Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Very naughty teen being rewarded!!

208 replies

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 12:15

My SIL took on her niece as a baby due to her mum being very ill. She's lived with her ever since. The girl is now 14 and behaving really badly. She vapes, stays out at night, has to be found and brought home by police, steals and beats up my SIL. The girl breaks stuff around the home when she doesn't get her way. She's been expelled from 2 schools already. When anyone talks to her she is full of bad attitude, swears and calls people horrid names for no reason. She had an assessment that found nothing wrong with her other than acting out. She apparently has a 31 year old boyfriend! Social services have sent her to a private school and are paying for her aunt and her to go on a nice holiday. The girl is still playing up and being awful. SIL had a black eye and cut lip just yesterday.Does anybody else think this is rewarding bad behaviour? I just can't believe this is what they do now!!

OP posts:
heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:34

SmileyClare · 16/09/2023 15:30

You’ve given an example of an adult male grooming and sexually abusing a child as an example of a “very naughty teen”

Your bigoted obnoxious views have no place on a parenting forum.

Im hoping this is just trolling.
Her dad was a sailor who went away sure.

No, I was talking about beating up my SIL, stealing etc. I went on to say that she had a much older boyfriend just to explain other things that were happening. I don't see how I'm bigoted or obnoxious for wondering how a private school and a holiday would make the girl better!

OP posts:
tolerable · 16/09/2023 15:33

@heavenhelpmenow .bet you wish you hadnt posted!!! Youve been ripped to shreds, mainly from those call you judgemental not asking questions(ie establish non res school)then make out your some sorta cold hearted nasty.
Its a funny old world.
i didnt actually think you came in unsymapathetic. Most actions by social services are questionable.
As far as school goes,i think its positive they've got her into one at all.The fact it costs money makes no difference really.shes a child and entitled to education.
The "boyfriend"is utterly vile.Even if she is a foul mouthed little witch with stinking attitude. Thats awful.
Not sure what you can actually do given updates re ss/police being "aware" -is crazy they banging on bout ban breeds of dogs but paedos are free to roam.
WHO exactly did assesment?and what for?
Attachment is always going to prelude any sorta behavioural issue-regardless of how well her home-life set up looks.
Its NOT normal "teen"behaviour to be a gobshite,aggressive,violent.
Thats utterly unacceptable-in scotland i think criminal procedures would apply.
I understand youre interpretation about rewarding her with holiday. to be honest-her poor aunt gony be in close confinement with an abusive teen doesnt exactly paint a pretty picture.
There has to be a proper safeguard plan -that includes her NOT being able to continue with the violence. She will end up some sorta institutionalised(prob cost more than fees/holiday#)and thats pretty shite given shes only 14 and obvioouusly so troubled. i think full psychiatric assesment and trauma informed is essential moving forward.

Miyagi99 · 16/09/2023 15:33

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:26

Ok but what do you expect my SIL to do? SS are aware and the police who are letting it happen! SIL is being attacked regularly and girl running off.

I’m sure she’s doing all she can and it sounds like SS are too by putting her into a specific school and paying for a holiday. Police need to pull their fingers out.

Hankunamatata · 16/09/2023 15:33

Sadly some kids gp off the rails no matter what the background. I do think your underestimating the impact of living with aunt and 'visiting mum', its not a normal set up and some kids don't cope with being different in any way

Traverseedubosphore · 16/09/2023 15:33

One of the things that could possibly make this worse for SiL is discovering a close family member has been describing her situation together with judgey comments on the internet. You might want to get the thread pulled to avoid that?

Takeachance18 · 16/09/2023 15:33

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:20

I'm really not getting the attachment issues thing. She has been with my aunt as the caregiver from 2 weeks old. She didn't build an attachment to her mum so it wasn't broken to leave my niece with issues.
My SIL can't cope with being hurt all the time, she nearly 60!

The attachment comes from knowing her aunt isn't her mum and society placing so much on how wonderful mums are. Not all adopted/ fostered children suffer this, but there are a high percentage even those who have had a stable upbringing - it can be searching for the missing.

There is the chance that there has been impacts on her development as a foetus, depending on the illness her mum had/has.

No-one should have to live with physical violence

Blueeyedmale · 16/09/2023 15:32

She's 14 and being Abused by a 31 year old man no wonder she's acting up massive safeguarding issue

NewKidOnTheBlock99 · 16/09/2023 15:32

VeridicalVagabond · 16/09/2023 15:30

No, but someone who speaks so disparagingly about a troubled child who is being sexually abused and describes the child's abuser as her "boyfriend" is probably jealous.

I hope she has a nice time on her holiday while you sit at home frothing with jealousy because a sexually abused child is getting a holiday.

This is one of the weirdest responses I’ve read on here in a long time.

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:31

Chanhedforthis · 16/09/2023 15:25

OP, why did you post here?

Do you want to help the child or not?

That wasn't my question. It was that I wanted answers to if people thought it was right to send a child to private school and give holidays in response to her behaviour. I can't help her and neither can my SIL, her caregiver, not for want of trying.

OP posts:
Blough · 16/09/2023 15:31

OP did not ask for advice. She’s indulging in rants about ‘taxpayers’, ‘liberal idiots’, social services sending people on cruises and to private schools. She’s arguing against the people pointing out the obvious child trauma etc. Vile.

titchy · 16/09/2023 15:31

Skodacool · 16/09/2023 15:07

Sorry OP, it looks as though you’ve fallen into the Mumsnet bear pit. I don’t think you’re going to get much helpful advice.

OP isn't asking for any advise though. She wants to mouth off about her privileged niece who despite being sexually abused and having a mum who she still doesnt live with, even though they have an amazing relationship, is nothing but a gobshite who should be thankful for her life.

VeridicalVagabond · 16/09/2023 15:30

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:15

Not jealous at all just amazed that SS think that going to a fancy school and having a nice holiday is going to change anything! So in your view, anyone that has a different view is jealous?

No, but someone who speaks so disparagingly about a troubled child who is being sexually abused and describes the child's abuser as her "boyfriend" is probably jealous.

I hope she has a nice time on her holiday while you sit at home frothing with jealousy because a sexually abused child is getting a holiday.

SmileyClare · 16/09/2023 15:30

You’ve given an example of an adult male grooming and sexually abusing a child as an example of a “very naughty teen”

Your bigoted obnoxious views have no place on a parenting forum.

Im hoping this is just trolling.
Her dad was a sailor who went away sure.

Yalta · 16/09/2023 15:30

I am very surprised any private school
would take her

The fighting, expulsions and the older bf are akin to my friends teen except she was assessed as having ADHD (I was similar in my teens, minus the older bf although I did get married at 17 to someone in their mid 20s) They struggles with the decision to put her on meds but when they did and she found her right dose the difference was incredible

I think that whilst her aunt has given her an idyllic childhood the fact that now she is older it is probably dawning in her that neither of her parents want her.

Nit it sure what her mother’s disability is but I suggest she is looking around and trying to replace her father figure with the older bf and her aunt is someone who “took” her from her mother

etc

TeenLifeMum · 16/09/2023 15:29

@heavenhelpmenow having a non conventional upbringing will feel like rejection. Her mum didn’t raise her like most of her peers would have been raised. I understand the reasons and it sounds like everyone did their best for the child but that doesn’t mean she can’t feel rejected.

could the mum step in and speak to her?

Stompythedinosaur · 16/09/2023 15:27

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:26

Ok but what do you expect my SIL to do? SS are aware and the police who are letting it happen! SIL is being attacked regularly and girl running off.

Assuming she has PR, she needs to explore whether a CAWN can be issued.

Stompythedinosaur · 16/09/2023 15:26

Your niece has experienced a traumatic early life, maybe attachment difficulties due to change of her carer, and is now being sexually exploited by an adult, and you choose to believe she's just a bad kid?

You are entirely in the wrong.

She also has not "had an assessment that says she is just acting out" because there is no such assessment. She may have had an assessment that says she does not have a neurodisablity, but there are other explanations.

Honestly, I can't decide whether you are just willfully ignorant regarding the difficulties she is experiencing, or just a person entirely lacking in compassion.

No one is paying for a holiday in order to encourage her challenging behaviour. I suspect it is a disruption tactic to the sexual exploitation (which most people can appreciate is the fault of the adult, not the child) with a secondary gain if strengthening her relationship with her caregiver.

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:26

Miyagi99 · 16/09/2023 15:21

She is being sexually abused as a child if she has a 31 year old ‘boyfriend’ I.E. abuser

Ok but what do you expect my SIL to do? SS are aware and the police who are letting it happen! SIL is being attacked regularly and girl running off.

OP posts:
Didimum · 16/09/2023 15:25

All behaviour is communication. You are not qualified to diagnose her as simply ‘a brat’.

Whatfreshhells · 16/09/2023 15:25

OP the tax payers money being invested in this young lady to try and keep her in education, get her exams passes, make friends with nice, normal aspirational kids her own age will all contribute to her having a much better chance at life. Do you know children in foster care cost the taxpayer thousands a month? Also the holiday is probably designed to help restore the difficult relationship they’re having and give this girl something nice to think about and do. I do not believe in punishment as a way to get kids to stay in line, because it’s pointless. They need to develop their own moral compass and make good choices for themselves.
my daughter was an absolute beast for a couple of years, it extended to damaging my home and running away and all sorts. I never threatened her, I never punished her. I never shouted at her. I just let her see the damage and hurt it caused and as she matured and developed a conscience she became the loveliest young lady you could wish to meet. This girl will likely come through this but she won’t if the relationship breaks down and she runs off to live with some bloke though.

Chanhedforthis · 16/09/2023 15:25

OP, why did you post here?

Do you want to help the child or not?

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:25

Incywincywoo · 16/09/2023 15:19

Blimey!

So this girl has an ill mother who she hasn’t been able to live with and no father.

Taken in by Aunt who can’t parent her and leaves her pray to a man who is sexually abusing her - right now. And they’re doing fa about it.

Wonderful she’s getting the opportunity at private school and a cruise coming from an underprivileged background and particularly with her current circumstances.

It strikes me the damage done to her is so severe this just may be the start of very many more dysfunctional years.

I hope for her sake the good influences she is around will help lift her out of this. And that the man is arrested with the guardians charged for their culpability in this matter.

She lived with her aunt from 2 weeks old. Her aunt is not leaving her prey at all, the girl is beating her up and running off somewhere. The police are called to find her and return her home. This 'boyfriend' has only just started and SS and police are fully aware but are allowing it to continue! What is SIL supposed to do? Perhaps in your holier than though opinion you could enlighten is! She's not from an underprivilged background at all, they are upper middle class!!

OP posts:
Miyagi99 · 16/09/2023 15:21

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 14:42

She wasn't sexually abused as a child! This is very recent and SS are doing nothing about it.

She is being sexually abused as a child if she has a 31 year old ‘boyfriend’ I.E. abuser

Goodornot · 16/09/2023 15:20

muddlingthrou · 16/09/2023 12:19

You sound v.judgmental. What happened to her mum? Her dad? Being brought up by anyone other than your bio parents would translate into feelings of rejection, I'd imagine.

14 is a very difficult age. Maybe trying to understand and help would be better than looking down on her?

So it's acceptable for her to black her aunts eye and split her lip?!

She'd be in foster care if it was me.

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:20

Takeachance18 · 16/09/2023 15:16

So your SIL has spent the last 14 years bringing up her niece, who is now physically hurting her. Sounds like therapy to deal with attachment issues than sending on a holiday where the abuse could continue would be more appropriate with a holiday at the end. The cost of fees for school, is probably less than a placement elsewhere.

I'm really not getting the attachment issues thing. She has been with my aunt as the caregiver from 2 weeks old. She didn't build an attachment to her mum so it wasn't broken to leave my niece with issues.
My SIL can't cope with being hurt all the time, she nearly 60!

OP posts: