Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Coughing lady at the movies

157 replies

HibiscusAndPineapples · 15/09/2023 14:52

Went to the cinema to watch a film, and the lady seated behind me spent the better part of the entire runtime coughing. It wasn’t just muffled coughs here and there either, but full on, loud, non-stop coughing.

Any quiet/tense moment in the film was completely ruined by loud coughing.

AIBU to think that anyone with a cough as loud and relentless as this should just stay away from the cinema?

OP posts:
jannier · 16/09/2023 12:28

10HailMarys · 16/09/2023 10:16

Nobody’s saying people who cough constantly should remain indoors and fade away. They should, however, leave the cinema if they can’t stop coughing, because they are ruining the film for everyone else. If someone brought a baby into the cinema and it started to scream, you would expect them to take it out. That doesn’t mean people with babies have to stay in, it just means they should accept that it’s not OK to monopolise a public event by making a loud noise all the way through it.

You have no concept of living with a disease like this, people with babies will move on and be people without babies people with disease will get worse. The physical strength to get into the theater in the first place is a major event when you're coughing you are also having a major lack of oxygen adding to the loss of strength. You can't physically move it's not a case of jumping up and running out like coughing with a cold or itchy throat so what you're actually saying is your disability is not allowed in a public place that is discrimination.
Special screenings are for the benefit of these needing things like more lighting and lower noise they are not there to remove an inconvenience for normal screenings or so all the noisy people can stick together like a zoo.

jannier · 16/09/2023 12:19

Foggyfoggyfoggy · 16/09/2023 08:15

Whatever illness someone has should a paying patron really have to embrace that illness too? Cost me nearly 50 quid to sit listening to 2 bloody dc shouting. Could have stayed home for free and done that..

I hope you never get cancer and after spending years in lockdown...yes years ...decide on your last few months sod it I'm doing my bucket list to be subjected to someone with this attitude

jannier · 16/09/2023 12:16

HappiDaze · 16/09/2023 00:44

I mean if you know your cough is ruining everyone's else viewing of the film then take yourself outside or move to the back and walk out every time you cough like crazy

And if you keep coughing then fuck off home

What you mean is Disabled needing a wheelchair two helpers and terminally ill fuck off your a nuisance and should stay home and die because your cough annoys me....not every awful cough is a virus

housethatbuiltme · 16/09/2023 10:57

SeriouslySeriouslySeriously · 15/09/2023 23:20

I have a chronic lung condition (bronchiectasis), it stops me going to places I used to really enjoy like cinema, shows, museums because I know I'd piss people off and be judged as selfish, I often get disgusted looks from strangers if my coughing starts on the bus where silence isn't isn't expected, if I get called selfish and told I shouldn't leave the house with my cough on the bus, I'm gonna get worse at a cinema.

It's been very hard to adjust to though, it's the sharing the excitement of going to see something like a new marvel film with family and friends and dissecting it all in the way home that I miss. Watching it on my own on Disney plus months later isn't the same but it is what it is. Drive in cinema is great when they show something we all want to see,

I've lost friends who think I should not let the filthy looks and nasty comments stop me doing the things I like and who have gotten frustrated with me declining invites to places I know I'll get looks of disgust and sometimes comments too.

I know its not quite the same as its often limited and awkward times (like morning or noon) and often not 18+ stuff but most cinemas and theaters hold 'non quiet' screenings for children, autistic and/or other types of disability who might not be able to conform to sitting in silence for 90+ minutes.

I have gone to a few of these with my young kids and honestly they aren't bad, usually pretty empty. I think we have had the whole cinema to ourselves before.

10HailMarys · 16/09/2023 10:16

Topseyt123 · 16/09/2023 09:14

I've had more than one episode of pneumonia in the past. The coughing lasted a year, afterwards, long after the illness and infectious period had subsided and I do now have some scarring on my lungs. This can mean that I cough/have to clear my chest a lot even now years later.

I do try to be considerate and as far as possible sit where I can get to a door if it does ratchet up, which thankfully isn't too often these days.

Should I never go out to the cinema? Thanks for that. There are many, many reasons why people cough. Many of them not at all infectious. I remember us regularly having to explain this at the start of the COVID pandemic when we were practically being accused of being murderers.

My mother has COPD which certainly isn't infectious but can cause hard to control coughing. She's pretty well at the moment. There certainly seem to be some people around though who think that people like her should just remain indoors and fade away.

You have no idea of people's medical issues or what might be going on in their lives so stop judging.

Edited

Nobody’s saying people who cough constantly should remain indoors and fade away. They should, however, leave the cinema if they can’t stop coughing, because they are ruining the film for everyone else. If someone brought a baby into the cinema and it started to scream, you would expect them to take it out. That doesn’t mean people with babies have to stay in, it just means they should accept that it’s not OK to monopolise a public event by making a loud noise all the way through it.

10HailMarys · 16/09/2023 10:11

NeunundneunzigHorseBallonz · 15/09/2023 14:53

Did you think about asking if she was okay?

Oh, do get over yourself

Topseyt123 · 16/09/2023 09:14

I've had more than one episode of pneumonia in the past. The coughing lasted a year, afterwards, long after the illness and infectious period had subsided and I do now have some scarring on my lungs. This can mean that I cough/have to clear my chest a lot even now years later.

I do try to be considerate and as far as possible sit where I can get to a door if it does ratchet up, which thankfully isn't too often these days.

Should I never go out to the cinema? Thanks for that. There are many, many reasons why people cough. Many of them not at all infectious. I remember us regularly having to explain this at the start of the COVID pandemic when we were practically being accused of being murderers.

My mother has COPD which certainly isn't infectious but can cause hard to control coughing. She's pretty well at the moment. There certainly seem to be some people around though who think that people like her should just remain indoors and fade away.

You have no idea of people's medical issues or what might be going on in their lives so stop judging.

ColleenDonaghy · 16/09/2023 08:59

I felt sorry for her suffering but I also thought ffs go home, you are clearly unwell. It was distressing each time but she didn't want help beyond a sip of water.

Comments like this demonstrate how some people just don't get it. A cough doesn't necessarily mean someone is unwell. It can also be a sign someone is chronically unwell and so this is as good as things get for them. People with chronic illnesses are allowed to go to the cinema, libraries and lectures.

(And to the poster upthread complaining about someone coughing in a lecture, if one of my students came to me about that they would likely not enjoy my response.)

fairyfluf · 16/09/2023 08:18

PuppyMonkey · 15/09/2023 19:03

Grin

It just seems silly. We're all people. Our bodies do people things. If someone can't accept other people's bodies do things they have no/little control over then they should stay inside away from other people.

fairyfluf · 16/09/2023 08:16

N3philim · 16/09/2023 06:40

Wow, the ignorance on this thread.
Have you ever met anyone with cystic fibrosis or a comparable condition? Have you ever lived with them and seen how a persistent cough never gives them a break? How acid reflux worsens their symptoms, or how they cough up blood because the relentless cough irritated their lungs so much?
And that many of these people are painfully aware that their coughing annoys other people, so they shy away from activities?

Of course there is a chance that the woman in the cinema was simply selfish and had a cold, but unless you know what is going on with her you really shouldn’t judge.

I know it's horrible. Like some people think the public should be shut away if they dare show any signs of a chronic condition

Foggyfoggyfoggy · 16/09/2023 08:15

Whatever illness someone has should a paying patron really have to embrace that illness too? Cost me nearly 50 quid to sit listening to 2 bloody dc shouting. Could have stayed home for free and done that..

N3philim · 16/09/2023 06:40

Wow, the ignorance on this thread.
Have you ever met anyone with cystic fibrosis or a comparable condition? Have you ever lived with them and seen how a persistent cough never gives them a break? How acid reflux worsens their symptoms, or how they cough up blood because the relentless cough irritated their lungs so much?
And that many of these people are painfully aware that their coughing annoys other people, so they shy away from activities?

Of course there is a chance that the woman in the cinema was simply selfish and had a cold, but unless you know what is going on with her you really shouldn’t judge.

Catsmere · 16/09/2023 06:24

The fact this woman had no strategy in place (such as using huffs) has me believing she's just someone with a chest infection who doesn't give a shit.

I agree, @ChristmasFluff . I'm asthmatic and currently have a post-viral cough that's lasted three times as long as the damn cold - and it's nothing like asthmatic wheezing or shortness of breath or a real asthma attack, it's gunge on the chest that takes a hell of a hard cough to shift, and no way would I go to a cinema like this! I'm baffled this woman bothered - how much did she even get out of the film?

DreamTheMoors · 16/09/2023 02:17

MorrisZapp · 16/09/2023 00:34

Choking is an entirely different matter. This is about persistent coughing from someone who was well enough to attend the cinema and eat a box of popcorn. Not gasping for life in a medical emergency.

Yeah, choking is.

But kindness and compassion are not.

LastHives · 16/09/2023 00:48

YouJustDoYou · 15/09/2023 18:47

Who cares if she was okay? She shouldn't've been there.

😂

HappiDaze · 16/09/2023 00:45

I think though if you have to leave because of being unwell and disturbing everyone in there then you should be entitled to your money back

HappiDaze · 16/09/2023 00:44

I mean if you know your cough is ruining everyone's else viewing of the film then take yourself outside or move to the back and walk out every time you cough like crazy

And if you keep coughing then fuck off home

AprQ · 16/09/2023 00:42

I find it so funny when people act like everyone in the cinema needs to sit in complete silence! ‘You shouldn’t be rustling bags of snacks, you shouldn’t open any snacks during ‘tense moments,’ you shouldn’t cough, speak during trailers or breathe too loudly’ etc etc.

I work in the film industry and one of our offices are based BOH in one of the cinemas. The amount of nonsense that people complain about to the ushers is absolutely ridiculous.

She’s still allowed to visit the cinema with a cough. Yes she should have stepped outside if she was being disruptive but either move seats or go to the box office and let someone know. Not any point coming on the internet once the film is now finished!

MorrisZapp · 16/09/2023 00:34

DreamTheMoors · 16/09/2023 00:29

Oh okay. I hope somebody someday will remind you of this when you need the Heimlich while dining out.

Your kindness and compassion is overwhelming. /s

Choking is an entirely different matter. This is about persistent coughing from someone who was well enough to attend the cinema and eat a box of popcorn. Not gasping for life in a medical emergency.

DreamTheMoors · 16/09/2023 00:29

YouJustDoYou · 15/09/2023 18:47

Who cares if she was okay? She shouldn't've been there.

Oh okay. I hope somebody someday will remind you of this when you need the Heimlich while dining out.

Your kindness and compassion is overwhelming. /s

jannier · 16/09/2023 00:23

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 15/09/2023 23:23

Just sat through a restaurant meal near the cougher from hell. Cheers then. We obviously all need it.

Possibly my sister who when saliva or food goes down her open airway sounds awful and very distressing scares the shit out of her (and me) but not infectious.

jannier · 16/09/2023 00:19

Cherryada · 15/09/2023 20:04

Yep I think it's selfish and inconsiderate of someone to do this - I would be so irritated by it but more irritated by the lack of social awareness of the person doing it.

When your terminal with a mass in your lungs and restricted diaphragm added to the damage done to your oesophagus when they tried to take biopsies the little life you have is full of lack of social awareness.

Ohthatsabitshit · 16/09/2023 00:17

Some medication for high blood pressure makes you cough. It’s for life so all you can do is crack on.

jannier · 16/09/2023 00:13

HibiscusAndPineapples · 15/09/2023 14:52

Went to the cinema to watch a film, and the lady seated behind me spent the better part of the entire runtime coughing. It wasn’t just muffled coughs here and there either, but full on, loud, non-stop coughing.

Any quiet/tense moment in the film was completely ruined by loud coughing.

AIBU to think that anyone with a cough as loud and relentless as this should just stay away from the cinema?

My sister has multiple illnesses including cancer she can't control her cough I guess by your criteria she should continue to stay home no last treats and wait for death so as not to inconvenience anyone.

MorrisZapp · 16/09/2023 00:10

I work in public research rooms and this is absolutely endemic.

I remember one lady started coughing quite normally but soon escalated to a quite scary, gasping, hacking attack. Staff rushed over and she was given water, offered help etc. She left the room briefly.

She came back and had three further awful hacking attacks throughout the day, with tears running down her face. Each time once the coughing reached an unbearable crescendo she left the room for a moment or two but then came back to resume her research, coughing quietly til the next huge blow up.

I felt sorry for her suffering but I also thought ffs go home, you are clearly unwell. It was distressing each time but she didn't want help beyond a sip of water.

It's better since covid but I can see coughing creeping back slowly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread