Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are my children Scottish or English

55 replies

Petranut1 · 15/09/2023 22:15

Have recently moved down south from Scotland with DH and our three DC aged 9, 4 and 10 months. I think the kids will grow up considering themselves to be Scottish, as that is where their parents come from, and where they were born. DH reckons they will end up considering themselves to be English, as this is where they will be growing up.

Not that it matters, really 😁

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
slithytoveisascientist · 12/02/2024 22:29

My kids are born in and have always lived in England and still consider themselves half Scottish as their Dad is fully Scottish.

Nationalism in the Scots js strong, I don't think your older kids will consider themselves English if you don't.

Chimummy73 · 12/02/2024 22:27

i moved to Scotland from England 18 years ago when my 3 DS were 2, 4 and 7. Other school mates that had moved at a similar time also had strong English dialects. Fast forward to now and those other kids have really strong Scottish accents including one that was thick Brummie and another Mancunian. My 3 DS now in their 20s however are still surprisingly very (south) English sounding! Is it because I’m a WFH mum that talked too much?!

Clarinet1 · 12/02/2024 21:53

I remember seeing a programme about the actor John Barrowman on television some time ago. He was born in Glasgow and moved to the US when he was quite young and, as you probably know, usually sounds all-American but, the moment he went to visit his parents, his Scottish accent immediately came back!

Nottodaty · 12/02/2024 21:19

My dad moved from Glasgow down to south England when he was 17 he lost his accent - occasionally he will slip into it depending on speaking to family! His brother moved down a few years later at around 20 - 40 years later he still sounds like he lives in Glasgow!!

My dad still very much sees himself as Scottish.

LoyalMember · 12/02/2024 21:10

They'll grow up socially and culturally English while mindful that they're Scots born. Whether that has any impact on them is up to how you raise them.

Callipygion · 12/02/2024 14:36

Petranut1 · 15/09/2023 22:27

Interested to see if their accents change over time. My eldest has a strong Scottish accent and at 9, not sure if that will change?!

Some childhood friends from across the road moved to Wales when they/us were around that age. They came back for a visit just a few months later and we were amazed at the children’s Welsh accents!

elsiesbonnet · 16/09/2023 00:07

My mums family were Scottish, but she was born in England & grew up there. My brother & I were born in England but moved to Scotland when he was 5 and I was 7. We both moved back to England as young adults & I have always considered myself English whereas he liked to consider himself Scottish. I guess we both have our reasons & perhaps the 2 years between us was significant when it came down to it.

deveronvalley · 16/09/2023 00:05

we moved to Scotland when I was 7. English parents. I’m 44 now and don’t feel at all English. I’ve only been in England a handful of times since I was 7. I can do both accents. If someone abroad asks me where I’m from I’d say Scotland.

Eccle80 · 16/09/2023 00:04

I was born in Wales and lived there until I was 2. My Mum is Welsh, my Dad isn’t. I tend to consider myself British more than anything as I have an affinity to both Wales and England, and feel a bit of a fraud calling myself Welsh when I have an English accent (though so does my Mum - she apparently deliberately lost her accent at uni).

in your case I would say the eldest is more likely to consider their self Scottish as they will have more memories of living there

WithASpider · 16/09/2023 00:02

YummyCookie · 15/09/2023 22:40

We moved from Scotland to England when I was 1yr old. I still consider myself Scottish.

Me too! My birth certificate is Scottish, I'd be claimed by them, I'm Scottish 😊

misssunshine4040 · 15/09/2023 23:59

I have Scottish parents but was born in England and spent my formative years there until moving to Scotland as young teenager.
Lost my English accent to fit in.

What would I be considered?

AliceMcK · 15/09/2023 23:58

Accents will definitely change over time.

Im Irish if anyone asks, my parents, grandparents, great grandparents and so on were Irish, I just happened to be born and raised in England. Maybe if one of my parents was English I’d consider myself English but I was raised in an Irish home even if it was located in England. My children have mixed English Irish and Scottish heritage and born in different countries so could claim to be anything really…

sunflowerdaisyrose · 15/09/2023 23:56

I was born abroad (one parent from abroad and one British) and moved here when I was four.

I definitely consider myself much more British/English but will still support the other country at sport! If they're playing each other I genuinely don't mind who wins.

Torganer · 15/09/2023 23:52

I feel British. My father’s side are mostly English, my mother’s side are Scottish (despite the last generation growing up in Wales, they were fiercely Scottish!).

Look at Americans, when I’ve been there most have said they are Irish/German/English etc. It always seems to be the underdog. As in, I’d be Scottish if I lived in England, but Welsh if I lived in Scotland. People don’t get a chance to feel a bit different, especially when you live in places like the UK and US and are of the ethnic norm.

I used to get so het up about this, as in ‘if you were born and grew up in a place you were that nationality’. It really annoyed me. I have no idea why now though, literally who cares, identify with which ever nation/country you want!!

continentallentil · 15/09/2023 23:51

That’s for them.

They aren’t a homogeneous lump though, the eldest is far more likely to view themselves and Scottish than the youngest.

The biggest favour you and your DH could do the is to stay out of it

Goldrill · 15/09/2023 23:46

I'm English; DH Scottish. Two kids born in England and we moved to Scotland a few years ago. They're 10 and 12 now and have still got a bit of a Cumbrian accent but older one is trying hard to pick up a bit of a Scottish one. They do debate between themselves whether they are Scottish or English from time to time.

School in P6 they have to learn and recite some Burns poetry in class. Bit of a tough call when you are very English. One of them chose a cut-glass southern accent; the other one had to be firmly dissuaded from doing her broad scots wee Jimmy impersonation in case she got lynched.

Sometimeswinning · 15/09/2023 23:45

My df was born in Scotland and came to England when he was around 6. He’s English. He was educated here and has lived here far longer than he did in Scotland. He even cringes whenever bagpipes come on the tv!

zusje · 15/09/2023 23:35

My mum is fron one country my dad from another. Me and my older sister where born in mom's country, then we all moved to my dad's country when I was a few months old and my parents had my brother a few years later. My sister would consider herself mostly from country a, has done so all her life and lives back there. My brother would consider himself mostly of country b, lives there and never thought of leaving or wanted to. I am in England and am considering myself neither more or less an a or b-er and now I can be considered a "foreigner who came here to steal jobs" by everyone else so all's good in the world! (Last bit was a joke btw).

carpool · 15/09/2023 23:33

DSIL was born in NI but moved to England aged 13. Still has strong accent so much so that I can't always understand what he says!

Afterrain · 15/09/2023 23:31

I am Scottish met Northumbrian Husband at Uni.
Both DC have home counties accents, however, the use Scottish and Northumbrian words in their everyday language.
Number 1 DC is European, Scottish, British.
Number 2 DC is British, European.
Both are looking into pursuing Irish passportd from Grandparent.
Both were born in Northumberland.
Recent quote from DC 'mum you sound more Scottish when you aren't well'

Lantyslee · 15/09/2023 23:14

DM was born in Scotland, moved to England as a baby but then lived in Scotland between the ages of 9 and 13 where she picked up a strong Scottish accent and when she returned to England lots of people couldn't understand her. She dropped it pretty quickly so that she could fit in at school. Her DF was Scottish and DM was English so she had both accents at home.

OP I think your DC will have English accents.

WobblyLondoner · 15/09/2023 23:12

I am a 56 year old version of your 10 month old. I sound English. I feel very close to Scotland and regularly visit family there (including my parents who eventually moved back). But if I said I was Scottish I'd feel a fool, having not lived there since infancy.

I'd never ever call myself English though - I'm British.

Sugarfree23 · 15/09/2023 23:05

I think the 9yo will consider themselves Scottish, the baby English but debatable for the 4yo

The 9yo will have memories of primary school etc

FunnysInLaJardin · 15/09/2023 23:03

We have this. Been in Jersey 25 years almost longer than in the UK and am definitely English.

The DC were born here and so are Jersey but with 2 English parents. So they are Jersey but not 100% in their minds

TheNinny · 15/09/2023 22:59

my cousins (with scottish parents) moved from scotland to england aged 4 and 5ish. Both sound english. think my male cousin considers himself scottish but my female cousin considers herself english as she doesn’t remember much from living in scotland.