Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should my colleague help or am I being racist?

140 replies

madamreign · 15/09/2023 12:40

We have a new hire. She is very experienced and qualified, but she is from overseas and is struggling. English is not her first language and I'm in awe of anybody who can do a professional job in a second language. If we can get her over her problems (confidence, communication, ways of working etc) she'll be a really asset to the business.

I'm trying my best to listen, understand and help her settle in. Taking cues from her on how to deal with this- I want to her to succeed!

I have a colleague who was born in the UK but who's parents came from the same country that our new hire did. I know they speak the language.

Would it be wrong to request that my colleague to help the new hire?

OP posts:
Roostercreek · 16/09/2023 10:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Care to define the legal definition of racism?

Roostercreek · 16/09/2023 10:43

GodDammitCecil · 16/09/2023 00:55

I honestly can’t believe you reported someone for using the term ‘white fragility’. The absolute irony - which you, of course, won’t get.

I’m white and I do not support your stance in the slightest.

So if you think there's nothing racist in that term, you'd better get onto admin, who certainly did see somethjng wrong with it. Just because you don't take offence to it, doesn't mean it's not an offensive label.

whyisitallsohard · 16/09/2023 10:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Roostercreek · 16/09/2023 10:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

inamarina · 16/09/2023 10:33

herewegoagainfriends · 16/09/2023 00:58

@madamreign You don't say what you do, but you suggest it's a professional role, so likely one with highly specialised jargon.

If someone speaks a certain language, it is a huge leap to assume they speak the right set of business language. I speak multiple foreign languages, but I couldn't do my day job in them, because I've never had the need to learn those words. I learnt them for the first time when I was being trained as an adult... in English.

At best, you run the risk of embarrassing someone by having to explain that no, they don't speak the language well enough to help (particularly embarrassing if it's their mother tongue) and at worst, you run the risk of offending them.

Is training someone within their usual responsibilities? Do they have enough time to train someone? Would you have to take work off them to free up their time? How does that fit with their development plan? Would you be sacrificing their own career goals to make life easier for you?

If someone was capable of helping and wanted to help, they'd be helping already.

It feels like you're demanding free labour from someone else because of their linguistic background, and with that so frequently tied up with culture... yeah, depending on the people involved, it could feel like racism.

You need to stop looking at this just from your intent and from the perspective of the person you would be asking. How would they see it? How would they feel?

At best, you run the risk of embarrassing someone by having to explain that no, they don't speak the language well enough to help (particularly embarrassing if it's their mother tongue) and at worst, you run the risk of offending them.

But why would it be embarrassing, unless the colleague was specifically hired because of those particular language skills?
They could just say ‚Sorry, but my knowledge of language X is pretty limited/ rusty/ not on a professional level’, why would that be an issue? I‘ve been in similar situations myself (been an immigrant most of my life), and that‘s exactly how I would respond.

Is training someone within their usual responsibilities? Do they have enough time to train someone? Would you have to take work off them to free up their time? How does that fit with their development plan? Would you be sacrificing their own career goals to make life easier for you?

The way I understood the OP it’s not about training/ full time mentoring as such, more about sitting down with the new recruit on one or two occasions to help her settle.

Of course they should have work taken off them to free up their time to do this. And if for whatever reason they don’t want to do it, they shouldn’t have to. I just don’t understand why even considering asking them is such a huge issue to some.

Regarding development plan and career goals - as PP said, do people never step out of their day-job to attend (endless boring) meetings, team announcements and so forth? I used to work in a pretty fast-paced environment with lots if deadlines and even there taking a bit of time out to talk to a colleague wouldn’t have affected a wider ‚career plan‘. People aren’t robots.

Sartre · 16/09/2023 10:06

Of course it isn’t racist. My Dad is French so if a French person started working with him, it wouldn’t be xenophobic of someone to ask him to help that person out.

They speak the same language, it just makes sense.

katepilar · 16/09/2023 09:36

I keep thinking what sort of help you have in mind? And whether it actually has the potential to help the new person, whether it is a matter of cultural settling in /which should happen in the window of about 3 months/ or whether it is a more of a personal issue without the cultural aspect. could be a mix of both as well.

RamsesTheChub · 16/09/2023 09:01

Yes, I'm confused why this is some sort of slave labour. It's a delicate issue in terms of offending the colleague but I don't know many jobs where you don't ever move out of your 'day-job' for the wider team/organisation/business. On those grounds I've a case to sue my employers for millions 😂

As for all the race-baiting, it's boring. No need to report someone talking about 'white fragility' and the behaviour of the resident "you're all racist" is probably the reason for the silly reaction. You're dealing with human beings, not robots. Grow up.

HairyKitty · 16/09/2023 04:53

OP it seems some people want to find racism in absolutely anything.

Language/translation is definitely not racism, particularly as it’s clear from your posts that you are not asking about cultural/racial or buddy/mentoring support.

Also, why are posters assuming that translating is more highly paid or skilled than the jobs the workers are already doing?

wombat1a · 16/09/2023 04:34

Absolutely ask the other person if they are willing to help if you need it. In our lab we often have people who are not 100% in English or the local language and use other lab members as ad hoc translators. The person being helped really really appreciates it as they have gone from not quite understanding to being felt like they are being included. We also found it tends to really improve their confidence to ask questions and also speeds up their learning/training.

Asking someone to translate is absolutely not racist, its inclusive.

herewegoagainfriends · 16/09/2023 00:58

@madamreign You don't say what you do, but you suggest it's a professional role, so likely one with highly specialised jargon.

If someone speaks a certain language, it is a huge leap to assume they speak the right set of business language. I speak multiple foreign languages, but I couldn't do my day job in them, because I've never had the need to learn those words. I learnt them for the first time when I was being trained as an adult... in English.

At best, you run the risk of embarrassing someone by having to explain that no, they don't speak the language well enough to help (particularly embarrassing if it's their mother tongue) and at worst, you run the risk of offending them.

Is training someone within their usual responsibilities? Do they have enough time to train someone? Would you have to take work off them to free up their time? How does that fit with their development plan? Would you be sacrificing their own career goals to make life easier for you?

If someone was capable of helping and wanted to help, they'd be helping already.

It feels like you're demanding free labour from someone else because of their linguistic background, and with that so frequently tied up with culture... yeah, depending on the people involved, it could feel like racism.

You need to stop looking at this just from your intent and from the perspective of the person you would be asking. How would they see it? How would they feel?

GodDammitCecil · 16/09/2023 00:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I honestly can’t believe you reported someone for using the term ‘white fragility’. The absolute irony - which you, of course, won’t get.

I’m white and I do not support your stance in the slightest.

Tandora · 16/09/2023 00:42

Tandora · 16/09/2023 00:40

Why are people of colour who explain racism automatically seen as “aggressive”

This is an anonymous internet forum. Nobody knew your colour until you pointed it out to them.
impressions of your words/ tone etc. have had nothing to do with judgements based on your colour / race, they have entirely been based on your written posts which are full of wild accusations/ judgements / assumptions, punctuated by excessive use of !!!! And ???? And assertions like OP should undergo disciplinary action, which most people think is absurd.

when all i am doing is just replying normally

you really aren’t.

there are massive amounts of projection going on here.

Oh and capitalisation of words and personal attacks like calling people “stupid”:

Tandora · 16/09/2023 00:40

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 23:24

Wow, you actually think I’m being aggressive?? Why are people of colour who explain racism automatically seen as “aggressive”. Why do responses have to be super duper nice and empathetic to you and your feelings when we ate the ones who deal with racism and asked to explain it , when all i am doing is just replying normally and you do nothing in responses to shared experiences of racism?? Why are you so fragile? Please Honestly, ask yourself that. Many of you on this thread in particular need a good education. Start here. Pretty Please. Less “aggressive” enough for you now??

Why are people of colour who explain racism automatically seen as “aggressive”

This is an anonymous internet forum. Nobody knew your colour until you pointed it out to them.
impressions of your words/ tone etc. have had nothing to do with judgements based on your colour / race, they have entirely been based on your written posts which are full of wild accusations/ judgements / assumptions, punctuated by excessive use of !!!! And ???? And assertions like OP should undergo disciplinary action, which most people think is absurd.

when all i am doing is just replying normally

you really aren’t.

there are massive amounts of projection going on here.

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 23:29

GirlOfTudor · 15/09/2023 22:56

"These colleagues OP is referring to are obviously people of colour and don’t share the same race as OP. How on earth would OP use the word “racist” otherwise???"

You do know that racism is more than just skin colour don't you?! 🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️

you just embarrassed yourself.

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 23:24

Wow, you actually think I’m being aggressive?? Why are people of colour who explain racism automatically seen as “aggressive”. Why do responses have to be super duper nice and empathetic to you and your feelings when we ate the ones who deal with racism and asked to explain it , when all i am doing is just replying normally and you do nothing in responses to shared experiences of racism?? Why are you so fragile? Please Honestly, ask yourself that. Many of you on this thread in particular need a good education. Start here. Pretty Please. Less “aggressive” enough for you now??

Coming to Terms With Racism’s Inertia: Ancestral Accountability | Rachel Cargle | TEDxBend

When it comes to race relations there is often the argument "Well I didnt own slaves" as a dismissive attempt to seperate onesself from the effects and reali...

https://youtu.be/VgufOtRq488?si=vMC8CQO-RGw-M0Cp

GirlOfTudor · 15/09/2023 22:56

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 21:55

Wow this thread is so utterly racist! It’s unbelievable and a good look into Britains work place today.

some of you asked and commented why am i bringing People of colour into this and why making it about race. Wow what a typical response.

it’s in the TITLE!!! OP themselves asked “am i being racist”. These colleagues OP is referring to are obviously people of colour and don’t share the same race as OP. How on earth would OP use the word “racist” otherwise???

honestly, OP. Please actually act on this at work. Please go ahead and approach your other colleague and see how it goes down and then let us know what happens. There’s your answer!!!

you know it’s wrong and came on here to create a debate and then have me telling you it’s racist explaining why and you have not bothered to correct other commenters who are assuming it’s someone “Polish or Spanish” as someone already said.

i am a person of colour and if you asked me this i would report you to HR. Especially if you weren’t my manager. If i owned a business i would take this seriously and have the entire company go through diversity training!

also, OP. Maybe you’re the only one with the language barrier problem. Maybe it’s you who doesn’t understand the new hire.

what a disgraceful country we live in. Mums net should be ashamed for deleting my comments when i am speaking from experience and MN is choosing to support racists on here instead.

"These colleagues OP is referring to are obviously people of colour and don’t share the same race as OP. How on earth would OP use the word “racist” otherwise???"

You do know that racism is more than just skin colour don't you?! 🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 22:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yes, there’s a book on it. You can write to the author who is also white and see where that goes.

GirlOfTudor · 15/09/2023 22:54

It would depend on whether the colleagues' roles are related at all and whether they'd both be comfortable with it.
Have you asked how the new colleague feels about her progress in her new role? Has she outwardly stated that she's struggling due to a language barrier? Or is this something that you're just assuming?
I assume that because your new colleague was offered the job, that her language skills are perfectly appropriate to her new job.
I'd recommend speaking with the new colleague first.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 15/09/2023 22:42

Wow this thread is so utterly racist!

So you keep saying ... if you really think so then report it, but maybe bear in mind that the only post that's been deleted is your own

Tandora · 15/09/2023 22:35

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 21:55

Wow this thread is so utterly racist! It’s unbelievable and a good look into Britains work place today.

some of you asked and commented why am i bringing People of colour into this and why making it about race. Wow what a typical response.

it’s in the TITLE!!! OP themselves asked “am i being racist”. These colleagues OP is referring to are obviously people of colour and don’t share the same race as OP. How on earth would OP use the word “racist” otherwise???

honestly, OP. Please actually act on this at work. Please go ahead and approach your other colleague and see how it goes down and then let us know what happens. There’s your answer!!!

you know it’s wrong and came on here to create a debate and then have me telling you it’s racist explaining why and you have not bothered to correct other commenters who are assuming it’s someone “Polish or Spanish” as someone already said.

i am a person of colour and if you asked me this i would report you to HR. Especially if you weren’t my manager. If i owned a business i would take this seriously and have the entire company go through diversity training!

also, OP. Maybe you’re the only one with the language barrier problem. Maybe it’s you who doesn’t understand the new hire.

what a disgraceful country we live in. Mums net should be ashamed for deleting my comments when i am speaking from experience and MN is choosing to support racists on here instead.

Please actually act on this at work. Please go ahead and approach your other colleague and see how it goes down and then let us know what happens

OP has already said, (twice? I believe) that she’s not going to do this, based on some helpful insight into why this would be a poor idea provided by another pp.

AnIndianWoman · 15/09/2023 22:11

If your new hire can’t follow instructions in English she isn’t great. Speaking English is a basic requirement for jobs in this country. Also some languages like Hindi / Gujarati etc have East African, West African, Caribbean and Indian dialects. And they can sound like totally different languages. Eg my mum and dad speak Ugandan Gujarati which is from the 1800s. We still use ancient words that fell out of use in India in the 1900s and to add to the complications we often add Swahili and English and Hindi words to the mix. Indians from India (like my husband’s family) often struggle to understand us.

So you can’t assume the other person can help

Example - the 1800s Gujarati word for stubborn used to be a metaphor that meant prawn as well. In India it just means prawn and the hindi word is used for stubborn as it’s considered more polite.

TheThingIsYeah · 15/09/2023 22:08

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 21:55

Wow this thread is so utterly racist! It’s unbelievable and a good look into Britains work place today.

some of you asked and commented why am i bringing People of colour into this and why making it about race. Wow what a typical response.

it’s in the TITLE!!! OP themselves asked “am i being racist”. These colleagues OP is referring to are obviously people of colour and don’t share the same race as OP. How on earth would OP use the word “racist” otherwise???

honestly, OP. Please actually act on this at work. Please go ahead and approach your other colleague and see how it goes down and then let us know what happens. There’s your answer!!!

you know it’s wrong and came on here to create a debate and then have me telling you it’s racist explaining why and you have not bothered to correct other commenters who are assuming it’s someone “Polish or Spanish” as someone already said.

i am a person of colour and if you asked me this i would report you to HR. Especially if you weren’t my manager. If i owned a business i would take this seriously and have the entire company go through diversity training!

also, OP. Maybe you’re the only one with the language barrier problem. Maybe it’s you who doesn’t understand the new hire.

what a disgraceful country we live in. Mums net should be ashamed for deleting my comments when i am speaking from experience and MN is choosing to support racists on here instead.

You must be a right barrel of laughs to work with.

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 21:55

Wow this thread is so utterly racist! It’s unbelievable and a good look into Britains work place today.

some of you asked and commented why am i bringing People of colour into this and why making it about race. Wow what a typical response.

it’s in the TITLE!!! OP themselves asked “am i being racist”. These colleagues OP is referring to are obviously people of colour and don’t share the same race as OP. How on earth would OP use the word “racist” otherwise???

honestly, OP. Please actually act on this at work. Please go ahead and approach your other colleague and see how it goes down and then let us know what happens. There’s your answer!!!

you know it’s wrong and came on here to create a debate and then have me telling you it’s racist explaining why and you have not bothered to correct other commenters who are assuming it’s someone “Polish or Spanish” as someone already said.

i am a person of colour and if you asked me this i would report you to HR. Especially if you weren’t my manager. If i owned a business i would take this seriously and have the entire company go through diversity training!

also, OP. Maybe you’re the only one with the language barrier problem. Maybe it’s you who doesn’t understand the new hire.

what a disgraceful country we live in. Mums net should be ashamed for deleting my comments when i am speaking from experience and MN is choosing to support racists on here instead.

Swipe left for the next trending thread