Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should my colleague help or am I being racist?

140 replies

madamreign · 15/09/2023 12:40

We have a new hire. She is very experienced and qualified, but she is from overseas and is struggling. English is not her first language and I'm in awe of anybody who can do a professional job in a second language. If we can get her over her problems (confidence, communication, ways of working etc) she'll be a really asset to the business.

I'm trying my best to listen, understand and help her settle in. Taking cues from her on how to deal with this- I want to her to succeed!

I have a colleague who was born in the UK but who's parents came from the same country that our new hire did. I know they speak the language.

Would it be wrong to request that my colleague to help the new hire?

OP posts:
SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 15/09/2023 21:43

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 19:02

@SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs

You have no words because you want people to do free work for you??

did you learn nothing from the BLM movement?? Of course not. It suits you to exploit people of colour and language skills that you dont possess yourself

🙄 You really don't see how extreme and ridiculous you are, do you?

JudgeRudy · 15/09/2023 21:22

It wouldn't be wrong to ask but it would be wrong to expect. If they're not keen don't press or even ask why not.
Whilst I understand you're keen to help, sometimes full immersion in a new culture is the best way to acclimatise rather than seeking out the familiar. Just because it's difficult don't assume the new person isn't thriving on the challenge.

inamarina · 15/09/2023 21:04

BrideNovToBe · 15/09/2023 20:59

I agree PP have been aggressive, but I think it's something that's not quite clear tbh.
Perhaps 'race' makes sense, but when you consider it in the light of any other protected characteristic. Only woman in an all-male team, asking them to mentor a new female hire because they are female? That is extra work that the men don't have to do. Now obviously people agree that you can learn from each other based on this characteristic, there are women's group, mentorship circles etc but to impose it on someone solely because of that doesn't sit right with me.

I think the difficulty here stems from something that someone should do based on a non-professionally related characteristic and the fact that it might be hard to say no. Helping clients is OK, in fact it improves your own job performance but helping a peer, especially when there are significant performance issues is fraught rather than just simply making them feel 'more' welcome.

As you said asking if they 'might' be able to help is OK, provided OP makes it very clear that colleague can say no, or even stop at any time, is clear about what they will be expected to do and that they are perfectly blameless regardless of what happens.

Edited

As you said asking if they 'might' be able to help is OK, provided OP makes it very clear that colleague can say no, or even stop at any time, is clear about what they will be expected to do and that they are perfectly blameless regardless of what happens.

That sounds like a very reasonable approach 🙂

Justcallmebebes · 15/09/2023 21:02

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 17:20

Do not do this!! Yes it is racist. Are you her manager? If not, do not get involved. If you are, ask the new hire what she wants to encourage her to ask for help where she feels she can get it best.

It really isn't

BrideNovToBe · 15/09/2023 20:59

inamarina · 15/09/2023 20:52

I agree with your post.
Of course the extent of the required help is important, and also whether the colleague has the time to take on additional tasks, how they would be compensated and how comfortable they would feel (maybe they’re not particularly sociable and would struggle with having to be the new recruit‘s ‚buddy‘). All these things need to be considered.
What I don’t agree with is to automatically call it racist to even consider whether the colleague might be able to help based on their cultural background.

I agree PP have been aggressive, but I think it's something that's not quite clear tbh.
Perhaps 'race' makes sense, but when you consider it in the light of any other protected characteristic. Only woman in an all-male team, asking them to mentor a new female hire because they are female? That is extra work that the men don't have to do. Now obviously people agree that you can learn from each other based on this characteristic, there are women's group, mentorship circles etc but to impose it on someone solely because of that doesn't sit right with me.

I think the difficulty here stems from something that someone should do based on a non-professionally related characteristic and the fact that it might be hard to say no. Helping clients is OK, in fact it improves your own job performance but helping a peer, especially when there are significant performance issues is fraught rather than just simply making them feel 'more' welcome.

As you said asking if they 'might' be able to help is OK, provided OP makes it very clear that colleague can say no, or even stop at any time, is clear about what they will be expected to do and that they are perfectly blameless regardless of what happens.

inamarina · 15/09/2023 20:52

BrideNovToBe · 15/09/2023 20:31

@JustFrustrated@moresleepthanks@inamarina
I don't think the idea of helping out it's the issue. It's the extent of help that's required.
'Settling in' to me means talking to people, making them feel welcome, in fact I've helped many people from my home country in a similar way. It does give you a nice feeling to speak to someone from a similar background, share tips on where to find our food, etc. I might even informally 'mentor' them on the way things work here, knowing that we have similar points of reference.

I'd baulk at a vague 'request to help' for 4 reasons:
a) What 'help' is required exactly? How much of my time is it going to take up?
b) Am I going to be held responsible if it doesn't improve things?
c) Having been asked, if it turns out that it's going to impact my own work how can I say no without sounding like a dick?
d) What would they have done without me? If they'd have paid a professional coach, then I'm just saving them money, aren't I?

It also does the colleague a disservice if she has performance issues she needs to be given proper assistance to succeed not 'side of desk'. PP also raised a good point that her issues may not necessarily be related to culture but also her personality. It's the manager's job to unpick all this and work out the best way forward, if OP has no clue and is 'guided by her' she can take advice from a HR professional expert in these things. Not foist it onto someone else.

Edited

I agree with your post.
Of course the extent of the required help is important, and also whether the colleague has the time to take on additional tasks, how they would be compensated and how comfortable they would feel (maybe they’re not particularly sociable and would struggle with having to be the new recruit‘s ‚buddy‘). All these things need to be considered.
What I don’t agree with is to automatically call it racist to even consider whether the colleague might be able to help based on their cultural background.

PeterssonnLndon · 15/09/2023 20:38

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Nanny0gg · 15/09/2023 20:38

Don't colleagues just help each other out any more?

Some of the actual horror at the thought!

I'm glad none of my workplaces were like that

inamarina · 15/09/2023 20:31

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 18:40

100% all of this!!!
This entire thread is racist too.
OP is not stating whether they are even the new hire's manager which means they are not, acting like a do-gooder and asking "am i racist" in their post. OP knows they are that's why theyre questioning it. Don't ask people to help others at work for FREE just because you "See" some similarities between them and want to pretend you're helping the company. Looks like a bonus opportunity is coming up for OP and they're excited to tell their own manager about their "good work" 🙄 I would put them under disciplinary action asap

Disciplinary action? Confused

BrideNovToBe · 15/09/2023 20:31

@JustFrustrated@moresleepthanks@inamarina
I don't think the idea of helping out it's the issue. It's the extent of help that's required.
'Settling in' to me means talking to people, making them feel welcome, in fact I've helped many people from my home country in a similar way. It does give you a nice feeling to speak to someone from a similar background, share tips on where to find our food, etc. I might even informally 'mentor' them on the way things work here, knowing that we have similar points of reference.

I'd baulk at a vague 'request to help' for 4 reasons:
a) What 'help' is required exactly? How much of my time is it going to take up?
b) Am I going to be held responsible if it doesn't improve things?
c) Having been asked, if it turns out that it's going to impact my own work how can I say no without sounding like a dick?
d) What would they have done without me? If they'd have paid a professional coach, then I'm just saving them money, aren't I?

It also does the colleague a disservice if she has performance issues she needs to be given proper assistance to succeed not 'side of desk'. PP also raised a good point that her issues may not necessarily be related to culture but also her personality. It's the manager's job to unpick all this and work out the best way forward, if OP has no clue and is 'guided by her' she can take advice from a HR professional expert in these things. Not foist it onto someone else.

inamarina · 15/09/2023 20:26

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 18:37

can you not read? i wrote You don’t get free work from people of colour based on their racial, cultural AND language skills. it applies across the board. you don't lump one new hire onto another employee because they both speak Spanish, that's friggin ridiculous. Calling my comment racist, are you actually that stupid? This entire thread is friggin racist. Stop asking people of colour and people with certain language skills to do FREE work.

i wrote You don’t get free work from people of colour based on their racial, cultural AND language skills.

Where are you getting the people of colour from? OP didn’t say where the new recruit was from and PP simply stated that they might as well be Polish or Spanish.
You might perceive her wondering whether she can ask her colleague for help as lumping people together based on their cultural background/ language skills, but others might disagree.
As already mentioned, I‘m an immigrant myself, and sorry, but I wouldn’t be offended if a colleague politely asked me for help with a new recruit from the same/ similar background as myself.
There is not only one correct way to see things.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 15/09/2023 20:12

Tandora · 15/09/2023 20:03

this has nothing to do with me. I’m not personally wounded by your comments, I just think you are being completely OTT.

Funny assumption being made here, that finding whyisitallsohard hard work means that you must be white.

Honest to cringe, some people's racism is so obsessive...

Wakintoblueskies · 15/09/2023 20:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

GodDammitCecil · 15/09/2023 20:11

I’m surprised by some of these responses.

The OP’s idea to support this new recruit is potentially going to inconvenience someone wholly unconnected with both the new recruit, and the OP.

The person being asked to help isn’t an interpreter, a translator, a member of HR, a mentor or a trainer.

I would feel awkward asking someone to do something like this that really is not part of their job, and will infringe on their time, and yes - this is an undercurrent of not racism exactly, but something uncomfortable - they’re not being asked because of their skills in this area, but purely because of their nationality. Again, it’s not racism, but I would be very wary of asking, and get why the OP is too, and is asking on here.

I’m not saying don’t ask.

But the person being asked would be doing the new recruit, the new recruit’s manager / OP and the organisation a massive favour.

So when asking, this should be recognised and acknowledged - especially as doing this will impact on that person’s ability to get on with their actual job. There should be something in it for the person being asked (beyond just feeling like a helpful person!).

Tandora · 15/09/2023 20:03

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 20:02

@Tandora

@whyisitallsohardyou are coming across as massively OTT. Disciplinary action? OP asked a question.
@Rubiconmango’s answer was much more helpful in explaining why this is the wrong idea.

i'm glad you're white fragility was spared.

this has nothing to do with me. I’m not personally wounded by your comments, I just think you are being completely OTT.

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 20:02

@Tandora

@whyisitallsohardyou are coming across as massively OTT. Disciplinary action? OP asked a question.
@Rubiconmango’s answer was much more helpful in explaining why this is the wrong idea.

i'm glad you're white fragility was spared.

inamarina · 15/09/2023 20:00

RamsesTheChub · 15/09/2023 17:29

So inclusion is now racist - Britain gone mad.

Exactly. OP is wondering what they could do to make the new recruit from overseas more comfortable, she’s not being racist fgs…
I‘m an immigrant myself and I wouldn’t want people to double and triple check themselves to make sure they don’t say the wrong thing before they talk to me.
OP, as others have suggested, I would ask your colleague if they would be willing to help out a bit if they have the time.

BrideNovToBe · 15/09/2023 19:58

Surely it depends on how badly her language use is impacting her job? And what exactly you mean by 'help her'? What do you want your colleague to do, help her translate things?
That's unfair on your colleague.

There are plenty of people from other countries who speak English well enough to have a working proficiency. If this woman doesn't then no matter how great she is technically, she's unfit for the role. If you're desperate to keep her pay for some business language courses (our company pays, for people going on secondments).

Btw I work in a very technical job but once that relies heavily on communication. it's hard enough communicating to English speakers, let alone a different language. If someone was great technically but struggled with language I'd let them go unfortunately and we are a shortage profession. Otherwise, they would create a huge mess.

Btw some things like communication and ways of working are unacceptable regardless of the reason for it. I had some colleagues for example who were extremely blunt to the point of rudeness. Culture, yes but the offended and upset a lot of other staff and despite being told repeatedly would not change so they had to go.

Every person working abroad, myself included knows that they have to adapt. it's part of the skillset. Even now I work with teams across 3 continents and we all adapt to meet halfway. If someone doesn't understand this sadly they're not suitable for an international role. I'm not sure how you came to hire her if her English is so bad.

katepilar · 15/09/2023 19:56

I dont think its racist. If this lady hasnt lived/worked in the UK before it could be a bit daunting. On the other hand she might be generally shy etc without any connection to her having a different cultural backround.

Blueblell · 15/09/2023 19:46

It is not racist! But it might create more work for your colleague, I would make sure she is on board with it first. However, it could be beneficial for both of them.

wizzywig · 15/09/2023 19:31

@Rubiconmango being nosy, where was she from?

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/09/2023 19:27

I don’t think it’s racist and I think it’s a good idea but I would absolutely check before you do it.

In a previous job we had a similar situation with a woman who was working freelance for us from a French speaking African country. Her English was very good but she had to speak to the media which she was (understandably) nervous about.

We got another bilingual colleague to help. It’s not so much speaking English as the cultural nuances of the role etc and it was very helpful.

But I would check and not presume

JustFrustrated · 15/09/2023 19:22

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 19:02

@SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs

You have no words because you want people to do free work for you??

did you learn nothing from the BLM movement?? Of course not. It suits you to exploit people of colour and language skills that you dont possess yourself

You're the one bringing POC into it.

moresleepthanks · 15/09/2023 19:18

Commonality of culture and language does not mean commonality beyond that,

This true. But that commonality itself can be massive particularly when you are not living in your home country.

I am honestly perplexed by the idea that it is unacceptable to try and help someone settle into a new country unless you are going to get paid for it.

I am very grateful for the people who supported us and did not take this mercenary transactional attitude.

Tandora · 15/09/2023 19:17

@whyisitallsohard you are coming across as massively OTT. Disciplinary action? OP asked a question.
@Rubiconmango ’s answer was much more helpful in explaining why this is the wrong idea.