Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My son being told to walk to school with another child!

282 replies

SunSeaSand55 · 15/09/2023 15:32

My son is in Yr 9 and walks the 10 - 15 min walk to school with his friend who lives over the road. Coming home today our new neighbour asks to speak to him and says her son has just started in Yr 7 and she's having to pay for a taxi to take him as she's working and doesn't want him walking alone. She then asked if they could walk together. My son barely had chance to speak and she just said thank you so much and walked away! As a working parent myself I totally get where she's coming from but think it's a bit cheeky. My son walked on his own right from the beginning until several weeks in when he made friends. He is now stropping as he doesn't want to have a Yr 7 walking with him! Apparently it's very uncool and Yr 9 do not associate with younger year groups!!
I am not going to tell the other mum my son isn't happy but I do see his point. He shouldn't be responsible for someone else's child. Should he just suck it up?

OP posts:
Lunde · 15/09/2023 18:28

Thementalloadisreal · 15/09/2023 17:36

I don’t think they should.
I think they should have some empathy for the younger boy and that spending 15 mins for 2-3 days making his life a little nicer wouldn’t hurt. Especially if he’s going that way anyway. Would probably mean a lot to the boy. We’ve all been nervous year 7s at some point.
For clarification I don’t give 2 hoots about the mum. And I don’t think it should be a long term thing.

But where are you getting the 2 or 3 days from? It sounds more like the other mum is regarding this as a permanent, unpaid babysitting arrangement. The year 7 child started school 2 weeks ago and the mum has done nothing to prepare him and is just seeing OP's child as a free option to save money.

OP is also doing little to help her own child and seems to be just ignoring him and hoping that her child goes along with this unwanted chore because it means a quieter life for her.

Thighdentitycrisis · 15/09/2023 18:22

I’m in the minority here, with caveats

the neighbour was out of order the way she asked but I would still encourage my DS to help others

Surely he’s old enough to understand that it was clumsy and wrong to approach it like that but he will come out the better person if you and he agree to do it temporarily with a definite end date and you say explicitly to her in his presence that the way she spoke to him was out of order.

also agree that mum and son should be practicing this weekend

we also don’t have lots of details. How new is new neighbour? 3 months, 2 weeks? Maybe she had to move quickly, maybe from a completely different area, and didn’t have the luxury of practicing.

StopProcrastinatingGerald · 15/09/2023 18:16

@IsItThough i agree the parents should have done it - I certainly did with my dc. Just suggesting something that might resolve the situation and give the dc the independence he needs.

I agree with everyone that it’s not the OP’s responsibility or the son’s: I was just suggesting a small kindness which might make the problem resolve.

Redrumredrumredrum · 15/09/2023 18:15

Because they've just moved according to op 🙄

DivingForLove · 15/09/2023 18:15

My DC would be fuming - it’s social suicide nowadays to associate with kids from younger years 🙄. Crazy but true so no, this is not ok and totally ridiculous of the mum.

Redrumredrumredrum · 15/09/2023 18:15

Wow you're all so mean!

So she's a new neighbour, potentially with work and moving she hasn't yet had chance to scope out the route and asked if ops Ds would walk with him, presumably he's nervous about the first time in a new school and area, and doesn't want his mum coming with so she's asked if he'd walk with him, I'd assume just to show him the route for a day. No mention of it being anything more, of him being responsible for him - literally nothing alluding to that and it's telling the op was going to tell her son to suck it up so from that I'd assume it wasn't a big deal or made into one.

And tbh a 13 year old is more than capable of making the decision to walk with someone to school, if I'm asking something of a 13 year old I'd address them not their mum, that's so disrespectful to go over their head when it concerns them doing something.

It's not a bad thing to promote kindness over being 'cool'. Some of these responses are abhorrent!! I've been asked this by a neighbour for our ten yo children, here's everyone walks and has independence early on, it wasn't a problem and the kids don't always walk together but those first couple of days weren't a big ask. FFS what is wrong with people 🤯

IsItThough · 15/09/2023 18:14

StopProcrastinatingGerald · 15/09/2023 18:05

I think that if your son was okay with it, it might be kind to walk the younger kid to school once or twice to ensure he knows the route and where it’s safe to cross. But as with others, my dc walked from age 11, and after the first week were confident doing it alone.

Why haven't his parents done that with him, over the summer or last term?

ididntwanttodoit · 15/09/2023 18:13

She should have spoken to you, not to your son. Then you and your son could have dealt with it privately before responding., However ... I think both you and your son are being very unreasonable .
it would be helpful to a younger pupil if your son accompany him to school.
You need to sit down with other parent and draw up some rule - eg:
he can say you agreed it, thereby not being responsible for the deal in the eyes of his peers.
you need to agree with other parent that your son isn't responsible for anything that happens on the journey (he is also a child after all)
if protogee is not at designed pick up points at designated times, your child is free from obligation to wait.
everyone should think of it as a "big brother, little brother" deal. But at the same time, there has to be a reward in this for your child, otherwise it's altruism, and where is that going to get you in the end????

IsItThough · 15/09/2023 18:13

StopProcrastinatingGerald · 15/09/2023 18:05

I think that if your son was okay with it, it might be kind to walk the younger kid to school once or twice to ensure he knows the route and where it’s safe to cross. But as with others, my dc walked from age 11, and after the first week were confident doing it alone.

Why haven't his parents done that with him, over the summer or last term?

Gymnopedie · 15/09/2023 18:12

To those saying to do it for a week or two/a few days, this is a mother who at present sends her son to school in a taxi, spoke to OP's son not OP and basically told him that her son would be walking with him (as in she didn't give him enough time to say no).

There's not a snowball in hell's chance that this would only be short term. The mother will still be expecting this when her precious child is sitting his GCSEs.

IsItThough · 15/09/2023 18:11

Oh that's not on at all

I appreciate she may have a difficult job but she needs to put the time in now to support her own child's ability to get themself to school.

I would simply say no, your child isn't going to do this.

By about 3 weeks in one of mine was going in randomly early to play football/meet his mates before (another one was habitually late).

There's a big gap between keeping an eye out for a neighbourhood kid and being told by their parent that are now responsible for walking them to school.

Notlaughingalot · 15/09/2023 18:05

Severalreasons · 15/09/2023 17:15

@Oioicaptain i completely agree.

I encourage my dc to help others and to always make sure they stand up for people.

I understand your son doesn't want to but it is that difficult to ask him to do it for a week or 2? After that the yr9 boys could ask the yr7 to walk alone or you could speak to the mum.

Kindness goes a long way

This.

StopProcrastinatingGerald · 15/09/2023 18:05

I think that if your son was okay with it, it might be kind to walk the younger kid to school once or twice to ensure he knows the route and where it’s safe to cross. But as with others, my dc walked from age 11, and after the first week were confident doing it alone.

LlynTegid · 15/09/2023 18:03

Focus on the responsibility. Occasionally children are ill, Covid is still about and your child if unlucky to catch it you would keep off school.

Say no. I'd say no on the grounds of not even giving a chance to consider it and just walking away.

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 18:02

you should say that YOU're not happy and not put it on your son, imo. the other mother will tell her son your son said that. Be the bigger adult and just explain the situation and that she needs to find another way. I also think it's cheeky and also weird she did this. It's nothing to do with being cool/uncool. You son shouldn't feel obliged to sort out their childcare.

Zebedee55 · 15/09/2023 18:00

SunSeaSand55 · 15/09/2023 15:32

My son is in Yr 9 and walks the 10 - 15 min walk to school with his friend who lives over the road. Coming home today our new neighbour asks to speak to him and says her son has just started in Yr 7 and she's having to pay for a taxi to take him as she's working and doesn't want him walking alone. She then asked if they could walk together. My son barely had chance to speak and she just said thank you so much and walked away! As a working parent myself I totally get where she's coming from but think it's a bit cheeky. My son walked on his own right from the beginning until several weeks in when he made friends. He is now stropping as he doesn't want to have a Yr 7 walking with him! Apparently it's very uncool and Yr 9 do not associate with younger year groups!!
I am not going to tell the other mum my son isn't happy but I do see his point. He shouldn't be responsible for someone else's child. Should he just suck it up?

Surely,at that age, they all walk along or together?

I had to get two buses - it wasn't a drama. Mates travelled together. Others travelled alone.😗

ThanksItHasPockets · 15/09/2023 17:59

I work with teenagers as a secondary school teacher. Beneath the bravado they generally are very kind indeed and will help each other in an emergency. You can think it’s important for teens to be kind AND think that OP’s DS shouldn’t have to capitulate to a manipulative parent who isn’t doing her job.

No-one yet seems to have an answer for @DrMarshaFieldstone about why the mother approached the son and not his parent. Obviously it is because she knew the request was unreasonable and knew that a child would be more easily manipulated into saying yes. #BeKind your way out of that.

SamphiretheTervosaurReturneth · 15/09/2023 17:56

Oioicaptain · 15/09/2023 16:35

Gosh, I must be in a minority here, but I always encourage my kids to look out for younger ones, particularly when starting a new school. I don't think that it's an unreasonable request at all, if it's just short term whilst he settles in. I'm sure that in a days or weeks he will be used to walking to school and his mum will have relaxed and your son will be fine to ditch him. Personally I would encourage it for a few days and then, if it's not working out, speak to the mother.

That's fine. It's what happens naturally as kids walk to and from school.

But a parent demanding that another kid who isn't in her own or her sons friendship circle is overstepping themself.

This has to be done with consent or it could have all sorts of unintended ramifications. Mostly an older child feeling put upon and resentful...

DrMarshaFieldstone · 15/09/2023 17:55

Thementalloadisreal · 15/09/2023 17:48

A year 7 kid is only 11 it’s really not unusual to be nervous of a new journey.

It’s really not about the older kid “being responsible” for the younger one but just showing him the way.

I’d hope that parents encourage their children to look out for others if they’re nervous, lost or upset, in or out of school!

Which is why it is the parent’s responsibility to prepare the child by walking the route together at different times of the day during the spring and summer before they start. Why should a fourteen year old compensate for a basic failure of parenting?

SamphiretheTervosaurReturneth · 15/09/2023 17:53

You need to tell her she had a fucking nerve talking to your son and effectively telling him what to do.

Then you need to add that he won't be taking any responsibility for walking her kid, that her kid needs to do what all the other kids who walk do, learn some independence. Or she keeps paying for that taxi. Her choice.

Thementalloadisreal · 15/09/2023 17:48

A year 7 kid is only 11 it’s really not unusual to be nervous of a new journey.

It’s really not about the older kid “being responsible” for the younger one but just showing him the way.

I’d hope that parents encourage their children to look out for others if they’re nervous, lost or upset, in or out of school!

Peacendkindness · 15/09/2023 17:48

StripeyDeckchair · 15/09/2023 15:50

If something happens to the Y7 on the way to school the parent will hold your son responsible.

I would be round there like a flash. How dare she bully my son into babysitting her child. I would not permit this to happen.
She's a CF if you let this slide she will take more & more advantage of your son / you.

This is an important life lesson for your son. It is OK to stand up for yourself & say no, do not let others take advantage

This pop a note through the letter box

Dear ?

I’m sorry I know your name or you, or your son or family at all - do we? I am wondering why you thought you would tell my 13 year son that he was going to be babysitting your son walking them to and from school without giving him or me a question asking the above?

Just to clarify - My son is not walking with yours, he has his own friends, schedule, clubs and family events and is not a free babysitter. You can’t tell children they are responsible for other children without even any courtesy to discuss. You are responsible for your son. It’s a no here.

kind regards

the family at number 2

Hibiscrubbed · 15/09/2023 17:47

Eh? Why aren’t you speaking up for your son? That woman’s child is not his responsibility for heaven’s sake.

Spaghettihulahoops · 15/09/2023 17:45

LudicrouslyCapaciousBag · 15/09/2023 17:35

There is some weaponised passive-aggressive guilting on this thread.

A Year 7 who can’t do a ten-minute walk independently either has particular needs or vulnerabilities or very overbearing parents. All of these are the responsibility of the parent and not of a fourteen year old child.

I think if the y7 child actually had additional needs and a care plan the school would be providing a taxi.
Sounds like an anxious parent to me.

Cupofteafortwo · 15/09/2023 17:39

Jeez what happened to ‘it takes a village’ and all that??

Swipe left for the next trending thread