Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Coughing lady at the movies

157 replies

HibiscusAndPineapples · 15/09/2023 14:52

Went to the cinema to watch a film, and the lady seated behind me spent the better part of the entire runtime coughing. It wasn’t just muffled coughs here and there either, but full on, loud, non-stop coughing.

Any quiet/tense moment in the film was completely ruined by loud coughing.

AIBU to think that anyone with a cough as loud and relentless as this should just stay away from the cinema?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
jannier · 18/09/2023 13:48

MartinChuzzlewit · 18/09/2023 13:16

Please don’t twist my words. I didn’t claim that - I won’t be responding to questions about things I didn’t say.

So if you can't think of any it goes back to with 1 in 5 having chronic lung disease the chance it high that at any showings someone will have a disease and at some point in your theater going life a few showings will be disrupted by coughing that is not a cold and is severe enough an episode to not allow that person to get up and leave because they are bent forward struggling to breathe once meds start to help the patient is exhausted and still can't go walking until recovered running down a flight of stairs in the dark is not possible

MartinChuzzlewit · 18/09/2023 13:16

jannier · 18/09/2023 12:59

Which condition does not cause coughing?

Please don’t twist my words. I didn’t claim that - I won’t be responding to questions about things I didn’t say.

jannier · 18/09/2023 12:59

MartinChuzzlewit · 18/09/2023 09:39

@jannier this doesn’t follow that 1 in 5 people have consistent and uncontrollable coughs

Which condition does not cause coughing?

housethatbuiltme · 18/09/2023 12:17

MartinChuzzlewit · 18/09/2023 09:24

This thread is bonkers. The likelihood is the woman just had a cough yet people are diagnosing her with a disability

12 MILLION people in the uk (thats 1 in 5 people) have a diagnosis of some form of lung disease... its really not far fetched to think in an entire cinema screen the one persons clearly struggling to breath properly is likely one of the several in there with the disability.

jannier · 18/09/2023 10:58

Wanderingllama · 18/09/2023 10:46

....such a shame your dad isn't confident enough to fight for a full life maybe if he had been born disabled he would be keener to fight.
Confused no he still wouldn't be fucking threatening legal action because a standard hiking group refused to go 1mile an hour speed and told him he can't go with them! So ridiculous what you written. Fucking patronising bs.

I hope he does have the best quality of life he can get but I'm not willing to shove any of my family into a keep out of sight box this is the one life we all have no matter how we are born
He is dead. Thought that would have been obvious from the past tense used. Yes he lived best quality if life without forcing others to lower theirs. He hiked himself or with family and friends, went fishing, travelled spent lots of time out and about etc.

Having to amend your life around your abilities and use more suited groups/screenings/activities is not shoving people into out of sight boxes. There is difference between "confidence to fight" for good quality of life and entitlement of "I come before everyone and if you are not happy you are discriminating". You are in the latter group.

Edited

I was born into a disabled family things have got better over 60 years thanks to disabled people fighting not rolling over I'm still caring for a brain injured brother, 2 with lung issues (plus me) one of which also has my mother's physical disabilities and cancer alongside her son who has ASD every time I take any one of them out we are obstructed from things you would take for granted last week it was a disabled toilet a shop refused access to the other user left to go home I fought for both of them the toilet is now accessible again did the poor lady who went home achieve that?
I'm not saying he should have forced others to wait for him but he should be allowed into the group and to walk with his carers at his own pace to join up at the end for a social gathering etc. Not just told to go away....generally when you join a group some will carry on and do their thing others will chat and take breaks with you up to them when you start your the only one ten after a while other members bring their disabled friends or family and you have company. You may not follow the same route that doesn't matter you do what you can. I've taken my sister sailing she loved it.

Wanderingllama · 18/09/2023 10:46

....such a shame your dad isn't confident enough to fight for a full life maybe if he had been born disabled he would be keener to fight.
Confused no he still wouldn't be fucking threatening legal action because a standard hiking group refused to go 1mile an hour speed and told him he can't go with them! So ridiculous what you written. Fucking patronising bs.

I hope he does have the best quality of life he can get but I'm not willing to shove any of my family into a keep out of sight box this is the one life we all have no matter how we are born
He is dead. Thought that would have been obvious from the past tense used. Yes he lived best quality if life without forcing others to lower theirs. He hiked himself or with family and friends, went fishing, travelled spent lots of time out and about etc.

Having to amend your life around your abilities and use more suited groups/screenings/activities is not shoving people into out of sight boxes. There is difference between "confidence to fight" for good quality of life and entitlement of "I come before everyone and if you are not happy you are discriminating". You are in the latter group.

jannier · 18/09/2023 10:31

Wanderingllama · 18/09/2023 10:02

Him insisting to be in activity which was not suitable would affect enjoyment of others and it would be a hight of entitlement. And the group would absolute chuck him out before the second hike.
Him finding suitable group would be the logical solution, yes.

Same way like someone who cannot help making loud noise or moving around has an option of autism friendly screenings in a cinema which allow noise, moving around etc...

If a group throws him out he can take legal action he chooses not to. If a cinema bans someone from a performance they can take legal action. ....autism friendly are higher light levels and lower noise they are not designed for all audiences and it does not mean people with ASD cannot attend a normal screening it is just a specially adapted screening for those who feel that is what they need as a disabled person to see a firm....not a dump all the annoying disabled into a holding pen for the convenience of the able bodied ....if people are thinking that is shows how far disability rights still have to go and the ignorance of the fit and well....such a shame your dad isn't confident enough to fight for a full life maybe if he had been born disabled he would be keener to fight. I hope he does have the best quality of life he can get but I'm not willing to shove any of my family into a keep out of sight box this is the one life we all have no matter how we are born

Wanderingllama · 18/09/2023 10:02

Him insisting to be in activity which was not suitable would affect enjoyment of others and it would be a hight of entitlement. And the group would absolute chuck him out before the second hike.
Him finding suitable group would be the logical solution, yes.

Same way like someone who cannot help making loud noise or moving around has an option of autism friendly screenings in a cinema which allow noise, moving around etc...

jannier · 18/09/2023 09:48

Wanderingllama · 18/09/2023 09:22

My father had heart disease impacting on his life and recieving full disability card. He liked nature but didn't join hiking group and making everyone go slow and rest every 15 min. Not everyone can do everything.

Sometimes people have to give up some things. Essentially everyone does actually at some point of their life. I don't know how not making loud and continous noise at cinrma morphed into disabled people being banned from shops. Confused I am assuming But olympics competition here.

It's not social rules stopping him joining a hiking group it is his own physical condition and attitude he can walk short distances without stopping only so he could join a wheelchair group or go hiking with support he decides not to nobody is stopping him by saying he is a pain in their arse. That is the difference. Many places have trampers for you to use such as the national trust properties.
Being thrown out because you have Touretts or any other disability is not the same and not the disabled person's choice to give something up. If you try taking a disabled person out you soon realise they are effectively banned from restaurants, public transport, shops, cinemas etc and have to go elsewhere. I'd say from every 3 shops there will be at least 1 where you can't get around in a wheelchair

MartinChuzzlewit · 18/09/2023 09:39

@jannier this doesn’t follow that 1 in 5 people have consistent and uncontrollable coughs

jannier · 18/09/2023 09:34

MartinChuzzlewit · 18/09/2023 09:24

This thread is bonkers. The likelihood is the woman just had a cough yet people are diagnosing her with a disability

Respiratory disease as opposed to colds and illness affects 1 in 5 of the population so if there are 30 in a cinema 6 will have some form of Lung disease so how can you say the chances are it isn't?

MartinChuzzlewit · 18/09/2023 09:25

Gingerwarthog · 17/09/2023 20:50

Poor woman behind us in pub the other night had a sneezing fit that lasted ages followed by blowing her nose etc. That didn't bother me - her husband constantly picking his teeth with his fingers did!

Pubs aren’t supposed to be quiet though

MartinChuzzlewit · 18/09/2023 09:24

This thread is bonkers. The likelihood is the woman just had a cough yet people are diagnosing her with a disability

Wanderingllama · 18/09/2023 09:22

jannier · 18/09/2023 09:12

So disabled barred from cinemas and theaters, buses and shops at rush hour, hey I know why not just put them in homes. I guess you have no experience of disability YET

My father had heart disease impacting on his life and recieving full disability card. He liked nature but didn't join hiking group and making everyone go slow and rest every 15 min. Not everyone can do everything.

Sometimes people have to give up some things. Essentially everyone does actually at some point of their life. I don't know how not making loud and continous noise at cinrma morphed into disabled people being banned from shops. Confused I am assuming But olympics competition here.

jannier · 18/09/2023 09:15

LastHives · 17/09/2023 16:46

One time I was at the cinema and a person was shouting out "no. no. no. no " or "yes,yes,yes, yes" all the time. It was a very quiet film "Suffragette" and it did spoil it as we could barely hear the soundtrack. Several people must have complained as someone came in and spoke to who I assume was a carer. They eventually left.

I hope they complained to the management for breaking the law.

jannier · 18/09/2023 09:12

Wanderingllama · 17/09/2023 18:37

This is why cinemas and theaters will die off. Because keeping to simple "silent so everyone can enjoy" is too much to ask and met with "but what about".
There is a timr and placr and not all times and places are suitable fot everyone.
So us who actually want to enjoy the performance or movie should just sit at home...ok. Lots of us started. So did closures

So disabled barred from cinemas and theaters, buses and shops at rush hour, hey I know why not just put them in homes. I guess you have no experience of disability YET

Gingerwarthog · 17/09/2023 20:50

Poor woman behind us in pub the other night had a sneezing fit that lasted ages followed by blowing her nose etc. That didn't bother me - her husband constantly picking his teeth with his fingers did!

suitcasecoveredincathair · 17/09/2023 20:33

Remember we are pretty much the only minority you can unwillfully join at anytime... and almost everyone eventually does.

Yeah @housethatbuiltme I didn’t want to say that but I was diagnosed with cough variant asthma in my 40s and it has rapidly got worse. Last winter I could barely go out in public because of it. And I could hardly breathe either.

These people going on about coughing and germs and “clearly being ill” had better watch out, it could happen to anyone.

Wanderingllama · 17/09/2023 18:37

This is why cinemas and theaters will die off. Because keeping to simple "silent so everyone can enjoy" is too much to ask and met with "but what about".
There is a timr and placr and not all times and places are suitable fot everyone.
So us who actually want to enjoy the performance or movie should just sit at home...ok. Lots of us started. So did closures

housethatbuiltme · 17/09/2023 18:26

Why do able people think their 'offense', 'dislike' or 'irritation' at disability side effects should remove the disabled persons rights?

No one gives a fuck what you personally 'like' or 'dislike'. Or if you deem disability as 'rude' or 'mannerless', no we don't have to constantly apologist and act mortified just for existing.

I was in HOSPITAL once when some bitch had a go at me about how the noise of my foot dragging from my limp was rude and 'mannerless'... the only mannerless person was the twat picking on a disabled person.

Like why does she think her 'dislike' of shuffling come above me just minding my buisiness and living my life. She is/was not the center of the universe and neither are PP who think their 'comfort' is all that matters.

If I could just 'pick up my feet' don't they think I fucking would? its ME that has to constantly buy new shoes and is covered in scars from falling and hurting myself, I dont do it for 'laziness'.

Remember we are pretty much the only minority you can unwillfully join at anytime... and almost everyone eventually does.

As for the person telling other cinema goes off for eating... the cinema makes the majority of its income selling food and drink. Maybe try supporting the cinema so its actually still there in future rather than thinking your 'dislike' for something takes priority over the business and everyone else.

jannier · 17/09/2023 17:40

LastHives · 17/09/2023 16:37

I've read some outlandish things on MN but think this may take the biscuit. As usual things are taken to extremes as opposed to the normal irritating people in cinemas.

No it describes my sister very well she has COPD and cancer as well as being in a wheelchair due to crippling arthritis I take her to cinemas and she coughs get over it.
There are many people in this world with chronic disease that means coughing there are many ignorant people who don't give a shit

LastHives · 17/09/2023 16:46

One time I was at the cinema and a person was shouting out "no. no. no. no " or "yes,yes,yes, yes" all the time. It was a very quiet film "Suffragette" and it did spoil it as we could barely hear the soundtrack. Several people must have complained as someone came in and spoke to who I assume was a carer. They eventually left.

MartinChuzzlewit · 17/09/2023 16:43

Why do people think that just because someone has a noisy condition that they must be upset or mortified about it? Why can’t they be a person who doesn’t give a shit about how it impacts others?

I worked with a man who had bronchitis who would spend ALL DAY hocking up and making revolting sounds and he openly took delight in making people feel sick. I though he could at least have, a few times, left the office to do his worst cough

Going to the cinema is not a god given right. It’s inconsiderate as fuck to go and make noise and make no effort to be away from others

LastHives · 17/09/2023 16:37

jannier · 17/09/2023 16:34

As discussed because they are disabled and dying and it's on their bucket list

I've read some outlandish things on MN but think this may take the biscuit. As usual things are taken to extremes as opposed to the normal irritating people in cinemas.

jannier · 17/09/2023 16:34

Frances0911 · 17/09/2023 13:22

I can't honestly think of any reason why someone would go to a cinema if they had a bad cough.

Absolutely selfish and ignorant behavior. Not only from a health aspect, but they are also spoiling the enjoyment of others, who have paid good money to watch a film.

As discussed because they are disabled and dying and it's on their bucket list

Swipe left for the next trending thread