Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it acceptable for a teacher to punish a child by making them stand facing the wall?

233 replies

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 10:43

Some context: I'm in France. Schools here are about 30 years behind the UK, however, there are rules (that many teachers just ignore) about what they are/are not allowed to do. Because I'm not in the UK I would really like some perspective on what is and isn't acceptable. French parents went through a harsh system themselves and because of that seem very blasé about any form of discipline that isn't obviously violent!

Anyway, my son is in a mixed class with ages from 5-8, 13 in total. School started two weeks ago and my son told me that in that time he and two others have had to stand facing the wall as a punishment. My son is confused about why but his friend told his mum that it was because DS kept answering questions without putting his hand up, which I can imagine being the case: he struggles not to blurt out his thoughts at the best of times. Another 7-year-old has had to stand there twice, my DS says for fidgeting and "being naughty" along with one of the girls in the class. Is this acceptable in UK schools? AIBU to want to take this up with the head and the mayor (mayors are the ultimate heads of the school here)?

OP posts:
BonnieLisbon · 17/09/2023 07:54

Looble · 16/09/2023 22:49

@MelodiousThunk Yes I totally agree. It's a real scandal. I recall several kids in my primary school class who were in retrospect obviously on the spectrum, and I shudder to recall how they were treated. I suspect things weren't great in the UK either in the early 80s, but at least kids weren't being routinely locked in dark cupboards or smacked by teachers for misbehaving.
I do think there's been some progress in recent years, but it's still patchy at best.

Kids were smacked in my primary school in the 70s but not locked in cupboards. The head in the infants used to put people over her knee in assembly. In juniors it was the slipper but I did see the head smack people too. All very common in other schools too based on what friends have said. There was the cane in secondary.

Siameasy · 16/09/2023 23:56

I think it sounds good and would like it to happen to one of the vile kids in my DC’s class who makes racist and homophobic comments yet never seems to see any punishment.

Looble · 16/09/2023 22:49

@MelodiousThunk Yes I totally agree. It's a real scandal. I recall several kids in my primary school class who were in retrospect obviously on the spectrum, and I shudder to recall how they were treated. I suspect things weren't great in the UK either in the early 80s, but at least kids weren't being routinely locked in dark cupboards or smacked by teachers for misbehaving.
I do think there's been some progress in recent years, but it's still patchy at best.

MelodiousThunk · 16/09/2023 22:31

@Looble oh I know it very well! But getting back to the point, ADHD and ASD are simply not acknowledged in France. Profound autism is institutionalised but there simply isn’t the recognition of a spectrum as there is in the U.K., and as far as I know ADHD simply isn’t recognised at all. It’s seen as an imaginary syndrome, in the same way that Brits laugh at ‘heavy legs’.

Looble · 16/09/2023 21:26

MelodiousThunk · 16/09/2023 21:13

@Looble i well remember being on holiday at my French grandparents’ aged 15 and going out for a run on a hot summer’s day and drinking a massive glass of menthe à l’eau with ice on my return. My lovely grand-mère was convinced I would drop dead. 40 years later I’m still running in the heat and drinking cold water on my return and I ate’ nt dead yet.

You've been very lucky so far 🤣. The other deathly danger in France is 'hydrocution', which happens if you enter a body of water too soon after a meal. Absolutely deadly.

Edited to say I've just looked it up and it is sort of a thing - it's actually cardiac arrest from cold water shock, nothing to do with food. But not, I think, a great risk on entering a 30 degree swimming pool after lunch, which was the common interpretation of my childhood!

Katypp · 16/09/2023 21:18

Flakey99 · 16/09/2023 12:42

Good job you’re not a teacher or a parent of a ND child. 🙄

It’s pretty obvious from your ‘suck it up’ mentality that you have zero understanding of Autism traits as fidgeting and blurting things out are extremely common. It’s got nothing to do with seeking attention, unlike your twatty post.

But autistic and Adhd children generally have to learn to adapt to the world around them. It's OK using this as an explanation but it should never be used as an excuse to disrupt others' education. How far do you suggest the teacher goes to accommodate behavior like this? Allow him to answer every question and not allow others a turn? Would you be happy if your child was in a class completely monopolised by one child and no effort was made to control his behavior?
As the mother of an autistic teenager, kindly I say the more people bend to accommodate your child, the harder it gets when they grow up and people stop letting them have their own way

MelodiousThunk · 16/09/2023 21:13

@Looble i well remember being on holiday at my French grandparents’ aged 15 and going out for a run on a hot summer’s day and drinking a massive glass of menthe à l’eau with ice on my return. My lovely grand-mère was convinced I would drop dead. 40 years later I’m still running in the heat and drinking cold water on my return and I ate’ nt dead yet.

Afterrain · 16/09/2023 21:07

I hate to bust the bubble but it does happen in UK schools. I am a supply teacher and cover a local Prep school. It is common practise for children to have a few minutes time out facing away from other children.
It stops the child becoming the class clown and playing to the audience. It is only for a short period of time. It is just a form of time out.

The Head Teacher has used the technique at assembly. (in front of parents) The 'Dinner Nanny' uses it at lunch time.
It is common practise and mentioned in their policies.
It isn't over used but has an effect.

It doesn't seem to put parents off as they have a long waiting list.

When I am working at the local state school I work within their rules. I sometimes think a couple of minutes time out would help. Rather than have to write up a sheet in triplicate about a minor misdemeanor and place on file.

In each school it is explained to the child why their behaviour wasn't satisfactory.
In each school it is hoped that it will help the individual learn to self regulate.

In the first instance I would speak to the teacher. I am assuming you and your DC have a good command of French.
The teacher may have concerns about his impulsiveness. It could be obvious in a small class. You need to work with the system.
You need to find out their discipline policies. Their expectations of your child.
It doesn't sound like the time out period was very long. Hopefully, used to self regulate and bring everyone's attention back to the lesson.
It is more immediate and better than missing a few minutes of their break after the fact.

Years ago I taught in France and found the expectations very clear cut. Some British families did find it very different.

Looble · 16/09/2023 20:57

MelodiousThunk · 16/09/2023 20:35

The French don’t believe in neurodiversity. Just like the British don’t believe in ‘les jambes lourdes’ or ‘colpo d’aria’. It’s cultural.

I know there's a serious point there but that did make me laugh! The deathly effects of blasts of cold air are very well-known across the channel (France and Spain too). We are curiously immune over here.

TheHateIsNotGood · 16/09/2023 20:52

I remember 'facing the wall' as a punishment when I was very, very young. Can't remember what I did, but I did manage to get through my 60s/70s education without suffering the various 'more severe' punishments on offer such as the slipper, strap, etc, though I did get plenty of detentions.

How the bloody hell is a dc 'facing the wall' possibly considered bad?

MelodiousThunk · 16/09/2023 20:35

Flakey99 · 16/09/2023 13:04

No, we’re saying it’s wholly inappropriate to punish someone for being Neuro Diverse.

We used to punish children for holding a pen in their left hand but presumably you wouldn’t support that ideology nowadays?

What is needed is for the education system to evolve and provide a basic education to fit the individual child’s needs and stop trying to stick children into a one size fits all strait jacket.

The French don’t believe in neurodiversity. Just like the British don’t believe in ‘les jambes lourdes’ or ‘colpo d’aria’. It’s cultural.

paradoxically2 · 16/09/2023 20:33

How is facing a wall humiliating? Do you have to take your pants off?

I seriously worry about how young people are going to cope when their parents are pushing the idea that facing a wall is in any way traumatic. It makes perfect sense. You stop hear the lesson. You don't get to engage so it's a kind of time out t without the problem of missing part of the lesson. Is it the standing? The wall? What part is humiliating? Is time-out humiliating?

Fifthtimelucky · 16/09/2023 20:02

hahahahahah · 16/09/2023 11:20

I can remember being told to stand in the corner, facing the wall because 'no-one wanted to see [my] ugly face!' This was about 55 years ago, in a small village school. The reason for this punishment was that I had flicked paper pellet at someone with my ruler (he had started it, but I got caught).

The fact that I can remember this incident after more than half a century shows that it did make an impact on me. Yet, I had behaved in a way that was wrong, and punishments like this were common in those days.

Calling out answers without putting up a hand, however, is something the teacher should be able to manage without humiliating the child. For example, ask the class to write down their answers; ask the group to stick their answers on the board on Postits; allow the child to answer, but also take answers from others; use an electronic/Smart tool which allows contributions from the whole group. If this is a very new teacher, it could be the case that he needs a few more behaviour management strategies up his sleeve.

I really do no agree with asking children to stand in the corner facing the wall, and it is certainly highly inappropriate for behaviour that shows the child is really engaged in the lesson.

I wonder if we were at the same primary school!

SaltyGod · 16/09/2023 19:50

It isn’t something I’d be worked up about. Your son shouldn’t be interrupting the class.

I certainly wouldn’t go to the mayor or head teacher but if you were concerned I would suggest a conversation with the teacher to understand what he did wrong from their point of view, and how you can help him avoid doing it again.

Yettisrus29 · 16/09/2023 19:44

NunsKnickers · 16/09/2023 10:56

I doubt that standing facing a wall is going to lead to trauma...

We were made to stand facing a wall at school as punishment back in the 90s, along with lines in the basement (it was boarding school). I have nothing but hate for that school and the fact it destroyed a happy, carefree child.

BonnieLisbon · 16/09/2023 19:35

hahahahahah · 16/09/2023 11:20

I can remember being told to stand in the corner, facing the wall because 'no-one wanted to see [my] ugly face!' This was about 55 years ago, in a small village school. The reason for this punishment was that I had flicked paper pellet at someone with my ruler (he had started it, but I got caught).

The fact that I can remember this incident after more than half a century shows that it did make an impact on me. Yet, I had behaved in a way that was wrong, and punishments like this were common in those days.

Calling out answers without putting up a hand, however, is something the teacher should be able to manage without humiliating the child. For example, ask the class to write down their answers; ask the group to stick their answers on the board on Postits; allow the child to answer, but also take answers from others; use an electronic/Smart tool which allows contributions from the whole group. If this is a very new teacher, it could be the case that he needs a few more behaviour management strategies up his sleeve.

I really do no agree with asking children to stand in the corner facing the wall, and it is certainly highly inappropriate for behaviour that shows the child is really engaged in the lesson.

That was said in my primary school in the 70s too. If someone was standing in the corner and looked round the teacher would say "Turn round, I don't want to see your ugly face!" Maybe it was taught at teacher training college back then! 😀Definitely wouldn't fly now. There was smacking too. Glad we've moved on from that.

MissJoGrant · 16/09/2023 19:19

Totaly · 16/09/2023 10:51

No it wouldn’t be acceptable in an English school - but you aren’t in England.

It happens at my school. I don't think it's harmful to face a wall.

Berlinlover · 16/09/2023 18:52

I see nothing wrong with it.

peebles32 · 16/09/2023 18:44

Spanish schools are exactly the same. My niece goes to a public primary in school and the teacher very often picks up work and rips it up. They are 7!

EvelynBeatrice · 16/09/2023 16:32

As a general thing without taking individual circumstances into account, this doesn't seem remotely abusive to me - but then I grew up when it was perfectly acceptable for a primary school teacher to smack the hand of an inattentive small child. I also wonder what types of discipline parents would support because the reality is - according to my nieces who teach in a primary school - that the continual low level misbehaviour of a couple of or even one child disrupts the learning of the whole class. I do appreciate though that individual needs, any SEN or school refusal need to be accounted for and hopefully different strategies adopted. I do wonder what these might be though!

sunshinesupermum · 16/09/2023 16:11

OP I 'm not sure why you are asking the question. The type of punishment you describe is not common in the UK but in a small village school in France they obviously do things differently
If you speak to the teacher concerned and are then able to help your DS through this, especially if he might have ADHD , that is your solution.

OneCup · 16/09/2023 15:59

Meh, I can't get worked up about it? How is that humiliating or embarrassing?

garlictwist · 16/09/2023 15:49

I was a language assistant in a few French primaries in 2001 and I was horrified by the "discipline". You're right that stuff is accepted there that just isn't here. Teachers grabbing small children by the scruff of the neck and manhandling them, yelling in their face etc. Standing in the corner seems relatively mild compared to that.

Ramalangadingdong · 16/09/2023 15:46

For those who don’t understand why some of us think this is not the mild punishment it seems to you here is a loose analogy.

We recognise violence as DV but we also recognise that there is coercive control which can take many subtle and (from the outside) benign forms.

you know what, you lot do you: “toughen” your kids up in your own way and leave others to discipline their children in a way that sits well with their conscience.

standing facing the wall is a draconian punishment hundreds of years old and has no place in contemporary society.

Ramalangadingdong · 16/09/2023 15:39

Tourmalines · 16/09/2023 13:25

Yep .

Are you telling me that you personally would do this to a five year old?

Swipe left for the next trending thread