Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My son being told to walk to school with another child!

282 replies

SunSeaSand55 · 15/09/2023 15:32

My son is in Yr 9 and walks the 10 - 15 min walk to school with his friend who lives over the road. Coming home today our new neighbour asks to speak to him and says her son has just started in Yr 7 and she's having to pay for a taxi to take him as she's working and doesn't want him walking alone. She then asked if they could walk together. My son barely had chance to speak and she just said thank you so much and walked away! As a working parent myself I totally get where she's coming from but think it's a bit cheeky. My son walked on his own right from the beginning until several weeks in when he made friends. He is now stropping as he doesn't want to have a Yr 7 walking with him! Apparently it's very uncool and Yr 9 do not associate with younger year groups!!
I am not going to tell the other mum my son isn't happy but I do see his point. He shouldn't be responsible for someone else's child. Should he just suck it up?

OP posts:
DiverseCity · 15/09/2023 19:27

Like many things in life, it’s not so much what is done, it’s how it is done.

Thementalloadisreal · 15/09/2023 19:25

Redmat · 15/09/2023 19:19

This used to be the norm, older children walking with younger. At our local secondary school the older children are still asked to look out for the younger ones if a school bus fails to arrive.
The mum might have gone about it the wrong way but it's not an awful request.
Shes not asking him to be responsible for him she's just asking that they walk together. I'm suprised at the unkindness being shown here.

Exactly this. I got 2 buses to school and my friends’ older siblings showed us where to go, what to do. Then when the little siblings and younger kids from the area joined y7 we did the same.

You’re all going the same way anyway, why not go together.

Thementalloadisreal · 15/09/2023 19:21

Lunde · 15/09/2023 18:28

But where are you getting the 2 or 3 days from? It sounds more like the other mum is regarding this as a permanent, unpaid babysitting arrangement. The year 7 child started school 2 weeks ago and the mum has done nothing to prepare him and is just seeing OP's child as a free option to save money.

OP is also doing little to help her own child and seems to be just ignoring him and hoping that her child goes along with this unwanted chore because it means a quieter life for her.

No one is signing a contract. I’m saying you can disagree to the mum’s ask but still offer to be nice to the younger boy. The 2-3 days is an example of a boundary the older boy can set. The OP can support this, they just go to the other parent and say sorry he’s not confident walking alone but it is not possible for us to help long term, however DS will be happy to show him the way for 2-3 days to build his confidence.

Redmat · 15/09/2023 19:19

This used to be the norm, older children walking with younger. At our local secondary school the older children are still asked to look out for the younger ones if a school bus fails to arrive.
The mum might have gone about it the wrong way but it's not an awful request.
Shes not asking him to be responsible for him she's just asking that they walk together. I'm suprised at the unkindness being shown here.

tommyhoundmum · 15/09/2023 19:18

It was the father. The parents were separated. He was able to meet her out most days. It was central London. She was an anxious child.

Thementalloadisreal · 15/09/2023 19:17

DivingForLove · 15/09/2023 18:15

My DC would be fuming - it’s social suicide nowadays to associate with kids from younger years 🙄. Crazy but true so no, this is not ok and totally ridiculous of the mum.

What’s not ok and totally ridiculous is parents actively facilitating a culture in which the younger kids aren’t supported by the older ones! And being cool is more important than being kind.

Some really revolting attitudes on here tbh. I hope your kids are never in a position where they need to ask another for help but if they are I hope that kid says yes because they had good parents who taught them decent principles .

Thementalloadisreal · 15/09/2023 19:13

I sincerely hope most teenagers are nicer than their parents are on here!

Thementalloadisreal · 15/09/2023 19:13

DrMarshaFieldstone · 15/09/2023 17:55

Which is why it is the parent’s responsibility to prepare the child by walking the route together at different times of the day during the spring and summer before they start. Why should a fourteen year old compensate for a basic failure of parenting?

Jesus, its just asking kids to be friendly!
No one is asking him to parent the boy!

SophieJo · 15/09/2023 19:07

So what are you going to do about it for your son’s sake?

EarthlyNightshade · 15/09/2023 19:05

tommyhoundmum · 15/09/2023 18:47

My daughter escorted a year 7 girl to school for 2 years when she was in years 10 and 11. It was a tube and bus journey. Not cool but she didn't mind. I hadn't realised it might have been an issue.

Was there a reason why a Y8, which presumably she was after 2 years, couldn't manage the journey on her own? Did your DD not do any extra curricular activities in that time?
Did the girl's mum ask her to do it?

Anniegetyourgun · 15/09/2023 19:05

It's the very beginning of the school year so most likely their ages are 11 and 13. I wouldn't expect a 13 year old my child didn't even know to be responsible for escorting him to school. Plus who's to say, if they don't get on, whether they would behave sensibly, especially the younger one? The main thing that would put me off doing this favour, though, is the way the mum "asked" but said thanks before the child could respond, so effectively dumping the task on him rather than genuinely requesting a favour. That sort of person is going to be trouble later on. Bet you find the kid left at your house for hours after school in a scarily short time - "Mum has to work late, she said it was ok to stay at your house" - you know how these things end up. Nip it in the bud, I say!

The uncool thing is a red herring though, I wouldn't encourage that attitude. A truly cool teen doesn't need to hold onto his dignity by ignoring pre-teens; his peers will accept that if he does it, it IS cool.

Romiii · 15/09/2023 18:59

would he do it for hard cash? £2 each way

Romiii · 15/09/2023 18:58

Can they leave 5 minutes early and stay out of view?

Inkpotlover · 15/09/2023 18:57

Also, any parent who doesn't want a Y7 to walk just 10-15 mins by themselves and is so cautious they've been getting them a taxi doesn't sound like they'll be easy to deal. Presuming she expects them to walk home too, what if your DS is running late and her kid is left waiting or yours wants to do an after-school club - will she expect hers to sit on the sidelines waiting for him? Nah, sounds too precious and a no-win situation.

Inkpotlover · 15/09/2023 18:52

If your DS doesn't want to do it, you cannot and should not force him. Even siblings hate walking with their younger ones at secondary! It's not just him it impacts either - it means his friend over the road would have to walk with the younger boy too or he'll have to go separately.

Just drop a note in saying your DS felt put on the spot and doesn't want to do it. These people are not your friends so it makes no odds if they get annoyed.

tommyhoundmum · 15/09/2023 18:47

My daughter escorted a year 7 girl to school for 2 years when she was in years 10 and 11. It was a tube and bus journey. Not cool but she didn't mind. I hadn't realised it might have been an issue.

Blanketpolicy · 15/09/2023 18:45

I would go around and speak to her and just be honest. Tell her she might not know what teens are like yet but is super uncool at school to hang about with anyone from the younger years so your son does not want to do it.

Perhaps, if you want to be kind and with your sons permission, tell her you son did it alone at first and there are plenty of kids on the same route so it is safe enough but if her son is nervous your son could walk with him for 2-3 days so he knows where he is going etc. Just make sure to be clear and set boundaries. Don't say he can walk with them until he is comfortable say an exact number of days.

HalfMoonSpectacles · 15/09/2023 18:44

I think you could agree to maybe 3 days for them to walk together and then the yr 7 should be fine. DS has to take the train to school and we did a couple of practice runs, took him the first day and then left him to it.

So a short walk should be absolutely fine.

IsItThough · 15/09/2023 18:43

Redrumredrumredrum · 15/09/2023 18:15

Because they've just moved according to op 🙄

But you know I don't suppose they are in witness protection and arrived by surprise, or had no idea that going to school would be a thing?

Its about the level of expectation. If the child had been helped already to learn the route and the parent had asked if OPs son could just keep an eye out for a day or two that is one thing - and perfectly fine. But it appears the poor kids just been shoved in a taxi and his mum wants him babysitting. Of course we don't know what is going on in their lives, but it isn't reasonable of her.

Plenty of what ifs - OP's kid is sick/late/doesn't have to go in/needs to go in early/wants to hang out with mates before going in. Neighbours kid is loose cannon/doesn't know how to cross the road/gets upset and OPs kid has to deal with it.

How is said child going to get home as well?

MiniCooperLover · 15/09/2023 18:38

Stand up for your son and tell her that her son is NOT your son's responsibility!! Why on earth wouldn't you ??

Princessfluffy · 15/09/2023 18:37

Why would a Y7 need walking to school?
At that age they all get themselves to school surely

CorvusPurpureus · 15/09/2023 18:37

Do you have contact details?

If so, I'd message: 'hi Sarah, we were all in a rush today so I didn't get a chance to clarify, but I definitely can't ask poor Adam to commit to walking with Bobby to school. He's usually hanging out with his y9 mates, & he walked independently from y7. There's all sorts going on afterschool, too, so Bobby would be on his own on the way back anyway.

I'm sure Bobby will find his feet!

All the best,

OP.'

If no obvious way of finding mum & saying this, I might treat my ds to a lift/taxi for the first week.

This puts the onus on her to either accept the situation or find you to discuss it, at which point, response as above.

Obviously you should not have to, but my concern would be that otherwise her y7 just tags on. It's not HIS fault.

& then either you're saddled with the arrangement, or you/ds have to pointedly & explicitly terminate it. Mean to the y7 with a CFer mum, & awkward for your ds.

NewName122 · 15/09/2023 18:35

No he should not have to do that. Tell him to avoid their house. Leave yours and walk fast out of view. Cheeky lady.

PoshPineapple · 15/09/2023 18:32

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 15/09/2023 15:50

You need to tell her that while you're happy for your son to walk to school without an adult, he's not old enough to be responsible for a younger child, and you will not allow it. You need to step in and be the adult in his corner here, he can't be expected to stand up against a random adult at 13, it's too much.

Don't give 'reasons' like he doesn't know him, or sometimes doesn't walk. She'll just come up with ways to 'solve' them. Just say no. Not happening.

If you do nothing, he will either handle it badly with the yr7 and be accused of bullying, abandon the kid and get in the shit for that, or be 'rude' to the neighbour and be berated for that.

This.

Totaly · 15/09/2023 18:31

moving she hasn't yet had chance to scope out the route

Evenings weekends - I mean make time for your own child!

I wouldn’t want my children to have that responsibility unless they wanted it. They do get a choice.