Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Very naughty teen being rewarded!!

208 replies

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 12:15

My SIL took on her niece as a baby due to her mum being very ill. She's lived with her ever since. The girl is now 14 and behaving really badly. She vapes, stays out at night, has to be found and brought home by police, steals and beats up my SIL. The girl breaks stuff around the home when she doesn't get her way. She's been expelled from 2 schools already. When anyone talks to her she is full of bad attitude, swears and calls people horrid names for no reason. She had an assessment that found nothing wrong with her other than acting out. She apparently has a 31 year old boyfriend! Social services have sent her to a private school and are paying for her aunt and her to go on a nice holiday. The girl is still playing up and being awful. SIL had a black eye and cut lip just yesterday.Does anybody else think this is rewarding bad behaviour? I just can't believe this is what they do now!!

OP posts:
Haveagomoron · 16/09/2023 15:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:55

NewKidOnTheBlock99 · 16/09/2023 15:32

This is one of the weirdest responses I’ve read on here in a long time.

That's what social services call him! This is not about jealousy but just questioning how SS are dealing with it! There's obviously no way she can be a self entitled, spoiled girl is there? They don't exist do they? 🙄
Clearly, the abuse by this man is unacceptable but nobody is doing anything about it. I have tried and worked with the police. It's her behaviour towards my nearly 60 year old SIL that I talking about. How would you like to be beaten up because you tried to set boundaries or would not keep giving her money to buy vapes??

OP posts:
SurpriseItsMeHorseyNeighNeigh · 16/09/2023 15:55

ohdamnitjanet · 16/09/2023 15:08

Are most of you missing the bit where this girl is violent and attacking her aunt? I’ve worked in children’s homes, which is probably where she is headed, and sadly there is no easy fix for children who behave like this. She definitely needs protection from grooming, but only a secure unit can enforce this.
You can wring your hearts as much as you like, but whatever her reasons for her behaviour, if you haven’t come across children like this they can be terrifying. I have enormous sympathy for aunt who has obviously done her best when she didn’t have to. It’s a very sad situation for everyone.

OP is not asking how to help SIL navigate through the ordeal, though? She is asking if the social services are spoiling a rotten horny brat with a dream life.

If she had asked if the behaviour was inacceptable and if her SIL would be right to take steps to protect herself, she might have received a nicer answer.

MumToBeOf2 · 16/09/2023 15:52

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 14:26

She wasn't taken from her aunt, she still lives in the family home and comes home like at a state school. The exclusions were due to her bullying other kids and punching them! What on earth am I jealous of? I'm just pointing out her awful behaviour and that her childhood was idylic so she doesn't come from a terrible background.

"Her childhood was idyllic"

She's 14 and being sexually abused.

Incywincywoo · 16/09/2023 15:51

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:34

No, I was talking about beating up my SIL, stealing etc. I went on to say that she had a much older boyfriend just to explain other things that were happening. I don't see how I'm bigoted or obnoxious for wondering how a private school and a holiday would make the girl better!

Omg

This is NOT the girl’s fault.

He is NOT a boyfriend - he is a PAEDOPHILE!!! She is a CHILD.

All of her behaviour is symptomatic of that.

As for how private school may help

  1. nicer well brought up children
  2. better education/opportunities
  3. more pastoral support
  4. more security around the school - very often abusers will groom the child’s friends to get access to them and they will come and pick them up near school.

Breaking her connection with the previous school considering all of this started when she was placed there seems essential.

Perhaps the holiday is to allow her to heal and bond with her Aunt.

I hope they arrest that man. Danger to society.

MayIcarryYourSchoolBooks · 16/09/2023 15:51

Are you also 14?

Damnbrsatz · 16/09/2023 15:50

OP you've asked if it is appropriate for SS to be spending money on school fees and holidays and been told many times that it is. It would cost far more to have her in foster care.
Near us is a fee paying day school, originally a quaker school which has a small behaviour unit which takes referrals from local state schools. Maybe it is something like this. Even if not, it probably is a good move to get her away from bad influences, a fresh start, maybe improve her self esteem.
The holiday sounds like a grant from a charity where they are given a budget and able to choose a holiday. Did you know that the owner of Timpsons shoe repair gives away holidays each year to foster families and those in kinship care?
The aunt sounds like she needs your love and support, not criticism of her niece who she probably loves massively.
Everyone needs to be doing more about the 31 year old - that is terrifying

SurpriseItsMeHorseyNeighNeigh · 16/09/2023 15:49

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 14:42

She wasn't sexually abused as a child! This is very recent and SS are doing nothing about it.

Jesus take the wheel.

You come across really bad. Are you part of this young girl's life? Is she a victim of your nastiness? Could you have it in you to give her the gift to mind your own business and never contact the poor soul again? Let the social service deal with it... You are toxic.

I actually think your SIL is keeping you out of the loop and lying to you to get you off her back. If this thread is real, you are a horrible, horrible person...

0021andabit · 16/09/2023 15:48

When you say private school, is it a PRU (pupil referral unit)? Is it because they think she’d benefit from smaller class sizes?

Maybe the holiday is intended as respite for your SIL, who it sounds like needs a break.

None if what you describe sounds like a reward to me, it sounds like a targeted intervention for a kid who - for whatever reason - is clearly really struggling.

What would you rather they did? Put her in a children’s home? A young offenders unit? Would that be what your SIL would want?

Someoneonlyyouknow · 16/09/2023 15:48

Would a 14 year old choose a cruise as a holiday? Genuine question (don't think my teens would have but it was never an option for them to consider)

LusaBatoosa · 16/09/2023 15:47

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:34

No, I was talking about beating up my SIL, stealing etc. I went on to say that she had a much older boyfriend just to explain other things that were happening. I don't see how I'm bigoted or obnoxious for wondering how a private school and a holiday would make the girl better!

What do you think would make her better?

Schoolmumeroo · 16/09/2023 15:45

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:13

It was 2 weeks after she was born so doesn't apply.

Could absolutely apply

Gilmorehill · 16/09/2023 15:45

xyz111 · 16/09/2023 15:39

Just because she moves in with her aunt at 2 weeks old, doesn't mean she doesn't have attachment issues. She might still feel rejected as she doesn't have a "normal" relationship with your mum. Relationship issues with parents affects even adults, let alone a child. Children aren't naughty for no reason. Has she had therapy? She probably feels she's going down this slippery slope and can't stop and needs help. She might see if her mum didn't want her, the schools don't want her. And how she's being preyed on by a man that is showing her "he wants her" so of course she's drawn to him. I feel extremely sorry for her.

Exactly. The Op clearly knows about children.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 16/09/2023 15:41

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:11

I'm not saying she doesn't need any help, what i'm saying is that private school and a holiday won't change anything and is at the expense of the taxpayer. I'm not at all nasty and bitter, I'm just don't think this is going to help and a waste of time. I don't believe she has suffered from her mum being ill or anything else in her life that's my point. I have contacted the police about the grooming but they are not doing anything. I am allowed an opinion that the approach is wrong. Its ok to have a difference of opinion without being insulted and called bitter, jealous and nasty!

To be frank, I’d imagine that social service have far more experience and expertise in dealing with troubled children than you. Particularly since only a few post ago you were referring to her abuser as her ‘boyfriend’.

Purpleboat · 16/09/2023 15:41

I do agree that her behaviour is unacceptable, and without seeing what else SS are doing, paying for a holiday for your aunt to deal with her on a cruise without a support network does not appear to be the best course of action.
I would have thought relationship therapy for both of them and a holiday as a reward for an improvement in behaviour might be better for both parties.
I do think she will be aware she has had a non-conventional upbringing and that should be explored with her to support her to accept it. Also, the older BF is a disaster waiting to happen. Your aunt is in an impossible position if SS are permitting it.
Again without knowing all the facts, could she not have stayed with her biological mother with lots of support from your aunt?I guess it’s somewhat irrelevant now 14 years later.
I certainly think your aunt needs support, dealing with this is tough and lots of other people would have given up. It takes a very special person to raise someone else’s child.

Miyagi99 · 16/09/2023 15:41

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:34

No, I was talking about beating up my SIL, stealing etc. I went on to say that she had a much older boyfriend just to explain other things that were happening. I don't see how I'm bigoted or obnoxious for wondering how a private school and a holiday would make the girl better!

Certain private schools can definitely help, they’ll have more focus on the issues, engagement, smaller classes and often (unfortunately for public schools) more qualified teachers and resources. The holiday we don’t know enough about, that’s not the usual so there must be specific reasons for this, maybe more aimed at your Sil. I don’t think these are steps to ‘make her better’ rather trying to improve their relationship. Her behaviour is out of order but it’s for a myriad of reasons which you listed. It doesn’t matter how great her childhood has been, she was brought up by someone who isn’t her mother and she doesn’t know her Dad, that’s where the feelings of rejection and resentment will come from no matter how amazing your sil has been.

Littlefish · 16/09/2023 15:40

Damnbrsatz · 16/09/2023 14:22

It doesn't matter if she had a lovely upbringing and a stable home with her aunt, who I am sure is lovely. She has still suffered trauma, the neural pathways in her brain would have stopped developing when she was removed from her primary caretaker, from her mother, from the only person she, as a baby, had a bond with. Now, those pathways can be rebuilt but the trauma is still there. We are only just beginning to learn how early detachment from a mother, in whose womb they've grown, heard her voice for 9 months etc can affect people their whole lives.

Agreed

FizzyWizard · 16/09/2023 15:40

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:31

That wasn't my question. It was that I wanted answers to if people thought it was right to send a child to private school and give holidays in response to her behaviour. I can't help her and neither can my SIL, her caregiver, not for want of trying.

Yes, it can be.

If she has an EHCP (which she may well for SEMH needs) then the Local Authority may fund a private school if it will meet her needs especially if it works out cheaper than a special school, which it may well do. This isn't a reward for her behaviour, it's finding a school which will meet her needs.

Holidays are usually under the header of "respite" although I've never heard of an LA funding a cruise before. Respite isn't a reward for her behaviour, it's breathing space away from the area and the family home.

If respite and a named independent school would serve to keep this child with her family then the LA are right to fund it.

I am not surprised that they will pull out all the stops if there is a risk of a child otherwise going into s.20 care.

I am very surprised if the help offered hasn't also included a family support worker, referral to CAMHS, therapy / counselling and so on, because that is where they would usually start.

You sound very judgemental. If I were your SIL I'd be paying for the private school and cruise and telling you they were funded by the LA just to watch you fume. Are you sure that's not a possibility here? A cruise sounds particularly unlikely. The school like I say could well be named on an EHCP.

Incywincywoo · 16/09/2023 15:39

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:25

She lived with her aunt from 2 weeks old. Her aunt is not leaving her prey at all, the girl is beating her up and running off somewhere. The police are called to find her and return her home. This 'boyfriend' has only just started and SS and police are fully aware but are allowing it to continue! What is SIL supposed to do? Perhaps in your holier than though opinion you could enlighten is! She's not from an underprivilged background at all, they are upper middle class!!

@heavenhelpmenow

Inclined to agree with others that you’re not actually here to help the child and don’t give a stuff about her as you have railed against anyone who isn’t in agreement with you about her being a spoilt little madam.

The Aunt is leaving her prey if she cannot parent her or meet her needs. It’s quite clear she can’t as she has totally come off the rails, her behaviour is abominable and she is in increasingly dangerous situations that she should not be in.

SIL should be asking for more outside help, perhaps even a male relative about the house to help try and put in boundaries and discipline. The girl needs therapy- urgently, she is under control of the paedophile and this may have been going on some time. Very often girls like this have had prior experiences of rape and abuse which normalise the behaviour to them and open the gateway for more. I can’t help but feel that the abnormal parental set up has left her vulnerable and it definitely sounds, if she is striking out and such, that she can’t communicate what is going on effectively. Or can’t face up to it. Her behaviour is very typical of abuse victims.

I don’t get why that isn’t your primary concern. This is horrendous and it may have already utterly ruined her life.

And don’t be bloody ridiculous - if she was upper middle class she would already be in private school and going on nice holidays. Or it wouldn’t be such a “thing” to you.

In any event she has no active parents and is being molested which sounds pretty underprivileged to me.

xyz111 · 16/09/2023 15:39

Just because she moves in with her aunt at 2 weeks old, doesn't mean she doesn't have attachment issues. She might still feel rejected as she doesn't have a "normal" relationship with your mum. Relationship issues with parents affects even adults, let alone a child. Children aren't naughty for no reason. Has she had therapy? She probably feels she's going down this slippery slope and can't stop and needs help. She might see if her mum didn't want her, the schools don't want her. And how she's being preyed on by a man that is showing her "he wants her" so of course she's drawn to him. I feel extremely sorry for her.

Littlefish · 16/09/2023 15:38

titchy · 16/09/2023 12:27

So to clarify, an extremely vulnerable child is being sexually abused, has a very unstable home life and a guardian who cannot safely parent her. SS have removed her from that environment and placed her in a residential school in order to keep her safe.

And you think that's a bad thing? Fuck me Hmm

Excellent summation of the situation.

Blough · 16/09/2023 15:38

@NewKidOnTheBlock99 The OP is the nastiest poster on the thread, by far.

SmileyClare · 16/09/2023 15:37

Sorry I’m not engaging with this goady nonsense.

An adult abusing a child is never a “boyfriend “ don’t be bloody ridiculous, there’s no excuse for your attitude. It stinks.

I guess you’d like to see this girl “taught a lesson” rather than supported by social services.

DinnaeFashYersel · 16/09/2023 15:37

ohdamnitjanet · 16/09/2023 15:08

Are most of you missing the bit where this girl is violent and attacking her aunt? I’ve worked in children’s homes, which is probably where she is headed, and sadly there is no easy fix for children who behave like this. She definitely needs protection from grooming, but only a secure unit can enforce this.
You can wring your hearts as much as you like, but whatever her reasons for her behaviour, if you haven’t come across children like this they can be terrifying. I have enormous sympathy for aunt who has obviously done her best when she didn’t have to. It’s a very sad situation for everyone.

Not missing that at all.

The attacks in the aunt are further evidence of the need for intervention to support the whole family.

Secure accommodation is the last resort though and can only be applied in specific circumstances - which she is not far off from.

There are other steps that need to be tried first before she meets the criteria for secure.

That's not hand wringing.

What is distasteful is the OP calling this girl a brat and going on about rewards when there's clearly a vulnerable young girl in trouble. Being abused and possibly raped. Definitely suffering.

NewKidOnTheBlock99 · 16/09/2023 15:36

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 15:34

No, I was talking about beating up my SIL, stealing etc. I went on to say that she had a much older boyfriend just to explain other things that were happening. I don't see how I'm bigoted or obnoxious for wondering how a private school and a holiday would make the girl better!

I feel sorry for you OP and hope you are ok as I think alot of people are being unnecessarily nasty to you!!