Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

20mph in Wales - why???

243 replies

Flpwer · 16/09/2023 15:28

I don't understand why Mark Drakeford has done this - surely this will just cause more road rage??? Is this a money-making ploy because they know a lot of people will probably drive over it as 20mph feels so unnatural.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
cheerypip · 16/09/2023 17:09

Hufflepods · 16/09/2023 16:03

They can’t be that rural if they are 30mph to begin with! This isn’t national speed limit roads being suddenly changed to 20.

Actually in my rural area (West Wales) there are several areas that are currently national speed limit where 20mph is being introduced - think through roads going past small clusters of housing. So people will literally be slowing from 50-60 mph down to 20 for about 100 metres and then back up to national speed limit.

I don't have any problem with 20mph in urban areas and residential areas, but to be honest some of this is nuts.

Some of the signage is already in place, and I tried to drive one bit this morning, up quite a steep hill and it was really quite difficult to keep to 20mph.

Hopefully some common sense will prevqil and the Councils over time will introduce more exemptions on through routes to return to 30mph ...

Wsmi · 16/09/2023 17:07

Because Welsh Labour is just an advanced form of the braindead Westminster government. More stupid and generally a worse version. Making roads slower has nothing to do with safety. It has everything to do with not wanting to invest because this country’s economy is broke. And Wales public finances are in even more trouble, being run by grandpa Drake.

The UK’s has an unofficial population of around 90 million, because of low skilled mass immigration. Economic growth has been close to 0 for years now. We need new roads, new towns, over and under passes, tons of new infrastructure to cope with this population explosion. But much like the general population, central and devolved governments are run by morons. Thickos who couldn’t run a bath. And corrupt to boot, embezzling public funds at every given opportunity.

So instead of building new roads, they come up with these kind of hare brained schemes and the idiotic public falls for it. Hook, line and sinker.

Yddraigoldragon · 16/09/2023 17:06

My worry is that there are so many roads with steep gradients in the Valleys. It’s going to burn some clutches….

gogomoto · 16/09/2023 17:01

Arterial routes can be kept at 30 or higher if local authorities think it would be better, there's a mechanism for this. Where I live just over the border lots are 20 including wide, unconjested arterial routes, Bath in particular!

Poblano · 16/09/2023 16:57

But if you're trying to do a quick turnaround as a carer in a rural area where your clients are 10 miles away from each other, crawling along on 20 mph with no cars, houses, or anything other than the odd sheep around of course it's a) going to add a significant amount of time to your overall journey b) feel frustrating and c) not feel like there's any discernible improvement.

But it's very unlikely that those roads with no cars, houses or anything other than the odd sheep are going to have 20mph speed limits.

The 20mph speed limits will be on roads which are currently 30mph.

Rural roads in between villages are usually either 50mph or 60mph and will still be tomorrow.

LakieLady · 16/09/2023 16:54

takemeouttown · 16/09/2023 15:58

If a child is knocked over at 20 they are far more likely to survive than at 30mph. The fools that drive at 40 on 30 roads will hopefully now just do 30 on the 20 roads. Win win.

On R4 earlier today, some road safety expert said that the risk of fatality when a pedestrian is hit at 30mph is 5 times that compared to being hit at 20mph. That sounds like a pretty good reason to me.

Our town centre and the roads on outlying estates have had 20mph limits for a fair few years now, and it really doesn't take any longer to get across town than it did before. And outside of peak times, there seems to be less congestion.

Saschka · 16/09/2023 16:53

But if you're trying to do a quick turnaround as a carer in a rural area where your clients are 10 miles away from each other, crawling along on 20 mph with no cars, houses, or anything other than the odd sheep around of course it's a) going to add a significant amount of time to your overall journey b) feel frustrating and c) not feel like there's any discernible improvement.

Given the size of Wales, they are not all going to be ten miles apart. Within a ten mile radius, maybe. Twenty mile radius even. But not ten miles separating each call, unless you have just the one single carer covering everywhere between Anglesey and Ruthin.

HangingByYourFingernails · 16/09/2023 16:47

CrazyCarDrivers · 16/09/2023 15:46

I agree.
I’ve had idiots tailgating me, gesturing, overtaking in dangerous spots and swearing at me -it’s terrifying! It’s going to be so much worse when it’s every road from tomorrow.

Are the idiots out of towners incapable of reading road signs and baffled by why you're driving so slowly?

You'd hope that when the 20mph hits everywhere the idiots will still speed but they won't blame the people abiding by the speed limit personally as in your experience.

DonnaBanana · 16/09/2023 16:43

Why would it cause more road rage? Since when does sound something more calmly and safely make it more stressful? You don’t see people getting angry at walking or cycling because it’s slower than driving.

CraftyGin · 16/09/2023 16:42

I don't mind 20 is plenty. A lot of boroughs in South London are 20 mph, as well as other places.

In rural Scotland, going from the M74 at Abingdon to Edinburgh, you have to go through quite a few villages, and they have 20 mph limits, and then again within the city limits.

There are lots of speed limits in South Wales, eg much of the M4 being 50 mph, some because of twisty roads, and others because of pollution control. Swansea doesn't have a lot of speed cameras, but they slow you down with mind-numbing traffic lights.

I just set my speed limiter to 20 and don't get stressed about it.

Saschka · 16/09/2023 16:42

Flpwer · 16/09/2023 15:48

@Ginmonkeyagain you can't really compare London roads to rural Welsh roads

I grew up in Sussex. Plenty of people bomb about on the narrow country lanes, but that doesn’t mean it is safe - we have pedestrians and horses hit by cars who’ve whizzed round a corner too fast, all the time.

They aren’t turning the M4 and dual carriageways to 20. Just smaller roads, and it is no hardship to slow down on those.

tokennamechange · 16/09/2023 16:41

Riverlee · 16/09/2023 15:34

I heard on the radio yesterday an interview with a Welsh minister (?). He said it would add, on average, one minute to each journey, and save ten lives per year.

the 'on average' thing is a completely ridiculous statistic because there is no way of working out how long the "average journey" is. If you were making a thirty mile journey on roads that were all 20mph, a journey that would previously take you an hour would now take an hour and a half. so for journeys to only take a minute more seems to assume the average journey is only about 3 minutes/1 mile long!
(obviously not an exact measurement because a lot of longer journeys will take place on faster roads).

So yes if you're giving the kids a lift to school down the road it might only take a minute longer, and will likely be a lot safer - and if that leads people to think fuck this I may as well walk, even better.

But if you're trying to do a quick turnaround as a carer in a rural area where your clients are 10 miles away from each other, crawling along on 20 mph with no cars, houses, or anything other than the odd sheep around of course it's a) going to add a significant amount of time to your overall journey b) feel frustrating and c) not feel like there's any discernible improvement.

Plus the cost. Welsh NHS is in a dire state, schools aren't much better, yet we can fund £32 million on this? (not to mention all the additional charges when more councils bow to pressure and start submitting requests to change roads back again).

They should have encouraged councils to proactively identify more ideas that would be suitable for 20mph areas themselves, offering incentives if needed, rather than a blanket change.

Poblano · 16/09/2023 16:36

I live in rural Wales too.

In the village itself the road past the primary school has been 20mph for some time and it has made things much safer for families to walk their children to school.

The only parts of our village that will change to 20mph (i.e. weren't already) are small stretches at either end which are currently 30mph. The roads outside the village are currently 60mph and will still be 60mph tomorrow.

In our nearest town (where I work) there are bigger stretches that will change from 30mph to 20mph, but to be honest most of the time the traffic doesn't flow at 30mph anyway so I expect very little difference. I've seen studies that show that continuous traffic flow is better at 20mph than 30mph anyway, so with the reduction in time spent actually having to stop completely I can't see there will be much change.

The only place where I'm anticipating much of a change is on longer journeys (50 miles +) that pass through a lot of towns and villages where the speed limit has been reduced. This will add time on to longer journeys. But I don't do these types of journeys frequently enough for it to make a difference.

In my opinion a lot of the people currently moaning about the change are going to be very surprised tomorrow when they realise that it really doesn't make that much difference to their normal day.

NeedToChangeName · 16/09/2023 16:34

@Kaaardiffgalnow that's a powerful image

I'm fully in favour of reducing speed limits

Kaaardiffgalnow · 16/09/2023 16:31

There are a lot of misconceptions about it.

Firstly, it's not every road, broadly it's ones with street lights and even those will have some exceptions put in place by local councils. They'll be reviewed too.

It's been 20mph where I live for some time. It's quieter, safer for kids and the sky hasn't fallen in. A few idiots go faster, but in the main, drivers have adapted. It'll be like smoking and seatbelts fairly soon.

The deputy environment minister has shared this image, which is the most compelling reason I've seen - and pointed out that children don't just go out around schools and hospitals (to counter the argument that it should be 20mph only around schools & hospitals).

PlipPlopChoo · 16/09/2023 16:31

I am not aware of what is going on in Wales however I support a 20mph limit on small enclosed residential areas. There is barely any time saved by doing 30mph.

MelodiousThunk · 16/09/2023 16:28

They’re not changing the national speed limit so this won’t affect rural roads. It will only affect roads in built areas with a 30mph limit (either indicated or due to the presence of street lights).

MrsJBaptiste · 16/09/2023 16:26

I live in a busy suburb and loads of the roads around here are now 20mph. However because there are so many, nobody sticks to the speed limit. 20mph is so slow and there's just no need for it on most of these roads.

Teddleshon · 16/09/2023 16:23

There are plenty of rural roads with a 30 mph speed limit. And not just through villages / hamlets with housing on both sides of the road. Some go on for 3 miles or more at a time.

dutysuite · 16/09/2023 16:22

Another money making scam.

Gwendimarco · 16/09/2023 16:17

Ginmonkeyagain · 16/09/2023 16:02

What's so special about rural Wales you need to drive at 30mph?

There are many A roads that are national speed limit 60 for many miles, but switch to 30 as you pass through a small hamlet (by which I mean a terraced row on either side of the road, couple of street lights and possibly a petrol station.

Slowing to 30 for a short stretch can feel a bit unnatural as nothing about the road conditions or visibility has changed, and the zone only lasts a few hundred metres until you have passed the garage and are on your way. It does make sense to look out for pedestrians of course, and these are the rules of the road - fine.

Further slowing the 30 to a 20 on these roads brings added risk imo, namely of somebody coming round a bend or over the brow of a hill at a possibly unwise but not illegal 60mph, and smashing into the law-abiding car in front that has obediently slowed to 18-19 for the 20mph zone stretch.

tanyaturneristhegoat · 16/09/2023 16:06

It is up to the individual local authority to change the signage. Mine hasn’t as of yet. SatNavs will also not be updated or the Highway Code for that matter.

Lovehearts82 · 16/09/2023 16:05

I'm in North Wales and I'm glad it's happening, my all be it small route to work will be affected but it doesn't bother me. The main road which has a few schools along it that I live next to, is one of the worst for drivers exceeding 30mph even in the small 20mph zone section that is outside my youngest primary school. Signs for schools kids crossing and flashing lights as a warning kids are crossing doesn't stop them from going faster. So I'm hoping the whole area being 20mph does stop them, If not the speed camera van that's going to be there next week surely will.

SamphiretheTervosaurReturneth · 16/09/2023 16:05

Flpwer · 16/09/2023 15:55

@BarbaraofSeville I live in rural Wales and the roads are changing to 20mph so yes, people aren't suggesting it because they're actually doing it

I was trying to find some hint on which roads would and would not be changing. It may have something to do with how far apart lampposts are - so in more urban areas but maybe not in more rural areas.

We are on the border ish and will have the be careful as we did in and out of Wales on a regular basis.

megletthesecond · 16/09/2023 16:05

Surely it will only cause road rage among twats who will then hopefully lose their licences quicker?
I drive at the correct speed and have had 25 yrs of losers getting annoyed behind me. They're not my problem.