Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be surprised to see threads on LGB being questioned now?!

318 replies

SuperNewMe · 15/09/2023 23:15

Just typed a reply and the thread disappeared quickly (makes a change as when it's trans related ones they stay?!)
So it's not a TAAT, it's just to say that after all the anti trans rhetoric you see on here sometimes, it comes as absolutely no surprise that there are now more threads attacking lesbian and gay couples ( not natural was the phrase used)
Not to mention one still on the go as far as I'm aware that refers to LGBTQ as "special rainbow people"
YABU you're imagining things
YANBU things seem to be ramping up against LGBT people in general
(I say this as someone who's straight and not trans)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
jeaux90 · 16/09/2023 09:24

@Tandora that sounds homophobic to me.

"and I do think it’s transphobic and sexist and wrongheaded to define a person wholly in terms of their genitals"

Lesbians are same SEX attracted.

SamW98 · 16/09/2023 09:23

lifeturnsonadime · 16/09/2023 09:11

I do think a person’s expressed sexual preferences can absolutely be a reflection of prejudice, however, (we can clearly see this in how black women and fat women and disabled women are often represented as sexually undesirable) and I do think it’s transphobic and sexist to define a person wholly in terms of their genitals .

Wow so you think lesbians who refuse to consider dating a transwoman because of their penis alone, are transphobic?

And you really can't see that this is homophobic?

This literally denies lesbian and gay people the right to same sex attraction.

Edited

100% agree @lifeturnsonadime

So if im reading the post you quoted correctly it is apparently bigoted and sexist for straight women and gay men not to be attracted to vaginas and ditto lesbians and straight men not to want sex with someone who had a penis?

I mean seriously WTAF???

Leafstamp · 16/09/2023 09:20

@Tandora you seem to be saying that lesbians might be transphobic for not wanting to date men who say they are women?

Please correct me if I am wrong.

Tandora · 16/09/2023 09:16

FarEast · 16/09/2023 09:08

@Tandora - On Woman’s Hour, former CEO of Stonewall, Nancy Kelley, likened lesbians who rejected including transwomen in their “dating pool” to “sexual racists.”

How much more homophobic can you get? The head of Stonewall saying that lesbians’ same-sex attraction was a version of racism.

As above:

no one should ever be questioned or coerced about their sexual practices. Everyone has the right to accept or reject any sexual encounter absolutely as they please. I believe that any decent person feels the same.

I do think a person’s expressed sexual preferences can absolutely be a reflection of prejudice, however- we can clearly see this in how black women and fat women and disabled women are often culturally represented as sexually undesirable - and I do think it’s transphobic and sexist and wrongheaded to define a person wholly in terms of their genitals.

in terms of the first point, I do think it’s ok (and in fact important) to have conversations around this, as difficult as they can be. For example, I recently had a row with my DP as he casually declared that he “isn’t attracted to black women”. I suggested his comments were informed by racism. he became furious: he insisted his preferences were biologically driven and had nothing to do with racial prejudice. I entirely disagree , both with his assertion he is not attracted to black women (I know full well there are any number of black women he would meet in the world and be wildly attracted to) , and with his belief that his opinion - “black women are not attractive” - is biologically, rather than socially and culturally produced.

These conversations are really difficult and complicated and don’t lend themselves well to a discussion on social media, but I hope this at least makes some sense.

Leafstamp · 16/09/2023 09:16

KimberleyClark · 16/09/2023 08:07

But what is new is trans women claiming to be "better than women" and "the real women", and pushing women's voices out of spaces that we've fought so hard to gain entry to.

Have you got any actual examples of transwomen making these claims to be better than women and the real women, because saying transwomen are women is not quite the same thing?

There’s the infamous India willoughby clip here. About a minute and a half in. Note use of the word ‘penetrate’ too. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=PsJxpvGzo3E

Have also seen men pretending to be women saying stuff along the lines that because they have to ‘put effort in’ to being a woman then that makes them ‘better’ than actual women.

Men are always trying to make out their better than women (people are always trying to make out they’re better than others) so of course some of them men want to make out they are better women than actual women. They are of course no better than the common garden misogynist.

India Kicks Off! | Day 4 | Celebrity Big Brother 2018

India wants to talk to the House... and she isn't impressed. SUBSCRIBE: http://bit.ly/BBUKYTWatch full episodes on MyFive: http://bit.ly/BBMy5Facebook: http:...

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=PsJxpvGzo3E

jeaux90 · 16/09/2023 09:15

@SpidersAreShitheads brilliant post.

lifeturnsonadime · 16/09/2023 09:11

I do think a person’s expressed sexual preferences can absolutely be a reflection of prejudice, however, (we can clearly see this in how black women and fat women and disabled women are often represented as sexually undesirable) and I do think it’s transphobic and sexist to define a person wholly in terms of their genitals .

Wow so you think lesbians who refuse to consider dating a transwoman because of their penis alone, are transphobic?

And you really can't see that this is homophobic?

This literally denies lesbian and gay people the right to same sex attraction.

EdithStourton · 16/09/2023 09:10

@SpidersAreShitheads brilliant post, thank you.

AnSolas · 16/09/2023 09:08

SuperNewMe · 16/09/2023 02:25

Can you even provide one link?
Did you even read the OP?

Not to mention one still on the go as far as I'm aware that refers to LGBTQ as "special rainbow people"

This was you ^
Do you have a link?

And while you are here can you give your opinion on what Q stands for if it not L or G or B or T?

What in your opinion are some key markers for what puts someone
into Q but not L and/or
into Q but not G and/or
into Q but not B and/or
into Q but not T and/or
One or two would be great.

Just so we know what rights should attach to the Q's

FarEast · 16/09/2023 09:08

@Tandora - On Woman’s Hour, former CEO of Stonewall, Nancy Kelley, likened lesbians who rejected including transwomen in their “dating pool” to “sexual racists.”

How much more homophobic can you get? The head of Stonewall saying that lesbians’ same-sex attraction was a version of racism.

Hogisies · 16/09/2023 09:05

Tandora · 16/09/2023 01:02

YANBU OP, of course transphobia has its routes in homophobia. The Difference is that homophobia is less tolerated in polite society and mumsnet deletes all the lgb focused threads very quickly.

How does it have its roots in homophobia? One thing is dislike of people who shag people of the same sex, and the other is people who think that they can change sex. There is an historic relationship between lgb and t in that gender none conformity was accepted by lgb people more easily than the general populace - but that’s it.

Unless by rooted in you mean that plenty of people just lump the weirdos together and hate all of it?

@SuperNewMe why are you surprised there are homophobes about? Did you think we lived in some kind of radical acceptance utopia?

Tandora · 16/09/2023 09:04

FOJN · 16/09/2023 08:56

Any response to the "sexual racists" remarks made by the CEO?

Do you think lesbians are bigoted and just need to get use to "girl dick"?

Please share the words in their actual context (and not couched in a load of transphobic propaganda) and I will attempt to explain their meaning.

Do you think lesbians are bigoted and just need to get use to "girl dick"
I think your language is utterly foul and I reject it wholeheartedly.
no one should ever be questioned or coerced about their sexual practices. Everyone has the right to accept or reject any sexual encounter absolutely as they please. I believe that any decent person feels the same.

I do think a person’s expressed sexual preferences can absolutely be a reflection of prejudice, however, (we can clearly see this in how black women and fat women and disabled women are often represented as sexually undesirable) and I do think it’s transphobic and sexist to define a person wholly in terms of their genitals .

nothingcomestonothing · 16/09/2023 09:03

As in, the T has been separated from LGB on here and elsewhere as in a "look, it's them, not us?"
They see themselves separate.

You've got it the wrong way round. It's not that T had been separated from LGB, it's that they didn't go together in the first place. T was forced-teamed with LGB (see the Dentons document). Sexuality is not an identity, and vice versa.

To not be surprised to see threads on LGB being questioned now?!
IhearyouClemFandango · 16/09/2023 08:58

Screamingabdabz · 16/09/2023 00:28

Oh god here we go… ‘anti-trans rhetoric’ 🙄

…by that do you mean ‘perfectly reasonable concerns voiced by women about their rights and dignities being infringed by men’?

I would superglue myself to a wall for LGB rights but this is different. Only the feeble minded or people who genuinely hate women refuse to see it.

This. 100 times.

AnSolas · 16/09/2023 08:58

SuperNewMe · 16/09/2023 02:23

@AnSolas I gave you the benefit of the doubt when you just left a.dot and no reply presumably waiting for answers.
Lots to say on trans replies though
Seems not so much to say when it comes to "gay" issues too.

Guess what I also did.....

You keep giving opinions and want poster to agree.

Yet have provided no proof just hand waving of how women discussing womens rights and child safeguarding if is anti-trans.

Where is the rainbow people thread link so that we can examine it and point out the problem posts?

Where are the threads questioning being lesbian or gay that you have seen recently?

But it would be great if there was a handy screen shotable vote where MN is declared to be homophobic.

What "gay issue" are you trying to explore because so far you have wobbled from trans righs are LGB rights and trans righs are womens rights so you appear to be trying to piggyback "trans" on to all other rights.

L and G and B and T are all different groups not one homogeneous blob with a single focus or a single aim. And yet you appear to want to shoehorn women into the group too

What do you want LGBTAIQ2SWM+ ?

Here is a trans issue and a "gay issue" in the Irish prison system.
A male in the female prison wants the law of being recognised as female be applied to strip searching. The female employees objected to being subjected to sexual harrassment by their employer when they were instructed to allow(demand) an inmate expose "her female penis" to them.
One of the employees is a Lesbian.

Opinion : a lesbian prison officer should not be obliged to look at an exposed penis ( female or male) in her work place.

Would you care to discuss the issue?

FOJN · 16/09/2023 08:56

Tandora · 16/09/2023 08:53

You baffle me! Stonewall is a charity that was set up to advocate for the rights of LGBT people. They are the last people on this earth who are homophobic. Just because they refuse to cut of the “t” , to abandon trans people, to throw them to the homophobic/ transphobic dogs, you call them homophobic. It is deeply twisted and ironic and just makes me want to scream and tear my hair out. Homophobia and transphobia share the same roots. It is the often the same people (and always) suffering the same discrimination, you have completely lost the plot

Any response to the "sexual racists" remarks made by the CEO?

Do you think lesbians are bigoted and just need to get use to "girl dick"?

catgirl1976 · 16/09/2023 08:56

@Tandora you’re really not up to speed re Stonewall I’m afraid. Even its founders are horrified by how homophobic it now is.

TrashedSofa · 16/09/2023 08:54

FOJN · 16/09/2023 08:50

Did you miss Nancy Kelly describing lesbians who don't want to have sex with males who identify as women "sexual racists"? Does that not qualify as homophobic to you?

thecritic.co.uk/thank-you-nancy-kelley/

It really was one of the more revoltingly homophobic comments that's come out of the TWAW crew. I presume the response will be more emojis though, what with the obvious difficulties formulating a coherent argument.

Tandora · 16/09/2023 08:53

catgirl1976 · 16/09/2023 08:45

Tandoras reaction to that Stonewall comment baffles me. Everyone knows how homophobic Stonewall is. Companies are leaving their schemes in droves and they were literally part of a tribunal for discrimination against a lesbian woman

You baffle me! Stonewall is a charity that was set up to advocate for the rights of LGBT people. They are the last people on this earth who are homophobic. Just because they refuse to cut of the “t” , to abandon trans people, to throw them to the homophobic/ transphobic dogs, you call them homophobic. It is deeply twisted and ironic and just makes me want to scream and tear my hair out. Homophobia and transphobia share the same roots. It is the often the same people (and always) suffering the same discrimination, you have completely lost the plot

FOJN · 16/09/2023 08:50

Tandora · 16/09/2023 08:42

🤦🏼‍♀️😭😭😭

Did you miss Nancy Kelly describing lesbians who don't want to have sex with males who identify as women "sexual racists"? Does that not qualify as homophobic to you?

thecritic.co.uk/thank-you-nancy-kelley/

FarEast · 16/09/2023 08:47

BreadInCaptivity · 16/09/2023 00:43

The constant attempts to re-frame legitimate safeguarding concerns about the rights of children and women as "anti-trans" is, quite frankly, ridiculous.

Anyone who is dismissive of such concerns needs to take a long, hard look in the mirror.

I am beyond bored of the "most oppressed" and "most marginalised" narrative that many trans advocates are trying to sell.

It's a movement that seeks to elevate one cause beyond all others whilst caring not a damn for the carnage (of more vulnerable people) it leaves in its wake.

Every word of this @BreadInCaptivity Thank you for writing so eloquently.

And @SuperNewMe my concern (and that of many other feminists) is not to denigrate individual trans people ( they generally need therapeutic help to heal their extreme mind/body split and dysphasia) but to question
n the violent and misogynistic attitudes of trans activism as a movement.

SamW98 · 16/09/2023 08:46

Tramlines · 16/09/2023 05:39

@SpidersAreShitheads if i could give you a million likes for your post, I would. Absolutely spot on.

Absolutely this. Brilliant post which spells out what most rational thinking people believe.

catgirl1976 · 16/09/2023 08:45

Tandoras reaction to that Stonewall comment baffles me. Everyone knows how homophobic Stonewall is. Companies are leaving their schemes in droves and they were literally part of a tribunal for discrimination against a lesbian woman

LizzieSiddal · 16/09/2023 08:45

BreadInCaptivity · 16/09/2023 00:43

The constant attempts to re-frame legitimate safeguarding concerns about the rights of children and women as "anti-trans" is, quite frankly, ridiculous.

Anyone who is dismissive of such concerns needs to take a long, hard look in the mirror.

I am beyond bored of the "most oppressed" and "most marginalised" narrative that many trans advocates are trying to sell.

It's a movement that seeks to elevate one cause beyond all others whilst caring not a damn for the carnage (of more vulnerable people) it leaves in its wake.

👏👏👏👏👏

Swipe left for the next trending thread