Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it acceptable for a teacher to punish a child by making them stand facing the wall?

233 replies

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 10:43

Some context: I'm in France. Schools here are about 30 years behind the UK, however, there are rules (that many teachers just ignore) about what they are/are not allowed to do. Because I'm not in the UK I would really like some perspective on what is and isn't acceptable. French parents went through a harsh system themselves and because of that seem very blasé about any form of discipline that isn't obviously violent!

Anyway, my son is in a mixed class with ages from 5-8, 13 in total. School started two weeks ago and my son told me that in that time he and two others have had to stand facing the wall as a punishment. My son is confused about why but his friend told his mum that it was because DS kept answering questions without putting his hand up, which I can imagine being the case: he struggles not to blurt out his thoughts at the best of times. Another 7-year-old has had to stand there twice, my DS says for fidgeting and "being naughty" along with one of the girls in the class. Is this acceptable in UK schools? AIBU to want to take this up with the head and the mayor (mayors are the ultimate heads of the school here)?

OP posts:
BoohooWoohoo · 16/09/2023 11:19

If you are going to punish a child then they should
know why they are being punished so that they can reflect on the behaviour that led to the punishment.

I hope that you get some answers from people in France but they don't use facing the wall punishment in English schools. I don't think that you should use the England excuse in France though- why would they care about what happens in other countries? Behaviour in English schools are at an all time low so I wouldn't use them as a role model.

Facing the wall doesn't help calling out - he can presumably hear the lesson so could still call out the answers anyway. How did his previous teachers deal with it ? Were their methods more effective ?

user1846385927482658 · 16/09/2023 11:18

BetterBee · 16/09/2023 11:10

The reason why this is not okay is because it’s a form of humiliation. She can achieve the same effect by making him stand out side the classroom (time out, time to reflect, not reaction from peers etc).

How is kicking a child out of the classroom entirely any less "humiliating"?

Surely by its very nature any punishment is going to provoke negative emotions - even if it's just disappointment at making a mistake - they're an unavoidable and necessary part of human experience.

Pleaseme · 16/09/2023 11:17

I remember having to do this in school in the 80s. Wouldn’t be acceptable in the Uk nowadays but I assume different rules in France.

tsmainsqueeze · 16/09/2023 11:15

As a mother of 3 i am not a pushover when it comes to 'bad' behaviour but i think this is unacceptable.
As a very young child i was punished this way at a pre school play group run by an absolute tyrant of a woman , she would not have got away with her behaviour today.
I clearly remember being made to stand in a corner facing the wall ,i remember the smell of a big wooden cupboard that was nearby , i remember feeling fear and humiliation and not knowing what to do.
I don't think i was a badly behaved child so i assume it was probably for something fairly trivial ,the punishments this woman dished out are clear in my mind over 50 years later.
So i don't think you are being unreasonable ,of course negative behaviour needs addressing but no adult should treat a child like that.

Distinguishedandmature · 16/09/2023 11:15

They used to do that in my primary school. I thought they still did this.

Somaliwildass · 16/09/2023 11:15

It definitely would and does happen in the UK. Sometimes children need to be removed from the situation and there's nowhere for them to go where supervised. Standing and facing away from others is hardly harming them. If they can't sit at the table, join in and be generally considerate of others after reminders, warnings and cajoling, then for the wellbeing of everyone, sometimes disruptions have to be taken away.

Sundaefraise · 16/09/2023 11:15

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 11:12

Well, in that case we're talking about much more serious physical and abusive punishments that are illegal today. The details of historic abuses in French schools aren't relevant to my question, which is basically, is this acceptable in UK schools? (I realise I am in France, it's a different system, etc...[

It’s not acceptable in UK schools, but I’m honestly not sure why that matters, unless you plan to come back to the UK. My sister teaches in France and the whole system is vastly different - you’re not going to change that.

Goodornot · 16/09/2023 11:13

Totaly · 16/09/2023 10:51

No it wouldn’t be acceptable in an English school - but you aren’t in England.

It's also why French children are better behaved than the UK.

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 11:12

NunsKnickers · 16/09/2023 11:06

That's not what I'm referring to. You said that French adults are suffering from trauma as a result of their schooling.

Well, in that case we're talking about much more serious physical and abusive punishments that are illegal today. The details of historic abuses in French schools aren't relevant to my question, which is basically, is this acceptable in UK schools? (I realise I am in France, it's a different system, etc...[

OP posts:
Yoyoban · 16/09/2023 11:11

I think the most important thing is that you help your son to understand why it happened. To which end I would be going to talk to the teacher, explaining that your son doesn't understand what he did wrong, find out the reason and discuss general expectations of classroom behaviour then going through that with your son so he is clear on what the expectations are.

The not knowing the reason will undoubtedly be causing more anxiety, because how can he possibly modify his behaviour to prevent it happening again if he doesn't understand what he did wrong.

Depending on what the reason given is then you will also then be able to judge whether it's a reasonable expectation and response from the teacher or overly harsh/unrealistic for his age.

I would also discuss your son's history with the teacher and open a discussion on how you and they can ensure your son behaves in the classroom and isn't disruptive, but without triggering his anxiety.

BetterBee · 16/09/2023 11:10

The reason why this is not okay is because it’s a form of humiliation. She can achieve the same effect by making him stand out side the classroom (time out, time to reflect, not reaction from peers etc).

NunsKnickers · 16/09/2023 11:06

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 11:01

He already suffered trauma at a previous school. It's taken 12 months and alot of patience and understanding to get him back into school full time.

That's not what I'm referring to. You said that French adults are suffering from trauma as a result of their schooling.

user1846385927482658 · 16/09/2023 11:06

I'm not sure I follow why standing against a wall would be traumatic?

What would you consider an acceptable measure if he is interrupting the class?

user1492757084 · 16/09/2023 11:06

Pros (for the teacher)
Child faces away from little friends who might be egging on any impolite behaviour and doesn't giggle or interact with any naughty kids for a minute or two.
Child reflects on correcting his ways.
Child who is blurting out gets to not answer a few questions while the other kids have a turn.
Child's face is not looking at class nor seeing any negative feedback from classmates.
Next time child considers doing the antisocial communication they remember that they might have to take time out.

I see it like a naughty corner strategy which some families employ.

TheMountainsCall · 16/09/2023 11:05

Well, it was fine in my day. I never had this particular punishment but I remember others did, and they had to stand with their nose touching the board inside a chalk circle the teacher had drawn. I don't think this would fly today.

I doubt any kid would be traumatised by having to stand facing the wall for a bit (without the extra described above) but I don't think it would generally be okay in this day and age.

BonnieLisbon · 16/09/2023 11:02

You'd be better off asking French people as saying to the school/mayor that it wouldn't happen in England won't help. It doesn't seem bad to me but then I was at primary in the 70s and there was corporal punishment so my opinions are probably skewed by that

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 11:01

NunsKnickers · 16/09/2023 10:56

I doubt that standing facing a wall is going to lead to trauma...

He already suffered trauma at a previous school. It's taken 12 months and alot of patience and understanding to get him back into school full time.

OP posts:
Jeschara · 16/09/2023 10:59

You need to speak to your son about disrupting lessons, he is not the only child in the class. He is lucky to be in a a class if 13.

You are in France, they have a different discipline system to the UK, you need to accept this, they will not change the system for your son.

NunsKnickers · 16/09/2023 10:56

I doubt that standing facing a wall is going to lead to trauma...

user1492757084 · 16/09/2023 10:56

Give it another week or two.

I think many teachers start a new year by really enforcing politeness rules and also many kids start a new year with a new teacher by trying hard to test the boundaries. It's likely that the teacher will relax when she and the children trust each other's behaviour.. Worst of all would be if the teacher had no control of the class.
Standing facing the wall for brief periods, for logical reasons and after a warning seems okay however you are right to contact a teacher for anything that bothers you.

Starlightstarbright2 · 16/09/2023 10:55

Somaliwildass · 16/09/2023 10:49

Teach you son not to call our and interrupt. In a class of 13, he will have plenty of chance to contribute, but it's the teacher's decision who answers what to ensure everyone is learning.

How exactly has he been badly impacted by facing a wall?

I'm sure the rest of the class were able to get on better while he wasn't blurting things out, seeking attention and monopolising the teacher's time.

I do disppair of this place sometimes .. my D’s has adhd and does that he manages it far better as he has got older. I am not suggesting this child has adhd just sometimes it isn’t as simple as teaching them .

no it wouldn’t happen in the uk but no idea what is normal for France

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 10:54

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 16/09/2023 10:52

It wouldn't be acceptable in the UK but as you're not in the UK I'm not sure how helpful that is - especially when you acknowledge the French system is very different to what you're used to.

I just want some perspective regarding my reaction. It's not allowed here but culturally most people just suck it up. Probably because they have never recovered from the trauma they suffered at school due to harsh discipline!

OP posts:
PixiePirate · 16/09/2023 10:53

Do they have a behaviour policy?

I think I’d try to understand if this is unusual for the school or a cultural norm in France.

I’d also work with my child to encourage them to behave with respect in class to minimise any future occurrences.

OneMoreStepAlongTheRoadIGo · 16/09/2023 10:53

No not at all okay but we're not in France...

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 16/09/2023 10:52

It wouldn't be acceptable in the UK but as you're not in the UK I'm not sure how helpful that is - especially when you acknowledge the French system is very different to what you're used to.