Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Please help me understand these bloody car seats!!!

32 replies

lookingforanswrra · 15/09/2023 13:12

https://www.johnlewis.com/joie-baby-i-spin-360-i-size-car-seat/p4071189

https://www.johnlewis.com/joie-baby-i-spin-safe-i-size-car-seat-coal/p5499712

why is one so much more expensive? I’m losing the will to live.

OP posts:
ShirleyPhallus · 15/09/2023 13:22

BertieBotts · 15/09/2023 13:17

They are basically identical - the i-Spin Safe is the rear facing only version, whereas the i-Spin 360 can be spun 360 degrees (forward facing or rear facing)

The rear facing only version has passed the Swedish plus test which is a test that measures neck loading and is supposedly a guarantee that the seat will protect a child from serious injury. Most of the time when you have a RF only and RF/FF version of spin seats, they are the same, the RF only one just doesn't have the slot to allow it to lock into place FF. However the Joie does have a slightly different shaped headrest, which I assume means that they had to make some changes to the design to get it to pass the plus test.

Which means that, the usual logic that a RF/FF version of a RF only seat is just as safe as the RF only version if you use it RF only, may not apply to these two models.

The Spin Safe isn't popular in the UK because only a very tiny portion of consumers care about the plus test or even know what it is, and most of them tend to buy 25kg limit seats like the Axkid Minikid anyway. So it remains an import seat and that's why it's expensive. Whereas the 360 versions of the Joie spin seats are extremely popular, because they offer premium features (spin, isofix, ERF up to 18kg) for a budget price. And Joie trade on price so they are frequently discounted. The Spin Safe is not so frequently discounted as it is not frequently stocked.

Your third link is the same seat as the first link, in a different colour.

What an amazingly informative response

BertieBotts · 15/09/2023 13:20

Um, no, the Joie seats are not minimally tested. The i-Spin 360 is one of the better scoring seats on the ADAC test, and the i-Spin Safe is Swedish Plus tested.

Confused

They are usually not the best option if you want to RF for a long time, because you can get much longer lasting ERF seats and also the leg room in the Joie spin seats is extremely limited, but they are decent options in terms of safety.

lookingforanswrra · 15/09/2023 13:20

@BertieBotts thanks. What actually is the best car seat for safety then? Do
you happen to know? Not bothered about money on this as want it to be safe. Thank you!!

OP posts:
OP posts:
BertieBotts · 15/09/2023 13:17

They are basically identical - the i-Spin Safe is the rear facing only version, whereas the i-Spin 360 can be spun 360 degrees (forward facing or rear facing)

The rear facing only version has passed the Swedish plus test which is a test that measures neck loading and is supposedly a guarantee that the seat will protect a child from serious injury. Most of the time when you have a RF only and RF/FF version of spin seats, they are the same, the RF only one just doesn't have the slot to allow it to lock into place FF. However the Joie does have a slightly different shaped headrest, which I assume means that they had to make some changes to the design to get it to pass the plus test.

Which means that, the usual logic that a RF/FF version of a RF only seat is just as safe as the RF only version if you use it RF only, may not apply to these two models.

The Spin Safe isn't popular in the UK because only a very tiny portion of consumers care about the plus test or even know what it is, and most of them tend to buy 25kg limit seats like the Axkid Minikid anyway. So it remains an import seat and that's why it's expensive. Whereas the 360 versions of the Joie spin seats are extremely popular, because they offer premium features (spin, isofix, ERF up to 18kg) for a budget price. And Joie trade on price so they are frequently discounted. The Spin Safe is not so frequently discounted as it is not frequently stocked.

Your third link is the same seat as the first link, in a different colour.

TheBarbieEffect · 15/09/2023 13:14

They’re all a waste of money and minimally tested.

360 spin seats do not give a good fit, especially for young babies. They’re big, bulky and become harder to put child in and out of as they get older.

The safest option is to fully max out your infant carrier then go straight to a Swedish plus tested ERF seat.

lookingforanswrra · 15/09/2023 13:12

This one also looks identical?!

https://www.johnlewis.com/joie-baby-i-spin-360-i-size-car-seat-cycle-shell-grey/p109964151

OP posts: