Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

20mph in Wales - why???

243 replies

Flpwer · 16/09/2023 15:28

I don't understand why Mark Drakeford has done this - surely this will just cause more road rage??? Is this a money-making ploy because they know a lot of people will probably drive over it as 20mph feels so unnatural.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
OoohLaLaLa · 16/09/2023 23:16

I’ve been on the website, took me a while to find the map. Then you have to leave the map to check the key before going back into the map.

It looks like the road going through a village near me will remain 30. The lovely stretch between villages where there’s bugger all? 20.

My village which is plagued by drunk drivers and is single track road? National speed limit.

I’m supportive of reducing speed. I do not support blanket restrictions. I was not consulted/ invited to take part in consultation. There are so many problems with the roads in my area but speed really isn’t one of them.

Truemilk · 16/09/2023 23:07

People causing accidents on 30mph roads are most likely speeding already anyway, so these accidents are still going to happen because these people will continue to speed

RandomButtons · 16/09/2023 22:57

Saschka · 16/09/2023 16:53

But if you're trying to do a quick turnaround as a carer in a rural area where your clients are 10 miles away from each other, crawling along on 20 mph with no cars, houses, or anything other than the odd sheep around of course it's a) going to add a significant amount of time to your overall journey b) feel frustrating and c) not feel like there's any discernible improvement.

Given the size of Wales, they are not all going to be ten miles apart. Within a ten mile radius, maybe. Twenty mile radius even. But not ten miles separating each call, unless you have just the one single carer covering everywhere between Anglesey and Ruthin.

And even then very little of the journey would be on 20mph roads.

feejee · 16/09/2023 22:57

I drive into Cardiff for work and very rarely see anyone else going 20. The light up speed sign is nearly always red as the cars go through, very few get a green smily face. Friday i was angily overtaken by a bmw driver on a leafy 2 lane avenue with cars parked down one side. I have found it quite difficult to stick to 20, especially when the cars in front go faster and the one behind is hassling you.

PandoraRocks · 16/09/2023 22:52

Because Drakeford is a twat who is dragging Wales into the Dark Ages. The proposed tourist tax, the new Landlord contracts, his policies on holiday cottages and now this stupid speed limit. All guaranteed to ruin business and tourism. This is a guy who can't even find a decent suit never mind run a country!

Brats4kid · 16/09/2023 22:51

ItsMyGuacamole · 16/09/2023 22:47

I live in Wales. For me, the most difficult thing seems to be that not all roads are 20mph, but signage hasn't been changed. So it's going to be very difficult to know which roads are which speed limit. Yes you can look it up online, but how am I meant to remember?? And how are they going to police it if there aren't signs?

My husband said (he's a driving instructor) if the road has street lights, assume it 20mph unless stated.

StillWantingADog · 16/09/2023 22:50

I would welcome this in urban areas. Safer for pedestrians, cyclists and children.

in rural areas it makes little sense and although the vast majority will comply a sizeable number will not

ItsMyGuacamole · 16/09/2023 22:47

I live in Wales. For me, the most difficult thing seems to be that not all roads are 20mph, but signage hasn't been changed. So it's going to be very difficult to know which roads are which speed limit. Yes you can look it up online, but how am I meant to remember?? And how are they going to police it if there aren't signs?

Brats4kid · 16/09/2023 22:46

If you hit someone driving 20mph it's a 2.5% chance of killing them, compared to a 20% chance of death driving at 30mph. Seems logical to me!

Spottywombat · 16/09/2023 22:44

And yes the situation with carers in Powys is dreadful. Truly dire, it's been fucked up by the lack of medical services generally plus historical issues with outsourcing the service, which hasn't worked. Mental health services are even worse.

Not to mention cross-border discrimination..refusal to pay the hospital bills and tonnes of historical/current issues. More than once I have had relatives advised they will have to wait longer for operations than if they lived in Shropshire.

WillowCraft · 16/09/2023 22:43

DrMadelineMaxwell · 16/09/2023 21:12

I live in one of the pilot areas so we've had this for a year now. It has been far from popular and remains so. For many reasons. Mostly because, no, they haven't limited it to only roads in residential areas. They kept one road only through our town at 30mph. The other main roads in and out were taken down to 20mph regardless of how built up they were.

And come tomorrow, they are even taking that one remaining 30mph road down to 20 until they then jump through the hoops of applying exceptions to this to revert it to 30mph.

It is costing a hideous amount of millions of £ in a time when cost of living is not good and the Welsh NHS struggles even more than England to keep to targets.

You can't overtake cyclists without speeding over the limit. It only adds one minute to your journey if your journey is one mile long. If you were driving for 60 miles on those roads, then you'd now be driving for 3 hours, not 2. They say that it lowers emmisions, but how can running your car for a 1/3 longer for every journey do that?

The first few months had many road rage incidents.

And, most worryingly, you have far more pedestrians stepping out into the road assuming that they have so much more time to cross safely, and often basically assuming you'll stop for them.

In a year the average speed on the roads here has dropped from 33mph when we had a 30 limit to 27mph in a 20.

Waste of time, resources and money.

Some of these points are just bonkers.
If the cyclist is going at the speed limit, then don't overtake. There's no need to overtake every single cyclist.
It uses less fuel to travel more slowly and there are also much lower emissions from brakes and tyres at slow speeds - the fuel usage/emissions isn't constant regardless of speed
Most journeys are less than 3 miles. So the effect of driving more slowly will be minimal. A journey is not driving at a steady speed from a to b at the speed limit (unless on the motorway or fast A road). In built up areas there are traffic lights, roundabouts, junctions, bends, slow moving traffic, parked cars etc etc. So the effect of the speed limit is very little compared to all these other things.
And how often would someone travel for an hour in a built up area anyway? Rarely.
I don't believe you about pedestrians throwing themselves under your car, but if they are, at least you'll be unlikely to kill them at 20.
Regardless of all this, even if there was a genuine inconvenience which I don't believe there is, it is worth it to reduce road deaths.

Jellykat · 16/09/2023 22:39

WithManyTot · 16/09/2023 22:19

I live in rural Wales, and on our twisty, 1.5 cars wide, high hedgerow roads, 20mph is already more than fast enough if you drive at a speed where you can easily stop easily in the distance you can see is clear. I assume you always drive to be easily able to stop in this distance?

The only real shame is that it is a NSL road so it will say 60, and I'll keep meeting idiots (local & visitors) doing a speed that they cannot stop in the distance they can see is clear, coming towards me.

I'll be pressuring my Senedd member to extend it!

Totally agree with you, same situation here.. blind corners, heavy farm machinery driven by young farmers on their phones, horse riders, wet leaves on road etc and yet its 60mph.. bloody ridiculous

One2threego · 16/09/2023 22:34

@Flpwer you’re in North Wales too? We have a main trunk road, hardly any houses, locals campaigned for 40 to 30 which was crazy enough but they’ve now reduced to 20!! A main A road 😫

WithManyTot · 16/09/2023 22:19

I live in rural Wales, and on our twisty, 1.5 cars wide, high hedgerow roads, 20mph is already more than fast enough if you drive at a speed where you can easily stop easily in the distance you can see is clear. I assume you always drive to be easily able to stop in this distance?

The only real shame is that it is a NSL road so it will say 60, and I'll keep meeting idiots (local & visitors) doing a speed that they cannot stop in the distance they can see is clear, coming towards me.

I'll be pressuring my Senedd member to extend it!

tokennamechange · 16/09/2023 22:17

@MariePaperRoses although looking at it, lots of those aren't newly 20mph roads - some of them are the M4 etc.

tokennamechange · 16/09/2023 22:15

Saschka · 16/09/2023 16:53

But if you're trying to do a quick turnaround as a carer in a rural area where your clients are 10 miles away from each other, crawling along on 20 mph with no cars, houses, or anything other than the odd sheep around of course it's a) going to add a significant amount of time to your overall journey b) feel frustrating and c) not feel like there's any discernible improvement.

Given the size of Wales, they are not all going to be ten miles apart. Within a ten mile radius, maybe. Twenty mile radius even. But not ten miles separating each call, unless you have just the one single carer covering everywhere between Anglesey and Ruthin.

have you tried to get a carer lately lol! there could just be one for the whole of powys given struggles I know people have. Plus agencies usually don't/can't kindly schedule them in geographical order so it's not like there is 60 miles between number 1 and number 6 on the list but you absolutely could end up doing 5 miles between 1 and 2, then 8 miles in a different direction between 2 and 3, then 2 miles down the road for 4, then back up to within a mile of number 1 etc...

thanks @MariePaperRoses

Spottywombat · 16/09/2023 22:02

The drive pretty fast, brake to 20mph, accelerate thing happens on the way to Edinburgh now. I have never understood why the main road to Edinburgh is basically an A-road and now it's even worse...

So I know from going there & also crawling around Edinburgh that this is going to be chaos where I live now as there's already road rage, lawless chavs on scramblers on bike paths and general apathy for rules/laws.

tttigress · 16/09/2023 21:28

What I don't get is, if the speed limit for the UK is 70mph, why do they sell cars that can go over that speed?

You wouldn't allow some one to buy a gun with features that are illegal in the UK, and then just say, oh yeah, please only use it in a way that complies with the law.

DrMadelineMaxwell · 16/09/2023 21:12

I live in one of the pilot areas so we've had this for a year now. It has been far from popular and remains so. For many reasons. Mostly because, no, they haven't limited it to only roads in residential areas. They kept one road only through our town at 30mph. The other main roads in and out were taken down to 20mph regardless of how built up they were.

And come tomorrow, they are even taking that one remaining 30mph road down to 20 until they then jump through the hoops of applying exceptions to this to revert it to 30mph.

It is costing a hideous amount of millions of £ in a time when cost of living is not good and the Welsh NHS struggles even more than England to keep to targets.

You can't overtake cyclists without speeding over the limit. It only adds one minute to your journey if your journey is one mile long. If you were driving for 60 miles on those roads, then you'd now be driving for 3 hours, not 2. They say that it lowers emmisions, but how can running your car for a 1/3 longer for every journey do that?

The first few months had many road rage incidents.

And, most worryingly, you have far more pedestrians stepping out into the road assuming that they have so much more time to cross safely, and often basically assuming you'll stop for them.

In a year the average speed on the roads here has dropped from 33mph when we had a 30 limit to 27mph in a 20.

Waste of time, resources and money.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 16/09/2023 20:59

Shade17 · 16/09/2023 20:40

Enjoy the £6.5b hit to your economy, Wales. You deserve it. If you support this nonsense.

+1

I won’t be visiting any longer. Fuck ‘em.!

Edited

You won't be missed

Shade17 · 16/09/2023 20:40

Enjoy the £6.5b hit to your economy, Wales. You deserve it. If you support this nonsense.

+1

I won’t be visiting any longer. Fuck ‘em.!

Jellykat · 16/09/2023 20:13

Flpwer · 16/09/2023 15:55

@BarbaraofSeville I live in rural Wales and the roads are changing to 20mph so yes, people aren't suggesting it because they're actually doing it

You cant be that rural, the 20mph limits are only where there are existing street lights.

brightdayloomingdark · 16/09/2023 20:08

Flpwer · 16/09/2023 15:42

@LunchBoxPolice I live in rural Wales and it seems this will work in the Urban side of Wales but the roads near me are not worth a 20mph speed limit

I think this. Since moving to Wales it is noticeable just how few people there are! Unless I am right in the city Centre in many residential areas there are just no/ very few people walking about. Where I live you would have to try pretty hard to find a pedestrian, let alone then hit them with your car. I support 20mph in built up areas where people do actually walk around a lot, but think a blanket default to 20mph is overkill in a country like Wales.

CasperGutman · 16/09/2023 20:01

I think the Welsh Conservatives' recent public opposition to making 20mph the default speed limit must be relying on most people not following proceedings in the Senedd particularly closely.

The reality is that the measures have had broad cross-party support since they were first proposed, by a Conservative, five years ago.

20mph in Wales - why???
Redwinestillfine · 16/09/2023 19:41

I wish they did it here ( England) I would fully support it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread