Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

20mph in Wales - why???

243 replies

Flpwer · 16/09/2023 15:28

I don't understand why Mark Drakeford has done this - surely this will just cause more road rage??? Is this a money-making ploy because they know a lot of people will probably drive over it as 20mph feels so unnatural.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
CrazyCarDrivers · 17/09/2023 18:37

We’ve already had impatient people overtaking us doing the 20mph limit today.
It’s going to take them having an accident for some people to begin to take notice of the new limit.

UsingChangeofName · 17/09/2023 18:17

It uses less fuel to travel more slowly and there are also much lower emissions from brakes and tyres at slow speeds - the fuel usage/emissions isn't constant regardless of speed

What source are you using for this? Because most of the emissions data I've seen for cars shows optimal emissions somewhere between 30mph and roughly 56mph pretty solidly over the past 40 years. Below 30 and above approx 60 and emissions rise.

Plus, of course, each and every car will be on the road for longer, each journey. Not sure how that helps the 'clean air' argument.

Poblano · 17/09/2023 15:21

I drove into my local town from my small, rural village earlier today. A 14 mile round trip.

Outside of the town centre (where you'd be hard pushed to drive at 30mph anyway) there was approximately a mile of the whole journey that was now 20mph. I noticed no real difference in travel time.

The biggest problem was an utter numpty right up my backside as we reached the 20mph sign. He was clearly struggling with it far more than I was.

stargirl1701 · 17/09/2023 15:03

Like everything there'll be frothing but decades later it'll be the norm.

See: drink driving limit, seatbelts, Back2Sleep, smoking indoors, etc...

Alexandra2001 · 17/09/2023 15:00

Numbers to Cornwall down by 20% and considering once in Cornwall, your lucky to ever get to 20mph, i doubt thats a reason to stay away.. perhaps super high prices and crappy weather has a bigger influence?

DdraigGoch · 17/09/2023 14:51

PandoraRocks · 17/09/2023 13:54

According to a Telegraph feature on 13 September, Wales has lost a third of its tourists since 2019. If you look at the comments section, many are saying the 20mph limit will put them off visiting us.
BTW I don't read the Telegraph but that article popped up in my feed. As a Welsh person, just reading the ignorant, anti Welsh comments of its readers makes me boil. But there is no doubt that this reduction to 20 will make the country less attractive.

If I remember correctly, many business owners considered the drop in tourist numbers to be a blessed relief. It just means that the "no vacancies" and "fully booked" signs go up a little bit later. Many parts of Wales are certainly over-touristed, the parking chaos on the Ogwen Pass is a testament to that.

Of all of the considerations I make when choosing where to go on holiday, the speed limit has never come up. Those commenters are talking out of their arses.

DdraigGoch · 17/09/2023 14:46

also OP hasn’t stated she is the only poster to live in north wales😂 she has just stated how different wales is and it’s not comparable to the bigger cities!
Country roads have the worst accident records. All the more reason for slowing down.

People really need to chill the heck down😂..
I quite agree. No need to drive around like a cat with the zoomies, calm down and slow down. Stop tailgating, stop using the horn (except in emergencies).

ThePoshUns · 17/09/2023 14:10

I am pro Wales @JustAnotherPoster00 but under the Welsh govt our standards in education have fallen, our NHS is crumbling and poverty is on the increase especially in the valleys which have stagnated.
Welsh govt had the opportunity to grow the Welsh economy ( cheap labour and previously good transport links) and they haven't.

PandoraRocks · 17/09/2023 13:54

According to a Telegraph feature on 13 September, Wales has lost a third of its tourists since 2019. If you look at the comments section, many are saying the 20mph limit will put them off visiting us.
BTW I don't read the Telegraph but that article popped up in my feed. As a Welsh person, just reading the ignorant, anti Welsh comments of its readers makes me boil. But there is no doubt that this reduction to 20 will make the country less attractive.

CrazyHedgehogLover · 17/09/2023 13:41

OP I can completely understand what you mean, I live in north wales and a lot of it is country roads, all 30mph that will be changing to 20mph, I agree it’s a straight country road where basically there is just bushes/trees! Nothing else at all..

obviously around the schools in my area it’s already 20mph, personally I think it should be less then that for going near a school.. so near schools/crossings all completely fair enough.. but no need for the rural roads around this area! People going slower on these roads could potentially cause more problems, you will have certain drivers who will decide to go faster anyway! Resulting in more overtaking and on the Welsh rural roads and with the blind corners this really isn’t a great idea.

also OP hasn’t stated she is the only poster to live in north wales😂 she has just stated how different wales is and it’s not comparable to the bigger cities! People really need to chill the heck down😂..

JustAnotherPoster00 · 17/09/2023 13:23

ThePoshUns · 17/09/2023 13:05

I live in Wales.
I cannot stand Drakeford. He won't be happy until Wales grinds to a complete halt.
Our transport links are abysmal thanks to him shelving the M4 relief road, Cardiff airport is a joke and now this 20mph.
There was no mandate for this, it's not needed and it's certainly wanted.
Welsh Labour is a dictatorship.
I voted against having a Welsh assembly as my first vote at 18, and I was right about it back then.

So not really on the side of Wales are you, conservatives forever in the thrall of Westminster, while I don't completely agree in the direction Drakeford takes I'm not sure why the Tories are so against him, a dictatorship just because your party can't come up with ideas that the Cymru can get on board with in a democracy, before devolution Wales had to stomach the brutal policies of their oppressors and now we get to benefit our own population the Tories can't help but cry into their cornflakes, aww bless

You are Andrew RT Davies right?**

ThePoshUns · 17/09/2023 13:05

I live in Wales.
I cannot stand Drakeford. He won't be happy until Wales grinds to a complete halt.
Our transport links are abysmal thanks to him shelving the M4 relief road, Cardiff airport is a joke and now this 20mph.
There was no mandate for this, it's not needed and it's certainly wanted.
Welsh Labour is a dictatorship.
I voted against having a Welsh assembly as my first vote at 18, and I was right about it back then.

BelindaBears · 17/09/2023 12:48

I don’t get how the 20mph is getting the blame for road rage induced accidents - this is fully the fault of the drivers getting the road rage. Anyone who can’t drive a bit slower than they’d like without flying into a dangerous rage doesn’t deserve a driving license and if this can flush them out and get the cunts fined or, better, banned then it’s win win.

LifeIsPeachy8 · 17/09/2023 12:45

It's horrendous OP. The road rage this is causing is going to cause an accident sooner or later.

Ironically I don't mind pootling along at 20 (once you get used to how slow it feels) but the tailgating and beeping is making every trip a nightmare. Also people are starting to dangerously overtake on single lane roads.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 17/09/2023 12:40

Flaskfan · 17/09/2023 12:30

I could be finishing my coffee. I already leave the house at 710.

I've had to fight my car all the way to stay under 20. It wants to go 24.

Sounds like a you problem

Flaskfan · 17/09/2023 12:30

DdraigGoch · 17/09/2023 11:36

Assuming that you would have been averaging thirty, and will now be averaging twenty (which won't be the case because you will have had to stop at junctions no matter what the limit is, so the averages will be much closer together) then a 14 minute journey will have become a 21 minute journey.

Just imagine what you could be doing with that extra seven minutes.

I could be finishing my coffee. I already leave the house at 710.

I've had to fight my car all the way to stay under 20. It wants to go 24.

DdraigGoch · 17/09/2023 11:43

Because most of the emissions data I've seen for cars shows optimal emissions somewhere between 30mph and roughly 56mph pretty solidly over the past 40 years. Below 30 and above approx 60 and emissions rise.

Gearboxes will be designed with 30mph/50kph in mind, as that's the limit in urban areas across most of Europe. As 20mph/30kph limits become more common, the gearboxes of the ICE cars still in production will be redesigned to run efficiently at the lower limit.

Never mind that though, on pollution/fuel economy grounds perhaps we need to reduce the motorway/dual carriageway speed limit to 60mph.

DdraigGoch · 17/09/2023 11:36

Flaskfan · 17/09/2023 08:26

It's the fact that where I live, you'll be driving at 20 for a long time before you can hit a faster road.
So when I go to the shopping park today, that's a 7 mile journey pretty much all at 20, which is going to add more than 1 minute onto my journey. And my car does not like 20.

Assuming that you would have been averaging thirty, and will now be averaging twenty (which won't be the case because you will have had to stop at junctions no matter what the limit is, so the averages will be much closer together) then a 14 minute journey will have become a 21 minute journey.

Just imagine what you could be doing with that extra seven minutes.

C4tastrophe · 17/09/2023 11:36

I’ve yet to see a credible reason on this thread why 20mph would be more detrimental than staying at 30mph.
If it does turn out worse then I’m sure there’ll be another political party can be voted in to reverse it.

DdraigGoch · 17/09/2023 11:15

You can't overtake cyclists without speeding over the limit.
@DrMadelineMaxwell then don't overtake, it won't kill you.

It only adds one minute to your journey if your journey is one mile long.
60% of journeys under 2 miles are made by car.

If you were driving for 60 miles on those roads, then you'd now be driving for 3 hours, not 2.
I'd like you to find me an example of where you would be driving for 60 miles on 20mph roads. 60 miles from where I live would get me all the way to Corris in one direction, Warrington in another, or alternatively somewhere in the middle of the Irish Sea beyond Holyhead if I headed west. Almost all of those journeys would be along A roads, with only short sections of 20 through towns or villages.

DdraigGoch · 17/09/2023 11:02

Jellykat · 16/09/2023 20:13

You cant be that rural, the 20mph limits are only where there are existing street lights.

Even a market town as large as Denbigh is technically 'rural', the definition includes any settlement of less than 10k people.

Gwendimarco · 17/09/2023 10:56

One2threego · 16/09/2023 22:34

@Flpwer you’re in North Wales too? We have a main trunk road, hardly any houses, locals campaigned for 40 to 30 which was crazy enough but they’ve now reduced to 20!! A main A road 😫

Deeside area, by any chance?
Nightmare!

WalterHWhite · 17/09/2023 10:50

Ignore me Maria - someone has just told me that signs have gone up on a road that isn't on your list!

C8H10N4O2 · 17/09/2023 10:50

It uses less fuel to travel more slowly and there are also much lower emissions from brakes and tyres at slow speeds - the fuel usage/emissions isn't constant regardless of speed

What source are you using for this? Because most of the emissions data I've seen for cars shows optimal emissions somewhere between 30mph and roughly 56mph pretty solidly over the past 40 years. Below 30 and above approx 60 and emissions rise.

20 on residential roads makes sense, potentially with pedestrian priority as in much of Europe. On main roads you are potentially increasing emissions without making a difference to safety.

Outside of residential roads accidents are more likely to be due to driving recklessly than a child running out in the road. Reckless drivers currently ignoring 30mph are unlikely to be influenced by 20mph, however many pictures of photogenic children politicians use and on those roads its smacks of gesture politics instead of addressing the root causes of the accidents.

tanyaturneristhegoat · 17/09/2023 10:26

I don’t know the names of the junctions but I know what stretch. Just seen evidence on the website also. Thankfully I break rules so 20mph doesn’t apply to me 👍🏻