Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just restrict dogs over a certain weight/size?

186 replies

Stroopwaffels · 16/09/2023 09:14

The main problem with the proposed law about banning these XL bulldogs appears to be defining exactly what a XL bulldog is, given that so many are part one thing, part another. All that's going to happen is that the irresponsible owners are just going to argue that their dog is something else, and it's going to cost a fortune in kennelling and legal fees while it's all decided.

Wouldn't it be simpler and fairer to come up with some sort of law that says that dogs over a certain height/weight are restricted - they must be chipped with owner's details regularly updated, must be muzzled in public, must be neutered unless you have registered and paid £££ to be an official breeder, must be kept on a lead at all times etc etc etc. It's then far easier for a police officer to whip out a tape measure or scales and say that this dog is either covered by the law, or not.

Yes it would affect people like the woman who lives near me and who has two large Newfoundland dogs which don't appear to be aggressive at all but it's certainly clearer and easier for public and police.

OP posts:
listsandbudgets · 16/09/2023 12:27

GolgafrinchamB · 16/09/2023 09:24

Ha! My first thought was “but Newfoundlands…”

Lovely gentle giants

Indeed they are!! my aunt has kept them for decades they are the soppiest things imaginable..

even when my aunt was burgled they just knocked the idiot over and lay on him until she arrived home.. he wasn't hurt but was quite glad.to be released and arrested as he was a bit squashed and rather hot and soggy after 4 hours of being slept on on by 2 great big drooly dogs .. he was lucky that my uncles Jack Ruswll was ewhere or he might well have been found bleeding

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 16/09/2023 12:24

I also fully support dog licences though. It’s nonsense we don’t have them, and leads to mistreatment / neglect of animals as well as animals causing harm to people due to having rubbish owners.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 16/09/2023 12:23

They can determine if something is an XL Bully the same way as they determine if something is a pitbull, by comparing to a certain number of points of reference/ similarity.

So X number of features in common with the definition, it’s a pitbull.

It probably just takes a bit of time to determine what the features should be.

Kpo58 · 16/09/2023 12:21

If the police cannot be bothered to investigate shoplifting where they already know the suspects or do anything when a dog kills another dog, why do you think that they will inforce any new dog regulations?

Homesweethome23 · 16/09/2023 12:20

My family are very big animal people and have had various animals over the years including wild animals that we have had to have licenses for and insurances also.

We have also had many different breeds of dogs over the years - we currently have a xl breed of dog - and have always felt that any dog owner of any breed should need a license for it and should attend dog training classes.
All dog breeds no matter what size can attack and can scar/kill a child/adult.
The dogs I have known attack over the last couple of years have been a Jack Russell/staff, a Labrador, a cocker spaniel and a French bull dog. I have met some xl bully’s and they have been some of the most gentle giants I have ever met, BUT they have had excellent training and owners who aware of how much work the breed needs to be a good family pet. I have also met a couple of owners of xl bully’s who have no clue and have bought them as some kind of statement dog - these owners are the problem. All dog breeds should have owners who are willing to put the hard work in with any dog they choose to own big or small.

I fully support dog licenses and that part of the license should be all dog owners participate in dog training classes from the puppy stage then yearly so that the dog doesn’t fall into bad habits.
All dogs should be required to be on leads in public places, and only be allowed off lead in dog secured areas.

The government should be making all dog owners responsible for their dogs not just the xl bully owners.

Cornettoninja · 16/09/2023 12:15

A child was killed last year by a dog that someone got (Bought?) in a pub the week before, after being told it was aggressive/not good with other dogs.
I'm not convinced that someone who takes(or buys) a aggressive dog on a whim from a bloke in a pub will be invested in training it or getting a licence

but if there was legislation around licensing, ownership and/or breed there would be an avenue for anyone witnessing this to alert authorities. Currently, if you rang the police and told them you’d witnessed the above there’s very little they could do.

I don’t think that there would always be someone prepared to alert the authorities but at the moment there is no cause for any authority to take a report like this seriously. They’re in the position of only being able to take action after any worse-case-scenario has happened. We don’t allow them to be anything but reactive.

lavenderlou · 16/09/2023 12:14

If banning certain breeds isn't going to be effective then all dogs should be muzzled in public places. Much easier to enforce if it's a blanket all dogs rule, not having to check specific breeds etc. Dog owners should have to pay a licence fee or similar to fund dog wardens who could enforce keeping dogs under control. Part of the problem is that some dog owners are not at all in control of their owners but it's down to the police to enforce this and they can barely manage to investigate armed robberies.

Cornettoninja · 16/09/2023 12:09

HangingByYourFingernails · 16/09/2023 12:00

Twat owners will remain twats, but if they don't get licences then action can, in theory, be taken the moment their dog looks at someone funny, or barks late at night.

I think that better results would probably be achieved by clamping down on breeders. A widespread advertising campaign saying "Paying money for a dog to anyone who's not on the registered breeders register or a registered dog rescue is a criminal offence" might help by stopping some of the innocent but clueless idiots making profit and incentivising the really nasty breeders.

I agree with you, I’d really like to see a proper campaign tackling the source of the problem.

I do think it's a good idea, but it won't make bad dog owners better dog owners

@Milkkbottles no it won’t, but almost all legislation doesn’t stop everyone committing the crimes legislated for. It does, however, exist and creates very clear boundaries about what is an isn’t acceptable in society. There is an impact from just formally having it in place.

Fizbosshoes · 16/09/2023 12:08

A child was killed last year by a dog that someone got (Bought?) in a pub the week before, after being told it was aggressive/not good with other dogs.
I'm not convinced that someone who takes(or buys) a aggressive dog on a whim from a bloke in a pub will be invested in training it or getting a licence.
Last year I was waiting to pay for some stuff in a pet shop 10 minutes before closing. A woman came in holding a puppy that she'd apparently just collected. She basically accosted a shop assistant and asked what she would need for it (food, leash, bed etc) I'm sorry but I would judge both the seller and the buyer of the dog in this instance that she was completely unprepared.

newhere24 · 16/09/2023 12:08

I own big breed dogs (Irish wolfhounds and standard poodle). i completely support restrictions on all dogs over a specific size weight. my dogs are neutered and well trained, including muzzle. they are also very gentle. I’m willing to register them, and do all that is required. And yes, if there would be any reasonable doubt I would rather have them euthanised than risk anything.
You never know what goes on inside a dog. Pain, being scared, and all big dogs can kill. A toy poodle is going to hurt you, but not kill.

steppemum · 16/09/2023 12:07

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

I agree about breeders. and buying from them being illegal.

But it will take really big consistent advertising to get that message across and get people to understand the consequences etc.

And still many won't care!

Milkkbottles · 16/09/2023 12:05

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

steppemum · 16/09/2023 12:01

Cornettoninja · 16/09/2023 11:51

@steppemum you raise good points and the truth is we haven’t got the police or legal system to enforce the laws we currently have never mind new ones.

But, as a country I don’t think we’ve quite reached the point of just accepting that (which I think is a good thing) and we shouldn’t lower our standards with the expectation of never being able to enforce this properly. If no legislation exists there is no argument or justification for funding it whereas if it is written into law there are obligations for it to be considered in budgets and its performance monitored, perhaps even enhanced in the future with exactly what others have called for with wider education.

I agree.
I guess my point was that we have to be prepared to sink quite a lot of money into dog police.
Initially it will mean tracking down many dogs and dog owners and getting them compliant and teaching them to law.
Then enforcement, which would have to be zero tolerance for it to be effective, otherwise cases drag through the courts, which is what happened with some under the DD act. Very few actually got euthanised.

As a dog lover it is hard. Perhaps one day my dog will do something wrong and then he will be removed and destroyed. But we do have to be prepared to put money into the policing of it. And a huge national advertising campaign to get people on board.

HangingByYourFingernails · 16/09/2023 12:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Twat owners will remain twats, but if they don't get licences then action can, in theory, be taken the moment their dog looks at someone funny, or barks late at night.

I think that better results would probably be achieved by clamping down on breeders. A widespread advertising campaign saying "Paying money for a dog to anyone who's not on the registered breeders register or a registered dog rescue is a criminal offence" might help by stopping some of the innocent but clueless idiots making profit and incentivising the really nasty breeders.

Shadowchaser · 16/09/2023 11:58

I always despair at the deed not breed posts. It’s always people clueless about genetics and heritability.

Then in the next breath…

Deed not breed…but chihuahuas are the most aggressive, labradors bite the most, German shepherds guard their owners and bite people, your more likley to be bitten from a small dog, staffies are nanny dogs not savages.

So, you agree chihuahuas have the breed trait to be aggressive, but not bully’s? You agree staffies all inherit nanny dog traits (Rubbish btw), but not the traits they were bred for?

You can’t pick an argument then discredit half of it.

Milkkbottles · 16/09/2023 11:57

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

steppemum · 16/09/2023 11:57

generally to improve all dog ownership I would

  1. make dog walkers licensed and limit the number of dogs they can walk at once
  2. make all dogs registered/licensed and chipped
  3. have rules around dogs ownership v. house size. Large dogs in small flats should be banned, limits of number of dogs one person can own etc
  4. any dog attack that is reported against another dog should enable the same measures as if it were against a person. There are frequent cases of dogs who have been known to viciously attack other dogs then going on to attack people. Dog attacks, dog gets put down.
  5. Stop all importing of all dogs from elsewhere, especially street dogs
  6. Have stricter rules about walking on leads, eg on pavement everywhere always on lead. Town parks on lead etc.
  7. Fine and prosecute dog owners regularly for breaking this stuff. Have dog wardens that can enforce patrolling parks until it becomes normal. On the same note, your dog attacks a person, you get prosecuted for dangerous body harm or whatever.

I have a large dog. He is a rescue. He is not perfect. I would abide by all these rules.

Cornettoninja · 16/09/2023 11:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

They would. But then they run the risk of being fined more than it would have cost to just licence the dog. Dogs aren’t particularly easy to conceal.

No one is going to check every dog, just like no one checks every car is taxed and insured but it’s still a very effective tool in ensuring cars are’t being driven around without either.

CuntRYMusicStar · 16/09/2023 11:55

I have a lovely soft Bernese dog. He is usually on lead unless within our closed estate where everyone knows him and no one is nervous (closed community - know all the neighbours).

I would happily train him to wear a basket muzzle if it became legislation. If it meant everyone else with badly trained dogs that run up to mine and growl and show teeth because he is big were also now muzzled. I'm sick to death of badly trained dogs and dog shit on the pavements.

Ultimately the problem is bad owners but as you can't ban people then making it more difficult to own a dog would seem sensible.

WetBandits · 16/09/2023 11:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Most dogs will see a vet at some point (at least for vaccinations etc), perhaps vets could be checking licences, chips and insurance and reporting non-compliance?

bombastix · 16/09/2023 11:54

@Milkkbottles - of course. It's not like they will suddenly all decide to have a personality transplant.

Owners that don't, well the precedent is that the dog is confiscated and destroyed. It is up to the Government to enforce it. Making a law by itself does nothing.

HashBrownandBeans · 16/09/2023 11:53

So my 45kg incredibly lazy and gentle hounds would be included. Don’t think so 🤣

Milkkbottles · 16/09/2023 11:52

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Cornettoninja · 16/09/2023 11:51

@steppemum you raise good points and the truth is we haven’t got the police or legal system to enforce the laws we currently have never mind new ones.

But, as a country I don’t think we’ve quite reached the point of just accepting that (which I think is a good thing) and we shouldn’t lower our standards with the expectation of never being able to enforce this properly. If no legislation exists there is no argument or justification for funding it whereas if it is written into law there are obligations for it to be considered in budgets and its performance monitored, perhaps even enhanced in the future with exactly what others have called for with wider education.

Milkkbottles · 16/09/2023 11:51

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.