Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it acceptable for a teacher to punish a child by making them stand facing the wall?

233 replies

twokidstwowheels · 16/09/2023 10:43

Some context: I'm in France. Schools here are about 30 years behind the UK, however, there are rules (that many teachers just ignore) about what they are/are not allowed to do. Because I'm not in the UK I would really like some perspective on what is and isn't acceptable. French parents went through a harsh system themselves and because of that seem very blasé about any form of discipline that isn't obviously violent!

Anyway, my son is in a mixed class with ages from 5-8, 13 in total. School started two weeks ago and my son told me that in that time he and two others have had to stand facing the wall as a punishment. My son is confused about why but his friend told his mum that it was because DS kept answering questions without putting his hand up, which I can imagine being the case: he struggles not to blurt out his thoughts at the best of times. Another 7-year-old has had to stand there twice, my DS says for fidgeting and "being naughty" along with one of the girls in the class. Is this acceptable in UK schools? AIBU to want to take this up with the head and the mayor (mayors are the ultimate heads of the school here)?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Coco1379 · 23/09/2023 23:19

Have you had a discussion with the teacher? She needs to explain to your son why he is being punished, and you need to tell her about your son’s sensitivity. It isn’t so long ago that facing the wall and worse, was commonplace in English schools, but as the saying goes, when in Rome…

Freneg98 · 20/09/2023 11:19

Having been through the french schooling system where you are 1 of 30 children in a class, meant to learn at the same pace, learn by rote, not to have any original thoughts and not to make any noise, I agree French schools suck and are quite behind the times.
I love my DC's mid-size SE England primary school where they are allowed to be individuals, encouraged to progress in the areas they excel, supported to catch-up in they areas they are behind.
And I don't think it's that much better in France at present. My nephews are same ages as my DCs but they are in french schools and they are learning to read, write and basic maths starting later but in a much, much tighter time frame.. They feel stressed out and pressured to get it all straight away.
Discipline is still a big part of french education because from 3/4 years there is 1 teacher per class (often 30 students) and it's hard to manage, so they come down hard on any "disturbance". There is also a massive government-set curriculum to get through each year and there no room for any slowing down. My step-sister quit teaching 3 years ago because of all this.
What happened to your child would not happen in my children's UK school and it would result in a complaint.
I think you should take it further, but I am not sure you will have any success as some things are "normal" and widely accepted in France.

BexleyTutor · 19/09/2023 22:46

Iknow this is going to be controversial but behaviour is getting worse in schools and the majority of children are losing out on their education. Part of the problem in the UK is that now teachers are having fewer and fewer sanctions they can use when children behave badly. The bad behaviour means that the rest of the class are unable to have the lesson they should have. And part of the reason that the teachers have fewer sanctions is because parents are more likely to complain instead of telling their DC that if he/she behaves better this won't happen. Parents need to be on the side of teachers more, and less prone to complain when DC has been taught that their behaviour has been unacceptable.

DisquietintheRanks · 19/09/2023 13:54

....and yet, this is the school system you have chosen to educate your child. Things will probably go better if you work with them and try and hide your very obvious disdain.
Or homeschool.
Or look for an internstional school.
Or repatriate.

twokidstwowheels · 19/09/2023 13:25

Bettyboobaloo · 16/09/2023 13:44

French schools aren't 30 years behind for starters. I find that quite offensive. This is a problem in your school, not in 'french' schools.

Feel free to be offended. I'll rephrase it to "local" French schools. This is something known to parents around here so my claim is based on evidence from talking to other parents: mostly French but also some Spanish, etc., as the community is pretty mixed in this area. Weirdly it's the other English parents who tend not to engage but I think part of that is because they're not speaking to the French parents and also can't imagine how bad it could be! It's easier to think that what happened to my son (and one other boy, and the countless others parents have told me about) is due to an anomaly and blame individual children. If you came out of your schooling here with good memories of your time in education, then you were lucky! Here it is undoubtedly 30 years behind and in villages it is utterly hit and miss. A mediocre teacher who doesn't traumatise any children is considered a win.

OP posts:
EvelynBeatrice · 19/09/2023 08:01

This is a general point about discipline in schools and not directed at the OP because, as I said below, it makes sense to take account of individual needs before imposing disciplinary measures.
My heart goes out to you. Navigating education practices in another country must be challenging especially with school refusal which is scary.

EvelynBeatrice · 19/09/2023 07:59

I was told my a primary school teacher acquaintance this week that the entire primary school are off to the theatre next week. Before that he would be spending part of the day trying to teach his class of nine year olds how to behave in a theatre - putting seats out in rows and explaining that they couldn't shout at the actors or get out of their chairs and move about every five minutes. These are NT children in a mixed, but not very poor catchment, several of whom are close to unmanageable and due to lack of parental support for any disciplinary measures at all, learn nothing.

Ladybug14 · 19/09/2023 06:06

Work with the teacher to stop your son shouting out in class

Happinessandlove · 19/09/2023 05:51

The question is not what is acceptable to France or the UK....but what is acceptable to YOU in relation to your child. Even if the French and English would accept this if it is traumatic for you son in light of his history it isn't acceptable. THAT is what you need to tell the teacher.

bridgetreilly · 19/09/2023 00:33

I really couldn’t get worked up about this as a punishment. Sometimes that’s exactly what a child needs: to be separated from their peers, without eye contact, until the teacher can get to them and resolve the situation. I’m kind of shocked at the outrage about it.

Madamfrog · 18/09/2023 23:29

When he behaves more appropriately he won't have to do that. He isn't being singled out or humiliated, he is learning that some behaviour isn't acceptable. Ecole primaire is for learning how to behave as a French person as much as anything else.

Children aren't sent out of the room because a) they can't follow what's going on in class and b) they would be unsupervised.

You may think we are strict and weird and old-fashioned because we insist on what we consider good behaviour; for us UK schools insisting children all wear the same thing and can't have their hair as they like it seems '30 years out of date'. Maybe France is not for you.

Don't go and tell the maire you think the punishment is too harsh, he or she won't understand why you would wish to have a badly-behaved child.

XenoBitch · 18/09/2023 23:02

I had no idea this was a thing anymore.
I was very good in school, but was forced to stand in the corner and face the wall for a lesson. My crime? It was end of term so the teacher set us games to play. One such game was being paired up with someone else, one person going on all fours, and the other person straddling them. I was paired with a boy, and I refused. I was made to stand in the corner for the rest of the lesson, and had a dinner time detention. I was 14 at this time.

Almostfifty1974 · 18/09/2023 22:56

Not acceptable- Teacher should give reminders in private and then keep in and chat at break for 2 mins if continues. Standing facing wall vey old fashioned and humiliating :(

Mollymalone123 · 18/09/2023 22:43

in Uk it’s quite a common practice to send a badly behaved child to sit in another class with a teacher.I really can’t see any difference between that and facing a wall. If you get sent to a class everyone knows why you’re there.It isn’t traumatic - upsetting maybe but as others have said it’ll give them time to reflect and think ‘hey maybe next time I’ll do as the teacher asked’
I certainly wouldn’t be complaining- I would be talking to my child about acceptable behaviour though.

IamMoodyBlue · 18/09/2023 22:32

It's absolutely ok to use standing facing a wall as a sanction when a child is refusing to behave acceptably.
There is no violence, children used to be smacked. There is no humiliation, children used to be shouted at and ridiculed.
Standing a child outside the classroom is not reasonable. The child is not being supervised, and cannot hear the lesson.
Well done teacher for not accepting the unacceptable, having lessons disrupted and simple rules flouted repeatedly.

Father1 · 18/09/2023 19:14

He'll be fine, be more strict yourself and stop being a bad parent. If he gets in trouble then you tell him off as well, he'll think twice about being a disruptive little shit next time. Stop letting him get away with bunking. If he's I'll send him in. If he's lost his shoes, send him in shoeless...

I'm 32 not 72 and our weak tolerable system is what leads to ASBOs, bring back the cane!

ConsuelaHammock · 17/09/2023 12:53

What happened in the previous school? You need to teach your child to be more resilient. The world is not a kind place and unfortunately sometimes kids do have to just suck it up.

ConsuelaHammock · 17/09/2023 12:52

I like the sound of the french schools tbh. Some kids here are practically feral.

ConsuelaHammock · 17/09/2023 12:51

Schools here will move children to another seat with the child’s back to the rest of the class. It’s almost the same thing and used to stop the disruptive child interacting and egging on the rest of the class. It’s a perfectly acceptable strategy.

Siameasy · 17/09/2023 11:41

ladykale · 17/09/2023 11:23

This is why U.K. schools are shite now... zero discipline and parents "kicking off" when their children are disciplined

Agree; many want to be friends with their kids. We are quite strict about behaviour and rudeness although DD has a lot of personal freedom and independence. I honestly only know a few families like us. Everyone else is “if you do that again I’m throwing all your toys in the bin”. I get shocked looks when I follow through on punishment. DD’s auntie finds it really uncomfortable and tries to placate and I find this quite typical now.

ladykale · 17/09/2023 11:23

Cheirosa · 16/09/2023 10:47

No it’s not and I’d absolutely kick off. This was a ‘thing’ in the very early 90s in the UK but not now!

This is why U.K. schools are shite now... zero discipline and parents "kicking off" when their children are disciplined

Aroma220 · 17/09/2023 10:35

UK teacher here, no it is not acceptable to make a child do this but equally if a child is being disruptive to the point no learning is taking place then you would naturally assume the teacher is going to give consequences.

I have no idea how the French education systems works so I’m not sure why you ask about UK schools but my thoughts on your problems are:

You mention you worked closely with the previous teacher and things were better? Have you not spoken to this new teacher? You are making assumptions that as she is new to the school that her style is different. Equally, your child is new to this teacher. A lot of children push boundaries in the first few weeks of school which is entirely natural. Children feel more comfortable knowing what is okay and what isn’t okay. I personally wouldn’t punish a child like this but I do make clear very early on what isn’t going to be tolerated in my classroom. A more constructive consequence for children who push the boundaries is to work with them on why we have rules in place and the impact their behaviour has on others. ND or not, we are teaching children how to survive in society where there are rules you have to follow. This can be done without publicly embarrassing or humiliating the child.

There are several posts on this thread about ND. At this developmental stage, our brains are making social connections. Children are literally programmed to connect with each other all the time and that biology had been around a lot longer than any formal education system. A child who is calling out isn’t necessarily ADHD, autistic or anything else, but it can be a sign.

OP you don’t give any context to this punishment. Is it a one off event or are the children constantly calling out? Seems pretty severe if your child called out once. Did his old teacher allow calling out? There’s a lot to unpick here.

You need to get into school and speak to the teacher asap. It’s my absolute pet peeve when parents would rather speak to other parents/other children/the neighbour’s cat about a problem rather than talking to me. Maybe the teacher isn’t aware of your son’s difficulties coming into school and you can work together on making things better for him.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 17/09/2023 09:14

Also there are a lot of responses about ADHD and ASD etc. Of course if he was doing something as a result of a neurdivergance then the teacher should make reasonable adjustments such as ignoring tics.

However has the OP said that he has Amy diagnosis or she has suspicious that he is not neurological?

There is a big difference between punishing a symptom of ASD and punishing a kid for a similar behaviour that they are doing deliberately to annoy others

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 17/09/2023 09:10

I don't think it would be acceptable in UK schools. But there are regular threads about UK schools along the lines of the teachers can't control the class as the kids know they have no real authority to punish, the kids do whatever they want as the teachers have no recourse day to day to stop bad behaviour in the classroom and there is no respect for teachers and so kids don't feel the need to listen to them etc.

So although it isn't like the UK, I'm not sure that the UK has the balance quite right either so might not be a useful comparison.

What does your son not like about it? That he doesn't feel he did anything wrong? That he doesn't understand why he was punished? That he felt humiliated infront of all his friends? That he is used to a parenting style that explains his behaviours and asks him to correct them, rather than being punished for them? How long was he there for? I don't think there is anything wrong in asking a child to stand away from distractions etc for a few minutes. But not explaining why, punishing for very small reasons (eg a single loud cough, first offence etc) without adequate warning, not explaining why you were being punished, or if the wall say is in the front of the class for all the other children to look at you and it is seen as some kind of humiliation, is different

JMSA · 17/09/2023 08:57

Did you get professional help for your son's school-based anxiety, before moving him to a different country with a different education system?
I'd have a gentle word with the teacher, and explain that this punishment is very different to the UK. Offer to support rather than complain.

Swipe left for the next trending thread