Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Coughing lady at the movies

157 replies

HibiscusAndPineapples · 15/09/2023 14:52

Went to the cinema to watch a film, and the lady seated behind me spent the better part of the entire runtime coughing. It wasn’t just muffled coughs here and there either, but full on, loud, non-stop coughing.

Any quiet/tense moment in the film was completely ruined by loud coughing.

AIBU to think that anyone with a cough as loud and relentless as this should just stay away from the cinema?

OP posts:
MartinChuzzlewit · 16/09/2023 21:00

NeunundneunzigHorseBallonz · 15/09/2023 14:53

Did you think about asking if she was okay?

Yeah OP and you should have offered her a crème egg too 😂😂

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 16/09/2023 21:00

I’m a cougher (nothing like this lady sounds to be, in fairness) and it’s due to an unlovely combination of chronic sinus issues which cause post nasal drip, and acid reflux that came on from nowhere during peri menopause. I’m on prescription meds for both which really help but don’t totally solve the problem. Somewhere like the cinema I always bring water, but sometimes in dry air I feel my nose suddenly start to swell/fill (!) and just know a cough will come. I’d generally take a decongestant before a film/theatre as a precaution.

i think Covid has made people really, really paranoid about coughs, and coughers really paranoid about coughing in public.

Butchyrestingface · 16/09/2023 20:54

An asthmatic cough has a particular timbre to it, because we aren't able to expel the air through our contracted pipes. It's a comparatively quiet and wheezy cough, not what the OP is talking about. Asthmatics literally cannot expel the air fast enough to do repeatedly loud coughs, and most of us know that coughing doesn't help anyway (and in fact makes things worse) so we try to avoid coughing if possible.

I have cough variant asthma, which it appears you have never heard of. Repeated, uncontrollable cough, not "comparatively quiet", not necessarily wheezy, and absolutely no problem expelling air fast fast enough for repeated coughs.

I'd probably have sat at the back though.

jannier · 16/09/2023 20:50

Foggyfoggyfoggy · 16/09/2023 19:55

No disrespect but cinema costs money. Should other people's health issues impact the enjoyment of a trip out that cost me part of my weekly wage? Should we all make financial sacrificed for other people?

So where does the line stop the person with Touretts shouting swear words upsetting you at dinner because you paid good money and your child might hear it, the wheelchair user who needs you to move to get on board, the person having a heart attack mid show who may have ignored their earlier warning signs. What about the tall person who dares to sit In front of you at the theater do they have to be forced to sit in a back row. The person with an overactive bladder who keeps making you stand up....We can all follow good etiquette like not eating sweets, not invading space etc but if we have disabilities we have a legal right to adaptations and to be allowed to be in the cinema in the scheme of things most are rarely severely affected by disabled people attending events what one or two events in your life I'm sure compared to the times disabled people are obstructed from accessing things they have paid for or that you take for granted it's a very insignificant percentage. For example....trip to supermarket took 4 stops for meds I had to fight a parking ticket for over staying, find a staff member to unlock a disabled toilet....who then said key was lost and if SHE looking at my sister could walk she could help her into the regular toilet....20 minutes later it was found....that ruined my sister's long looked forward to food shop....it's typical for every trip I've taken either with my sister or mother (and talking to others) to find an issue can't get around a shop, obstructed isles, locked loos that are not broken but they don't want to open, changing rooms too small so your flashing to the store ....the list is endless and every time we go out.

trampoline123 · 16/09/2023 20:41

Never said it was right, or wrong, just the way it is.

And yes, a cinema is a public space. A public space doesn't have to be outside and free to use, it's a place where people meet.

fairyfluf · 16/09/2023 20:25

Foggyfoggyfoggy · 16/09/2023 19:55

No disrespect but cinema costs money. Should other people's health issues impact the enjoyment of a trip out that cost me part of my weekly wage? Should we all make financial sacrificed for other people?

You choose to spend your money on sharing the screening of a film with other humans. You have to accept they have bodily functions.

HibiscusAndPineapples · 16/09/2023 20:23

trampoline123 · 16/09/2023 20:13

If people are so bothered about noises, wait until you can watch it at home. Simple.

Could have easily have been someone rustling a crisp packet or chatting to their mate, the cause of the noise is irrelevant.

It's public space, people make noises and disturb others for all sort of reasons. Honestly, get over yourself.

Cinemas are not public spaces. It's not the park or the beach where noise is just something that's expected. Do you really think it's right for someone to be "chatting to their mate" while a movie is going on? Confused

OP posts:
jonnyjanetkeogh · 16/09/2023 20:18

trampoline123 · 16/09/2023 20:13

If people are so bothered about noises, wait until you can watch it at home. Simple.

Could have easily have been someone rustling a crisp packet or chatting to their mate, the cause of the noise is irrelevant.

It's public space, people make noises and disturb others for all sort of reasons. Honestly, get over yourself.

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

jonnyjanetkeogh · 16/09/2023 20:17

@jannier I have appreciated every single thing you've said on here and I'm sorry to hear you and your family are experiencing this. You're right too that there's an assumption that COPD is a smoker's illness, I can imagine that must be another blow to deal with when you haven't smoked a day in your life.
Sending you love and to your sister too.

trampoline123 · 16/09/2023 20:13

If people are so bothered about noises, wait until you can watch it at home. Simple.

Could have easily have been someone rustling a crisp packet or chatting to their mate, the cause of the noise is irrelevant.

It's public space, people make noises and disturb others for all sort of reasons. Honestly, get over yourself.

jonnyjanetkeogh · 16/09/2023 20:01

@Notmyfirstusername it could be pulmonary fibrosis. My relative has this and although she can walk around and seem fine she has a persistent hacking cough that comes on seemingly out of nowhere and causes great pain and discomfort. She can still eat popcorn.
As her life is limited (there is no cure, it will progressively worsen the next few years) we ensure she experiences the things she enjoys while she still can.
I am not for one minute saying it's what the woman in this scenario has, we have no way of knowing and she may well be just an arse, but yes there are chronic lung conditions that would allow this all to happen.

Foggyfoggyfoggy · 16/09/2023 19:55

No disrespect but cinema costs money. Should other people's health issues impact the enjoyment of a trip out that cost me part of my weekly wage? Should we all make financial sacrificed for other people?

trampoline123 · 16/09/2023 19:36

I've had a cough since December, they think asthma but my cough is so bad I can't do the test.

Anyway, I still have to live my life, go to work, see friends, not just going to stay inside am I? People look down their noses at me on the train, in meetings, etc - can't do anything about it. Honestly, 1 woman's dog licked my leg on a train and she didn't give a shot kept letting him do it. I cough and she moved away...

It's a public space at the end of the day.

jannier · 16/09/2023 19:29

Tourmalines · 16/09/2023 13:16

Yes, if you gonna cough up a lung , leave . Be more considerate of patrons who obviously can’t hear the sound over your constant coughing. So annoying.

So nice I guess you ignored every post and don't give a shit about disability as long as you're not inconvenienced

jannier · 16/09/2023 19:27

Topseyt123 · 16/09/2023 12:53

@jannier Thank you. Well put posts.

It is so true that people posting here clearly have no experience of living with these conditions. My mother is a wheelchair user, both because of osteoporosis and because COPD can affect blood oxygen levels.

She doesn't go out that much anymore, just for the occasional pub lunch and to do her shopping when my sister or I are there to help.

People like her should not just be excluded from places though because they cannot simply get up and leg it out for a bit if a coughing fit takes hold. That is discrimination. Maybe thoughtless rather than intentional, but discrimination nonetheless.

I don't want it to be applied to me either, as my own lungs, whilst mostly adequate, are not tip top because of my history.

Thank you ...treatments have come on my mum disabled all my life had COPD alongside spinal injuries, my sister and brother now have it and I know one day I will contract it my lungs are already deteriorating were all non smokers and will be treated like we brought it on ourselves this lock them up like Lepers attitude is appalling.

jannier · 16/09/2023 19:21

Catsmere · 16/09/2023 12:51

I know, my neighbour had COPD. It didn't sound like this woman was in such a case, though - but my neighbour was at the stage of needing breathing equipment with her a lot of the time. Would that only be late-stage?

But honestly I wouldn't go to a cinema if I had such chronic lung illness. Apart from spoiling it for everyone else, I wouldn't enjoy sitting in a crowded cinema coughing my lungs out, not getting anything out of the film, and probably being more tired and stressed at the end of it.

With respect, your saying you wouldn't go somewhere with this condition but don't you think when you are facing the end of your life you might prefer to try and go out and enjoy as much life as you can rather than sit in your chair waiting to die? Because quiet frankly what would be the pleasure in living like that....you have to remember back to lockdown when you were allowed at least to go for a walk and out to buy food....most struggled with that limit on freedom but people with chronic illness went into lockdown earlier and came out later during that time they didn't go shopping or walking and lost all contact with people why would they want to go back into that just to avoid coughing in public?
The policy of oxygen at home is much more complicated now than it used to be as our nebulisers so you can't say because someone doesn't have O2 they are not as ill. My sister has COPD and thoracic cancer (non smoker) where the biopsy had to be done while she was awake and damaged her oesophagus, needs a heart bypass and also has 3 types of arthritis and is wheelchair bound and under Palliative care she's been out for shopping (the supermarket) twice since end of lockdown and found it an amazing treat to actually choose her own food from a shelf. We've managed a meal around 10 times (yes coughing badly) if I can get her out I will if people don't like it shame on them.

kitsuneghost · 16/09/2023 14:27

If your in a crowd you just need to deal.
2 weeks in a row at gigs I had a dog owner stood next to me. It was stinking.

Catsmere · 16/09/2023 14:00

suitcasecoveredincathair · 16/09/2023 13:19

Thanks for that. As you probably realised, this is a bit of a sore point for me. 💐

Understandably!

suitcasecoveredincathair · 16/09/2023 13:19

Catsmere · 16/09/2023 13:05

Sorry to hear yours is that bad - I should've said "it's nothing like my asthmatic wheezing" rather than generalising.

Thanks for that. As you probably realised, this is a bit of a sore point for me. 💐

Tourmalines · 16/09/2023 13:16

Cherryada · 15/09/2023 20:04

Yep I think it's selfish and inconsiderate of someone to do this - I would be so irritated by it but more irritated by the lack of social awareness of the person doing it.

Yes, if you gonna cough up a lung , leave . Be more considerate of patrons who obviously can’t hear the sound over your constant coughing. So annoying.

Catsmere · 16/09/2023 13:05

suitcasecoveredincathair · 16/09/2023 12:59

I would also never go to the cinema like that but in my case the really gungy heavy cough IS asthma. For some of us the asthma causes chronic irritation and inflammation and, well, the results are pretty disgusting.

I have an inhaler for sudden coughing fits (which are rare) and would be using it in that instance, but I’m a bit shocked at all of the confidently incorrect posters here who believe they can diagnose asthma simply by listening. There are many forms of asthma. And frankly mine is absolutely shit.

Sorry to hear yours is that bad - I should've said "it's nothing like my asthmatic wheezing" rather than generalising.

suitcasecoveredincathair · 16/09/2023 12:59

Catsmere · 16/09/2023 06:24

The fact this woman had no strategy in place (such as using huffs) has me believing she's just someone with a chest infection who doesn't give a shit.

I agree, @ChristmasFluff . I'm asthmatic and currently have a post-viral cough that's lasted three times as long as the damn cold - and it's nothing like asthmatic wheezing or shortness of breath or a real asthma attack, it's gunge on the chest that takes a hell of a hard cough to shift, and no way would I go to a cinema like this! I'm baffled this woman bothered - how much did she even get out of the film?

I would also never go to the cinema like that but in my case the really gungy heavy cough IS asthma. For some of us the asthma causes chronic irritation and inflammation and, well, the results are pretty disgusting.

I have an inhaler for sudden coughing fits (which are rare) and would be using it in that instance, but I’m a bit shocked at all of the confidently incorrect posters here who believe they can diagnose asthma simply by listening. There are many forms of asthma. And frankly mine is absolutely shit.

Topseyt123 · 16/09/2023 12:53

@jannier Thank you. Well put posts.

It is so true that people posting here clearly have no experience of living with these conditions. My mother is a wheelchair user, both because of osteoporosis and because COPD can affect blood oxygen levels.

She doesn't go out that much anymore, just for the occasional pub lunch and to do her shopping when my sister or I are there to help.

People like her should not just be excluded from places though because they cannot simply get up and leg it out for a bit if a coughing fit takes hold. That is discrimination. Maybe thoughtless rather than intentional, but discrimination nonetheless.

I don't want it to be applied to me either, as my own lungs, whilst mostly adequate, are not tip top because of my history.

Catsmere · 16/09/2023 12:51

jannier · 16/09/2023 12:34

Some illnesses leave lungs becoming more and more congested that's why they are life limiting COPD has that gunge continually building so the feeling you get after a cold on top of Asthma is a good day. You can say oh well next month I maybe better other lung conditions are facing next month I will be worse today maybe my last chance.

I know, my neighbour had COPD. It didn't sound like this woman was in such a case, though - but my neighbour was at the stage of needing breathing equipment with her a lot of the time. Would that only be late-stage?

But honestly I wouldn't go to a cinema if I had such chronic lung illness. Apart from spoiling it for everyone else, I wouldn't enjoy sitting in a crowded cinema coughing my lungs out, not getting anything out of the film, and probably being more tired and stressed at the end of it.

jannier · 16/09/2023 12:34

Catsmere · 16/09/2023 06:24

The fact this woman had no strategy in place (such as using huffs) has me believing she's just someone with a chest infection who doesn't give a shit.

I agree, @ChristmasFluff . I'm asthmatic and currently have a post-viral cough that's lasted three times as long as the damn cold - and it's nothing like asthmatic wheezing or shortness of breath or a real asthma attack, it's gunge on the chest that takes a hell of a hard cough to shift, and no way would I go to a cinema like this! I'm baffled this woman bothered - how much did she even get out of the film?

Some illnesses leave lungs becoming more and more congested that's why they are life limiting COPD has that gunge continually building so the feeling you get after a cold on top of Asthma is a good day. You can say oh well next month I maybe better other lung conditions are facing next month I will be worse today maybe my last chance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread