Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Very naughty teen being rewarded!!

208 replies

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 12:15

My SIL took on her niece as a baby due to her mum being very ill. She's lived with her ever since. The girl is now 14 and behaving really badly. She vapes, stays out at night, has to be found and brought home by police, steals and beats up my SIL. The girl breaks stuff around the home when she doesn't get her way. She's been expelled from 2 schools already. When anyone talks to her she is full of bad attitude, swears and calls people horrid names for no reason. She had an assessment that found nothing wrong with her other than acting out. She apparently has a 31 year old boyfriend! Social services have sent her to a private school and are paying for her aunt and her to go on a nice holiday. The girl is still playing up and being awful. SIL had a black eye and cut lip just yesterday.Does anybody else think this is rewarding bad behaviour? I just can't believe this is what they do now!!

OP posts:
SurpriseItsMeHorseyNeighNeigh · 16/09/2023 17:27

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 17:26

You're telling me to stop doing things then go on to tell me what to do - hypocrite!

No. Stay away from the girl.

Send the link to your SIL then let her deal with it.

But let's be honest, there is no SIL, is there? You are just here because life is boring and you want to pick a fight on Mumsnet ;)

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 17:26

SurpriseItsMeHorseyNeighNeigh · 16/09/2023 17:16

That's kinda funny that you expect a 14 years old to understand when being explained. But you, yourself, can't understand attachment disorder when being explained....

There, read this. https://www.healthline.com/health/reactive-attachment-disorder-in-teenager#signs-and-symptoms

Tell your SIL to find someone specialising in reactive attachment disorder and explore that avenue. And get down of your judgemental high horse and stop raging about a private schools and free holidays that you probably misunderstood anyway.

You're telling me to stop doing things then go on to tell me what to do - hypocrite!

OP posts:
heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 17:23

LolaSmiles · 16/09/2023 17:13

Her childhood was a bit over indulged but nothing more.
Except not being raised by her parent(s), which is a major adverse childhood experience.

Your absolute insistence that she's just an overindulged brat who shouldn't have nice things is really quite concerning.

Adverse Childhood Experiences have an impact on children as they grow up. It has an impact on a child's social, emotional and mental health over time.
Trauma doesn't always show up straight away.

I can't understand why an adult who knows a vulnerable child would be so wedded to the idea that they're a spoilt brat rather than the multitude of other evidence-informed explanations.

Never once said she shouldn't have nice things.....

OP posts:
heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 17:21

lifeturnsonadime · 16/09/2023 17:11

If nobody explains to her about her entitled behaviour then how does she learn?

What entitled behaviour?

You seem to think she is behaving like a 'brat' because you think she has had a good upbringing (despite what many on here are explaining about attachment disorder and abuse).

It's bad behaviour, but nothing about it strikes me of coming from a place of entitlement. The child needs help and to learn about appropriate ways of communicating distress certainly but not to be punished for being 'bratty'.

Entitled behaviour - battering her aunt when she won't do what she wants?
Putting her foot through the television?
Kicking and hitting the dog?
Expecting money any time she asks? Stealing if its not given?
Saying she can do whatever she likes and no-one can stop her? Then going off and doing it....
She has been explained to that this behaviour is wrong but she doesn't care...

OP posts:
SurpriseItsMeHorseyNeighNeigh · 16/09/2023 17:16

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 17:08

I can only say what I have seen nothingcomestonothing. Her childhood was a bit over indulged but nothing more. If nobody explains to her about her entitled behaviour then how does she learn? At 14 she can understand how her behaviour impacts others and not having any remorse ever is not right. She does need to understand these things if she's going to get over whatever it is that's affecting her.

That's kinda funny that you expect a 14 years old to understand when being explained. But you, yourself, can't understand attachment disorder when being explained....

There, read this. https://www.healthline.com/health/reactive-attachment-disorder-in-teenager#signs-and-symptoms

Tell your SIL to find someone specialising in reactive attachment disorder and explore that avenue. And get down of your judgemental high horse and stop raging about a private schools and free holidays that you probably misunderstood anyway.

LolaSmiles · 16/09/2023 17:13

Her childhood was a bit over indulged but nothing more.
Except not being raised by her parent(s), which is a major adverse childhood experience.

Your absolute insistence that she's just an overindulged brat who shouldn't have nice things is really quite concerning.

Adverse Childhood Experiences have an impact on children as they grow up. It has an impact on a child's social, emotional and mental health over time.
Trauma doesn't always show up straight away.

I can't understand why an adult who knows a vulnerable child would be so wedded to the idea that they're a spoilt brat rather than the multitude of other evidence-informed explanations.

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 17:12

Nomoremarchingtalcumpowder · 16/09/2023 17:07

Poor kid. Yes I can see why you are angry at your SIL as far as you can she is suffering as well.

But your anger is misplaced towards the "brat" 🙄.

Trauma can take years to come out.

Also she cannot have a 31yr old BF!

Could the link between your SIL getting older and maybe fearing it.

Also she will be at a teenage stage of hormones where teenagers naturally rebel against their parents. But in this case she can't do that as she doesn't live with them.

She will see, hear and absorb traditional nuclear families all over social media and that must be incredibly traumatic for her.

I'm not saying her physically assaulting SIL is right. But the context is incredibly important.

Certainly have no anger towards SIL just recognising that over indulgence can lead to entitled behaviour during the teens. I do feel some resentment towards the girl yes, imagine seeing your SIL's face bruised and marked and the sadness. So many people judging on here 😒

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 16/09/2023 17:11

If nobody explains to her about her entitled behaviour then how does she learn?

What entitled behaviour?

You seem to think she is behaving like a 'brat' because you think she has had a good upbringing (despite what many on here are explaining about attachment disorder and abuse).

It's bad behaviour, but nothing about it strikes me of coming from a place of entitlement. The child needs help and to learn about appropriate ways of communicating distress certainly but not to be punished for being 'bratty'.

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 17:08

nothingcomestonothing · 16/09/2023 16:41

You've no idea whether any other posters have to deal with this kind of behaviour day in day out. I have an adopted 15 year old, I can readily understand some of what's going on here. Unlike the OP, who just seems to see this child as a spoiled brat.

I can only say what I have seen nothingcomestonothing. Her childhood was a bit over indulged but nothing more. If nobody explains to her about her entitled behaviour then how does she learn? At 14 she can understand how her behaviour impacts others and not having any remorse ever is not right. She does need to understand these things if she's going to get over whatever it is that's affecting her.

OP posts:
Nomoremarchingtalcumpowder · 16/09/2023 17:07

Poor kid. Yes I can see why you are angry at your SIL as far as you can she is suffering as well.

But your anger is misplaced towards the "brat" 🙄.

Trauma can take years to come out.

Also she cannot have a 31yr old BF!

Could the link between your SIL getting older and maybe fearing it.

Also she will be at a teenage stage of hormones where teenagers naturally rebel against their parents. But in this case she can't do that as she doesn't live with them.

She will see, hear and absorb traditional nuclear families all over social media and that must be incredibly traumatic for her.

I'm not saying her physically assaulting SIL is right. But the context is incredibly important.

LolaSmiles · 16/09/2023 17:04

the sexual abuse isn't a separate issue!!!! Its all mixed together. If she wasn't being groomed and sexually exploited by this man then possibly her behaviour would be better. She's taking her anger and frustrations out on the one person she knows loves her.
This!
A child being groomed by an older man is not separate to the trauma and adverse childhood experience(s).

Then again it seems that the OP's view is to lock children like this up, give them a bit of counselling and don't do anything remotely positive to improve their educational and social prospects in case the little 'brats' have a positive experience once in a while.

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 17:03

aintnothinbutagstring · 16/09/2023 16:46

I presume it is the LEA that are paying for the school not social services. What type of private school is it? That are lots of private schools for SEN, SEMH etc. It could be that the school was put forward as a suggestion when trying to find her a new placement - where it seems a regular state secondary is not meeting her needs. Permanent exclusion doesn't happen willy nilly - your niece sounds like she needs a lot of help, swift interventions to get her education back on track. Even so-called 'naughty' or 'spoilt, entitled' children as you OP would put it, have the right to an education, and it may be the case that their educational setting may cost the taxpayer a bit more than other children - if that means they are able to obtain some qualifications and contribute to society then surely that it is a good thing.

It's a fee paying private school like Eton. Thank you for a logical answer that's not littered with emotions and insults!

OP posts:
heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 17:00

HarrietSchulenberg · 16/09/2023 16:53

Being perm exed from 2 state schools makes her unlikely to accepted by a 3rd. The options would have been for a PRU or the private school and children's services clearly felt that investing in her education was a better option than the PRU.
What would your ideal outcome be here, OP?

I don't think she should be living with my SIL due to the risk of harm. I also believe that the police and SS should be doing something to protect her so maybe some kind of unit that she can't just leave when she feels like it. This is not punishment but for her own safety. She can then have counselling or some sort of classes to find out why this is happening.

OP posts:
heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 16:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What do you want me to do???? Police and SS know! You clearly have all the answers so lets hear them? Aside from going off and murdering the man there isn't much else if the professionals arne't doing anything.

OP posts:
00100001 · 16/09/2023 16:53

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 14:42

She wasn't sexually abused as a child! This is very recent and SS are doing nothing about it.

errrrr...she's 14 with a 31 yo BF.

That's a child being sexually abused...

HarrietSchulenberg · 16/09/2023 16:53

Being perm exed from 2 state schools makes her unlikely to accepted by a 3rd. The options would have been for a PRU or the private school and children's services clearly felt that investing in her education was a better option than the PRU.
What would your ideal outcome be here, OP?

heavenhelpmenow · 16/09/2023 16:51

SmileyClare · 16/09/2023 16:35

In light of the fact that this child has only had issues for a few months, The main issue appears to be her being groomed and abused by a paedophile- including her staying out all night and having violent outbursts.

At least after 7 pages of comments you are now calling him an abuser.

One clear way to help your niece is to gather evidence against this man to take to the police; including any phone or online communication from him.

Folding your arms and tutting about social services’ involvement on chat forums isn’t a great look. The whole tone of this thread is off.

I get the impression you think she’s a naughty girl who deserves a good hiding.

Of course he's an abuser! Even SS were calling him a boyfriend, its just a figure of speech and no way intended to normalise things ffs.
Of course we have tried working with the police and SS about this man. They know all about it and at the moment are doing absolutely nothing. Your ideas about SS and police seem to hark back to an earlier time. One day if you ever need them, you would discover this.
I would never condone anybody giving a child a good hiding so your impression is wrong. I just failed to see the benefit of sending her to another school but having read others messages, I am starting to understand. Why is it off to critisize SS?? They are regularly critisized in the media and by many people who haven't felt helped by them.

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 16/09/2023 16:49

And I agree that you'd all be giving different responses if you had to deal with this kind of behaviour day in, day out 😣

I have had to deal with this kind of behaviour from my own child when his mental health was at an all time low due to undiagnosed SEN .

Most children don't want to be bad, and that includes teenagers and the behaviour is a method of communicating that something is wrong.

Punishing my child would have made behaviours worse. For children whose poor behaviour is due to mental health issues, sen or abuse punishment is the worst thing you can do. They need support to fix the problem then the behaviour improves.

That's what happened with my son.

People on here would have had him criminalised. He was 10 at the time he was lashing out at me and damaging our property. This girl is only 4 years older.

aintnothinbutagstring · 16/09/2023 16:46

I presume it is the LEA that are paying for the school not social services. What type of private school is it? That are lots of private schools for SEN, SEMH etc. It could be that the school was put forward as a suggestion when trying to find her a new placement - where it seems a regular state secondary is not meeting her needs. Permanent exclusion doesn't happen willy nilly - your niece sounds like she needs a lot of help, swift interventions to get her education back on track. Even so-called 'naughty' or 'spoilt, entitled' children as you OP would put it, have the right to an education, and it may be the case that their educational setting may cost the taxpayer a bit more than other children - if that means they are able to obtain some qualifications and contribute to society then surely that it is a good thing.

nothingcomestonothing · 16/09/2023 16:41

MrsJBaptiste · 16/09/2023 16:36

Not really... 40% of people agree with @heavenhelpmenow

And I agree that you'd all be giving different responses if you had to deal with this kind of behaviour day in, day out 😣

You've no idea whether any other posters have to deal with this kind of behaviour day in day out. I have an adopted 15 year old, I can readily understand some of what's going on here. Unlike the OP, who just seems to see this child as a spoiled brat.

Incywincywoo · 16/09/2023 16:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Lahdedahiam · 16/09/2023 16:40

You sound awful and should be ashamed of yourself!

nothingcomestonothing · 16/09/2023 16:37

There is nothing in her upbringing to have caused this at all

There have been NO problems in her childhood at all. She's just a brat!

How can people be this clueless about attachment? OP you should be ashamed of yourself for the way you view this child. And I venture to suggest that your SIL probably doesn't find you very helpful, if this is the attitude you display towards the troubled child she is trying to parent. Your judgement and lack of understanding is palpable.

MrsJBaptiste · 16/09/2023 16:36

JassyRadlett · 16/09/2023 16:18

OP: AIBU?

Overwhelming majority of thread: Yes. Here is your arse.

OP: You're all liberal lefty clueless woke snowflakes! What would you know anyway? This girl used to be lovely and this behaviour has come out of nowhere and there can DEFINITELY be no other reasons for it than she's a brat!

Not really... 40% of people agree with @heavenhelpmenow

And I agree that you'd all be giving different responses if you had to deal with this kind of behaviour day in, day out 😣

SmileyClare · 16/09/2023 16:35

In light of the fact that this child has only had issues for a few months, The main issue appears to be her being groomed and abused by a paedophile- including her staying out all night and having violent outbursts.

At least after 7 pages of comments you are now calling him an abuser.

One clear way to help your niece is to gather evidence against this man to take to the police; including any phone or online communication from him.

Folding your arms and tutting about social services’ involvement on chat forums isn’t a great look. The whole tone of this thread is off.

I get the impression you think she’s a naughty girl who deserves a good hiding.

Swipe left for the next trending thread