Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is my son unpopular

91 replies

Whatfreshhorrorstoday · 16/09/2023 18:15

My son is 6 and a half. He loves other kids and playing with friends but I’ve noticed other kids tend to pull away from him. In the school playground and at parties. They play with him a bit but he’s never the one being called to do something, or being asked to sit next to them. I can see my son is sad when it happens.

I’m not sure why he isn’t popular. He has similar interests to the other kids, dresses like them etc. He doesn’t seem to brag more than the others or whinge more.

I know people will tell me it’s normal and I can’t do anything but maybe my question is, how do I support him? and get through this myself? I feel so sad when I see him upset.

OP posts:
Theblacksheepandme · 16/09/2023 22:22

OP I think involving your son in sports is a great idea, but only great if that's what he would like. If he's not into sport you're only pushing something on him and that certainly wouldn't make him happy.

He may just be reserved and likes to take time to start making friends. My teen daughter was like this at that age and still is. She likes to suss people out before she commits to friendship. I really wouldn't worry, easy to say I know but I'm sure he will be fine. I would look at clubs and ask what he would like to join.

Pebblesontheside · 16/09/2023 22:17

JMSA · 16/09/2023 21:52

Goodness me, I'm sorry if I caused any offence with the only child question. But I've worked with children my entire career, and there is sometimes a difference. Most only children are lovely and very kind, but there is sometimes a rigidity about them that doesn't always go down well with their peers.
I don't know anything about the theories, but only children are often easily identified in the classroom (both at primary and secondary level). These are only my observations for what they're worth, and plenty will disagree! Again, no offence meant.

You’ve worked with children your entire career and ‘you don’t know anything about the theories’?

Is it not your duty to maintain your CPD and learn about research and studies related to your work, rather than making sweeping generalisations like this?

Theblacksheepandme · 16/09/2023 22:11

Luana1 · 16/09/2023 21:56

If there is only sometimes a difference then what’s the point in your comment, you could equally say sometimes there is a difference seen in children with siblings! My eldest was an only child for 5 years and I would get ridiculous comments like yours but as soon as he had a sibling they stopped, but he was still the same child..

Great example, I see this regularly.

LaBelleSauvage123 · 16/09/2023 22:08

My son was like this at this age. He was often on the outside of groups and was definitely not one of the popular kids. He wasn’t sporty and was quite old for his years, which I think some of his peers saw as a bit odd. I did worry about it and made sure that I arranged plenty of play dates. I also helped him a bit with practising how to join in with games. In the latter years of secondary school he became very popular and now at uni he has a wide group of friends with a core of very close friends both there and at home. But I do remember it causing me heartache at the time.

JMSA · 16/09/2023 22:05

Anyway OP, I certainly don't want to derail your thread, but just to say that I agree with the comments about getting him involved in extracurricular activities (sport is always a good leveller, and can build confidence and teamwork) and playdates. The latter really helps friendships to grow, outside of the school setting. It's definitely also worth having a word with your son's teacher, so that they're aware and can observe the situation.
Best of luck.

Theblacksheepandme · 16/09/2023 22:03

Yellowlegobrick · 16/09/2023 21:09

why do you think being an only child would make a difference?

Some only children are worse at sharing and turn taking at this age, they don't have to take turns at what they want on tv because there's no one else, they don't have to tolerate being taken along to a siblings hobby every week.

You're talking absolute nonsense. I think you have unfairly labelled only children. It has hit a nerve with me too. Strangely enough my teen daughter was away for 2 weeks on a language course recently. She stayed in someone's home. The lady in the home asked her how many siblings she had and she told her she didn't have any. The lady said she was surprised because she was such a lovely girl for an only child.

She was speechless and said it to me when she got home. It obviously left an impact as she was away for 2 weeks. She was disgusted by the unfair opinions of people towards only children. This outdated thinking needs to stop.

Oh and by the way, when my daughter was OP's sons age, she was capable of sharing and forming queues and being polite etc, shock horror.

poormanspombears · 16/09/2023 22:03

@Catsafterme to be honest, I think lockdown knocked me more than I'd like to admit too.
I consider myself quite extrovert, but it's a social anxiety performance and I've only really learnt that through some trauma work. Technically my son has experienced 'trauma' and has a high ACE score but I'm not sure it would be much different if that wasn't the case. People always want to assess him but I just think he's being 6 and finding his way so bat them off!
I struggle to balance his needs with how he 'should' be in certain situations, like parties, but I'm getting better. I just hope for his sake he finds his way as we live in a very cruel world unfortunately.

JMSA · 16/09/2023 22:01

@Luana1

I was trying to be polite. You can call it ridiculous all you like, but I can't apologise for what I've noticed over the years Confused

Luana1 · 16/09/2023 21:56

JMSA · 16/09/2023 21:52

Goodness me, I'm sorry if I caused any offence with the only child question. But I've worked with children my entire career, and there is sometimes a difference. Most only children are lovely and very kind, but there is sometimes a rigidity about them that doesn't always go down well with their peers.
I don't know anything about the theories, but only children are often easily identified in the classroom (both at primary and secondary level). These are only my observations for what they're worth, and plenty will disagree! Again, no offence meant.

If there is only sometimes a difference then what’s the point in your comment, you could equally say sometimes there is a difference seen in children with siblings! My eldest was an only child for 5 years and I would get ridiculous comments like yours but as soon as he had a sibling they stopped, but he was still the same child..

katem98 · 16/09/2023 21:55

@Luana1 I think I agree with this. My 2 are 2 years apart aged 4 and 2 and older child absolutely hates sharing and becomes quite territorial over things.

Catsafterme · 16/09/2023 21:54

@poormanspombears That's what I was like as a child, I was happy with my own company and quiet and reserved, although that kept me back socially throughout and even now. One on one, small groups fine but larger I would either avoid or fall into the background if I was there.

Lockdown affected mine who's extroverted so quite likely did, they retreated slightly. It did me anyway, although lockdown was a walk in the park in a way, it did revert me back into old habits of not even caring about going out or seeing people and took a long time to readjust.

Be fine and likely associate with those who are similar. Some just aren't interested in being part of the bigger group or louder ones.

Luana1 · 16/09/2023 21:53

Yellowlegobrick · 16/09/2023 21:09

why do you think being an only child would make a difference?

Some only children are worse at sharing and turn taking at this age, they don't have to take turns at what they want on tv because there's no one else, they don't have to tolerate being taken along to a siblings hobby every week.

Some of the worst sharers I have seen are those with a sibling! They have to compete for parental
resources at home so don’t want to in social settings. The worst I’ve are those with a sibling very close in age.

OP is your son really actually upset or is he picking up
on you being upset- it doesn’t sound like he is being excluded or anything, at the moment he is not one of the more popular kids, but in 6 months time he might be :)

JMSA · 16/09/2023 21:52

Goodness me, I'm sorry if I caused any offence with the only child question. But I've worked with children my entire career, and there is sometimes a difference. Most only children are lovely and very kind, but there is sometimes a rigidity about them that doesn't always go down well with their peers.
I don't know anything about the theories, but only children are often easily identified in the classroom (both at primary and secondary level). These are only my observations for what they're worth, and plenty will disagree! Again, no offence meant.

Daffodil63 · 16/09/2023 21:48

I think there are a lot of MNs who have or had children that experience this. My recommendation is get him interested in a hobby or sport away from school so that a) he has a separate group of friends and b) becomes good/excels at something that boosts his confidence.

poormanspombears · 16/09/2023 21:42

My son is about the same age and I've been more aware of this since he started attending lots of parties.
I really struggle seeing my son being on the sidelines and acting quite awkward.
He's always the one at parties that doesn't like to take part in games and would rather sit out and just do his own thing. He is quite introverted in bigger social gatherings but does better in smaller groups and is always playing football or basketball at school.
I made a conscious effort to watch not just him, but others too, and I think its cyclic, they all go through it in their own way and time.
My DH gets a little tired of me saying this but I think COVID really did a number on DS and his ability to socialise.

Theblacksheepandme · 16/09/2023 21:40

JMSA · 16/09/2023 18:20

Aww, that's such a shame Sad

I'm sure your son is lovely, but is it that he maybe tries a bit too hard or is a bit intense with the other children?
Is he an only child?

Please dont use the only child question? Anyone with half a brain knows that this is now a very outdated theory. A 1987 quantitative review of 141 studies on 16 different personality traits failed to support the opinion, held by theorists including Alfred Adler, that only-children are more likely to be maladjusted due to pampering. The study found no evidence of any greater prevalence of maladjustment in only-children.

Bored1000 · 16/09/2023 21:38

He dosent really sound unpopular just not the most popular, sometimes the most popular kids are actually not the nicest and popular for other reasons so not sure I would want him to be in that category.

Maybe arrange small play groups in your home (invite maybe 2 kids) as in a group that small it’s hard to exclude someone and you can observe how he interacts then.
You sound like a good mum

Justaredherring · 16/09/2023 21:29

Bobbotgegrinch · 16/09/2023 18:35

Are you sure this isn't just confirmation bias. You've said he has friends, and plays with others, but that sometimes he gets left out.

That happens to everyone, but you're always going to notice the times that it happens to your son, rather than someone else.

Even if it does happen more often to your son, I'd try to ignore it. You're not going to be able to change your son's personality, and trying to suggest he does things differently is just going to make him feel like he's doing something wrong.

I agree with this, and also having a word with your child’s teacher to see if there really is a problem

ladyvimes · 16/09/2023 21:19

Sometimes it takes children time to find someone they really ‘click’ with. Maybe invite someone her gets on with for a play date after school and foster some of those friendships outside of school?

Whatfreshhorrorstoday · 16/09/2023 21:18

@katem98 thank you for sharing. It’s nice to know I’m not the only one

everyone has been very kind about this and I’m genuinely touched. I know mumsnet posts can go awry to so grateful for the replies

OP posts:
FluffyCloudsofShit · 16/09/2023 21:17

They could be in established groups already due to going to the same classes or groups outside of school or having play dates together because their parents know eachother.

I would start to arrange a few play dates to cultivate closer friendships.

SausageinaBun · 16/09/2023 21:15

Is he trying to be friends with the wrong children? This probably sounds horrible, but when children don't understand the social pecking order, they tend to try to be friends with the most popular children and get rejected. They need to aim for more realistic friends (who are probably actually nicer to be friends with).

wearedoingthis · 16/09/2023 21:12

I think asking if they are an only child is relevant. It can be obvious who is an only child when watching children interact.

Yellowlegobrick · 16/09/2023 21:09

why do you think being an only child would make a difference?

Some only children are worse at sharing and turn taking at this age, they don't have to take turns at what they want on tv because there's no one else, they don't have to tolerate being taken along to a siblings hobby every week.

Yellowlegobrick · 16/09/2023 21:07

Ds is the same age.

Honestly? The most popular boys in his class at the moment are the less well behaved ones. They fight, say funny (rude!) things. I think what's most common among them is confidence and not giving a shit but also they tend to be average academically. The very able kids who are keen readers or good at maths etc are rarely popular in our school. Being a fast runner and knowledgeable/good at football seem to be key as well (DS is neither).

A pp commented that most kids are somewhere in the middle, not popular and not isolated. My ds is like this, I think many are but it can look like being unpopular if you have unrealistic expectations of your child being queen bee.