ideally one that is predictive in advance and not just waiting for the dogs to kill first... Size/weight? Zero tolerance for "minor" bites? Dog licences for all? Make owners & breeders criminally responsible for murders their dogs commit?

YANBU = yes this is a serious issue
YABU = my velvet hippo would never hurt a fly

OP posts:
Thatcat · 17/09/2023 12:30

Hard agree, pp. We just need enforcement of the laws already in place. Police are not on it. There’s not enough monitoring or prosecution. Breeders do whatever tf they want and get away with it.

Bananaman123 · 17/09/2023 12:20

We desperately need tougher laws and prison sentences. My rescue came from a large puppy farm whe had hundreds of dogs, she was starved, slept in her own mess, deprived of water, truly awful circumstances. The guys that were charged said they did it because they got into debt and needed the money, shame eh. They got a ban from owning dog, not one day spent in prison for the suffering they caused.

do they actually check they don’t have new dogs, nope. We need proper laws, sentences, licenses for breeders and money to actually prosecute.

Astronutter · 17/09/2023 12:18

Low hanging fruit? Greater prosecution of ear cropping. It’s already illegal, cruel, unnecessary and strongly correlates to twats who want a status dog/ backyard breeders rather than responsible owners. Substantial fixed penalty notice if reported/ seen by police, registration of dog and mandatory attendance to dog health, welfare and training course. (Motivation to owner to attend is that once they have the dog is registered otherwise they can be fined again).

Only acceptable defence to cancel FPN is evidence dog is rehomed from a registered charity and therefore unendorsed by current owner who will have already be externally assessed by charity as meeting minimum standards of competence/responsibility. Reduction in penalty if person responsible for cropping is named, with carrying out the act receiving a 5 figure fine and potential prison sentence.

MartinChuzzlewit · 17/09/2023 12:14

OneFrenchEgg · 17/09/2023 12:09

I also think we should try to change the culture away from treating dogs like our furbabies/harmless/nanny dogs and put them back in the 'animal' box rather than the 'just like a human' box. Destroy any dangerous ones rather than coop them up in shelters, none of this 'he needs a good home with no children or other animals and a Lon owner that can train him not to react bla bla bla' just put it down.
Sick of seeing stupid parents with dogs three times the size of their newborn drooling over it 'protecting the baby/best friends bla bla'

100% this.

BIL has an XL Bully.

Fair enough it’s never bitten anyone but I won’t let my kids anywhere near the slathering horrible beast, it’s head is twice the size of my 6yo’s and if it turned whoever is closest would be screwed.

BIL acts like I’m the most ridiculous precious human ever and says “He’s soft I can’t believe you’re scared of him he would never hurt a fly” and is now posting “cute” pictures on FB saying “Look at my oh so dangerous dog” and moron ILs are commenting on how lovely he is.

I don’t have time for this level of total delusion and quite frankly if police seized all Bully XLs tomorrow from their ‘furever homes’ (🤮) it couldn’t come sooner IMO and I’d be delighted and no I wouldn’t feel sorry for the people who could choose any family dog or calm dog and chose one that makes them look hard instead.

Dragonwindow · 17/09/2023 12:13

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 17/09/2023 11:43

It's a legal requirement now for all dogs to be chipped. If a dog is found without one the owner has X amount of days to get it chipped or a £500 fine.

Yes, but I mean there could be more info on the chip, and if any of the legal requirements are missing (yearly vet check, compulsory owner training, or whatever it might be) then the dog can and will be seized. In reality, no one's going to be doing random spot checks on a dog walking calmly down the street on a lead. But in a scenario where a dog is causing concern, immediate action could be taken.

OneFrenchEgg · 17/09/2023 12:09

I also think we should try to change the culture away from treating dogs like our furbabies/harmless/nanny dogs and put them back in the 'animal' box rather than the 'just like a human' box. Destroy any dangerous ones rather than coop them up in shelters, none of this 'he needs a good home with no children or other animals and a Lon owner that can train him not to react bla bla bla' just put it down.
Sick of seeing stupid parents with dogs three times the size of their newborn drooling over it 'protecting the baby/best friends bla bla'

fearfuloffluff · 17/09/2023 12:06

Licensing for all breeders.

Change insurance requirements so dogs from unlicensed breeders cannot be covered.

Make it an offence not to have 3P insurance for a dog.

These would probably pay for themselves in reducing insurance costs.

If I were a politician, I'd want to be very careful to avoid basically making it impossible for working class people to afford dogs. Which many proposals would do.

You could possibly make completion of a training course a requirement for some breeds or sizes of dog. And have pet insurance priced lower for people who complete a pre-dog purchase training course that would include a module on how to choose a breed and manage risk.

Gizlotsmum · 17/09/2023 11:50

honestly all dogs should need a licence and evidence of at least basic obedience training and socialisation. Breeders should be legally made to accept any returned puppies ( their details could be stored on the microchip alongside the owners). We were discussing this at puppy class today.

WeWereInParis · 17/09/2023 11:45

Zero tolerance for "minor" bites?

Yes. The man that owned the two dogs from the attack the other day had already been spoken to twice about them. I can't understand why he still had them. I'd have zero tolerance for aggression, or a dog being out of control. Removing aggressive dogs quickly should be the norm.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 17/09/2023 11:43

Dragonwindow · 17/09/2023 11:27

But you could say the same about MOTs and insurance. Of course some people still drive illegal vehicles, but there are consequences if/when they're caught. If all dogs were chipped, and police/dog wardens carried scanners, any non-compliant dogs could be seized on the spot.

It's a legal requirement now for all dogs to be chipped. If a dog is found without one the owner has X amount of days to get it chipped or a £500 fine.

Dragonwindow · 17/09/2023 11:29

And as a society we need to toughen up about humane euthanasia. It's horrible for the owners, but the animal literally knows nothing about it, it's no different to them than being anaesthetised for neutering etc.

MartinChuzzlewit · 17/09/2023 11:28

anniegun · 17/09/2023 10:47

Lets just get rid of all dogs. Attacks, shit everywhere, constant barking. They are not worth it.

I agree with this.

Dragonwindow · 17/09/2023 11:27

CoalCraft · 17/09/2023 08:52

The problem with a lot of these suggestions is that they require compliance. Mandatory vet checks, mandatory puppy training, licenses, even muzzles in public to an extent; these are all things that responsible, law-abiding citizens will do and the kind of people who breed and keep dangerous dogs will just ignore. It already illegal to own a dangerously out of control dog. That hasn't stopped people.

I'm not sure what the answer is. Banning is definitely an imperfect solution for the reasons outlined in the OP. Much tougher sentences for owning a dog that hurts someone might help, though it may often be tough to determine who that is.

But you could say the same about MOTs and insurance. Of course some people still drive illegal vehicles, but there are consequences if/when they're caught. If all dogs were chipped, and police/dog wardens carried scanners, any non-compliant dogs could be seized on the spot.

MartinChuzzlewit · 17/09/2023 11:24

FrangipaniBlue · 17/09/2023 07:20

I have small dogs, if one of them went rabid and attacked to kill you’d get stitches and a bad bruise.

Ah so that's ok then if they bite me! It's only a bruise and stitches why should I care!

This kind of attitude from small breed owners fucks me right off.

It's like a get out of jail card for lazy owners who don't want to put any time and effort into training their rats to be well behaved.

I don’t think anyone is saying small dogs shouldn’t be trained

The point is that if a small dog bit you, you could kick it off and you would at best get a small wound. If a bill XL bit you you’d stand no chance. So this “all dogs has the potential to harm” is BS really

LizzieSiddal · 17/09/2023 10:51

anniegun · 17/09/2023 10:47

Lets just get rid of all dogs. Attacks, shit everywhere, constant barking. They are not worth it.

I do agree about the constant barking. We had a recent holiday ruined because everywhere we went including restaurants/pubs, there were dogs barking and owners not able to stop it. I looked at dogs being dragged around, including in heat of 30 degrees, the vast majority looking absolutely miserable, and felt so sorry for the dogs. Most owners I encountered didn’t seem to have a clue how to look after their pet.

anniegun · 17/09/2023 10:47

Lets just get rid of all dogs. Attacks, shit everywhere, constant barking. They are not worth it.

OneFrenchEgg · 17/09/2023 10:45

I would have:

Licence to own a dog given after a home check
Mandatory pet insurance
Mandatory annual vet visit at least
Mandatory chip
Mandatory self funded training for recall and other basic commands

Stop and check powers granted for the first two years of implementing this - if you can't provide evidence your dog is removed and destroyed.

Whammyyammy · 17/09/2023 10:42

I'll certainly be glad to see XL bully's banned from breeding and forced to wear muzzles and be om a lead.

There's a moron in my daughters town that walks with his status dog off lead and its attacked a few dog's, but as its dog on dog the police not interested, they will be from.now on thankfully as anybody that sees him breaking the new rules will report to police

Shadowchaser · 17/09/2023 10:33

@ntmdino no not necessarily. I supposed the KC would be the obvious ones to oversee whether the documents/health testing has been done and the COI is low enough. There would have to be some sort of database somewhere. Whether you agree with the KC or not isn't really the question here.

My personal opinion is that qualified independent and registered behaviourist and veterinarian should assess all dogs being rehomed or bred from, not random lay people in kennels with no knowledge of background of general behaviour, genetics or health problems that influence behaviour.
Providing a qualified person is responsible for assessing and reporting on the data and making the decision it shouldn’t really matter which organisation holds and displays it- it’s not like they could edit the information or decision.

Its too hypothetical anyway because the money and resources just aren’t there!

ntmdino · 17/09/2023 10:17

@Shadowchaser - hang on, you want a private organisation to be determining the legal status of dogs and breeding? An organisation that explicitly selects for inbreeding and poor health in their breed standards?

The Kennel Club is part of the problem. Part of the solution is to remove their influence, not expand it.

frayble · 17/09/2023 09:59

Trinity69 · 16/09/2023 22:18

Dog licences for ALL breeds. Specific legislation for potentially dangerous breeds and compulsory training. Hard to police I know, but the problem isn’t usually the dog. It’s the people who want that particular dog as a status symbol/guard dog and don’t give the time and effort to train the dog.
You don’t see ‘Road men’ or drugs dealers wandering the streets with a dangerously out of control golden retriever because those dogs don’t have the intimidating look/nature these people require their dogs to have. There are many XL bullies who have been bred responsibility and trained to an exceptionally high standard by responsible owners. Irresponsible owners and breeders are the issue.
Personally I wouldn’t have one. The sheer weight and strength puts me off because all dogs are unpredictable, but some more than others.

This.

For disclosure, I love bull breeds and own an American Bulldog as well as a Staffie.

I do think that by and large, these dog attacks in the media are dogs that have been poorly bred by backyard breeders and kept in inappropriate conditions with inadequate training. My job involves visiting people at home - it is shocking the amount of people who keep dogs in small flats or houses with no gardens and never walk them! This coupled with allowing kids to climb all over them and scream and shout at them is a recipe for disaster. These conditions would be dreadful for any dog, yet the XL bully seems to be the dog du jour and their huge current popularity for these owners is skewing the statistics.

There is no doubt they have much more capability than some other dogs to cause injury or worse, yet I do not believe it is the actual breed of dog that is inherently aggressive, just that many more of them are kept in these appalling conditions which means there is an accident waiting to happen.

The XL bully should not be banned, but there absolutely needs to be a massive crackdown on dog ownership. The most logical way is dog licences with robust legislation, mandatory training and proper penalties for people breaching the licence conditions. There also needs to be a huge crackdown on unregulated dog breeding.

Banning the XL will not tackle the root cause of the issue, these people will move on to another breed of dog and the cycle will continue.

HappiestSleeping · 17/09/2023 09:36

The problem here is the cost of admin vs the benefit. The government will only do what wins votes and what is cost effective. Since this is a relatively small, but well publicised problem, the government will not expend limitless resources to solve it.

I would think the fastest and cheapest way to solve most dog issues would be to ban the sale of dogs on Facebook, gumtree etc. It won't solve all of it, but it would stop a lot of irresponsible breeding as there would be no market. Then some targeted action against the breeders of fighting dogs with higher penalties for instances where the dog has attacked.

Blanket breed bans will just move the problem in the way we have seen with the XL Bullies, which aren't actually a breed. Something else will get created to replace them, so we will be in a never ending loop.

HamstersAreMyLife · 17/09/2023 09:36

HamstersAreMyLife · 17/09/2023 09:28

I'd like to see muzzles and leads being mandatory for all dogs, with increased spending on police and council patrols to enforce. I can't see taxes going up to pay for this though given the austerity towards public services

Sent too soon wanted to say I'd like licences to cover some form of insurance for dogs to support their health and better regulation of breaders

HamstersAreMyLife · 17/09/2023 09:28

I'd like to see muzzles and leads being mandatory for all dogs, with increased spending on police and council patrols to enforce. I can't see taxes going up to pay for this though given the austerity towards public services

sjj28358 · 17/09/2023 09:22

I think all dogs should have to be licensed with the license conditions adjusted according to breed and personal history eg. a dog of a particular breed, or one who has bitten before is only allowed out with a muzzle. The licence should be like a driving licence, you have to be able to produce it all all times.

Also owners should be insured for damage to person or property their dog might cause. Obviously big heavy breeds or those with a propensity for biting would have higher premiums (just like teenage or elderly drivers do).

Also dogs over a certain size / weight shouldn't be allowed off lead in public places. I recently dog-sat for a relative's Labradoodle - a soppy beast but big and strong. I struggled to contain him, even on a lead, when he took a dislike to another passing dog. It scared me a bit; he nearly pulled me over. I was just glad for that leash or we would have had a full blown fight on our hands and I wouldn't have dared intervene.