Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just restrict dogs over a certain weight/size?

186 replies

Stroopwaffels · 16/09/2023 09:14

The main problem with the proposed law about banning these XL bulldogs appears to be defining exactly what a XL bulldog is, given that so many are part one thing, part another. All that's going to happen is that the irresponsible owners are just going to argue that their dog is something else, and it's going to cost a fortune in kennelling and legal fees while it's all decided.

Wouldn't it be simpler and fairer to come up with some sort of law that says that dogs over a certain height/weight are restricted - they must be chipped with owner's details regularly updated, must be muzzled in public, must be neutered unless you have registered and paid £££ to be an official breeder, must be kept on a lead at all times etc etc etc. It's then far easier for a police officer to whip out a tape measure or scales and say that this dog is either covered by the law, or not.

Yes it would affect people like the woman who lives near me and who has two large Newfoundland dogs which don't appear to be aggressive at all but it's certainly clearer and easier for public and police.

OP posts:
JohnFinlaysNewTeeth · 16/09/2023 09:51

A child near me was permanently disfigured by a Jack Russell. Lost sight in one eye. Out with her mum and dad and sibling in a park, disabled mum who couldn’t easily fend off the dog, dad had taken sibling to toilet.

Its not hard to muzzle train a dog, but small dog owners always think they’re above big dog owners. At the end of the day you own an unpredictable animal that can cause harm, do something to protect others.

Ascendant15 · 16/09/2023 09:50

GolgafrinchamB · 16/09/2023 09:24

Ha! My first thought was “but Newfoundlands…”

Lovely gentle giants

My last service dog was nearly killed by two Newfoundland dogs. Two weeks in a veterinary hospital and he was never able to work again.

I don't like the so- called "status dogs" but whatever the breed it's the owners that are the problem. Banning dogs doesn't solve the problem and neither does registers. The irresponsible owners just move on to the next one, and the responsible ones will be the only ones on the register.

WalkingThroughTreacle · 16/09/2023 09:49

Personally, I would make owners face criminal charges directly proportionate to the actions of their dog(s). Your dog shits in a public place and you don't immediately clear it up then you personally get charged as if you had taken a shit yourself. Your dog snarls/barks aggressively at someone in a manner that would put a reasonable person in a state of fear then you get charged as if you had been acting in a threatening and aggressive manner yourself. Your dog bites someone then you get charged with assault/gbh etc. Your dog kills someone then you get charged with manslaughter/murder/unlawful killing. Such an approach would negate all this painful jumping through hoops as to the definition of a breed and puts the responsibility and consequences firmly where they should be, with the owner.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 16/09/2023 09:46

if a primary school aged kid couldn’t defeat it in a fight, ban it.

Frequency · 16/09/2023 09:46

@Stroopwaffels The government has known about it since it was highlighted in the report they asked EFRA to create a report re the effectiveness of the DDA.

I suspect it won't get the Tories as many votes as banning an unquantifiable mixed breed will though as it's based on common sense and scientific evidence around dog behaviour and not knee-jerk hysteria.

Bylaws related to dogs (calgary.ca)

https://redstarcafe.wordpress.com/2010/08/25/the-calgary-model/

Bylaws related to dogs

Responsible dog ownership is an important part of maintaining a happy, healthy dog and avoiding dog-related disputes with your neighbours. Part of being

https://www.calgary.ca/bylaws/dogs.html

GolgafrinchamB · 16/09/2023 09:45

Loafie · 16/09/2023 09:40

I'd be more scared of an aggressive chihuahua than a newfoundland.

My brother nearly lost part of an ear to a Jack Russell when he was a kid.

A Newfound is a mountain of gentleness. (And drool and shedding hair)

Wanderingllama · 16/09/2023 09:44

My first thought was "erm, poor Bernese!". @GolgafrinchamB

Licenece, mandatory training attendance. Where I grew up we made it very clear what we thought of people who didn't train their dogs. Everyone i know went to training ground.

billysillydilly · 16/09/2023 09:42

It isn’t just the XL bully deaths it’s the dogs under no control in parks, shops, restaurants, the vast amount of dog crap lying about, the incessant barking etc all because idiots buy dogs and then can’t be arsed with the upkeep

this is true, the amount of shit on pavements now!!!

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 16/09/2023 09:42

CurlewKate · 16/09/2023 09:36

I do think that's a good idea. I know this is impossible, but I'd actually also like a prison sentence for anyone who posts a picture on social media of a baby/child cuddling/sleeping on/sharing toys or food with/ dogs. Or any other so called "cute" interaction. They are all just disasters waiting to happen. For everyone involved, including the dog.

A prison sentence 🤣🤣🤣

Loafie · 16/09/2023 09:40

GolgafrinchamB · 16/09/2023 09:24

Ha! My first thought was “but Newfoundlands…”

Lovely gentle giants

I'd be more scared of an aggressive chihuahua than a newfoundland.

billysillydilly · 16/09/2023 09:39

I think even little dogs have the ability to savage people and other dogs / wildlife so no cant agree.

I'd prefer to take on a chihuahua attacking my dc as opposed to bully breed!

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 16/09/2023 09:39

Surely just reducing the amount of irresponsible dog owners and the number of dogs would go some way towards reducing the problems currently faced? It isn’t just the XL bully deaths it’s the dogs under no control in parks, shops, restaurants, the vast amount of dog crap lying about, the incessant barking etc all because idiots buy dogs and then can’t be arsed with the upkeep

crowsfeet57 · 16/09/2023 09:38

My newfoundland is so gentle. He doesn't appear to know what his teeth are for and wouldn't hurt a fly. We don't allow him off the lead when we walk him because his recall isn't brilliant and people are often nervous of him because of his size. If we had to muzzle him he would die because he doesn't cope well with heat and needs to be able to pant even in relatively mild temperatures.

Let's bite the bullet and deal with people who have large dogs to intimidate others and make themselves look big ibstead of penalising people who research dog breeds and specifically select gentle breeds.

MelodiousThunk · 16/09/2023 09:38

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 16/09/2023 09:22

Or how about just making it more difficult for the general public to have ANY type of breed of dog, make it as inconvenient and expensive as possible with lots of training and proof needed to be able to have one the only those who are properly responsible owners and working dogs would be left

In a country where 34% of households own a dog that’s never going to happen. No MP who actually wanted to stay in the job would vote for it.

Stroopwaffels · 16/09/2023 09:37

Frequency · 16/09/2023 09:34

Or we could use evidence-based techniques to reduce the number of attacks and/or copy other countries or states that have successfully reduced the number of attacks by 80% or more.

It's widely believed that Calagary's method is the most successful, having reduced the number of dog-related injuries by over 80% since it was started. As opposed to BSL and the DDA which has seen our dog-related injuries rise by over 150% since it was implemented.

And what have they done? You post as if this "evidence-based technique" is common knowledge and I really don't think it is.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 16/09/2023 09:36

I do think that's a good idea. I know this is impossible, but I'd actually also like a prison sentence for anyone who posts a picture on social media of a baby/child cuddling/sleeping on/sharing toys or food with/ dogs. Or any other so called "cute" interaction. They are all just disasters waiting to happen. For everyone involved, including the dog.

3WildOnes · 16/09/2023 09:35

All dog owners should be registered and as a requirement of that they should have to have their dogs chipped, take puppy training classes and have insurance. This would cut down on irresponsible dog ownership.

Theimpossiblegirl · 16/09/2023 09:35

The Tories are desperate to look like they're doing something about something. An outright ban on a breed that isn't a recognised breed, so difficult to prove, is just to try to get some votes. They will just be replaced with another big status dog. The XL bullies, not the Tories, unfortunately.

loudbatperson · 16/09/2023 09:34

I am a dog lover and but I agree that we need far more regulations around dogs, including ownership and breeding.

Yes people will ignore regulation's etc, but just because the system wouldn't be perfect doesn't mean it's not worth doing.

I have a rescue beagle cross, and he is the gentlest dog going. However I still take precautions, as you can never be 100% what any animal will do.

Frequency · 16/09/2023 09:34

Or we could use evidence-based techniques to reduce the number of attacks and/or copy other countries or states that have successfully reduced the number of attacks by 80% or more.

It's widely believed that Calagary's method is the most successful, having reduced the number of dog-related injuries by over 80% since it was started. As opposed to BSL and the DDA which has seen our dog-related injuries rise by over 150% since it was implemented.

drinkuptheezider · 16/09/2023 09:34

bombastix · 16/09/2023 09:23

It's exactly what the government should do, to make licensing, insurance compulsory for big breeds to address risk. Responsible owners will do that.

The irresponsible ones will not, and they can be banned from keeping animals for life and prosecuted.

There has to be the appetite to actually prosecute. Given that electric scooters are illegal but the police turn a blind eye, I can't see it happening. The problem dogs usually belong to a certain type of person, who dont follow laws on drugs, trafficking, prostitution, extortion, I can't see them being that fussed that 'Titan' isn't registered.

Coatscoatscoast · 16/09/2023 09:31

I agree with you OP and I say that as a dog lover. There should be regulations about owning any animal really, particularly over a certain size. Yes large dogs are often gentle giants but the point is <if> they were to attack the damage would be far more devastating. I thinking of house cats and big cats - both hunt in the same way (yes house cats are domestic but still predators) - you could fight off a house cat while a big cat would just eat you! I honestly think all dogs needs to be licences but all dogs with a certain jaw size need muzzles. Feels unfair but that’s the damage these idiot owners have done.

D3LAN3Y · 16/09/2023 09:29

This is the argument all over the Internet at the moment.
"Well yorkies have killed babies...."
I can punt a small dog over a fence in an attack, I can't against a bigger dog.
I do think dog licensing should make a come back. If you can't afford it, then you can't really afford a dog.

I think the tories have just declared an outright ban on XL bullies to make it look like they've taken action when they've yet to establish what the XL bullbreeds actually consist of. The variants in puppies is absolutely crazy. You have some that are stocky, little tanks and others with a leaner, longer build. They aren't even a pure breed of dog. It's lazy law making.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 16/09/2023 09:27

Me personally I would never have a dog because I work and have children so couldn’t provide the time and training it would need plus I don’t really want to have to pick up another animals faeces which, judging by the amount of dog crap lying about, neither do actual dog owners

Stroopwaffels · 16/09/2023 09:27

zingally · 16/09/2023 09:25

Not that simple. What about breeds like Saint Bernards? Or Irish Wolfhounds? Absolutely giant things, but wouldn't ever hurt a fly.

You are much more likely to get a nasty bite from something like a chihuahua which is just a rat on a rope.

Again, you are not going to be killed or permanently disfigured by a "rat on a rope".

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread