Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

20mph in Wales - why???

243 replies

Flpwer · 16/09/2023 15:28

I don't understand why Mark Drakeford has done this - surely this will just cause more road rage??? Is this a money-making ploy because they know a lot of people will probably drive over it as 20mph feels so unnatural.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Debini · 18/09/2023 15:44

Why would they be angry with you if they are also driving at 20mph?

Spottywombat · 18/09/2023 15:43

If you drive at 15 mph, the queue behind you is down to 10. Stay home to listen to the wireless! It's dangerous.

UsingChangeofName · 18/09/2023 15:37

essaytwenty · 18/09/2023 15:09

Stolen from a local Facebook group.

The next 'Speed Awareness Course' in Wales.

Grin
essaytwenty · 18/09/2023 15:09

Stolen from a local Facebook group.

The next 'Speed Awareness Course' in Wales.

20mph in Wales - why???
CasperGutman · 18/09/2023 13:34

ChilliNoodleGoodness · 18/09/2023 11:21

I am finding it really frustrating, but what is more frustrating is that they haven't bothered to change the road signs!! Everywhere is still showing 30. Do I have to assume that all 30 signs really mean 20? Apart from when I am in a residential area..

No. If there are specific signs displaying a limit of 30 mph then the limit is 30 mph (or at least, the only limit anyone can enforce is 30 mph).

Hecate01 · 18/09/2023 13:16

Traffic in my area has been chaos today because no one has any idea what roads are 20mph and what have stayed at 30mph. On Facebook the local labour councillor is telling everyone that a certain road is still 30mph but the council put new 20mph signs up there last week, if the people in charge don't know how are we supposed to know?

On another note people who don't drive will be impacted by this 20mph speed limit too. My BIL is a class one driver and he's already said that the amount of deliveries they usually do in a day will drop due to driving time laws. When my sister spoke to him on his break he said he was already 1hr 45 minutes behind because people are driving on every road apart from motorways at 20mph.

This is what happens when people blindly vote for the same part over and over again without actually reading their manifesto, it did actually say in there that they would do this so if you voted for then this is what you asked for.

DdraigGoch · 18/09/2023 12:31

far greater sanctions for motorists who use their cars as little more than a weapon.

That would certainly be nice. There was a case near me, motorist was recorded shouting "I'll f+*&ing kill you" as he ran someone off of the road. He then drove off, returning shortly afterwards with his wife driving so that he could rubber neck as the paramedics did their work.

Given the clear statement of intent, recorded both on video and audio, did he get charged with attempted murder? Did he fairycakes. "Driving without due care and attention" so not even a charge of dangerous driving.

I also agree with what you say about retesting. It's ridiculous that you can pass your test at 17 and avoid ever having to be reassessed for decades after that, so long as you avoid getting prosecuted for anything. At my workplace we get our competency checked regularly; with medicals every five years (more often as you get older), full theory tests every three years (comprehensive ones, not just a random sample), riding assessments, covert monitoring and black box/CCTV downloads.

At the very least motorists should be subject to retesting every ten years.

Spottywombat · 18/09/2023 11:37

The 40 to 20 on our main road is going to be an issue, I think.

monpetitlapin · 18/09/2023 11:28

Wsmi · 18/09/2023 10:52

Why 15? Why not 10 or 5? 15 seems dizzyingly fast.

Also why listen to podcasts? You should park up in the middle of the road and get a picnic out. Wave at everyone else crawling past at 15 mph.

This place is utterly weird.

Not sure why she's even getting in the car, she doesn't seem to want to actually go anywhere.

ChilliNoodleGoodness · 18/09/2023 11:21

I am finding it really frustrating, but what is more frustrating is that they haven't bothered to change the road signs!! Everywhere is still showing 30. Do I have to assume that all 30 signs really mean 20? Apart from when I am in a residential area..

Muchtoomuchtodo · 18/09/2023 11:20

Day 2 and I quite like it. It’s not a blanket change to all of Wales’ roads and I hope that those who are grumbling gif involved in their council’s consultations

Yesterday I drove from Pembrokeshire to cardiff and only the first and last few miles were different to when I left on friday

Today I have been for a haircut and to get my prescription, meat and groceries in our local high street about 4 miles away. Just over half of my journey had changed from 30 to 20. I can’t say that I noticed it taking me much longer!

Wsmi · 18/09/2023 10:52

DonnaBanana · 18/09/2023 09:31

Also it’s a speed limit not a speed target, it doesn’t mean you have to be flat out at 20 the whole time. I’ve been setting my cruise control to 15mph to be safe and putting my podcasts on. It’s nice to actually get through more of them on the journey now

Why 15? Why not 10 or 5? 15 seems dizzyingly fast.

Also why listen to podcasts? You should park up in the middle of the road and get a picnic out. Wave at everyone else crawling past at 15 mph.

This place is utterly weird.

GPTec1 · 18/09/2023 10:22

DdraigGoch · 18/09/2023 09:56

the greenest car is one which is maintained and used until it is end of life

@C8H10N4O2 that's far too simplistic. If a car hardly gets used then yes, the embodied emissions in a new car would outweigh the savings from a more efficient engine. If you do high mileages on the other hand then it certainly is worth replacing.

Battery manufacture is hugely damaging & with few options for recycling, EVs also have to be large, in order to carry these heavy batteries, so we wreck roads and cause issues for cyclists etc.

The tech just isn't there yet and thats before we get onto charging infrastructure and how electricity is generated to charge.

GPTec1 · 18/09/2023 10:18

C8H10N4O2 · 18/09/2023 09:33

I'm referring to data taken from urban cycle tests which includes stopping and starting and gear changing as part of the test.

Accelerating the move to EVs will accelerate the carbon problem - the greenest car is one which is maintained and used until it is end of life. That is the point to look at replacement with EV, not because its the latest fashion statement.

For residential roads, 20mph has a strong case (along with pedestrian priority in many cases). Outside of that - not so much. To me its just a big distraction and bit of virtue signalling which fails to address the actual problem of driving quality which is the cause in most accidents on non residential roads.

Of course driving standards are the cause of almost all "accidents" i'd like to see the test improved and regular re tests too & with far greater sanctions for motorists who use their cars as little more than a weapon.

Agree on EVs, look at whats been wasted by not having better fuels and engines? Euro 6 was 8 years ago, nothing since, as we move to (the wider environmental impact of) EVs, even if they can improve local air quality.

No one needs more than a 1600cc vehicle (outside of specific sectors such as agri) with the vast majority limited to a 1l one.

DdraigGoch · 18/09/2023 09:56

the greenest car is one which is maintained and used until it is end of life

@C8H10N4O2 that's far too simplistic. If a car hardly gets used then yes, the embodied emissions in a new car would outweigh the savings from a more efficient engine. If you do high mileages on the other hand then it certainly is worth replacing.

DdraigGoch · 18/09/2023 09:52

C8H10N4O2 · 18/09/2023 08:22

I realise your ambition is simply to get rid of all cars but your argument isn't served by throwing in random claims outside of the point being discussed - ie lower speed limits in Wales.

The fact that cars are optimally efficient between 30-56mph isn't a matter to "agree on" its a fact. (And is the origin of the long running 56mph limit in parts of the US which date back to the oil crises).

The case for the 20mph limit is made largely through the medium of sadface pictures. In residential roads there is a good case for 20mph, not so much on main roads where the issue is far more likely to be poor driving. That driving is the issue to address but its much easier to publish sadface pictures and posture around making spurious claims with the backing of the anti car lobby.

If you want to start a separate thread on speed limits at the other end then yes, I do have opinions on managing larger roads as well. This thread isn't that discussion.

As a pedestrian, a cyclist, and a resident 20mph is safer for me. I realise that being contained within a metal box makes many motorists fail to consider the needs of vulnerable road users, but tough, we have rights too.

C8H10N4O2 · 18/09/2023 09:33

GPTec1 · 18/09/2023 08:33

@C8H10N4O2 We ve a new ish 30mph speed limit nr me, enforced with cameras, my car (1.5 diesel) will be in 4th gear, 1200 revs and 30mph, i tried it yesterday at 20mph, 3rd gear 1200 revs.

"Efficiency" will depend on engine size, driving style & fuel used, there is so much congestion and junctions etc etc in the UK that short periods of time spent at 20mph is going to make no difference at all, esp as we all move to EV's.

People just don't like change.

I'm referring to data taken from urban cycle tests which includes stopping and starting and gear changing as part of the test.

Accelerating the move to EVs will accelerate the carbon problem - the greenest car is one which is maintained and used until it is end of life. That is the point to look at replacement with EV, not because its the latest fashion statement.

For residential roads, 20mph has a strong case (along with pedestrian priority in many cases). Outside of that - not so much. To me its just a big distraction and bit of virtue signalling which fails to address the actual problem of driving quality which is the cause in most accidents on non residential roads.

DonnaBanana · 18/09/2023 09:31

Also it’s a speed limit not a speed target, it doesn’t mean you have to be flat out at 20 the whole time. I’ve been setting my cruise control to 15mph to be safe and putting my podcasts on. It’s nice to actually get through more of them on the journey now

Teddleshon · 18/09/2023 09:09

Personally I would rather existing speed limits were enforced, particularly in rural areas where there tend to be very few speed cameras and traffic police.

GPTec1 · 18/09/2023 08:33

@C8H10N4O2 We ve a new ish 30mph speed limit nr me, enforced with cameras, my car (1.5 diesel) will be in 4th gear, 1200 revs and 30mph, i tried it yesterday at 20mph, 3rd gear 1200 revs.

"Efficiency" will depend on engine size, driving style & fuel used, there is so much congestion and junctions etc etc in the UK that short periods of time spent at 20mph is going to make no difference at all, esp as we all move to EV's.

People just don't like change.

C8H10N4O2 · 18/09/2023 08:22

DdraigGoch · 18/09/2023 00:51

Only if you agree that permitting 70mph on motorways/dual carriageways is also polluting and we should limit to the optimum 56mph (90kph). It would be quite nice if the Irish lorries actually stuck to limits on the A55, I've clocked them doing more than 10mph over their limit.

In built-up areas you're going to get pollution from cars anyway, with all of the stopping and starting. The answer is to get rid of the cars.

Councils had the option to retain 30 limits on some roads.

I realise your ambition is simply to get rid of all cars but your argument isn't served by throwing in random claims outside of the point being discussed - ie lower speed limits in Wales.

The fact that cars are optimally efficient between 30-56mph isn't a matter to "agree on" its a fact. (And is the origin of the long running 56mph limit in parts of the US which date back to the oil crises).

The case for the 20mph limit is made largely through the medium of sadface pictures. In residential roads there is a good case for 20mph, not so much on main roads where the issue is far more likely to be poor driving. That driving is the issue to address but its much easier to publish sadface pictures and posture around making spurious claims with the backing of the anti car lobby.

If you want to start a separate thread on speed limits at the other end then yes, I do have opinions on managing larger roads as well. This thread isn't that discussion.

DdraigGoch · 18/09/2023 00:51

C8H10N4O2 · 17/09/2023 22:11

So you agree - below 30mph creates more pollution. What a long winded way of saying it.

20mph in most of Europe has been in place for more than a generation with no resultant change in car technology to shift the most carbon efficient range to be below 30mph.

There are good reasons to have 20mph and pedestrian priority in many residential roads. It isn't necessary to make stuff up to prop up the case.

Outside of residential roads the case is weaker and sad-face pictures designed to appeal to emotions are generally a sign of lack of actual evidence to support the argument.

Only if you agree that permitting 70mph on motorways/dual carriageways is also polluting and we should limit to the optimum 56mph (90kph). It would be quite nice if the Irish lorries actually stuck to limits on the A55, I've clocked them doing more than 10mph over their limit.

In built-up areas you're going to get pollution from cars anyway, with all of the stopping and starting. The answer is to get rid of the cars.

Councils had the option to retain 30 limits on some roads.

CasperGutman · 17/09/2023 22:42

What a load of nonsense. Precisely none of the M4 will have a 20 mph speed limit. I've driven the length of it from the bridge to Pont Abraham twice today. It's all still 70 mph apart from the bits wwhich already had 50 limits and one stretch of roadworks around Swansea.

And the whole "wherever there are street lights" thing is a bit of a red herring in practice. It's the same rule that theoretically applied to the 30 mph limit before, and in reality there were signs 99% of the time whenever the limit changed to 30 mph. It will be the same with the new limits. They'll just change the 30 signs to 20 ones. They can't enforce a 20 mph limit if you just passed a whacking great big "30" sign, can they?

C8H10N4O2 · 17/09/2023 22:11

DdraigGoch · 17/09/2023 11:43

Because most of the emissions data I've seen for cars shows optimal emissions somewhere between 30mph and roughly 56mph pretty solidly over the past 40 years. Below 30 and above approx 60 and emissions rise.

Gearboxes will be designed with 30mph/50kph in mind, as that's the limit in urban areas across most of Europe. As 20mph/30kph limits become more common, the gearboxes of the ICE cars still in production will be redesigned to run efficiently at the lower limit.

Never mind that though, on pollution/fuel economy grounds perhaps we need to reduce the motorway/dual carriageway speed limit to 60mph.

So you agree - below 30mph creates more pollution. What a long winded way of saying it.

20mph in most of Europe has been in place for more than a generation with no resultant change in car technology to shift the most carbon efficient range to be below 30mph.

There are good reasons to have 20mph and pedestrian priority in many residential roads. It isn't necessary to make stuff up to prop up the case.

Outside of residential roads the case is weaker and sad-face pictures designed to appeal to emotions are generally a sign of lack of actual evidence to support the argument.

Sigmama · 17/09/2023 18:58

Drivers are an impatient lot,both sure why everyone is in such a rush