Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it acceptable for a teacher to punish a child by making them stand facing the wall?

233 replies

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 10:43

Some context: I'm in France. Schools here are about 30 years behind the UK, however, there are rules (that many teachers just ignore) about what they are/are not allowed to do. Because I'm not in the UK I would really like some perspective on what is and isn't acceptable. French parents went through a harsh system themselves and because of that seem very blasé about any form of discipline that isn't obviously violent!

Anyway, my son is in a mixed class with ages from 5-8, 13 in total. School started two weeks ago and my son told me that in that time he and two others have had to stand facing the wall as a punishment. My son is confused about why but his friend told his mum that it was because DS kept answering questions without putting his hand up, which I can imagine being the case: he struggles not to blurt out his thoughts at the best of times. Another 7-year-old has had to stand there twice, my DS says for fidgeting and "being naughty" along with one of the girls in the class. Is this acceptable in UK schools? AIBU to want to take this up with the head and the mayor (mayors are the ultimate heads of the school here)?

OP posts:
Greensleeves · 16/09/2023 12:39

Neither I nor any of the teachers I know would consider doing this; it's completely outdated and inappropriate. I don't know whether it's common practice in France but I would certainly raise an objection.

I see the "didn't do me any harm" brigade have arrived. Personally, as a child living with daily abuse at home, I found it terrifying to be made to face the wall at school. Being able to hear people while being prevented from seeing them was a nightmare. The humiliation was a secondary factor.

AnnaMagnani · 16/09/2023 12:39

We had to do that in my prep school. TBH it was about the only punishment there that wasn't traumatic as there was also corporal punishment and verbal humiliation.

I was a v gobby child too but as the rules were consistent I and everyone else learned to put our hands up and be quiet.

Ramalangadingdong · 16/09/2023 12:35

Children should be disciplined but not like this. What does a child learn from it except to “respect” and fear bullies.

brightdayloomingdark · 16/09/2023 12:35

It was normal when I was that age, four decades ago, but not now. And those reasons fidgeting and not putting his hand up, are appalling. I would not be happy. Those reasons weren’t used for punishment even in my day!

JudgeJ · 16/09/2023 12:33

Probably because they have never recovered from the trauma they suffered at school due to harsh discipline!

Harsh discipline? Maybe you object to any form of discipline! Hardly 'traumatic', a word few on this site understand.

Iusedtoliveinsanfrancisco · 16/09/2023 12:32

If the consequences of specific bits of disruptive behaviour are made clear to all pupils and this rule is used fairly then I think it’s for you to explain to your child that such rules are needed for the lesson to
be fair to all pupils.

JudgeJ · 16/09/2023 12:31

Somaliwildass · 16/09/2023 10:49

Teach you son not to call our and interrupt. In a class of 13, he will have plenty of chance to contribute, but it's the teacher's decision who answers what to ensure everyone is learning.

How exactly has he been badly impacted by facing a wall?

I'm sure the rest of the class were able to get on better while he wasn't blurting things out, seeking attention and monopolising the teacher's time.

Exactly! It's the MN mantra that children should not be 'punished' for their yobbish behaviour, better that they are 'understood' and to hell with the children who actually want to learn. For those who are attacking the French school's discipline mode what would you do with the gobby littlescotes interfering with your lesson?

Ramalangadingdong · 16/09/2023 12:29

I would ask all of you to try it for yourselves. Go and stand in front of a wall without turning around, sitting down or fidgeting. Put your timer on for 5/10 mins then tell me what it was like.

Now imagine a 5 year old having to do that. During a whole lesson. In front of classmates and a power wielding teacher.

Hollyhead · 16/09/2023 12:25

It depends, if it’s to just get them out the way to diffuse a situation I think it’s quite effective - I use it with my dc when they’re fighting and I want it broken up. I don’t think it really sounds appropriate for the situation you describe.

Flatandhappy · 16/09/2023 12:23

I have no idea why you are asking UK based parents if this punishment would be ok in the UK system because it is absolutely irrelevant. Most people will agree that we think it is pretty archaic, you are in France where different norms apply. I have a French MIL who has lived in the UK for most of her adult life because she didn’t want to live in what she perceives as a very conservative culture (she is in her 80s and still thinks that). You have to go with the system you are in or move elsewhere if you are unhappy. One thing is definite, the French education system will not change for you.

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 16/09/2023 12:21

I don’t see what’s humiliating about it? It’s better than being sent out of the classroom, because the teacher can keep an eye on you, you can still hear the class etc. The child can’t face the room for obvious reasons. I remember sitting outside the classroom and feeling gleeful I could daydream without getting caught - hardly a punishment!

Is it being punished in front of other kids? I think if the acting up happened in front of other kids, it’s a natural consequence and the teacher has to do what she can. I doubt your DS wasn’t reminded/warned a few times to raise his hand before speaking. That’s worth checking.

I think you need to speak to him more about this. This sort of behavioural punishment doesn’t just happen unless the woman is a real witch (which is possible). Talk to her, too, at drop off. Get the measure of her. If she’s normal but strict, then frankly your son doesn’t get to school-refuse because he can’t behave himself and doesn’t want natural consequences (assuming he’s NT).

Ramalangadingdong · 16/09/2023 12:19

I can’t believe people think this is acceptable. Wherever you are.

This post is incredibly triggering for me. It brought back memories I thought I had buried of when I was looked after by a close relative and they would punish me like this.

I now think of what happened to me as a subtle form of psychological torture. It is incredibly demeaning and humiliating (awful also for the kids who witness it). I wish I could be more articulate about what it feels like.

I wouldn’t keep a child in a school that allows this. If it is common practice in France all I can say is that they are barbaric.

BertieBotts · 16/09/2023 12:19

It wouldn't be acceptable in the UK, and I think it's appallingly outdated, but I doubt you'll have much success bringing it up with the mayor etc. Unfortunately I think it's one of those where you have to accept the culture that you've adopted. It's not as bad as it could be. If there are severe effects on DC then it might be worth looking at individual support or alternative options outside the normal school system.

babyproblems · 16/09/2023 12:17

@twokidstwowheels im also in france but DS isn’t in school yet - you’re right they are behind the times. Just wanted to say I would go mad if this was done to my son here at school! So YADNBU - I’m English for context but sounds like the teacher thinks she is teaching teens rather than young kids imo. I wouldn’t tolerate this here despite knowing how old fashioned they are. Let us know what you decide to do?? Xx

JuicyDrop · 16/09/2023 12:16

I remember having to do this in the first years of primary school- so like 1994-1996. No idea if they still do it in England or not as my son is only three. No trauma suffered from having to stand facing the wall as far as I know. I honestly can’t remember why I was made to stand facing the wall but I’m sure I must have been doing something which wasn’t seen as acceptable. I actually have fond memories of primary school and all the teachers who taught me- I remember everyone of them to this day.

1of2 · 16/09/2023 12:16

This is punishment we used to get in the 90’s in the UK. Didn’t realise it wasn’t a thing anymore! Never did us any harm.

ZadocPDederick · 16/09/2023 12:14

MariePaperRoses · 16/09/2023 11:54

Our music teacher (senior school) in the 70s/80s made any child that disrupted class go and stand at the front, side on with their hands behind their back, bent over with their nose resting on the desk for the duration of the lesson.

Needless to say, no girls ever disrupted his class and once a boy had been 'punished' in this manner he never did it again.

It was embarrassing but no one was traumatised.

Very effective at getting a children to pay attention and not be disruptive.

How do you know that no-one was traumatised?

Pottyberry · 16/09/2023 12:14

Very poor teaching/class management especially if your son has to be told by others what he has done wrong.

ZadocPDederick · 16/09/2023 12:13

NunsKnickers · 16/09/2023 10:56

I doubt that standing facing a wall is going to lead to trauma...

Even in a child with known anxiety and emotionally-based school avoidance?

Dolallytats · 16/09/2023 12:13

I think that you need to explain to your son why he can't just call out answers, but I also think that you should have a chat with his new teacher about your son's past experience.
It's all well and good people saying that he shouldn't feel traumatised and therefore get on with it, but he is upset and he is showing this in his behaviour before school.
Some children need a little more help to understand what is expected of them in school.

maddening · 16/09/2023 12:08

How do you deal with poor behaviour at home?

lavenderlou · 16/09/2023 12:06

I teach that age group and no, we aren't allowed to do that. We can do "time out" where a child sits in a different area of the classroom or is sent to another class.

Goldenbear · 16/09/2023 12:03

C1N1C · 16/09/2023 11:56

Kids these days get offended by having an F or red pen on their papers... (or is it the adults getting traumatised on their behalf?)

I think the world is tough, and you have to prepare your kids for the hardships of life just as much as you have to educate them in schools. If facing a wall is the worst thing you've experienced by the time you leave school, adulthood is going to be like a brick to the face.

Perhaps the world would be a kinder place if these practices were not considered necessary to toughen children up. IME there was an element of some teachers being very unkind.

melj1213 · 16/09/2023 12:00

Also, I forgot to add to my post, is your child one of the oldest in the mixed age group?

I taught in Spanish schools and in one rural school there were so few students that there was literally 3 classes - Kindergarten and Reception; Yr1-Yr3; Yr4-6 - but that meant that you often had to teach a few different things at various levels at the same time and it was often a balancing act of keeping everyone engaged but not letting the oldest kids constantly bulldoze over the youngest because they already know the answers.

If you have a Yr 6 child who is constantly calling out answers to the Yr 4 level questions before the Yr 4s had a chance to answer (for example) then it can be disruptive and also actively hinder the Yr4s from learning.

Motheranddaughter · 16/09/2023 11:59

I think that is absolutely terrible ,and that a good teacher would not have to resort to this type of bullying behaviour