Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be surprised to see threads on LGB being questioned now?!

318 replies

SuperNewMe · 15/09/2023 23:15

Just typed a reply and the thread disappeared quickly (makes a change as when it's trans related ones they stay?!)
So it's not a TAAT, it's just to say that after all the anti trans rhetoric you see on here sometimes, it comes as absolutely no surprise that there are now more threads attacking lesbian and gay couples ( not natural was the phrase used)
Not to mention one still on the go as far as I'm aware that refers to LGBTQ as "special rainbow people"
YABU you're imagining things
YANBU things seem to be ramping up against LGBT people in general
(I say this as someone who's straight and not trans)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
AliOlis · 16/09/2023 10:24

SuperNewMe · 16/09/2023 00:08

Clymene

Not noticed it. I'm pretty hot on homophobia
Ok
You're usually pretty vocal on trans threads though so would have hoped you'd have more to say than no, I havent seen it?
Fair enough though if actually haven't

If people are telling you they haven't seen it, then they haven't seen it?!
I haven't either, fwiw.

Tandora · 16/09/2023 10:24

Brefugee · 16/09/2023 10:20

tedious claptrap.
Bleats that MN is homophobic and can't prove it because MN is so far from homophobic that the site owners take homophobic threads down.

Again for those who never listen: if you see a homophobic, racist, transphobic or ableist thread, report it to MN using the report button.

And IMO you should write in that thread that you have reported it for homophobia (or the others) so that if it stands at least people know.

Bleats that MN is homophobic

I don’t recall “bleating” 🤣🤣 and I didn’t say “mumsnet is homophobic”. Nor did OP.

Tandora · 16/09/2023 10:22

catgirl1976 · 16/09/2023 10:21

@Tandora “It would also be helpful if you could define a “male born person”.

Do you honestly need help defining what a male is?

Yes please: a lot of scientists and policy makers would appreciate help with this too.

Tandora · 16/09/2023 10:22

FarEast · 16/09/2023 10:10

I do think it’s transphobic and sexist and wrongheaded to define a person wholly in terms of their genitals.

Well @Tandora you can believe that, but I can also point out the contradiction in your position.

You say that people should not be criticised or shamed for their sexual attractions & preferences:

no one should ever be questioned or coerced about their sexual practices. Everyone has the right to accept or reject any sexual encounter absolutely as they please. I believe that any decent person feels the same.

But sexual attraction is often (not necessarily always) very much about genitals. I'm straight & female and I am not in the least sexually interested in other women's genitals; it's a really basic sexual preference. I would not contemplate a romantic relationship with a woman for that reason; my sexual preference is for maleness and male bodies.

So by your logic, I am wrongheaded.

Our genitals are prescribed by our gametes, which determine our sex.
So defining people in sex categories by genitals is basic biology.

So by your logic, I am wrongheaded

wrongheaded in the sense that I would be surprised if this actually how your sexuality works. For example, presumably you meet men/ date them etc, and have a very strong sense of whether or not you are attracted to them before you have ever seen their genitals? What shapes your attraction might be how they look, how they present themselves, what you talk about, how your relate to each other , etc etc. you have no idea what their genitals look like (although you perhaps might make assumptions about them). Of course once you see their genitals you might feel differently , eg if they look different to how you expected , if they are too small etc. I’m not saying genital appearance/ structure is not a factor in sexuality, but sexual attraction is defined by so , so much more than genitals, at least for the vast vast majority of people.

catgirl1976 · 16/09/2023 10:21

@Tandora “It would also be helpful if you could define a “male born person”.

Do you honestly need help defining what a male is?

Brefugee · 16/09/2023 10:20

Tandora · 16/09/2023 01:44

Can you please link the thread you are refering to so that we can all read the posts ourselves

I wish I could, but it was taken down by HQ within an hour or so because of the overt homophobia.

tedious claptrap.
Bleats that MN is homophobic and can't prove it because MN is so far from homophobic that the site owners take homophobic threads down.

Again for those who never listen: if you see a homophobic, racist, transphobic or ableist thread, report it to MN using the report button.

And IMO you should write in that thread that you have reported it for homophobia (or the others) so that if it stands at least people know.

Seagullchippy · 16/09/2023 10:19

catgirl1976 · 16/09/2023 00:06

I think a lot of people questioning the TRA agenda ARE LGB. It’s an incredibly homophobic ideology as well as everything else.

you’ll get a few bigots who are anti LGB in all views but I really think you’re stretching things if you think the concerns about gender woo are because people are homophobia. Quite the opposite in most cases

Yes, this is what I'd say from what I've read on the site. However, I'm aware that as I'm heterosexual I might not notice as much (same as I'd notice misogyny, as a female, more than a male might), so I might be wrong.

I imagine the "rainbow people" comment was referring to gender identities joining sexualities in the acronym, rather than about the LGB part, but I agree it was still unpleasant and uncalled for.

Naunet · 16/09/2023 10:19

Well obviously, the trans ideology is deeply homophobic and attempts to redefine what homosexuality is. Have you only just noticed this? As it gains momentum, of course they push their anti LGB ideology further.

Tandora · 16/09/2023 10:16

Gerrataere · 16/09/2023 09:25

and I do think it’s transphobic and sexist and wrongheaded to define a person wholly in terms of their genitals.

@Tandora

You don’t seem to understand what sex and sexuality is. It’s not just genitalia but that is obviously a part of it. Women and men are sexually and physiologically different. You cannot overcome your same sex attraction because a man believes they’re a woman enough yet are still a straight male who wants relations with a female born woman.

No male born person can be a lesbian, they are the wrong sex. Only those of the female sex can be lesbians, it has nothing to do with what sort of person they are outside of their physiology.

Women and men are sexually and physiologically different

could you please elaborate? If it’s not just genitalia, then which parts are the important parts? Or is it a particular package of parts that determines sexuality (all biological of course, nothing social, cultural , environmental to see), and please elaborate on which precisely is the required package.

It would also be helpful if you could define a “male born person”.

Brefugee · 16/09/2023 10:13

SuperNewMe · 16/09/2023 00:35

@catgirl1976

I think a lot of people questioning the TRA agenda ARE LGB
That's kind of tied in with my point though?
As in, the T has been separated from LGB on here and elsewhere as in a "look, it's them, not us?"
They see themselves separate.
When it comes down to it, yes, a lot of people will be with you (general you) as they don't agree with the T
Doesn't make it right though. An attack on LGBT rights all seems to be an attack on women as well ( bodily autonomy, whether it be surrogacy laws being reduced, trans men (as in born female ) being portrayed as vulnerable little children even when they're grown adults.
I'm not surprised to see more threads questioning being lesbian or gay recently was my point

a lot of LGB people see the T as a parasite undoing years of work they have done towards acceptance in society. Pretty much as women had to.

If you see homophobia report the post. If you want to call it out in the thread too, that is fine and dandy.

FarEast · 16/09/2023 10:10

I do think it’s transphobic and sexist and wrongheaded to define a person wholly in terms of their genitals.

Well @Tandora you can believe that, but I can also point out the contradiction in your position.

You say that people should not be criticised or shamed for their sexual attractions & preferences:

no one should ever be questioned or coerced about their sexual practices. Everyone has the right to accept or reject any sexual encounter absolutely as they please. I believe that any decent person feels the same.

But sexual attraction is often (not necessarily always) very much about genitals. I'm straight & female and I am not in the least sexually interested in other women's genitals; it's a really basic sexual preference. I would not contemplate a romantic relationship with a woman for that reason; my sexual preference is for maleness and male bodies.

So by your logic, I am wrongheaded.

Our genitals are prescribed by our gametes, which determine our sex.
So defining people in sex categories by genitals is basic biology.

Iforgotmyusernameagainandagain · 16/09/2023 09:59

SuperNewMe · 16/09/2023 02:04

I just see the increase in homophobia overtly displayed and think.no shit, sherlock.

Things that never happened #3264890

Defiantjazz · 16/09/2023 09:43

"and I do think it’s transphobic and sexist and wrongheaded to define a person wholly in terms of their genitals"

Lesbians are same SEX attracted

Exactly.

Quite apart from the fact you don’t have sleep with anyone you don’t want to, without having to justify it or worry people will think your committing some form of hate crime, anyone who thinks lesbians are happy to sleep with biological males or gay men are happy to sleep with biological females has lost the plot.

Obviously some people are bisexual or attracted to trans specifically but you still can’t accuse the ones who reject you of discrimination.

I mean I’m a biological female. If a lesbian tells me she doesn’t want to have sex with me because of reasons (doesn’t fancy me) where’s my recourse to kick off? 🤣

Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/09/2023 09:40

Indeed.

Gerrataere · 16/09/2023 09:40

Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/09/2023 09:39

It's homophobic to suggest lesbians should want to date penis people, and misogynist to suggest males in dresses are a type of women. It's the current year version of ' they just haven't found the right man yet'.

So much this. It used to be a tired old dad joke that "I'm a lesbian trapped in a man's body".

A line paraphrased by a certain comedian until it became an acceptable truth, was it not.

VickyEadieofThigh · 16/09/2023 09:40

catgirl1976 · 16/09/2023 00:06

I think a lot of people questioning the TRA agenda ARE LGB. It’s an incredibly homophobic ideology as well as everything else.

you’ll get a few bigots who are anti LGB in all views but I really think you’re stretching things if you think the concerns about gender woo are because people are homophobia. Quite the opposite in most cases

I agree. Trans activists tend to push policy and practice that is homophobic - for example, lesbians not being allowed female-only dating apps, meetings, etc.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/09/2023 09:39

It's homophobic to suggest lesbians should want to date penis people, and misogynist to suggest males in dresses are a type of women. It's the current year version of ' they just haven't found the right man yet'.

So much this. It used to be a tired old dad joke that "I'm a lesbian trapped in a man's body".

Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/09/2023 09:36

do think a person’s expressed sexual preferences can absolutely be a reflection of prejudice, however- we can clearly see this in how black women and fat women and disabled women are often culturally represented as sexually undesirable - and I do think it’s transphobic and sexist and wrongheaded to define a person wholly in terms of their genitals.

It's not, it's defining males who call themselves women as not in their dating pool, because quite understandably most homosexual women aren't attracted to them.

LizzieSiddal · 16/09/2023 09:34

@Notpooryet You are quite correct but don't expect the "GC" crowd on here to admit it for a nanosecond. It's the iceberg of prejudice.

Oh aye. Labour supporter here who campaigned against section 28, supported gay friends “coming out” in our work place in the early 90s, went on marches against Apartheid, wrote supporting letter for Amnesty International international prisoners for years, hate the Tory’s with a passion and will never vote for them etc etc etc. and I’m very typical of a GC woman. You obviously know very little about the “GC crowd”.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/09/2023 09:34

@EmpressaurusOfCats is a lesbian so surely allowed a view on Stonewall even if you don't agree, no, @Tandora ? There are many lesbians and bisexual women on FWR.

Your comparison with your DH not being attracted to black skin is entirely facile, as lesbians are women attracted to women, not men, and in any case people aren't subject to the Equality Act in who they fancy.

Carouselfish · 16/09/2023 09:29

Left wing, long time gay rights campaigner, definite gender critical here.
I haven't seen it luckily and would absolutely report if I had.
LGB has nothing to do with T and it's a clear tactic to lump them together, to scare left wing, reasonable people into worrying that they are not being reasonable by refusing to accept humans can be 'born in the wrong body'. And agree with other posters, trans ideology is incredibly damaging to gay and lesbian rights and identities.

Notpooryet · 16/09/2023 09:27

SuperNewMe · 15/09/2023 23:15

Just typed a reply and the thread disappeared quickly (makes a change as when it's trans related ones they stay?!)
So it's not a TAAT, it's just to say that after all the anti trans rhetoric you see on here sometimes, it comes as absolutely no surprise that there are now more threads attacking lesbian and gay couples ( not natural was the phrase used)
Not to mention one still on the go as far as I'm aware that refers to LGBTQ as "special rainbow people"
YABU you're imagining things
YANBU things seem to be ramping up against LGBT people in general
(I say this as someone who's straight and not trans)

You are quite correct but don't expect the "GC" crowd on here to admit it for a nanosecond. It's the iceberg of prejudice.

FOJN · 16/09/2023 09:26

Tandora · 16/09/2023 09:04

Please share the words in their actual context (and not couched in a load of transphobic propaganda) and I will attempt to explain their meaning.

Do you think lesbians are bigoted and just need to get use to "girl dick"
I think your language is utterly foul and I reject it wholeheartedly.
no one should ever be questioned or coerced about their sexual practices. Everyone has the right to accept or reject any sexual encounter absolutely as they please. I believe that any decent person feels the same.

I do think a person’s expressed sexual preferences can absolutely be a reflection of prejudice, however, (we can clearly see this in how black women and fat women and disabled women are often represented as sexually undesirable) and I do think it’s transphobic and sexist to define a person wholly in terms of their genitals .

She literally said it in a TV interview. You seem to think you know a lot about Stonewall but you missed that event. It was widely reported at the time.

I think your language is utterly foul...

The inverted commas make it clear it's not "my language" but I am glad you think it's foul, I believe that makes you a transphobic bigot. It's so easy to fall into that category these days.

Dating and attraction is inherently discriminatory, there is nothing wrong with ruling someone out of your dating pool on the basis that, for any reason, you do not find them attractive. Few 25 year old men would be attracted to me, a plump, middle aged woman, attractive; I'm surprisingly fine with that.

No one is defined by their genitals, that would be quite reductive - a bit like describing women as menstruators, but genitals are a pretty good indicator of biological sex in nearly all humans. There is nothing sexist or transphobic about material reality or the binary nature of biological sex.

nothingcomestonothing · 16/09/2023 09:25

I do think a person’s expressed sexual preferences can absolutely be a reflection of prejudice, however- we can clearly see this in how black women and fat women and disabled women are often culturally represented as sexually undesirable - and I do think it’s transphobic and sexist and wrongheaded to define a person wholly in terms of their genitals.

Black women and fat women and disabled women are all women. Transwomen are men. It's not just a question of what characteristics an individual finds sexually desirable - saying that a subset of males are a type of women is offensive.

Lesbians who don't want to have sex with people with males bodies are not equivalent to your partner saying he doesn't fancy black women. Suggesting that lesbians might or should want to have sex with penis people is denying their lesbianism. It's homophobic to suggest lesbians should want to date penis people, and misogynist to suggest males in dresses are a type of women. It's the current year version of ' they just haven't found the right man yet'.

Gerrataere · 16/09/2023 09:25

and I do think it’s transphobic and sexist and wrongheaded to define a person wholly in terms of their genitals.

@Tandora

You don’t seem to understand what sex and sexuality is. It’s not just genitalia but that is obviously a part of it. Women and men are sexually and physiologically different. You cannot overcome your same sex attraction because a man believes they’re a woman enough yet are still a straight male who wants relations with a female born woman.

No male born person can be a lesbian, they are the wrong sex. Only those of the female sex can be lesbians, it has nothing to do with what sort of person they are outside of their physiology.

Swipe left for the next trending thread