Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should my colleague help or am I being racist?

140 replies

madamreign · 15/09/2023 12:40

We have a new hire. She is very experienced and qualified, but she is from overseas and is struggling. English is not her first language and I'm in awe of anybody who can do a professional job in a second language. If we can get her over her problems (confidence, communication, ways of working etc) she'll be a really asset to the business.

I'm trying my best to listen, understand and help her settle in. Taking cues from her on how to deal with this- I want to her to succeed!

I have a colleague who was born in the UK but who's parents came from the same country that our new hire did. I know they speak the language.

Would it be wrong to request that my colleague to help the new hire?

OP posts:
Namechangedforthis25 · 16/09/2023 12:50

I’m British born but Asian. If done wrongly it would annoy me but is fine if done properly:

  1. the manager needs to do it - not another employee as that others
  2. It needs to be based on language not race or eg because their heritage is from the same part of the world eg India. If the language here was French it wouldn’t be an issue - so it must be about the language
  3. the manager needs to discuss with the second colleague first rather than assume or ask - ie it’s about collaboration rather than using authority
inamarina · 16/09/2023 12:48

Nanny0gg · 16/09/2023 12:44

Surely if there's no 'extra' workload, if they don't have to put in overtime to complete their work and there's no consequence to having to do this too then they are being paid?

Are jobs so regulated these days that you just do exactly what's in your contract and it has to be fitted in your contracted hours that there's no breathing space or room for initiative?

That’s what I‘ve been wondering too reading some of the replies.
Does every human interaction at a work place have to be regulated and specified in a contract?

Nanny0gg · 16/09/2023 12:44

Puzzledandpissedoff · 16/09/2023 12:37

funny how OP hasn't returned to clarify anything! ... how people like OP think it's okay to add (unpaid) labour onto others

Mistaken once again I'm afraid; OP did return to clarify - and I quote - "Nobody will be asked to work for free, that is unacceptable"

And it would be appreciated if you could stop damning people as an entire group, as in your latest deleted post. You'd quite rightly resent that if it was done about POC, so perhaps you could extend the same courtesy in avoiding it?

Surely if there's no 'extra' workload, if they don't have to put in overtime to complete their work and there's no consequence to having to do this too then they are being paid?

Are jobs so regulated these days that you just do exactly what's in your contract and it has to be fitted in your contracted hours that there's no breathing space or room for initiative?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 16/09/2023 12:44

In my workplace people are seen as people - each different! The differences between us are utilised in a positive way not used against us because we look or speak differently
Attitude is key!

Beautifully put, Therocksword; though retired now it's what I aimed for myself, and happily - apart from a couple of troublemakers who were swiftly got rid of - we seemed to avoid this kind of angst

boromu222 · 16/09/2023 12:37

Ponoka7 · 16/09/2023 11:21

It isn't racist as long as it is the norm to pull another staff member from their job to help a colleague struggling with the basics of the job. As long as the help given would be the same, trime, effort wise etc and the other person's work load adjusted without any effect on performance reviews, growth opportunities etc. If the firm would normally hire someone who didn't need help with a basic requirement or use staff training by a trainer, then it could be seen as a discriminatory work practice and indirect discrimination. Tbh the OP should have put this to HR and not the internet.

Even if it wasn't the norm, you haven't shown at all how it would be racist...rather than unfair, or inappropriate, etc.

Where is the racism? That entire scenario could play out with 2 white french speaking people.
Not everything bad that involves a POC is racism.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 16/09/2023 12:37

funny how OP hasn't returned to clarify anything! ... how people like OP think it's okay to add (unpaid) labour onto others

Mistaken once again I'm afraid; OP did return to clarify - and I quote - "Nobody will be asked to work for free, that is unacceptable"

And it would be appreciated if you could stop damning people as an entire group, as in your latest deleted post. You'd quite rightly resent that if it was done about POC, so perhaps you could extend the same courtesy in avoiding it?

FatandRoundBouncingontheGround · 16/09/2023 12:36

My niece and nephew were put in this position. They are at school in another country, of which they are citizens, but they are bilingual. A new family arrived speaking niece and nephew's minority language and they were paired up and asked to show them the ropes. Which they duly did, but having not much in common apart from a language, didn't become great friends. That was presumptuous and a bit annoying but we never thought of it as racist.

We also did this for a friend's new wife. He spent two years abroad and married a woman from that country. Her English was not great when they arrived back in the UK. I knew another person from her home country and put them in touch (with mutual permission). They are now absolute best friends, see each other all the time, and my friend's wife's whole experience of arriving in the UK would have been substantially lonelier without the bridge our mutual friend provided. Good job I didn't overthink the potential racism involved at the time.

whyisitallsohard · 16/09/2023 11:49

GodDammitCecil · 16/09/2023 11:03

White fragility is not racist.

When people of colour raise something they’re uncomfortable with, and white people go on the defensive and rush to get offended - instead of simply taking what they say on board, considering it and potentially changing their mind, or even just just disagreeing politely having genuinely considered it - THAT’S ‘white fragility’

This thread is littered with it. It’s embarrassing.

And yes, @madamreign - are you coming back to your thread….?

Mumsnet reinstated it. thanks for your support. I will use my life to fight every racist and microaggression where I can, even online. Have a great weekend ❤

RamsesTheChub · 16/09/2023 11:47

Ponoka7 · 16/09/2023 11:28

It would change the job title. It depends on the work contract and how performance reviews are done. How additional training candidates are selected etc. Teaching someone a language is a skill and the pay more than your average office work. It's great to utilise your staff but it has to be decided at the start and how that will impact on the helpers actual job and workload. It isn't the job the colleague took. What if they don't like each other?

Ok understood. Not sure if it really is outwith employment contract - like I said earlier I'd have grounds for many claims on that basis - but equally not being a party to the contract appreciate the point you're making.

I certainly agree with your (I think) previous post that said approach HR first. Best advice on the thread.

inamarina · 16/09/2023 11:35

Therocksword · 16/09/2023 11:27

I think you need to ask your colleague not putting any pressure on them.

In general I do not think it’s racist to ask the question.
Mentoring is common in my very multicultural workplace, quite often people of the same mother tongue are put together. It is always following discussion from both sides, some people that are trying to improve their English will request only English speaking mentorship, is that racist? Again I don’t believe it is - it’s no different to identifying a skill gap and making arrangements to bridge that gap.

I have certain skills that are often utilised for new hires, I don’t feel uncomfortable with that.

but then in my workplace people are seen as people - each different! The differences between us are utilised in a positive way not used against us because we look or speak differently.
Attitude is key!

The way your work place approaches it sounds very reasonable.

Ponoka7 · 16/09/2023 11:28

RamsesTheChub · 16/09/2023 11:15

If you care to provide the Law and clause which outlaws this I think we'd all - especially OP - appreciate the clarity.

The accusatory emotion you attach to me is plain bollocks, but I don't feel the need to get angry over it.

It would change the job title. It depends on the work contract and how performance reviews are done. How additional training candidates are selected etc. Teaching someone a language is a skill and the pay more than your average office work. It's great to utilise your staff but it has to be decided at the start and how that will impact on the helpers actual job and workload. It isn't the job the colleague took. What if they don't like each other?

Therocksword · 16/09/2023 11:27

I think you need to ask your colleague not putting any pressure on them.

In general I do not think it’s racist to ask the question.
Mentoring is common in my very multicultural workplace, quite often people of the same mother tongue are put together. It is always following discussion from both sides, some people that are trying to improve their English will request only English speaking mentorship, is that racist? Again I don’t believe it is - it’s no different to identifying a skill gap and making arrangements to bridge that gap.

I have certain skills that are often utilised for new hires, I don’t feel uncomfortable with that.

but then in my workplace people are seen as people - each different! The differences between us are utilised in a positive way not used against us because we look or speak differently.
Attitude is key!

Ponoka7 · 16/09/2023 11:21

boromu222 · 16/09/2023 11:05

It's not racist to ask someone wo speaks French to help someone else out whose first language is French.
It doesn't make it any different if the language is not French and/or the people involved are a different race to you.

I mean, it could be a bad idea for many reasons, it could be inappropriate, it could be unhelpful. But it's not racist.

Edited

It isn't racist as long as it is the norm to pull another staff member from their job to help a colleague struggling with the basics of the job. As long as the help given would be the same, trime, effort wise etc and the other person's work load adjusted without any effect on performance reviews, growth opportunities etc. If the firm would normally hire someone who didn't need help with a basic requirement or use staff training by a trainer, then it could be seen as a discriminatory work practice and indirect discrimination. Tbh the OP should have put this to HR and not the internet.

inamarina · 16/09/2023 11:18

Ponoka7 · 16/09/2023 11:02

@inamarina it would have to be included in the helpers performance review. They would be taken off their job to do one they aren't contracted to do. That could mean less progression or training etc for them. Can you go to work, decide to ignore your work duties and do something else? Can a employer decide to change the job you are paid for? That's a HR matter. Do you know how much interiors earn? Would there be a pay rise, who sets out what's needed etc etc. Or do you think language teaching is a simple job?

Edited

Again, maybe I misunderstood the OP, but to me it didn’t sound like she was expecting her colleague to become a full time mentor/ interpreter/ language teacher to the new recruit.

Can you go to work, decide to ignore your work duties and do something else?

Nobody was suggesting that.

Can a employer decide to change the job you are paid for?

I‘m pretty sure that happens, but again, would that really be the case here if the colleague was asked (not told) to talk to the new recruit on a couple of occasions? How much training would they really miss out on if that case?

RamsesTheChub · 16/09/2023 11:15

Ponoka7 · 16/09/2023 11:07

@RamsesTheChub, ooh threaten the minority if they dare to quote employment law, yeah that doesn't work anymore. Isn't she being compliant enough?

If you care to provide the Law and clause which outlaws this I think we'd all - especially OP - appreciate the clarity.

The accusatory emotion you attach to me is plain bollocks, but I don't feel the need to get angry over it.

Dutch1e · 16/09/2023 11:11

I'm really glad you've decided to stay well out of it OP.

I'm a native English-speaker emigrant to the Netherlands and it is a little tiresome to hear "oh perhaps you can help Jane, she's English too!"

  1. I'm not English, or even from the UK. I just speak the language so my shared connection to Jane is tenuous at best, just like your two colleagues.
  1. I already chatted with Jane (because I'm not an idiot that needs guidance to do the bleeding obvious things) and discovered I have no desire to spend time with her in any capacity.

Edit: I can't speak to racism but I can speak to this kind of well-meant but deeply tone-deaf approach that will never end well. It feels like "oh the kids are the same age, they're bound to get on!"

Ponoka7 · 16/09/2023 11:07

@RamsesTheChub, ooh threaten the minority if they dare to quote employment law, yeah that doesn't work anymore. Isn't she being compliant enough?

boromu222 · 16/09/2023 11:05

whyisitallsohard · 15/09/2023 17:20

Do not do this!! Yes it is racist. Are you her manager? If not, do not get involved. If you are, ask the new hire what she wants to encourage her to ask for help where she feels she can get it best.

It's not racist to ask someone wo speaks French to help someone else out whose first language is French.
It doesn't make it any different if the language is not French and/or the people involved are a different race to you.

I mean, it could be a bad idea for many reasons, it could be inappropriate, it could be unhelpful. But it's not racist.

GodDammitCecil · 16/09/2023 11:03

Roostercreek · 16/09/2023 10:43

So if you think there's nothing racist in that term, you'd better get onto admin, who certainly did see somethjng wrong with it. Just because you don't take offence to it, doesn't mean it's not an offensive label.

White fragility is not racist.

When people of colour raise something they’re uncomfortable with, and white people go on the defensive and rush to get offended - instead of simply taking what they say on board, considering it and potentially changing their mind, or even just just disagreeing politely having genuinely considered it - THAT’S ‘white fragility’

This thread is littered with it. It’s embarrassing.

And yes, @madamreign - are you coming back to your thread….?

Ponoka7 · 16/09/2023 11:02

@inamarina it would have to be included in the helpers performance review. They would be taken off their job to do one they aren't contracted to do. That could mean less progression or training etc for them. Can you go to work, decide to ignore your work duties and do something else? Can a employer decide to change the job you are paid for? That's a HR matter. Do you know how much interiors earn? Would there be a pay rise, who sets out what's needed etc etc. Or do you think language teaching is a simple job?

RamsesTheChub · 16/09/2023 11:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

"Im the only one who has saved their ass st work"

"Thank god for us"

You think very highly of yourself. I suppose confidence is a good thing but the way you attack people... believe me if that's how you behave at work you'll be the one hauled over the coals by HR.

Ponoka7 · 16/09/2023 10:59

Tandora · 16/09/2023 00:40

Why are people of colour who explain racism automatically seen as “aggressive”

This is an anonymous internet forum. Nobody knew your colour until you pointed it out to them.
impressions of your words/ tone etc. have had nothing to do with judgements based on your colour / race, they have entirely been based on your written posts which are full of wild accusations/ judgements / assumptions, punctuated by excessive use of !!!! And ???? And assertions like OP should undergo disciplinary action, which most people think is absurd.

when all i am doing is just replying normally

you really aren’t.

there are massive amounts of projection going on here.

It's easy to dismiss lived experience and knowledge as projection to shut down opposing opinions on why this isn't a good management, good for either party and a poor work decision.

inamarina · 16/09/2023 10:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What exactly would you be reporting them to the HR for? For wanting to help a new colleague?

whyisitallsohard · 16/09/2023 10:55

GodDammitCecil · 16/09/2023 00:55

I honestly can’t believe you reported someone for using the term ‘white fragility’. The absolute irony - which you, of course, won’t get.

I’m white and I do not support your stance in the slightest.

thank you for sharing this. absolutely ironic and proves me point!

mumsnet deleted my one comment mentioning white fragility, and i've written a formal complaint to them for their support of this blatant racism and their rejecting an academic and scientifically backed term "WHITE FRAGILITY". the fact that it is denied is racist in itself.

mumsnet refuses to delete this person's comment where they say "saying white fragility is racist", when i have sent them evidence it is a real societal issue that also effects workplaces. white fragility is a huge problem especially in the workplace that works to silence people of colour and put the feelings of white people first so that no change in racism can ever occur. it is blatant in this thread. I am astounded that there are people who deny it, even when presented with the author (who is white) and came up with the term.

also, funny how OP hasn't returned to clarify anything! this is such a disgusting thread inc OP's original thought of action themselves, and reflects the vile nature of the workplace and challenges for many people of colour or anyone different from the majority, and how people like OP think it's okay to add (unpaid) labour onto others while they can pretend to be do gooders, a lot like these anonymous commenters refuting the racism in OP's proposed actions and my explanations as to why it is racist in the first place . not to mention, OP ASKED themselves "am i being racist?". the acceptable answer to fragile white commenters on here is only "no". if you say "Yes", you are attacked. the gaslighting by many of them is real and also reflects people really think and say when the boss and HR aren't listening.

the fact that they also want me to be polite and sweet and manage their fragility is so ironic lol.

again, thanks for your supportive comment.

Roostercreek · 16/09/2023 10:48

Racism is about discrimination NOT, in the OP's case. Where she is looking to help somebody. Get a grip @whyisitallsohard 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread