Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just restrict dogs over a certain weight/size?

186 replies

Stroopwaffels · 16/09/2023 09:14

The main problem with the proposed law about banning these XL bulldogs appears to be defining exactly what a XL bulldog is, given that so many are part one thing, part another. All that's going to happen is that the irresponsible owners are just going to argue that their dog is something else, and it's going to cost a fortune in kennelling and legal fees while it's all decided.

Wouldn't it be simpler and fairer to come up with some sort of law that says that dogs over a certain height/weight are restricted - they must be chipped with owner's details regularly updated, must be muzzled in public, must be neutered unless you have registered and paid £££ to be an official breeder, must be kept on a lead at all times etc etc etc. It's then far easier for a police officer to whip out a tape measure or scales and say that this dog is either covered by the law, or not.

Yes it would affect people like the woman who lives near me and who has two large Newfoundland dogs which don't appear to be aggressive at all but it's certainly clearer and easier for public and police.

OP posts:
steppemum · 16/09/2023 11:50

CurlewKate · 16/09/2023 11:48

@steppemum
We know that most of the owners of these dogs would be unlikely to follow it"

Why not? Apparently they are all law abiding middle class accountants....

😂yes and their XL bullies are gentle souls who wouldn't harma fly....

CurlewKate · 16/09/2023 11:48

@steppemum
We know that most of the owners of these dogs would be unlikely to follow it"

Why not? Apparently they are all law abiding middle class accountants....

steppemum · 16/09/2023 11:44

I'll admit to having not read the whole thread.

But the elephant in the room seems to be that you can have every law you like, who is going to enforce it?

We know that most of the owners of these dogs would be unlikely to follow it.
So how do we enforce it?
To bring in any new law will need loads of police enforcers.
What do they do when presented with a house with a big dog, not neutered, no muzzle and no paperwork?
Are we going to have massive sets of kennels to take these dogs in? Who will enthanise?
Will vets co-operate with the scheme? What happens when someone takes it to court? Who looks after the dog in the meantime?
If we leave the dog in the home, then next time the police visit it has 'gone' What then?

Remembering that a big dog, shut in kennels and not exercised will become a much more dangerous dog.

So whatever law we decide on, and I could suggest quite a few to improve dog ownership, the issue is always how will it be enforced?

Cornettoninja · 16/09/2023 11:41

DorotheaDiamond · 16/09/2023 11:15

This!! Until there are enough police/dog wardens around to check chips/licenses it will be pointless to make any laws.

It’s a chicken and egg situation, though I can’t argue policing in this country is in dire need of attention and funding.

Just the existence of any legislation will influence a proportion of people to make different choices though. It absolutely wouldn’t be 100% pointless.

HangingByYourFingernails · 16/09/2023 11:32

Babies have died. Or don't they count as they weren't an adult?

Anything can kill a newborn baby. We don't go around banning pillows, duvets, iron tablets, honey, plastic bags - we require their parents to exercise ceaseless vigilance and we label them "keep out of reach of the under 4s". We start to control dangerous items for things that pose risks to children above that age where they're out of reach of their parents.

tt9 · 16/09/2023 11:28

@Twistler bless you, are you OK? my post was a joke, in response to the OP's batshit recommendation that all dogs above a certain weight need to be muzzled and based on the well known trope that chihuahuas are a bit mad.

I am 100% in support of xl bully restriction once the breed has been defined

ps I would tone down the nasty personal remarks on the intelligence of people you don't know if I were you. someone less nice than me might report you. also maybe have your funny bone looked at by a doc. needs adjusting

D3LAN3Y · 16/09/2023 11:28

I know that I'd rather take my chances with a jack Russell with a 100-200 bite force rather than an XL bully breed of 500+ that weighs in at 12 stone in some cases.

WetBandits · 16/09/2023 11:28

Twistler · 16/09/2023 11:23

You see normal, sensible people with brains aren't remotely surprised when people like you tt9 come out with shit like that. We've heard all the excuses, all of them and they don't wash I'm afraid.

Only people with very tiny brains come out with "but look at all the nasty chihuahuas" and "what about all the RTAs" actually think people, you know the ones with brains, are going to say "oh yer, duh, why on earth didn't it occur to me fighting off an 8 stone Pitbull cross would be just the same as fighting off a chihuahua" and all swap our cars that we actually need to live for an XLbastard.

Are you all professional idiots or is it just a hobby?

Edited

Yep. I mean, I’ve met a lot of chihuahuas and few have been pleasant so I don’t particularly like them, but I’d have a far better chance of fending off an attack from a chihuahua than I would an XL bully.

Incidentally, the small handful of XL bullies I have encountered have all been well-behaved, but I still wouldn’t want to have any responsibility for one, or be in a situation where I had to defend myself against one.

SleepingStandingUp · 16/09/2023 11:28

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 16/09/2023 11:24

I know it won't be a popular opinion but I don't think people should be allowed to own dogs at all.

They're unpredictable, they're potentially very dangerous, they smell, they crap everywhere, they run up to people that don't want them near them.
I just don't understand why we need to have them as pets at all.

I'd be thrilled if ownership was made illegal, but that'll never happen so I just have to put up with other people's stinky dogs running up to me when I don't want the bloody things anywhere near me at all.
Big or small.

Are you actually suggesting a large scale slaughter of 12 million dogs, including compulsory seizure of pets against owners wishes so break and enter / arrest etc?

HangingByYourFingernails · 16/09/2023 11:25

GRex · 16/09/2023 10:40

I think the law should require every dog to be microchipped, every new puppy from the date of legislation must come from a licensed breeder, delegated authority powers to RSPCA to set clear rules for licensed breeders on welfare as well as breeding out aggression, and multiple police reports logged against the same breeder lead to investigation and loss of license. Police and dog wardens to have scanners able to check microchips against owner ID, a lot more fines for public nuisance or leaving poo, and mandated fines plus sentencing through magistrates Court (poo testing where needed for proof). It can all be self funded through fines.

This is the kind of plan we need.

Breed specific legislation is knee jerk nonsense which has been repeatedly tried and failed. It's the wrong approach not because some breeds aren't more dangerous than others, but because the definitions of what falls in the breed get really messy and the dangerous owners and breeders always just move on to a new status breed with the same characteristics.

Nanny0gg · 16/09/2023 11:25

Frequency · 16/09/2023 09:34

Or we could use evidence-based techniques to reduce the number of attacks and/or copy other countries or states that have successfully reduced the number of attacks by 80% or more.

It's widely believed that Calagary's method is the most successful, having reduced the number of dog-related injuries by over 80% since it was started. As opposed to BSL and the DDA which has seen our dog-related injuries rise by over 150% since it was implemented.

So what have they done?

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 16/09/2023 11:24

I know it won't be a popular opinion but I don't think people should be allowed to own dogs at all.

They're unpredictable, they're potentially very dangerous, they smell, they crap everywhere, they run up to people that don't want them near them.
I just don't understand why we need to have them as pets at all.

I'd be thrilled if ownership was made illegal, but that'll never happen so I just have to put up with other people's stinky dogs running up to me when I don't want the bloody things anywhere near me at all.
Big or small.

Twistler · 16/09/2023 11:23

You see normal, sensible people with brains aren't remotely surprised when people like you tt9 come out with shit like that. We've heard all the excuses, all of them and they don't wash I'm afraid.

Only people with very tiny brains come out with "but look at all the nasty chihuahuas" and "what about all the RTAs" actually think people, you know the ones with brains, are going to say "oh yer, duh, why on earth didn't it occur to me fighting off an 8 stone Pitbull cross would be just the same as fighting off a chihuahua" and all swap our cars that we actually need to live for an XLbastard.

Are you all professional idiots or is it just a hobby?

Zodfa · 16/09/2023 11:19

I encounter irresponsible dog owners once every few months. I encounter irresponsible motorists every damn day.

Let's focus on the real issues.

billysillydilly · 16/09/2023 11:18

And once the prey drive is activated an adult would have difficulty over powering it.

And then it doesn't matter whether it is a big dog or a small dog doing the damage.

That's nonsense though. A cocker spaniel bit me & a passing adult easily subdued it. I saw a jack russell pounce on another dog and then get booted off.

RudsyFarmer · 16/09/2023 11:17

They’re going to do the cheapest thing they can. Always.

WetBandits · 16/09/2023 11:16

CurlewKate · 16/09/2023 11:02

There's another thread-I think it's still running-where people are boasting about how "protective" their dogs are, and how they snarl and bark at anybody "suspicious" looking who approaches them. It really isn't a huge leap from that to the owners if these XL Bullies.....

Yep, makes me cringe! My dog snarled and growled at a man who was closely following and calling out to me on the otherwise empty beach, in the dark, telling me to stop so he could ‘talk to me’ as he got closer and closer. I was terrified of him and so was my dog, but I’m ever thankful that my dog expressed his own fear by snarling and making himself look scary, because it made the man back off. If he had continued to follow, I think my next ‘plan’ would probably have been to let my dog off the lead to chase him away. I have no idea what his intentions were, but I’m glad we didn’t get to find out.

Some idiots would say that my dog was ‘being protective’ but really he was just picking up on my fear whilst simultaneously trying to make the threat to himself go away, he wasn’t protecting me because he doesn’t know how to do that as he’s never been trained in protection. Whatever he thought he was doing just happened to have the effect of eliminating what was probably a genuine threat to my safety.

{Edited to add that he has never been trained in protection - he has, of course, been trained to be a good boy!}

Thelnebriati · 16/09/2023 11:15

Compulsory registration, licence and third party liability insurance for all dogs would sort out a lot of problems.
Let the insurance industry measure the risk and charge accordingly. Its what they are good at.

DorotheaDiamond · 16/09/2023 11:15

TheSpruce · 16/09/2023 10:44

I think we can all agree there are many laws and regulations that can be implemented to try and make positive change. But none of that matters of there is no way to ENFORCE it. We need resources where the police, or a well funded dog warden, can follow up on complaints and ensure people are punished for breakings these rules.

This!! Until there are enough police/dog wardens around to check chips/licenses it will be pointless to make any laws.

billysillydilly · 16/09/2023 11:15

There are dog attacks every week but majority don't make the news. Of course it's the Staffie / pitbull / XL bully types that make the news. It feeds into the "them" and "us" PLUs / NPLUs classist thing we have going on in the U.K. ("naice people like us wouldn't own such a dog" etc)

Any time a person is killed by a dog it makes the news regardless of the breed.

Idratherbepaddleboarding · 16/09/2023 11:13

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

MindfulBear · 16/09/2023 11:13

tt9 · 16/09/2023 11:11

have you ever met a chihuahua?

if any dog needs to be on a lead with a muzzle .... its that one. probably should be registered with the police too. they look like they are planning serial murders.

Totally agree.

I am wary around small dogs (I have the scarred knees as a reminder of why).

But I'm terrified of chihuahuas. They look scary!!!

Fwiw my lab is also terrified of small dogs and gets very skittish as they come towards us and then bolts straight past them and waits for me a few metres beyond!!!

tt9 · 16/09/2023 11:12

on the other hand... there are absolutely massive dogs with zero aggression

tt9 · 16/09/2023 11:11

have you ever met a chihuahua?

if any dog needs to be on a lead with a muzzle .... its that one. probably should be registered with the police too. they look like they are planning serial murders.

MindfulBear · 16/09/2023 11:11

@WetBandits at least you are aware. And what a responsible owner you are in the first place - getting dna checked.

As you are aware and a responsible owner, I imagine you keep a close eye and are on top of training.

However it isn't you that is the problem here.

And fwiw - I don't think a blanket euthanasia requirement will be brought in. Too expensive and doesn't address the actual issues. A bit like banning guns and knives. Legal bans do not make a huge impact.

Educating granny that this type of dog could kill her grandkids and perhaps a different breed would be more appropriate - that would help.