Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just restrict dogs over a certain weight/size?

186 replies

Stroopwaffels · 16/09/2023 09:14

The main problem with the proposed law about banning these XL bulldogs appears to be defining exactly what a XL bulldog is, given that so many are part one thing, part another. All that's going to happen is that the irresponsible owners are just going to argue that their dog is something else, and it's going to cost a fortune in kennelling and legal fees while it's all decided.

Wouldn't it be simpler and fairer to come up with some sort of law that says that dogs over a certain height/weight are restricted - they must be chipped with owner's details regularly updated, must be muzzled in public, must be neutered unless you have registered and paid £££ to be an official breeder, must be kept on a lead at all times etc etc etc. It's then far easier for a police officer to whip out a tape measure or scales and say that this dog is either covered by the law, or not.

Yes it would affect people like the woman who lives near me and who has two large Newfoundland dogs which don't appear to be aggressive at all but it's certainly clearer and easier for public and police.

OP posts:
ChallengeAnneka · 16/09/2023 11:08

I agree with the OP. And I say this as someone who has owned gentle, large dog breeds. Having those conditions imposed would not be a problem for responsible owners.

WetBandits · 16/09/2023 11:04

MindfulBear · 16/09/2023 10:43

The problem is not the size of the dog. The problem is the fact these problem dogs are doing what they have been bred for - to be physically aggressive and killers.

However means DNA testing will be a must prior to euthanising a dog that hasn't actually inflicted GBH or murder on someone. Hence that isn't the solution offered by government.

The police have data on the DNA of euthanised dogs and dogs involved in injuring / killing people. I understand that with these XL Bully types can often be traced back to a specific aggressive American dog which was bred for dog fighting. Which was legal until the 70s and still happening in the early 2000s.

Why you would want to own such a dog in the U.K. is totally beyond me. I can understand it in violent lawless countries where you might need to defend yourself, your family and your property. But many of these incidents happen in urban areas of the U.K.

The proposal to muzzle, register and neuter certain types of dogs is good. But only for law abiding pet owners out n about.

I don't think it resolves the majority of the problem - ie people being mauled to death / seriously injured in their granny's caravan or at their mates house and definitely not on the street by a stranger's dog.

I’m uneasy about DNA testing being used to determine the fate of a dog that hasn’t put a foot wrong. I had my rescue dog DNA tested out of pure curiosity and his result came back as absolute mutt (as expected!) but part of that mutt turned out to be a small percentage of APBT. Phenotypically, he looks nothing like an APBT so it was a huge surprise to discover that in his results!

I never tell anyone about that part of his DNA because I don’t know where I would stand legally if he was reported as being part APBT, based on it being a banned breed in the UK. It’s a small percentage of his genetic makeup, unreflected in his outward appearance, but it’s still there.

CurlewKate · 16/09/2023 11:02

There's another thread-I think it's still running-where people are boasting about how "protective" their dogs are, and how they snarl and bark at anybody "suspicious" looking who approaches them. It really isn't a huge leap from that to the owners if these XL Bullies.....

MindfulBear · 16/09/2023 11:01

This thread is bizarre.

All dogs can kill or maim. Yes. Even that yorkie or westie or the chihuahua. They could remove eyes ears fingers and, if they went for the jugular they could kill. Babies have died. Or don't they count as they weren't an adult?

There are dog attacks every week but majority don't make the news. Of course it's the Staffie / pitbull / XL bully types that make the news. It feeds into the "them" and "us" PLUs / NPLUs classist thing we have going on in the U.K. ("naice people like us wouldn't own such a dog" etc)

look at what dogs have been bred for. If they were bred for ratting or driving badgers out of their sets, then yes that dog will have a prey drive.

And once the prey drive is activated an adult would have difficulty over powering it.

And then it doesn't matter whether it is a big dog or a small dog doing the damage.

Yes training helps. But that is part of responsible ownership. However we have a problem in the U.K. with drugs and county lines and also with status / status symbols.

More needs to be done to deal with these social issues in order to stop the dog attacks.

If people don't need the dogs, if county lines gangs don't breed them, etc then their number will automatically reduce.

Mountainhowl · 16/09/2023 11:01

@AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii

Of course, what I'm saying is that spaying/neutering shouldn't be a requirement for a dog to exist unless it's going to be bred from, there are other reasons responsible owners have for keeping their dog intact.

If we bring back licences then we could do something like spay/neuter discount vouchers with the profits, which will encourage those who want to neuter but struggle with the £300+ cost for a bitch spay, and we could have an enhanced license for those who are intact, at a higher cost, and could include DNA profiling as part of this, so that if a dog attacks and it is found to be related to one of these dogs then that can be traced back and the breeder punished too. This would encourage breeders to really vet their potential puppy buyers

D3LAN3Y · 16/09/2023 10:57

My DD was bitten by our Yorkshire terrier (almost took her eye out) and got rehomed to a woman with no DC or DGC, I've been bitten by a rottweiler when I was a teen (in a park, luckily owner jumped straight in, so damage was a singular bite that wasn't fixed) and my DS has been bitten by our neighbours Japanese Akita. All different dogs, all different bite strengths. All fucking terrifying.
Licensing would probably be the best way forward but requires the most legal framework and effort.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 16/09/2023 10:55

@Mountainhowl that’s fine I’m assuming you take reasonable steps though to stop your dog just having litter after litter Willy nilly? A lot don’t

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 16/09/2023 10:54

@YapYap2023 presumably these people would be able to prove they can care for their pet and pick up after them, giving them the time and training needed? I’m not talking about these people I’m talking about the idiots buying dogs and not taking care of them properly effectively making them other peoples problem and unfortunately this continues to rise

GolgafrinchamB · 16/09/2023 10:53

Calgary is a city, not a province, state or country. Its bylaw has all dogs registered and issues fines for chasing, biting, any sort of antisocial behaviour. The city invests in animal control. That's why there's the 70-80% drop in dog attacks

It's much more doable on a smaller scale of a city than a country of 65 million where infrastructure is shot all to hell and there's no public investment.

Setting up a legally required licencing system for all dogs, with an annual charge, to fund monitoring and policing policies like the Calgary bylaws would be a massive undertaking in the UK and I don't think the political will is there.

This feckless government would rather make announcements about completely ungovernable laws to attract headlines than address the problem itself.

BygoneDays · 16/09/2023 10:52

The police really want to be weighing and measuring random dogs. Imagine the pleasure it will bring them. Better than catching criminals certainly.

YapYap2023 · 16/09/2023 10:51

Pisses

Mountainhowl · 16/09/2023 10:51

Neutering isn't always a good thing, neutering an anxious dog prior to training can often times make them worse, early neutering under 2 years old can be problematic as the growth plates haven't closed yet, spaying can cause spay incontinence (why we chose not to spay our second bitch, after our first needed lifelong medication to stop her pissing herself without noticing) etc etc. It's not a one size fits all thing

YapYap2023 · 16/09/2023 10:51

Stroopwaffels · 16/09/2023 09:25

I would support that - but I don't think it would be popular with the "fur baby mums". Owning a dog should be expensive - and for people who do it properly with insurance, vet checks, buying from a reputable breeder etc it is expensive.

This privileged thinking possession me off.

What about homeless people whose only companion is their dog?

Or elderly people?

People that have had their dog years and is part of the family, but they are very close to scraping by now because of col.

Why punish everyone because of the few Confused

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 16/09/2023 10:48

@SleepingStandingUp surely only those with a licence to breed should be left with unneautered dogs though? Would stop just anyone having litters there is no need for general public to have unneutered pets

Justcashnosweets · 16/09/2023 10:48

Twistler · 16/09/2023 10:04

The bloody fur baby mentality has a lot to answer for!! All you twatting idiots who think you're so big and clever owning a dog bred purely to be intimidating have caused an absolute fucking car crash of a situation.

The prospect of Golden Retrievers, Springers Spaniels etc etc having to be kept muzzled and on the lead purely because you wanted the latest fucking fad just to go along with your inflated egos and lips. You didn't want a pet, you wanted something put on facebook. To show off to your equally twatty mates. Well, well done, good for you for potentially ruining dog ownership for hundreds of thousands of decent people who genuinely want a dog as a pet that poses no threat to others.

There are so many hundreds of dog breeds to choose from that make suitable pets and pose little to not threat to other people of animals even if they are badly bred or reared. XL bully/American Staff owners don't want a pet though. Their whole existence is focused on showing off. You selfish, selfish bastards.

I totally agree with you.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 16/09/2023 10:46

@TheSpruce exactly; that’s why it should be make very very expensive with costs at every turn for dog owners, it would cover the costs for enacting such policies and hopefully put off idiots

SleepingStandingUp · 16/09/2023 10:46

zingally · 16/09/2023 09:25

Not that simple. What about breeds like Saint Bernards? Or Irish Wolfhounds? Absolutely giant things, but wouldn't ever hurt a fly.

You are much more likely to get a nasty bite from something like a chihuahua which is just a rat on a rope.

I don't own a dog but can you clarify, if you owner a Saint Bernard or an Irish Wolfhound, which bits your object to and why?
Muzzling - I assume like anything there are kinder and meaner versions available?
Chipped - surely something any decent owner does?
Lead - presumably there will be options at dog free parks etc but frankly I don't need any dog small or large up in my space on the beach, walking through the main part of a park, walking to school etc.
Neutered - I do see why this is a bigger issue. I think there should be an option that isn't compulsory sterilisation unless the plan is to wipe out the dog population in a few generations.

Re smaller dogs, I assume people think thinks more like Staffies than something you can pop in your handbag

TheSpruce · 16/09/2023 10:44

I think we can all agree there are many laws and regulations that can be implemented to try and make positive change. But none of that matters of there is no way to ENFORCE it. We need resources where the police, or a well funded dog warden, can follow up on complaints and ensure people are punished for breakings these rules.

MindfulBear · 16/09/2023 10:43

The problem is not the size of the dog. The problem is the fact these problem dogs are doing what they have been bred for - to be physically aggressive and killers.

However means DNA testing will be a must prior to euthanising a dog that hasn't actually inflicted GBH or murder on someone. Hence that isn't the solution offered by government.

The police have data on the DNA of euthanised dogs and dogs involved in injuring / killing people. I understand that with these XL Bully types can often be traced back to a specific aggressive American dog which was bred for dog fighting. Which was legal until the 70s and still happening in the early 2000s.

Why you would want to own such a dog in the U.K. is totally beyond me. I can understand it in violent lawless countries where you might need to defend yourself, your family and your property. But many of these incidents happen in urban areas of the U.K.

The proposal to muzzle, register and neuter certain types of dogs is good. But only for law abiding pet owners out n about.

I don't think it resolves the majority of the problem - ie people being mauled to death / seriously injured in their granny's caravan or at their mates house and definitely not on the street by a stranger's dog.

GRex · 16/09/2023 10:40

I think the law should require every dog to be microchipped, every new puppy from the date of legislation must come from a licensed breeder, delegated authority powers to RSPCA to set clear rules for licensed breeders on welfare as well as breeding out aggression, and multiple police reports logged against the same breeder lead to investigation and loss of license. Police and dog wardens to have scanners able to check microchips against owner ID, a lot more fines for public nuisance or leaving poo, and mandated fines plus sentencing through magistrates Court (poo testing where needed for proof). It can all be self funded through fines.

Ponoka7 · 16/09/2023 10:40

"Any adult dog could win in a fair fight with a primary school-age child."

But it isn't primary aged children fighting them off. There's been at least two adult men trying to get the XL off, without success, in every case. There's a XL Billy in the US, his frozen sperm has been bought by people in the UK. His children are responsible for many deaths in the US, one dog took 14 gun shots before they lost their grip on the child they had hold of and had killed. That's one of the issues, the prey drive for anything smaller. Then the fighting ability, couple that with the irresponsible owners and we are saying that WC kids are worth sacrificing. In this recent attack, once again the dogs had previous history on attacking other dogs. In the area were I live they've been being walked in the intense heat passed schools at 3pm. They have also been getting taken on buses, into city centers etc Just why? I was a GS owner, the GS has qualities that outshine any downsides, the downsides only exist if they are overbred, so let's control breeding. Antisocial behaviour and in particular behaviour of teens is having a real impact, I agree that we need to address a few points to do with low level crime and dog ownership. Muzzling wouldn't have stopped four of the deaths and a dog if this size could still kill wearing a muzzle.

MrsMara · 16/09/2023 10:37

Twistler · 16/09/2023 10:23

The few have ruined it for the many with their obsession with parading the sort of animal round the streets no one should be allowed without a licence.

Requiring ALL dog to be muzzled and on a lead in public won't happen because the Gov are more concerned about votes than all the people and animals XL bullies are maiming and killing so I wouldn't worry.

IMO, honestly, as sad as it is and it will affect me, all dogs should be on a lead in public. All bull breeds should be licenced, muzzled and neutered so they eventually die out. I have a very docile Rottweiler but like a PP, would muzzle her if it meant Chayanne and Dwayne had to keep their bastard bully muzzled too and no more innocent people and animals became XL bully fodder.

Edited

I know there is nothing remotely funny about any of this, but your descriptions are so accurate @Twistler

I was on FB last night and the people defending these dogs all seemed to call each other hun and mate and had a similar command of English.

It is frightening that people of limited means can get hold of these damn dogs and nothing can be done about it. The whole situation was a ticking time bomb and sadly, if this inept government does decide to effect change, responsible owners of other breeds will be negatively affected too.

Crapsummer2023 · 16/09/2023 10:28

The problem with this government is they just make stuff up on the fly. They don’t believe in experts so decisions aren’t backed up by data. If they were serious people, they would not have made an announcement without knowing what an XL Bully actually is. Now it’s going to months of flim flam followed by multiple legal challenges from Bully owners claiming their dog isn’t a Bully.

The most sensible course of action would have been to learn lessons from somewhere like Spain and muzzle all dogs over a certain size. Also all dogs would have to be chipped, owners have insurance and proof the dog has received training. All breeders should be made to carry out risk assessments of owners including the suitability of the home the dog is going to. For example when the buyer provides an address, check if it’s a flat or house with a garden etc. Also check other occupants of the house, are there children under a certain age there etc.

We have lots of technology available now to check these things. Of course, poor breeders won’t care so resources should be provided to find these people, put them out of business and destroy all of their dogs before they get out into the public.

Twistler · 16/09/2023 10:28

Goldbar · 16/09/2023 10:24

It would solve the problem for most of us, though.

We can't control what others do within their own homes or the dangers to which they subject their own children (and this is not limited to dogs), unless it reaches a standard when social services would intervene, but anything that would reduce the risk to the general public has to be a good thing.

Exactly this. If people want a merle fat headed child killer in their house, more fool them. In an ideal world all the wankers that wanted to own the latest fad just to look 'ard would live on a different island to the rest of us.

Cornettoninja · 16/09/2023 10:25

People are spending about £400+ in some cases

Dog walking, day care and classes..

When did dogs become children

@Goodornot i take your point about people babying their animals but at least these are focused on encouraging training and the dogs wellbeing. I’d rather people spent £400 on this stuff than excessive grooming and accessories to pimp out their pets.