Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it acceptable for a teacher to punish a child by making them stand facing the wall?

233 replies

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 10:43

Some context: I'm in France. Schools here are about 30 years behind the UK, however, there are rules (that many teachers just ignore) about what they are/are not allowed to do. Because I'm not in the UK I would really like some perspective on what is and isn't acceptable. French parents went through a harsh system themselves and because of that seem very blasé about any form of discipline that isn't obviously violent!

Anyway, my son is in a mixed class with ages from 5-8, 13 in total. School started two weeks ago and my son told me that in that time he and two others have had to stand facing the wall as a punishment. My son is confused about why but his friend told his mum that it was because DS kept answering questions without putting his hand up, which I can imagine being the case: he struggles not to blurt out his thoughts at the best of times. Another 7-year-old has had to stand there twice, my DS says for fidgeting and "being naughty" along with one of the girls in the class. Is this acceptable in UK schools? AIBU to want to take this up with the head and the mayor (mayors are the ultimate heads of the school here)?

OP posts:
HobbiddoH · 16/09/2023 14:20

To be honest I’m sick of bad behaviour or even just disruptive/disrespectful behaviour being permitted to slide at my DCs primary school. I’d welcome a face the wall punishment if it improved behaviour.

Skinthin · 16/09/2023 14:17

Aprilx · 16/09/2023 14:14

Standing facing a wall is not a trauma. I don’t think you are doing him any favours by suggesting that it is.

Of course it is, it’s a degrading form of punishment that is intended to degrade and humiliate

Switcher · 16/09/2023 14:17

Not sure I see the issue. The UK is maybe "ahead" or maybe just has other ideas about education and discipline. Can't say the results are great, so who knows what's right.

Crazycrazylady · 16/09/2023 14:17

Honestly this is very standard behaviour in French schools who do take a different approach to discipline to Uk and Irish schools. I'm not sure there is much to be gained by marching in and asking she adopt English rules .
In schools where space and resources are a issue. This is a way of removing child from situation while ensuring they are safe ( not on their own in the corridors) .
I don't know what happened in his previous school but you claim the teacher there traumatised him which is definitely very unusual and now a week in you believe he is on the road to being traumatised again. Respectfully I'd suggest that the French education system isn't for you .

HowWhatWhyWhen · 16/09/2023 14:15

I remember this being a thing when I was primary school aged so the mid 90s. I spent many hours staring at the walls as some weird form of punishment whenever I misbehave in school. Didn't realise this was still a thing. Ridiculous.

Aprilx · 16/09/2023 14:14

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 11:01

He already suffered trauma at a previous school. It's taken 12 months and alot of patience and understanding to get him back into school full time.

Standing facing a wall is not a trauma. I don’t think you are doing him any favours by suggesting that it is.

NatashaDancing · 16/09/2023 14:11

MrsSlocombesCat · 16/09/2023 13:28

That’s exactly what I was thinking, how humiliated I would have felt if this had been done to me at school. I remember getting smacked across the back for doodling when in primary school and that was bad enough but it was preferable to being made to get up in front of the class and go stand against a wall. It doesn’t sit right with me. Can you homeschool or change to a different one?

I've skipped from the first post being quoted to this one but completely agree. It's humiliating.

CosyNightsOnTheSofa · 16/09/2023 14:11

Triggered standing by a wall? I mean I'd be annoyed if he was being punished in lesson time, but if he's disruptive he needs to learn that isn't acceptable. It is an outdated punishment, I've had to stand facing the wall during playtime for being disruptive, but I wasn't removed during class time. I'd be annoyed he was missing school time but not that he was punished. Sounds like he's treated like a delicate flower so its not surprising he thinks the rules don't apply to him, I don't think you are helping him. Do you complain everytime he's told off?

Skinthin · 16/09/2023 14:06

Oh my god this is awful. This is humiliation punishment and deeply harmful to children. I would absolutely be kicking off if this were my child.

Mumwithbaggage · 16/09/2023 14:04

I was talking to my class (Y5/6) about it this week - when I started teaching there was lots of it. Also hands on head and your nose had to keep a piece of paper up on the wall otherwise you were in even more trouble.

I hasten to add I never gave out a punishment like this - it was those old school usually male teachers (secondary teacher back then) whose idea of tutor time was to keep the kids silent so they could read the Daily Mirror.

My class were shocked!

Someoneonlyyouknow · 16/09/2023 14:03

I think a chat with the teacher to explain that your son does not seem to understand what behaviour resulted in the punishment would be the best way forward. That confusion is probably causing more anxiety to you son than the actual having to face the wall. Maybe you can talk with him about what other children did that was unacceptable to the teacher and why that would disrupt the class. It's not the worst punishment but seems a bit outdated.

Bearbookagainandagain · 16/09/2023 14:02

Dragonwindow · 16/09/2023 13:37

This was kind of what I was trying to get at. In the UK, this would be absolutely humiliating, largely because it's never used. But if it's widely used in France, then this dilutes that shame significantly, in a kind of "meh, it happens to everyone" way. I still would never use this as a punishment myself, but I'm not aghast at the idea that other countries do.

It's definitely about shame, you wouldn't get a 5yo to do a time out like that, you get the 10yo because they will be a bit ashamed. Again - unless the teacher single out a child - no one would get traumatised by that.
One of my teacher when I was about 9 would send us play in the little kids sandpit as a punishment when we were talking in class.

cooldarkroom · 16/09/2023 13:56

How long was this punishment?
I dont think its particularly harsh. Your son will learn to put his hand up & the teacher will be able to teach the whole class with set rules

Notellinganyone · 16/09/2023 13:53

Absolutely wouldn’t happen in the UK and shouldn’t be happening anywhere. You need to step in fast I think. French education system is v rigid - I did an exchange as a teacher and was pretty shocked by the lack of flexibility in the curriculum.

NoraBattysCurlers · 16/09/2023 13:52

Whether of not it is acceptable in China, India, Nigeria, Brazil, UK, or wherever for a teacher to punish a child by making them stand facing the wall is irrelevant. You live in France and your child goes to school in France.

Bearbookagainandagain · 16/09/2023 13:48

😂😂😂the trauma of being made to stand for 10 min in class?
I'm french and I can assure that 1) it is totally allowed to get kids to stand ! and 2) there is no trauma there...

Given the state of anarchy some schools end up in here in the UK, I'm not sure the UK is "30 years ahead" like you like to tell yourself. I haven't yet heard of French schools giving detention for having the wrong shoes or having to lock lavatories during breaks...

BatshitCrazyWoman · 16/09/2023 13:47

I worked in a school in 2013. The head teacher used standing facing the wall in her office as a punishment. I always thought it was wrong, and it wasn't done at my now-adult DC's schools. I went to school in the 70s, so hitting was the thing 🙁

Bettyboobaloo · 16/09/2023 13:44

French schools aren't 30 years behind for starters. I find that quite offensive. This is a problem in your school, not in 'french' schools.

lifebeginsat48 · 16/09/2023 13:43

Jeffreybubblesbombom · 16/09/2023 11:34

Why is he in school if he's suffered trauma? I'm here crying for a little boy l don't even know..just imagining him stood facing the wall breaks my heart.
Home educate him...his mental health is worth much more.

We found a wonderful teacher and worked with her to bring him back. He's happy there and enjoys learning along with the social aspects. Homeschooling is a last resort given our financial situation. Alternative schools will be our next avenue, if this teacher doesn't work out. But first we want to try to work it out.

CyclingLegs · 16/09/2023 13:40

Sorry I haven't read the whole thread, just the OPs posts. In our school, if a child misbehaved, then their name was written on the board. Next time it was underlined. The third time a box was drawn round it. That seemed to be enough for most kids, and for the kids who didn't respond to that I think there would be a behavioural assessment for special needs.

It sounds as though OPs DS would benefit from an assessment. I and DC are diagnosed ASD and life got much much easier after diagnosis.

AnneValentine · 16/09/2023 13:40

Time outs still happen in English primary. Regularly. I’m surprised so many don’t realise this!

Maria1982 · 16/09/2023 13:38

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 10:54

I just want some perspective regarding my reaction. It's not allowed here but culturally most people just suck it up. Probably because they have never recovered from the trauma they suffered at school due to harsh discipline!

If it’s not allowed then I would suggest don’t let yourself be swayed by cultural norms. What I mean is, you feel it’s not okay. I also feel it’s not okay by the way!

if it’s not allowed then you have that to your advantage- have a conversation with the headteacher and see where it takes you initially .

pS for background I grew up in Spain in the 80s/90s and I am familiar with this punishment but it would not be used these days! Am surprised at how behind the times France is if this is still happening …

Dragonwindow · 16/09/2023 13:37

DivorcingEU · 16/09/2023 13:21

The biggest difference is the shame aspect, and we absolutely do not use shame as a punishment in the UK.

The French use "low level" shame as a punishment frequently. It's not considered bad. I'm not sure they even think about it at all tbh.

This was kind of what I was trying to get at. In the UK, this would be absolutely humiliating, largely because it's never used. But if it's widely used in France, then this dilutes that shame significantly, in a kind of "meh, it happens to everyone" way. I still would never use this as a punishment myself, but I'm not aghast at the idea that other countries do.

sleepy78 · 16/09/2023 13:37

Hello. As an English trained teacher in an international school in France, this is something that would never be allowed at my school.
HOWEVER, my child is in French school and although this has never happened to them, it doesn't surprise me. The whole system of French schools is very "old school" - blackboards, writing of lines, hours of memorisation, no movement in the classroom etc etc. My child is used to it but if yours is coming from England or is small, they may not be. You can definitely bring it up with the teacher or head teacher, but expect them to be dismissive and defensive. And the mayor won't do anything as he does not control the pedagogical side of things. For that, you would need to complain to the inspectrice. But nothing would happen I don't think.
If you are staying in France, your child will need to get used to this sort of thing.

Notlaughingalot · 16/09/2023 13:36

JulianCasa · 16/09/2023 13:21

Absolutely not okay. If it would be an unacceptable way to treat adults then it’s an unacceptable to treat children like this. All it teaches him is that he’s inferior to the teacher instead of actually learning that he needs to respect his peers and put his hand up so there is equal opportunity.

Nonsense. The child is inferior to the teacher. It's attitudes like this that lead to children thinking they are equal to adults, thinking they can do as they please and causing mayhem in many UK schools.

You can't apply the same standards to adults as you do to children, who are still being taught how to fit into society.