Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just restrict dogs over a certain weight/size?

186 replies

Stroopwaffels · 16/09/2023 09:14

The main problem with the proposed law about banning these XL bulldogs appears to be defining exactly what a XL bulldog is, given that so many are part one thing, part another. All that's going to happen is that the irresponsible owners are just going to argue that their dog is something else, and it's going to cost a fortune in kennelling and legal fees while it's all decided.

Wouldn't it be simpler and fairer to come up with some sort of law that says that dogs over a certain height/weight are restricted - they must be chipped with owner's details regularly updated, must be muzzled in public, must be neutered unless you have registered and paid £££ to be an official breeder, must be kept on a lead at all times etc etc etc. It's then far easier for a police officer to whip out a tape measure or scales and say that this dog is either covered by the law, or not.

Yes it would affect people like the woman who lives near me and who has two large Newfoundland dogs which don't appear to be aggressive at all but it's certainly clearer and easier for public and police.

OP posts:
tigpig · 16/09/2023 10:25

I'm in complete agreement with strick licencing and Insurance for all dogs. Also ye s these new Frankenstein breeds created by people to be strong and agessive like XL bullys absolutely need banning.
But not sure weight/ height is the right way?
How big is a golden retriever for example?
Now jaw type and strength perhaps should be considered? What was the dog actually bred for?
I absolutely hate this trend for strong mascular dogs and sorry that includes Stafford bull terriers.
Maybe all owners as part of the licence should have to pay for a DNA of the dog showing the mix?

Goldbar · 16/09/2023 10:24

theluckiest · 16/09/2023 10:15

Compulsory muzzling in public won't solve the problem.

What about people (particularly kids) who have been killed in their own homes by the family 'pet?'

I don't know what the answer is. Banning XL bully breeds would be a start though...

It would solve the problem for most of us, though.

We can't control what others do within their own homes or the dangers to which they subject their own children (and this is not limited to dogs), unless it reaches a standard when social services would intervene, but anything that would reduce the risk to the general public has to be a good thing.

Twistler · 16/09/2023 10:23

The few have ruined it for the many with their obsession with parading the sort of animal round the streets no one should be allowed without a licence.

Requiring ALL dog to be muzzled and on a lead in public won't happen because the Gov are more concerned about votes than all the people and animals XL bullies are maiming and killing so I wouldn't worry.

IMO, honestly, as sad as it is and it will affect me, all dogs should be on a lead in public. All bull breeds should be licenced, muzzled and neutered so they eventually die out. I have a very docile Rottweiler but like a PP, would muzzle her if it meant Chayanne and Dwayne had to keep their bastard bully muzzled too and no more innocent people and animals became XL bully fodder.

StBrides · 16/09/2023 10:21

billysillydilly · 16/09/2023 10:08

@StBrides I haven't said they have? However you said small dogs can do just as much harm? In response to "rat on a rope"...

You rather missed the bigger point...

Which is that it's ridiculous to place restrictions such as enforcing muzzles on all large dogs (or dogs over a certain size, if you like) on the basis that certain people 'breed' (and I use the term loosely) dogs to meet certain requirements of body shape and temperament to be dangerous in order to strengthen their own reputations as dangerous men (usually men).

The result is familial lines of mixed breeds dogs that have had the characteristics of strength and aggression bred into them. Mixed breeds seem to be such an issue in the UK because pit bulls are already banned.

It would be more realistic to ban all dogs vaguely of that type, which would include staffies, than it would be to muzzle and restrict all dogs that are too big to reasonably carry (for example).

Of course, many people know that isn't a certain breed of dog which is a problem, but a certain type of person. That doesn't remove the argument for banning certain types of dangerous dogs, however, and I'm not suggesting it should.

The view that size is directly proportional to risk is ridiculous and (honestly) pretty ignorant.

Cornettoninja · 16/09/2023 10:20

Frequency · 16/09/2023 10:12

I think Calgary found that education was the key to reducing dangerous dog behaviour and irresponsible ownership. They use licensing and fines to fund education around welfare and behaviour.

They are not the only state/country to repeal BSL either. Italy, Spain, Germany, and the Netherlands have all repealed their BSL laws after research has proven it to be ineffective in reducing the number of hospitalisations due to dog-related injuries.

There was a Panorama show in January this year which looked into where these dogs are coming from. They are primarily being bred by county lines dealers and criminals who are making tens of thousands a month from them. Do we really believe these people will just give up a commodity that earns them more than drugs ever did because the law says they have to?

BSL didn't reduce the number of Pitbulls in the UK nor did it reduce the number of Pitbull related deaths. I have no idea why anyone is in support of adding more breeds to BSL. It does absolutely nothing to resolve the problems caused by irresponsible ownership.

It does absolutely nothing to resolve the problems caused by irresponsible ownership

What would resolve that then? Realistically and within the resources we have?

education is great and I’m all for it; however, criminals and dealers are also not going to give a shiny shit about that either. The types of people involved in dog fighting, for instance, would be more inclined to follow any education as a guide on how to produce a really dangerous dog by doing the opposite.

There are many people who want to be responsible owners and will make different choices by legislation just existing. In this instance, something is absolutely better than nothing.

AnchorWHAT · 16/09/2023 10:18

billysillydilly · 16/09/2023 10:10

@AnchorWHAT you can use whatever wording you like. However you said you didn't want to be perceived as dumb, so just a helpful tip!

i was not being sarcastic as you seem to have percieved my reply, i agreed that i had perhaps used the wrong word. Also i never said i dont want to be perceived as dumb at all, i said i am not dumb in response to a poster who i felt was unnecessarily rude

Frequency · 16/09/2023 10:17

Any adult dog could win in a fair fight with a primary school-age child.

This is patently untrue and does as much to fuel the hysteria as calls to carry guns in public do.

My DD has two Chihuahuas. If I put them both in a box with a rat I'd put money on the rat faring better than the dogs. They certainly could not kill or seriously injure a primary school-aged child. Their mouths aren't big enough to fit more than a finger inside.

One of them bit me once when DD asked me to hold her while she trimmed her nails. She bit me so hard she was physically shaking from the effort. I had a bruise and minor cuts that could be remedied with a sticking plaster.

Both sides of the debate need to be sensible for it to achieve anything meaningful.

Aquestioningmind · 16/09/2023 10:15

YABVVU.

The sort of scum people who have dogs like this won’t muzzle it. They won’t pay a fine. And the police won’t do anything to enforce it as they’re too scared not equipped.

My golden was been attacked by a Jack Russel two weeks ago - the wound was so deep (on his stomach) it required stitches and cost me several hundred to get sorted. All my lump of a dog did was roll onto his back and cower and scream.

But sure let’s stop the gentle giants being able to defend themselves whilst these monsters and scum drug dealer owners carry on as normal.

Ultimately, these people won’t ever turn a golden retriever, cavapoo or a Newfie aggressive. They will buy particular dogs with particular characteristics as a ‘status symbol’ as they have tiny willies and need something to make themselves feel good.

We need restrictions on who can buy dogs that can be used as attack dogs. Yes - I do include GSDs etc in that. No one needs a GSD/Rottie/Doberman/Belgium M unless they serve in the military or forces. And I say that as someone who grew up with GSDs.

theluckiest · 16/09/2023 10:15

Compulsory muzzling in public won't solve the problem.

What about people (particularly kids) who have been killed in their own homes by the family 'pet?'

I don't know what the answer is. Banning XL bully breeds would be a start though...

Goodornot · 16/09/2023 10:13

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 16/09/2023 09:22

Or how about just making it more difficult for the general public to have ANY type of breed of dog, make it as inconvenient and expensive as possible with lots of training and proof needed to be able to have one the only those who are properly responsible owners and working dogs would be left

There is an active thread called how much do you spend on your dog per month.

People are spending about £400+ in some cases.

Dog walking, day care and classes.

When did dogs become children?

Based on that thread only the Roch can afford them.

AgentProvocateur · 16/09/2023 10:13

All dogs, whatever their size, should be muzzled in public.

billysillydilly · 16/09/2023 10:12

I love dogs, grew up with an Irish wolfie & granny had dobermans. But some of the arguments people use to justify their dogs is akin to the crazy gun arguments. Too many people are plain thick.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 16/09/2023 10:12

missmollygreen · 16/09/2023 09:56

So many stupid statements in this thread, might as well add another I guess!

Any adult dog could win in a fair fight with a primary school age child.

How about a tweak. Ban any dog an average adult woman couldn’t beat in a fight.

We ban carrying knives with blades > 3” because of their potential to fatally injure. Do the same with dogs.

Frequency · 16/09/2023 10:12

I think Calgary found that education was the key to reducing dangerous dog behaviour and irresponsible ownership. They use licensing and fines to fund education around welfare and behaviour.

They are not the only state/country to repeal BSL either. Italy, Spain, Germany, and the Netherlands have all repealed their BSL laws after research has proven it to be ineffective in reducing the number of hospitalisations due to dog-related injuries.

There was a Panorama show in January this year which looked into where these dogs are coming from. They are primarily being bred by county lines dealers and criminals who are making tens of thousands a month from them. Do we really believe these people will just give up a commodity that earns them more than drugs ever did because the law says they have to?

BSL didn't reduce the number of Pitbulls in the UK nor did it reduce the number of Pitbull related deaths. I have no idea why anyone is in support of adding more breeds to BSL. It does absolutely nothing to resolve the problems caused by irresponsible ownership.

Marblessolveeverything · 16/09/2023 10:11

There are several large breeds which wouldn't manage a muzzle e.g. Newfoundlands etc. Plenty of large dogs have no history of attacking.

I don't think I've ever heard of an attack leading to serious injuries from such gentle giants as Great Danes, Irish Wolf hounds.

We have a reasonable amount of research sadly of attacks surely a study could be conducted to identify key risks apply that and carry out reviews to expand banned breeds if needed.

billysillydilly · 16/09/2023 10:10

@AnchorWHAT you can use whatever wording you like. However you said you didn't want to be perceived as dumb, so just a helpful tip!

Cornettoninja · 16/09/2023 10:10

@SaturdayGiraffe from your link:

Friendly reminder that pitbull slander is one small step away from alt-right racism.

"This group is only x% of the population but does y% of the violence" is quite literally neonazi talking point.

Hmm

that’s some impressive hyperbolic anthropomorphism. Five stars for proving the point that some owners simply shouldn’t be in charge of any animal. They simply can’t respect the basic fact they’re not human and psychologically work very, very differently.

billysillydilly · 16/09/2023 10:08

@StBrides I haven't said they have? However you said small dogs can do just as much harm? In response to "rat on a rope"...

Densol57 · 16/09/2023 10:08

Ive owned many dogs, trained and shown them. Dogs behave for me, apart from a Staff my ex owned. It was utterly vile, nasty piece of work. It had hate in its eyes when it looked at me. I still have scars on my arms from it. I refused to have it near me or to my house.

Size is irrelevant. Its the dogs temperament and jaw strength. I hate any staff type mixes of dogs. Ban cannot come soon enough 🦴🐾🐶

BoobyDazzler · 16/09/2023 10:07

That is patently untrue. Small dogs when aggressive can just as much damage and harm.

This might be the stupidest thing I’ve ever read on one of these threads. There is no way a border terrier or a whippet or a chihuahua could cause anywhere near the level of damage a bull breed, a cane corso or a mastiff could.

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 16/09/2023 10:06

Frequency · 16/09/2023 09:34

Or we could use evidence-based techniques to reduce the number of attacks and/or copy other countries or states that have successfully reduced the number of attacks by 80% or more.

It's widely believed that Calagary's method is the most successful, having reduced the number of dog-related injuries by over 80% since it was started. As opposed to BSL and the DDA which has seen our dog-related injuries rise by over 150% since it was implemented.

What are these techniques you mention?

Enthusedeggplant · 16/09/2023 10:06

The policy of generic muzzling wouldn’t make any difference to the owners of these dogs who generally won’t comply.

StBrides · 16/09/2023 10:06

billysillydilly · 16/09/2023 10:04

@StBrides have any toy dogs killed adults in the UK?

Have any great Danes?

Cutestfeet · 16/09/2023 10:05

I agree but I don't agree with being on a lead always. The reason a lot of dogs attack is because of lack of exercise. Big dogs need to be able to run around and not everyone has a garden.
Muzzle fine, not off lead near a playground fine but large fields or parks or forest they should be able to run around

Mountainhowl · 16/09/2023 10:05

I don't think size/weight is the way to go, it looked like a staffy size dog who was chewing on that lads arm in Walsall, didn't look large enough to be an XL bully (the breed wasn't in the news story I read, sorry if I'm wrong), Staffies are quite short so if you wanted to include all breeds that have recently attacked someone then you're going to have to have the height limit quite low, some are the size of spaniels!

If it's going on weight that seems unfair (my dog was under 20kg in her prime, she was spayed late in life due to pyo and ballooned and we are struggling to get it back off, she's 13 and never so much as looked at someone the wrong way) and could well cause the idiots who want a dodgy dog to just underfeed their dogs to keep them under the weight threshold

There needs to be more dog wardens, enforced leash laws and enclosed dog parks that are public use, there was one where we used to live and it was great, but here the only ones are pay per hour and all out in the sticks. If dogs had to be on a 6ft lead outside of these off lead areas (which should be in most/all large parks ideally, so there's no excuse not to use one) and there were big fines for dogs not on lead (unless working) that would curb people letting them run all about the place out of control. The problem would be that the dogs in the park could be at risk, we didn't have many problems at the dog park but obviously scraps did happen occasionally, maybe separate sections for small and large dogs like they do in the USA.

More dog wardens to report to and follow up on reports of our of control dogs, in this I would absolutely include dogs who are dragging their owners around, jumping and barking at people, yes some non aggressive dogs do this out of excitement/lack of training, but it would encourage people to put more effort into training.

Put this info on adverts on the TV/radio/bus stops, have an easy to remember number for the dog warden, enforce the lead fines and make the punishment for owning an aggressive dog prison time (and being Ramsey Bolton-ed if it attacks someone)