Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Coughing lady at the movies

157 replies

HibiscusAndPineapples · 15/09/2023 14:52

Went to the cinema to watch a film, and the lady seated behind me spent the better part of the entire runtime coughing. It wasn’t just muffled coughs here and there either, but full on, loud, non-stop coughing.

Any quiet/tense moment in the film was completely ruined by loud coughing.

AIBU to think that anyone with a cough as loud and relentless as this should just stay away from the cinema?

OP posts:
TorqueWrench · 17/09/2023 14:05

LittlePudding1 · 15/09/2023 17:31

These patronising comments where the poster is trying to be "clever" are just annoying and wankish!!

You are right to be annoyed OP, it's selfish behaviour.

Indeed. Candidates for the mumsnet passive aggressive thread.

fairyfluf · 17/09/2023 13:28

ZadocPDederick · 17/09/2023 07:46

She should stay away out of normal human consideration. Having a chronic illness doesn't entitle you to spoil several other people's entertainment that they've paid quite a lot for. It's not fair on everyone else, and it's highly unlikely that she wouldn't be able to watch the film at home.

Thats so othering

fairyfluf · 17/09/2023 13:26

Frances0911 · 17/09/2023 13:22

I can't honestly think of any reason why someone would go to a cinema if they had a bad cough.

Absolutely selfish and ignorant behavior. Not only from a health aspect, but they are also spoiling the enjoyment of others, who have paid good money to watch a film.

To watch a film?

Frances0911 · 17/09/2023 13:22

I can't honestly think of any reason why someone would go to a cinema if they had a bad cough.

Absolutely selfish and ignorant behavior. Not only from a health aspect, but they are also spoiling the enjoyment of others, who have paid good money to watch a film.

Lifeinlists · 17/09/2023 13:17

@Floogal
That took me back to my first lecture where several students got their fag packets out and started smoking!! The lecturer said nothing. I was Shock

It didn't happen often but was allowed in those neolithic days.
Perhaps they developed smokers coughs and never ventured out again.
Or perhaps that's who was in the cinema!

Floogal · 17/09/2023 12:28

Cazziebo · 17/09/2023 08:59

I am asthmatic and prone to coughing. I tend to keep away from anywhere public (especially since Covid years when a slight ahem brings dirty looks!).

When I was at university, one lecturer would throw coughers out of lectures. There was hardly any coughing after that.

Good on your lecturer. So distracting - along with constant whispering (I have ASD). Used to record the lecture on dictaphone, and you could hear it drown out the actual lecture. Phlegm chorus I used to call it. Funny how people weren't coughing so much before and after the actual lecture

Cazziebo · 17/09/2023 08:59

I am asthmatic and prone to coughing. I tend to keep away from anywhere public (especially since Covid years when a slight ahem brings dirty looks!).

When I was at university, one lecturer would throw coughers out of lectures. There was hardly any coughing after that.

Fab973 · 17/09/2023 08:42

Why didn’t you just move seats?

Jk987 · 17/09/2023 08:40

I've had an awful cough for a while and there's no way I'd be going to the cinema.

Ohthatsabitshit · 17/09/2023 08:32

ZadocPDederick · 17/09/2023 07:58

At the very least he could have stood away from other people so that he would minimise both the risk of infection and the nuisance factor. And deep sniffs are always avoidable. If other parents can't hear the presentation because of the noise you are making, you are being very inconsiderate to the teachers who have taken the trouble to put it on.

Just to clear something up “deep sniffs” are NOT always avoidable, they’re one of THE most common tics and school is THE most common time to get them.

xyz111 · 17/09/2023 08:27

HappiDaze · 17/09/2023 04:54

I get annoyed if I hear someone even breathe at the cinema let alone rustle their snacks or cough throughout the whole film.

I find the snacks thing so unbelievably annoying I rarely go to the cinema now

I did go to see Barbie and of course the silly cow behind me was rustling her snacks non stop during the ads beforehand

I politely, because it gives me the absolute rage, said I hoped she would stop when the film started. I can't remember how I worded it but it was ok not patronising or condescending.

Her and her partner started to have a go because obviously they found me completely annoying by saying anything. Fair enough. But then they stopped and didn't snack throughout the whole film. They probably decided I was a bit of a nutter. I do get the rage though with rustling in cinemas. I'm probably on the spectrum

YABU if it was just in the ads. They're the worst part about going to the cinema

MaidOfSteel · 17/09/2023 07:58

I have a near permanent cough despite numerous medications, natural remedies, medical tests etc. If I couldn't go out in public until the cough goes away, I'd never leave the house again. I always have a drink, cough sweet or the like with me, to try & minimise it.

YABVU. I'd tell you to move if you made it clear I was getting on your nerves.

ZadocPDederick · 17/09/2023 07:58

jannier · 16/09/2023 21:40

How do you think he felt? I know with my sister she's mortified and even with family keeps apologising but short of end things there is nothing she can do. Would you suggest if it's a long term thing he misses every event for his child? If he was shouting obscenities would you say he shouldn't be there too? What if he's incontinent and smells is that an issue too?

At the very least he could have stood away from other people so that he would minimise both the risk of infection and the nuisance factor. And deep sniffs are always avoidable. If other parents can't hear the presentation because of the noise you are making, you are being very inconsiderate to the teachers who have taken the trouble to put it on.

ZadocPDederick · 17/09/2023 07:51

fairyfluf · 15/09/2023 19:02

If you don't like the public doing things humans do with no control over then don't go out in public

Why do people with coughs have no control over whether they go to the cinema?

ZadocPDederick · 17/09/2023 07:46

fairyfluf · 15/09/2023 18:03

If she has a chronic health condition that gives her a cough are you saying she should be banned?

She should stay away out of normal human consideration. Having a chronic illness doesn't entitle you to spoil several other people's entertainment that they've paid quite a lot for. It's not fair on everyone else, and it's highly unlikely that she wouldn't be able to watch the film at home.

HappiDaze · 17/09/2023 04:54

I get annoyed if I hear someone even breathe at the cinema let alone rustle their snacks or cough throughout the whole film.

I find the snacks thing so unbelievably annoying I rarely go to the cinema now

I did go to see Barbie and of course the silly cow behind me was rustling her snacks non stop during the ads beforehand

I politely, because it gives me the absolute rage, said I hoped she would stop when the film started. I can't remember how I worded it but it was ok not patronising or condescending.

Her and her partner started to have a go because obviously they found me completely annoying by saying anything. Fair enough. But then they stopped and didn't snack throughout the whole film. They probably decided I was a bit of a nutter. I do get the rage though with rustling in cinemas. I'm probably on the spectrum

Tourmalines · 16/09/2023 23:27

jannier · 16/09/2023 19:29

So nice I guess you ignored every post and don't give a shit about disability as long as you're not inconvenienced

Pot kettle black

Catsmere · 16/09/2023 22:48

jannier · 16/09/2023 19:21

With respect, your saying you wouldn't go somewhere with this condition but don't you think when you are facing the end of your life you might prefer to try and go out and enjoy as much life as you can rather than sit in your chair waiting to die? Because quiet frankly what would be the pleasure in living like that....you have to remember back to lockdown when you were allowed at least to go for a walk and out to buy food....most struggled with that limit on freedom but people with chronic illness went into lockdown earlier and came out later during that time they didn't go shopping or walking and lost all contact with people why would they want to go back into that just to avoid coughing in public?
The policy of oxygen at home is much more complicated now than it used to be as our nebulisers so you can't say because someone doesn't have O2 they are not as ill. My sister has COPD and thoracic cancer (non smoker) where the biopsy had to be done while she was awake and damaged her oesophagus, needs a heart bypass and also has 3 types of arthritis and is wheelchair bound and under Palliative care she's been out for shopping (the supermarket) twice since end of lockdown and found it an amazing treat to actually choose her own food from a shelf. We've managed a meal around 10 times (yes coughing badly) if I can get her out I will if people don't like it shame on them.

No, I didn't say I wouldn't go out at all - I said I wouldn't go to a cinema. Going to shops or places of interest or parks and the like isn't the same as going to a place where there's an expectation of being quiet for the others in the audience who have also paid to see and listen to the film. I certainly wouldn't suggest, and am not suggesting for anyone else, not going out in general with a chronic cough.

I don't know if the policies about breathing equipment in Britain bear any resemblance to those in Australia, I was only wondering about the stages of the illness. I'm sorry about your sister - one thing I have had a glimpse of from my neighbour is how awful this illness is.

jannier · 16/09/2023 22:03

Lifeinlists · 16/09/2023 21:57

There's more than blurred lines between public and private space nowadays. Many people just behave as they would at home and sod everyone else.
Theatres, cinemas, concert halls, parents' meetings etc.

Doesn't sound like Captain Cattarh was either mortified or apologetic @jannier. Just insensitive and thoughtless.

I'm sorry but how do you know what he was feeling or was he supposed to say sorry sorry sorry or shuffle off into a box ....only he knows why he's coughing it's wrong to assume he's just an ignorant bug spreader. Chronic illness can sound like Cattarh is it fair to make a mockery of him by name calling? My sister's is so bad you would think she's going to vomit I can imagine what names you would be calling her.

Lifeinlists · 16/09/2023 21:57

There's more than blurred lines between public and private space nowadays. Many people just behave as they would at home and sod everyone else.
Theatres, cinemas, concert halls, parents' meetings etc.

Doesn't sound like Captain Cattarh was either mortified or apologetic @jannier. Just insensitive and thoughtless.

jannier · 16/09/2023 21:40

QuizzlyBear · 16/09/2023 21:22

At a parent's evening presentation at DS's school last week I had a man in the seat behind I named Captain Catarrh. Nonstop thick snot noises, clearing his throat / chest, rattling cough, deep sniffs and thick, cacky coughing.

I could feel his hot breath on my neck every time. 🤢

Not sure if I felt this completely grossed out pre-Covid, but now it made me feel both sick and like running away.

How do you think he felt? I know with my sister she's mortified and even with family keeps apologising but short of end things there is nothing she can do. Would you suggest if it's a long term thing he misses every event for his child? If he was shouting obscenities would you say he shouldn't be there too? What if he's incontinent and smells is that an issue too?

QuizzlyBear · 16/09/2023 21:22

At a parent's evening presentation at DS's school last week I had a man in the seat behind I named Captain Catarrh. Nonstop thick snot noises, clearing his throat / chest, rattling cough, deep sniffs and thick, cacky coughing.

I could feel his hot breath on my neck every time. 🤢

Not sure if I felt this completely grossed out pre-Covid, but now it made me feel both sick and like running away.

jannier · 16/09/2023 21:12

jonnyjanetkeogh · 16/09/2023 20:17

@jannier I have appreciated every single thing you've said on here and I'm sorry to hear you and your family are experiencing this. You're right too that there's an assumption that COPD is a smoker's illness, I can imagine that must be another blow to deal with when you haven't smoked a day in your life.
Sending you love and to your sister too.

Thank you.
I wish people would stop and think that this could be me next week what would I want?

jannier · 16/09/2023 21:10

MartinChuzzlewit · 16/09/2023 21:02

I agree that cinemas cost (a lot!!!) of money and that people going should have basic manners - I’m afraid “I can’t help it” doesn’t cut the mustard.

I bet if it was a screaming baby people wouldn’t be whinging at you OP

Babies get nothing from seeing a film so it's not a reasonable comparison.
Manners have nothing to do with what could be a disability or chronic life limiting illness....babies grow up disabled and chronically ill don't get better today is the best chance to live a life that has already been cut short.

MartinChuzzlewit · 16/09/2023 21:02

I agree that cinemas cost (a lot!!!) of money and that people going should have basic manners - I’m afraid “I can’t help it” doesn’t cut the mustard.

I bet if it was a screaming baby people wouldn’t be whinging at you OP