Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it acceptable for a teacher to punish a child by making them stand facing the wall?

233 replies

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 10:43

Some context: I'm in France. Schools here are about 30 years behind the UK, however, there are rules (that many teachers just ignore) about what they are/are not allowed to do. Because I'm not in the UK I would really like some perspective on what is and isn't acceptable. French parents went through a harsh system themselves and because of that seem very blasé about any form of discipline that isn't obviously violent!

Anyway, my son is in a mixed class with ages from 5-8, 13 in total. School started two weeks ago and my son told me that in that time he and two others have had to stand facing the wall as a punishment. My son is confused about why but his friend told his mum that it was because DS kept answering questions without putting his hand up, which I can imagine being the case: he struggles not to blurt out his thoughts at the best of times. Another 7-year-old has had to stand there twice, my DS says for fidgeting and "being naughty" along with one of the girls in the class. Is this acceptable in UK schools? AIBU to want to take this up with the head and the mayor (mayors are the ultimate heads of the school here)?

OP posts:
Notlaughingalot · 16/09/2023 13:11

Flakey99 · 16/09/2023 13:04

No, we’re saying it’s wholly inappropriate to punish someone for being Neuro Diverse.

We used to punish children for holding a pen in their left hand but presumably you wouldn’t support that ideology nowadays?

What is needed is for the education system to evolve and provide a basic education to fit the individual child’s needs and stop trying to stick children into a one size fits all strait jacket.

Did I miss the bit where the OP says her son is neuro diverse?
As soon as discipline is mentioned, autism is assumed.
Good luck with finding an education system that fits every individual child's needs.

Katrinawaves · 16/09/2023 13:10

I don’t think this is a banned punishment in the U.K. though it may have largely fallen out of fashion. It was certainly still being used 5 years ago at my son’s secondary school which for what it’s worth had an Ofsted outstanding rating and the headteacher was knighted because he had transformed discipline and therefore outcomes in a short period taking the school from special measures to outstanding across two inspection periods.

Clearly it’s not a sanction suitable for every child or every infraction but I don’t understand the posters shouting this is unacceptable. Sanctions for poor behaviour are supposed to be unpleasant within a reasonable spectrum and this one doesn’t feel outside of that spectrum.

ConsuelaHammock · 16/09/2023 13:09

It wouldn’t happen in our schools. Whether I think it’s acceptable or not depends on the behaviour being punished. Some children could do with a short sharp shock.
French people have always had more balls than us though. What’s behaviour like in french schools? What’s the teacher retention situation? Perhaps they’re onto something!

CountingDownTheHours · 16/09/2023 13:05

I went to school in France 25+ years ago and I remember in college, so around age 12 a couple of kids being slapped around the face by the teacher for being "insolent" (I think they were answering back if I recall), so this seems mild in comparison!

One thing I would say is that by the time I got to lycee (so age 15 or so) I genuinely don't remember any cases of bad behaviour, talking back, being rude in any of my classes.

I'm obviously not saying corporal punishment is ok at all, but perhaps stricter discipline in school results in better behaved classes, much like parenting.

My DD says that there are plenty of "troublemakers" in her classes here in the UK and they get sanctions or have to sit in isolation, but the kids don't seem to care, so I don't know if it has any direct impact on behaviour.

Looble · 16/09/2023 13:05

Tempone · 16/09/2023 13:01

My kids (very touchy feely) state primary school in the UK makes kids face the wall in the playground if they've misbehaved during break! And if they misbehave in class they are sent to another class. Yes it's probably embarrassing but that's sort of the point of any punishment, no? If a child is disrupting the learning of others there needs to be some action taken.

No embarrassment is not appropriate, and the aim should be teaching the correct way to do things, not humiliating them into submission.

I agree in theory. I don't punish my kids at all in that sense. But if I was dealing with 30 7yos all by myself, I suspect my options for dealing with disruptive kids would become a little less gentle.

Flakey99 · 16/09/2023 13:04

Middlelanehogger · 16/09/2023 12:51

This is the mildest possible punishment I can imagine, are we seriously saying this is horrible and traumatising?!

No, we’re saying it’s wholly inappropriate to punish someone for being Neuro Diverse.

We used to punish children for holding a pen in their left hand but presumably you wouldn’t support that ideology nowadays?

What is needed is for the education system to evolve and provide a basic education to fit the individual child’s needs and stop trying to stick children into a one size fits all strait jacket.

Tempone · 16/09/2023 13:01

My kids (very touchy feely) state primary school in the UK makes kids face the wall in the playground if they've misbehaved during break! And if they misbehave in class they are sent to another class. Yes it's probably embarrassing but that's sort of the point of any punishment, no? If a child is disrupting the learning of others there needs to be some action taken.

No embarrassment is not appropriate, and the aim should be teaching the correct way to do things, not humiliating them into submission.

rollonretirementfgs · 16/09/2023 13:00

Why is facing the wall a terrible punishment? Better than being sent out the class. He can still listen whilst facing the wall, and not disrupt the lesson which is what he was punished for doing in the first place. How would you expect a teacher to deal with your unruly child??

Looble · 16/09/2023 12:59

My kids (very touchy feely) state primary school in the UK makes kids face the wall in the playground if they've misbehaved during break! And if they misbehave in class they are sent to another class. Yes it's probably embarrassing but that's sort of the point of any punishment, no? If a child is disrupting the learning of others there needs to be some action taken.

With regards to challenging the French system of discipline, you are tilting at windmills. It's a tough system and very unsympathetic to special needs of any description. If you approach the mayor the only consequence will be a good laugh at the crazy English lady. It's far from ideal I agree, but that's what you sign up for if you move to a small french village.

For context, my (french) primary school 45 years ago had teachers lifting kids up by their ears, and punishment was being locked in a cupboard. Others my age were slapped and smacked by teachers. So things are better than they were!

sunnyseed · 16/09/2023 12:58

This was a punishment used by at the first school I went to - in the 1980s. I didn’t hear the teacher ask me to do something and they made me stand facing the wall in the lunch hall while all the other pupils were sat eating their lunch. I was only around 6 years old. If this happened at my childrens’ school I would be really upset. It’s designed to degrade and humiliate the child. It’s cruel and out dated.

Tempone · 16/09/2023 12:57

I doubt that standing facing a wall is going to lead to trauma...

No offence, but you have no idea what causes trauma, as its very individual and depends on the context, what may be fine for you may be traumatic for others. Op has already said her son has had previous bad experiences in school, so potentially yes, this may cause trauma.

Onelifeonly · 16/09/2023 12:57

Children at my school are sometimes asked to stand near the fence or edge of the playground as a time out. That's not the same as facing a wall. They can see what is going on around them but can't play or interact with others.

Nanny0gg · 16/09/2023 12:56

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 10:46

To add... this is my son's first year with this teacher and the teacher's first year in this small village school. He has had school phobia in the past and only by working closely with a very wonderful teacher, to unravel the damage done by the bad one before her, were we able to get him back to school full-time last year, so this is really triggering for him and he is starting to show signs of refusal again (having a sore throat, can't find shoes/socks so can't go, etc.) so we can't let this go.

It's designed to humiliate.

Unacceptable

NewName122 · 16/09/2023 12:56

brightdayloomingdark · 16/09/2023 12:35

It was normal when I was that age, four decades ago, but not now. And those reasons fidgeting and not putting his hand up, are appalling. I would not be happy. Those reasons weren’t used for punishment even in my day!

They are now. In my sons school anyway.

Somaliwildass · 16/09/2023 12:55

Flakey99 · 16/09/2023 12:42

Good job you’re not a teacher or a parent of a ND child. 🙄

It’s pretty obvious from your ‘suck it up’ mentality that you have zero understanding of Autism traits as fidgeting and blurting things out are extremely common. It’s got nothing to do with seeking attention, unlike your twatty post.

I'm not sure why you think you know anything about me and have confidently asserted so.

I see children behaving like this everyday and I'm saying that taking them away from the situation is valid in showing them how to behave in it. Autism doesn't stop a child being able to learn what's appropriate and short of excluding children physically from the classroom, movement within the room and seeing that they won't be included without following certain rules is effective. With no diagnosis of an issue, and improvement of behaviour with discipline, there's not really an argument.

Blurting things out might sound relatively harmless and is often attributed to one developmental disorder or another, but without often in a classroom it is to gain attention/status/power over others. It can mostly be helped and 'low level' things like this must be addressed otherwise masses of time is wasted, children miss explanations, the whole class don't get chance to be challenged or think for themselves, the teacher can't as accurately judge understanding of everyone and it's reinforced for the disruptive child that by being vocal they can get their own way above others.

Ramalangadingdong · 16/09/2023 12:54

Dragonwindow · 16/09/2023 12:49

I was going to say that of course that wouldn't be acceptable in the UK. But then I remembered that at my kids' primary school they have to stand out by the wall for 2 mins at a time if they're being silly at break/lunch and they don't listen to the first warning.

It does sound very old fashioned. But tbf it's quite standard to send kids out into the corridor for a couple of minutes if they're being disruptive. If it's a small school with few "roaming" staff, then it might be too risky to send them out. But from what I've heard (I'm a secondary teacher at a school with a very mixed international intake) French schools are very strict!

waiting in a corridor is actually very different to standing facing a wall. Try it.

LolaSmiles · 16/09/2023 12:54

The punishment wouldn't be ok in UK schools because it would be deemed humiliation.
It would be reasonable in the UK to tell a student who is disrupting learning to step outside the classroom, speak to them, and if no change in behaviour send them to work in a different room so others can learn.

What matters here is you get advice from someone who knows the French system though.

NewName122 · 16/09/2023 12:53

No that is not acceptable here in the UK. Our kids get screamed at and sent out the class. Think I'd prefer standing at a wall tbh.

Flakey99 · 16/09/2023 12:53

maddening · 16/09/2023 12:08

How do you deal with poor behaviour at home?

Poor behaviour implies that the individual has control over their actions and has the intention to cause disruption.

An ND person like myself (50’s female with Autism) does not have the same level of control and so interactions with groups of people can still be awkward. Unlike NT people, I actually have to be thinking of 2 or 3 things at once to enable me to focus on a single task.

Presumably you wouldn’t punish someone with a squint for looking at you oddly? Or maybe you would?

Middlelanehogger · 16/09/2023 12:51

This is the mildest possible punishment I can imagine, are we seriously saying this is horrible and traumatising?!

Dragonwindow · 16/09/2023 12:49

I was going to say that of course that wouldn't be acceptable in the UK. But then I remembered that at my kids' primary school they have to stand out by the wall for 2 mins at a time if they're being silly at break/lunch and they don't listen to the first warning.

It does sound very old fashioned. But tbf it's quite standard to send kids out into the corridor for a couple of minutes if they're being disruptive. If it's a small school with few "roaming" staff, then it might be too risky to send them out. But from what I've heard (I'm a secondary teacher at a school with a very mixed international intake) French schools are very strict!

Jusgettingby · 16/09/2023 12:42

The school my child attends does this at break and lunch times.
If there naughty for what ever reason in lessons they have to miss some break time by facing the wall in the playground.
And yes it's a UK school.

BonnieLisbon · 16/09/2023 12:42

Could you practise at-home by playing schools op? He practises putting his hand up to answer rather than calling out. It might help him more than going to the mayor.

Flakey99 · 16/09/2023 12:42

Somaliwildass · 16/09/2023 10:49

Teach you son not to call our and interrupt. In a class of 13, he will have plenty of chance to contribute, but it's the teacher's decision who answers what to ensure everyone is learning.

How exactly has he been badly impacted by facing a wall?

I'm sure the rest of the class were able to get on better while he wasn't blurting things out, seeking attention and monopolising the teacher's time.

Good job you’re not a teacher or a parent of a ND child. 🙄

It’s pretty obvious from your ‘suck it up’ mentality that you have zero understanding of Autism traits as fidgeting and blurting things out are extremely common. It’s got nothing to do with seeking attention, unlike your twatty post.

Onelifeonly · 16/09/2023 12:39

It's not acceptable. It is humiliating and quite a vulnerable position to be in - everyone can see you but you can't see anyone. It is also horrible to treat a new child so severely. Calling out is not a crime against humanity. He just needs a kindly reminder or a non verbal signal to prompt him in the moment. I work in a primary and our behaviour policy has sanctions but our overall approach is respectful and calm. Unwanted behaviours should be dealt with the lightest touch (not touch, literally) possible. Behaviour at our school is mainly excellent because all staff follow the same approach. We do have difficult behaviours at times but still deal with them calmly and respectfully