Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it acceptable for a teacher to punish a child by making them stand facing the wall?

233 replies

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 10:43

Some context: I'm in France. Schools here are about 30 years behind the UK, however, there are rules (that many teachers just ignore) about what they are/are not allowed to do. Because I'm not in the UK I would really like some perspective on what is and isn't acceptable. French parents went through a harsh system themselves and because of that seem very blasé about any form of discipline that isn't obviously violent!

Anyway, my son is in a mixed class with ages from 5-8, 13 in total. School started two weeks ago and my son told me that in that time he and two others have had to stand facing the wall as a punishment. My son is confused about why but his friend told his mum that it was because DS kept answering questions without putting his hand up, which I can imagine being the case: he struggles not to blurt out his thoughts at the best of times. Another 7-year-old has had to stand there twice, my DS says for fidgeting and "being naughty" along with one of the girls in the class. Is this acceptable in UK schools? AIBU to want to take this up with the head and the mayor (mayors are the ultimate heads of the school here)?

OP posts:
Ramalangadingdong · 16/09/2023 15:36

user1846385927482658 · 16/09/2023 13:18

How is standing by a wall for a few minutes "psychological torture"?

Some of this hyperbole is utterly offensive.

I am allowed to talk about my experience at the hands of an idiot. It may not be damaging to you but it was for me.

IDriveMySupernova · 16/09/2023 15:27

This was normal at my school, as well as getting ‘sent out’.

I get that it isn’t pleasant to have to do it, but it isn’t pleasant to be disruptive and disregarding of others either (assuming a child is actually being disruptive). Yes, it’s humiliating and I can still feel my face stinging with the embarrassment when it happened to me. But life is full of unpleasant feelings and people have to learn to deal with them at some point.

maddening · 16/09/2023 15:19

Ramalangadingdong · 16/09/2023 12:29

I would ask all of you to try it for yourselves. Go and stand in front of a wall without turning around, sitting down or fidgeting. Put your timer on for 5/10 mins then tell me what it was like.

Now imagine a 5 year old having to do that. During a whole lesson. In front of classmates and a power wielding teacher.

I have done it, as a child, no it wasn't awful

Theroom · 16/09/2023 15:13

I had to stand against the wall in the late 80s. One time was justified - I knew I'd broken the rules and taught me a valuable lesson re peer pressure. I never did it again. The second time I was innocent of the alleged crime and I remembered fuming over the injustice.

Personally I don't have a problem with standing against the wall as a punishment per se, but in your son's case it seems like he didn't actually know what he was being punished for. I'd have an issue with that.

Gellhell · 16/09/2023 15:00

It does not sound progressive. I think they did in UK schools in the 70s as I was facing a wall when my mother picked me up from nursery once. They also used to rip up your pictures if you didn't have pockets in your dress to take them home. 😭

Yoyoban · 16/09/2023 14:54

I just wanted to add to my earlier reply - once you've clarified with the teacher what the punishment was for / what the expectations are for classroom behaviour, assuming it was for something it's reasonable to 'get in trouble' for and the teacher is a reasonable sort, you should make sure when you're explaining to your son why he got punished, that you also reassure him about things that he won't get in trouble for e.g. if he at the moment thinks he'll get in trouble for things he can't control e.g. coughing that will also be creating anxiety so he needs to know that it's ok to cough. Or that it's ok to not understand something and ask a question but make sure he understands how to do that appropriately - e.g. by raising his hand.

(And if the teacher is punishing unreasonably that's then the point to go to the headteacher to discuss it)

Hyppogriff · 16/09/2023 14:52

This was the norm at my prep school in the late 90s - don’t think it was overly harmful! Though the (13 year old) prefects could do it to the other kids as well as the teachers !!

Pootle23 · 16/09/2023 14:48

It’s not though is it. The people at university who went through all the coddling and it’s the taking part nonsense are failing and falling apart! They cannot cope with life.

I know every parent thinks their child is an angel but in reality that is simply not true.

Does he not understand what he did wrong because he wasn’t listening? Quite common in that age group.

How do you feel he should have been punished?

Parents these days don’t seem to think their little darlings ever need to be punished. Not met a perfect child yet. They need boundaries and if those are broken, they need consequences.

As the teacher, how would you deal with disruptive children?

Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 16/09/2023 14:46

Not tolerated in the UK but we have huge discipline problems here so maybe we should bring it back!

Yellowlegobrick · 16/09/2023 14:45

It's humiliating.

The humiliation/shame stems from your behaviour being bad.

A child should feel ashamed of being badly behaved. Not feeling ashamed would mean, rather like a toddler, that they aren't recognising that the behaviour is not acceptable, which is itself worrying in a school aged child.

CremeEggThief · 16/09/2023 14:45

Completely normal in the 1980s along with lines, but no, not in tune with modern educational thinking in the UK. If you're in France and it's still the norm there, not really sure what you can do to challenge it though.

DappledThings · 16/09/2023 14:45

Never saw this happen in my primary schools in the 80s. I think I would have felt awful for any child I saw doing it. And I would have felt embarrassed and really vulnerable with my back to the whole class. The element of humiliation is intrinsic to it as a punishment. It's as much about humiliation as any time to reflect and that is what makes it distressing to me.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 16/09/2023 14:41

I can imagine the reaction of my mayor to being ‘approached ‘ over this. He would probably have asked us as the token English people in the Commune whether we thought this lady was ‘serious’.

Then we would all have had a glass of Rosé and a bit of a chuckle.

Are you intending to live in France for a long time?

Looble · 16/09/2023 14:40

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 16/09/2023 14:37

It's not acceptable here and from your post it's also not permitted in France so you are on strong grounds.

I would go and talk to his teacher and explain the situation. Ask that an alternative is implemented but check what that is going to be and if you have suggestions that you could also implement at home, you should make them.

If you get a non committal response or it happens again, escalate.

It is absolutely used here - my own kids' state primary does! Are you absolutely sure yours doesn't?

Notagains · 16/09/2023 14:40

That certainly wouldn't happen at my GCs primary school. It's didn't even happen at my DCs school in the 90s.
I would say yes it is unacceptable

Yellowlegobrick · 16/09/2023 14:39

I wouldn't consider standing facing a wall "harsh discipline" - sure its unpleasant but how long are we talking, a few minutes? Consequences like this stem from a recognition that sometimes removing stimulation can help kids calm down & reflect.

Its probably not in vogue any more in the UK but definitely has been in the past, it was done at my school 30 years ago, the secondary equivalent would have involved holding a chair out!

Interrupting/not putting your hand up wouldn't be tolerated in the UK either - I just asked my y2 DC and said you'd get told off if you were interrupting in class.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 16/09/2023 14:37

It's not acceptable here and from your post it's also not permitted in France so you are on strong grounds.

I would go and talk to his teacher and explain the situation. Ask that an alternative is implemented but check what that is going to be and if you have suggestions that you could also implement at home, you should make them.

If you get a non committal response or it happens again, escalate.

Looble · 16/09/2023 14:37

I think a pp who also grew up in the French system is right that it's a bit offensive to say the French system is '30 years behind'. French schools are super strict in some ways but on the other hand they don't have the weird prison camp mentality of many UK schools nowadays- kids are freer to be themselves in lots of ways. No uniform, no silent corridors, no whole day isolation for minor misdemeanours or stopping kids from going to the loo. I sometimes think that our treading on eggshells culture, with kids seen as psychologically fragile, ends up with worse outcomes - behaviour is worse, which then leads to the need for harsher collective discipline policies that impact all kids, not just the misbehaving ones.

Also, notwithstanding this, I think UK schools are stricter than some seem to believe on here. Many of them do use shame-based techniques! It's just not as widespread societally as in France, where kids expect it both at home and at school.

Bobby80 · 16/09/2023 14:30

This isn’t uncommon in France. There are very different approaches to discipline/class management. Does the school have a behaviour policy?

Incywincywoo · 16/09/2023 14:29

I thought you were going to say they were hitting him.

We had this at prep school, my DC has it at catholic school.

It’s rarely needed once they get the hang of appropriate ways of behaving and proves a useful deterrent.

My DC is SEN too but I am not averse to discipline if being a twerp - usually the teacher can tell if an adhd issue or a little kid misbehaving issue, they are trained.

By contrast other kids we‘ve come across don’t have as nice manners and have bad language and so forth. I’d rather have the wall than that, though it does make me think of the handmaids tale and GOT 😂

Fanlover1122 · 16/09/2023 14:28

Perhaps France is not the place then for your son to be educated - sounds like you may want to seriously consider a move.

Hufflepods · 16/09/2023 14:23

Fuck me some parents are such drama queens. Standing looking at a wall is not abuse, trauma or worse than corporal punishment! What on earth am I reading.
Some parents clearly just don’t give a shit if their kids mess about in schools or not.

HobbiddoH · 16/09/2023 14:21

charlotte361 · 16/09/2023 14:20

what sort of adults are these children going to be with so little resilience?

Exactly. Absolute fannies.

Honeychickpea · 16/09/2023 14:21

Somaliwildass · 16/09/2023 10:49

Teach you son not to call our and interrupt. In a class of 13, he will have plenty of chance to contribute, but it's the teacher's decision who answers what to ensure everyone is learning.

How exactly has he been badly impacted by facing a wall?

I'm sure the rest of the class were able to get on better while he wasn't blurting things out, seeking attention and monopolising the teacher's time.

I agree with this, and also - it doesn't matter if it is acceptable in the UK, your child is not going to school in the UK.

charlotte361 · 16/09/2023 14:20

what sort of adults are these children going to be with so little resilience?