Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it acceptable for a teacher to punish a child by making them stand facing the wall?

233 replies

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 10:43

Some context: I'm in France. Schools here are about 30 years behind the UK, however, there are rules (that many teachers just ignore) about what they are/are not allowed to do. Because I'm not in the UK I would really like some perspective on what is and isn't acceptable. French parents went through a harsh system themselves and because of that seem very blasé about any form of discipline that isn't obviously violent!

Anyway, my son is in a mixed class with ages from 5-8, 13 in total. School started two weeks ago and my son told me that in that time he and two others have had to stand facing the wall as a punishment. My son is confused about why but his friend told his mum that it was because DS kept answering questions without putting his hand up, which I can imagine being the case: he struggles not to blurt out his thoughts at the best of times. Another 7-year-old has had to stand there twice, my DS says for fidgeting and "being naughty" along with one of the girls in the class. Is this acceptable in UK schools? AIBU to want to take this up with the head and the mayor (mayors are the ultimate heads of the school here)?

OP posts:
ClaraBourne · 16/09/2023 13:35

It was a thing in the 70s, I see remember a lot of time staring at the wall !

I'd have somebody having time out at a wall but facing out.

MrsSlocombesCat · 16/09/2023 13:31

Tourmalines · 16/09/2023 13:25

Yep .

Some people are more sensitive than others. I found the whole school experience traumatic (undiagnosed ASD) and just because you’re tough enough to handle something it doesn’t mean that someone else can. Lifelong trauma can be caused by something like this.

greenspaces4peace · 16/09/2023 13:30

The French from my limited experience have a much more socialist view of children and acceptable behavior.
Be it state or private their view on acceptable behaviors in children is more rigid than UK, Canada or US.
Special needs will be treated as poor parenting.

Flatulence · 16/09/2023 13:28

I used to teach in French schools (albeit older children at collège and not for about a decade). Standing making children stand facing the wall/standing outside the classroom etc. was quite normal at the schools I worked in, though it was not a punishment I used.
It's not used in UK schools anymore afaik (probably because it's pretty ineffective; I can remember being made to do the same when I was a child at school in the 80s/90s).
As you say, the French school system is TOTALLY different from schools in the UK; some of those differences are better in my opinion, some are worse, some are just neutral. So taking something that's normal in UK schools (e.g. a 40-min lunch break, or a uniform, or starting at 9am and finishing at 3.20pm) and using that as the 'gold standard' is really meaningless; imo this extends to pedagogical or disciplinary methods.
So YABU in thinking this punishment is 'wrong'. Ineffective? Probably. Old-fashioned? Yes. But certainly not traumatic imo.
You'd be better to work with the school and let them know that your son has had past difficulties, and you know he struggles to keep quiet til it's his turn to speak - ask how you can work together to improve this.

MrsSlocombesCat · 16/09/2023 13:28

BetterBee · 16/09/2023 11:10

The reason why this is not okay is because it’s a form of humiliation. She can achieve the same effect by making him stand out side the classroom (time out, time to reflect, not reaction from peers etc).

That’s exactly what I was thinking, how humiliated I would have felt if this had been done to me at school. I remember getting smacked across the back for doodling when in primary school and that was bad enough but it was preferable to being made to get up in front of the class and go stand against a wall. It doesn’t sit right with me. Can you homeschool or change to a different one?

thegreylady · 16/09/2023 13:26

Do you remember “Hands on heads!” “ Fingers on lips!” ? Ah the draconian punishments of yesteryear.Facing the wall was usually for disturbing other students and was effective. So what do you think a teacher can do if a child is being a bit disruptive? They aren’t bad enough to be sent out of the class, they have carried on bad behaviour like calling out, whispering, passing notes or whatever so what would you all suggest when you have a class of over 20 pupils and you are trying to teach a lesson which is why you are all there? I know the answer! It is the teacher’s fault of course.

DivorcingEU · 16/09/2023 13:26

It doesn't matter if we all find it acceptable or not, or whether it's normal in France or not. Point is it IS damaging to her DS.

When people say he's "playing up", for certain it's not anything like what happens under that label in British schools. Discipline is much tighter in France. Much. There are positives and negatives to that, however, given the type of punishment he received and that the mother hasn't been spoken to about his behaviour, it's very likely behaviour that nobody would even notice in Britain.

Tourmalines · 16/09/2023 13:25

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 16/09/2023 13:22

Honestly, if your child is traumatized from having to face a wall for a few minutes, then they need to toughen up. FFS.

Yep .

Frenchfancy · 16/09/2023 13:24

It is a totally normal punishment in French schools. At least they have (mostly) stopped putting tape over their mouths.

I'm not quite sure what asking about UK schools will help.

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 16/09/2023 13:23

@DivorcingEU

I think it can have its place. One should be made to feel ashamed for poor choices.

Somaliwildass · 16/09/2023 13:23

Flakey99 · 16/09/2023 13:13

@Somaliwildass

I see children behaving like this everyday and I'm saying that taking them away from the situation is valid in showing them how to behave in it. Autism doesn't stop a child being able to learn what's appropriate and short of excluding children…

🤦🏻‍♀️

Yes, you can choose to humiliate a left handed child and make them write with their right hand, but why would you want to do that?

Do you honestly believe that by explaining to a child with Autism that their behaviour is unacceptable, that it will magically cure them?

FML! I’m 58 and haven’t been cured yet. 🤷🏻‍♀️

It's not humiliation to give clear rules for everyone and consistently give immediate consequences for failure to follow them.

Of course I believe that explaining expectations, actively teaching behaviours and giving reasons for certain conduct is necessary.

(And of course I don't believe autism can be cured. But, as has been pointed out to by other posters, the child in question hasn't been described as being autistic by his parent, so this isn't really relevant)

*Also, you've just quoted only part of my previous post and then said 'Yes......' and something about left handed children as if responding to something not displayed. This is misleading, as I never mentioned that at all.

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 16/09/2023 13:22

Honestly, if your child is traumatized from having to face a wall for a few minutes, then they need to toughen up. FFS.

DivorcingEU · 16/09/2023 13:21

The biggest difference is the shame aspect, and we absolutely do not use shame as a punishment in the UK.

The French use "low level" shame as a punishment frequently. It's not considered bad. I'm not sure they even think about it at all tbh.

JulianCasa · 16/09/2023 13:21

Absolutely not okay. If it would be an unacceptable way to treat adults then it’s an unacceptable to treat children like this. All it teaches him is that he’s inferior to the teacher instead of actually learning that he needs to respect his peers and put his hand up so there is equal opportunity.

Millymoney · 16/09/2023 13:20

Standing facing the wall for a few minutes is hardly "cruel or degrading punishment" is it.
Just adapt to things being different in France like driving on the other side of the road.

Pasithean · 16/09/2023 13:18

Teach your child to behave. Easy. Then it won’t happen.

user1846385927482658 · 16/09/2023 13:18

How is standing by a wall for a few minutes "psychological torture"?

Some of this hyperbole is utterly offensive.

katepilar · 16/09/2023 13:17

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 10:54

I just want some perspective regarding my reaction. It's not allowed here but culturally most people just suck it up. Probably because they have never recovered from the trauma they suffered at school due to harsh discipline!

I agree with you. Nobody deserves to be humiliated and shamed. I thought this was done in schools more than a hundred years ago not today!

DivorcingEU · 16/09/2023 13:16

OP you've said it's not allowed but it's done.

You've said French parents have different ideas of what's acceptable punishments.

Both of those are correct from my family experience. We deliberately did not put our child in French school. Very deliberately.

You've also said that your DS found school traumatic, he has managed to recover from the impact of that over the past year.

You've said the last year's recovery was due to working closely with the teacher.

And now he's starting to show early signs of school refusing.

My question back to you is this: for whatever reason, you've chosen to live in France, with a child. As you're British, there is a certain decision about it, even if you've been living there for 20 years. He's still young an managed to have a decent year of school due to your involvement with the teacher. You know the attitude at school. Are you ready to get involved every year? Because it's a very real possibility. And in a mixed age class in a small village, you don't have many alternatives.

I would be very seriously considering all options at this point. Damage to your son's mental health isn't something that can be reset - as you can see, even things many other parents see as insignificant are now "triggers" for him. He needs a chance to develop in a psychologically safe place.

I've met teachers in France who were nice enough. I'm pretty certain none of them knew the concept of "psychologically safe".

Pushmepullu · 16/09/2023 13:15

FGS your son is playing up, whether it’s to keep calling out or in some other way. He’s obviously not listening to the teacher and they are having to instil discipline. Would he prefer to be sent to stand outside the classroom or outside the headteachers office?

Friend’s DD is teaching Year 2 this year, so far she has had a child stand up and scream for nearly 5 minutes, a boy expose himself and three children refuse to sit down and do any work. Any discipline she has tried to impose has had parents complaining because their child suffers from anxiety, or ‘they’re well behaved at home’. She is seriously considering packing it in, she’s giving it 2 more weeks. She’s an experienced teacher but reckons that since lockdown some children have become almost feral and the parents are enabling this behaviour.

Dragonwindow · 16/09/2023 13:15

Ramalangadingdong · 16/09/2023 12:54

waiting in a corridor is actually very different to standing facing a wall. Try it.

I'm not saying I actively agree with it, and I certainly wouldn't use it as a punishment myself. But I have other options available to me which are possibly not available in a very small school.

The biggest difference is the shame aspect, and we absolutely do not use shame as a punishment in the UK.

justabigmuckingfuddle · 16/09/2023 13:14

I don't even remember having to do this at primary school and I was there in the late 80s/early 90s!

We had to stand with our backs against a wall at lunchtimes if we were naughty, but never facing it and never in the classroom.

We were however sent out of the classroom to stand outside the door in a 'middle area'. Wouldn't have dared wander off or do anything else naughty once you were sent out and no one was keeping an eye on you either!

Funnily enough I was often 'sent out' and punished so I remember it very well. Often for interrupting, calling out, fidgeting, rocking on my chair or chatting. Turns out I'm autistic, and have ADHD. But I'm female and cognitively able so no one knew. I liked being sent out because it was quiet out there and gave me a break, no doubt.

France or no France I wouldn't send my children to a school that made them stand facing a wall for any reason. It's awful. It wouldn't -or shouldn't -happen now in the UK.

Crumpleton · 16/09/2023 13:14

Totaly · 16/09/2023 10:51

No it wouldn’t be acceptable in an English school - but you aren’t in England.

Absolutely this...

MargaretThursday · 16/09/2023 13:13

Middlelanehogger · 16/09/2023 12:51

This is the mildest possible punishment I can imagine, are we seriously saying this is horrible and traumatising?!

I'm wondering what "consequence" people who are objecting strongly would give for a disruptive child. Or should we just expect children to be disruptive and let them get on with it?

I remember being sent to stand in the corner in reception for telling the child next to me to sit properly as she was sitting with her toes poking me and we were meant to sit cross legged. It was the third time we'd both been told to stop whispering.
What irritated me is she bumped her knee when she stood up and cried so spent the time on the TA's lap having her knee rubbed. It was her fault anyway; if she'd sat properly I wouldn't have had to whisper. 😁
I don't remember doing the standing. But I do remember thinking that pretending to bump my knee and crying seemed a very good way of getting out of a punishment.

Flakey99 · 16/09/2023 13:13

@Somaliwildass

I see children behaving like this everyday and I'm saying that taking them away from the situation is valid in showing them how to behave in it. Autism doesn't stop a child being able to learn what's appropriate and short of excluding children…

🤦🏻‍♀️

Yes, you can choose to humiliate a left handed child and make them write with their right hand, but why would you want to do that?

Do you honestly believe that by explaining to a child with Autism that their behaviour is unacceptable, that it will magically cure them?

FML! I’m 58 and haven’t been cured yet. 🤷🏻‍♀️