Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Really fucking stupid things people do… can this be topped?!

339 replies

wbagnlw · 14/09/2023 21:57

Writing a review of a product…

’haven’t used it yet because I got it for my cousin’s birthday and she hasn’t opened it.

why write the review then?! Are people genuinely that stupid?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Raffles76 · 18/09/2023 22:39

Yes!! I ALWAYS think this! Or when someone asks a product question on Amazon and a person replies saying “I’m not sure I’m afraid”. They weren’t talking directly to you!

user1497207191 · 18/09/2023 11:37

SavBlancTonight · 18/09/2023 11:00

I think this is because they have to input the security questions in order to access the order info.

I keep having similar ridiculous questions with the company managing our house insurance claim for subsidence. They ring me to book an appointment but we have to go through security every time, tedious but fine. The questions are a randomised set of questions based on the data they hold on me. It's always amusing when one of the questions they ask me is, "what is your phone number"... having just called me, on the exact number they're now asking me for!

Nail on the head. They don't have any choice/discretion. The computer will keep asking questions and they need to be answered. It's not as if the phone operator will have open/unfettered access to the company database - there'll be all kinds of controls, etc., that they'll have no choice but to go through to get from one area/screen to another. In many cases, the phone operator will have virtually the same screens as you do by logging into your own computer - they "may" have slightly more permissions and functions, but usually not much, if any.

The thing is that people will try to abuse the system, whether customers phoning in, or even staff, so controls need to be in place. You could say you don't need to go through security if, say, you're phoning your bank to ask for a copy statement to be sent, or for a paying in slip book, as they're not security risk tasks, but if the operator logs in and does that without checking you out, it'd be easy for them to get suckered in to confirming your balance etc if there weren't controls, so it's safer to have to go through security before they can access anything, so at least they know it's "you". Also, you don't really want random customer service staff being able to log in to someone's bank account just for nosiness or even worse, to steal money, etc., so they aren't given access without the customer giving the security details to them.

At the end of the day, they don't have access to the data, until you give them your security details which is what grants them the access.

Nutterjacks · 18/09/2023 11:08

budgetingnovice1993 · 18/09/2023 05:29

@Nutterjacks I didn't understand your pair. Once you left a review that triggered a refund? Couldn't you show EBay the item had been delivered?

I did show eBay tracking evidence of delivery, but he still said he hadn't received it. It was about ten years ago, before the photo evidence thing started.

boromu222 · 18/09/2023 11:05

Angryappendix · 14/09/2023 22:05

Arghhh since becoming parent, the amount of 5 star reviews I have seen from grandparents saying things like below drives me mad!

”brought for my new grandson as a gift but hasn’t used it yet”

Especially as they nearly always say brought instead of bought! Why is this so widespread an error now? It's not at all the same word.

GingerIsBest · 18/09/2023 11:01

CanadianJohn · 18/09/2023 04:31

Some years ago, I had to send someone a postal money order, which I bought at the local post office. It turned out, I didn't need to send the money order.

So, I went back to the post office, the same clerk, and asked if I could get a refund, or something. She said that the easiest thing to do was just to make out the money order to myself, and then she could cash it.

Okay, so I borrowed her pen, made out the money order to myself, and ... now you have to sign it, she said. So I did that.

Then she asked me for i.d. Why? So she could verify I was the person the money order was made out to. I protested that she had just seen me print my own name on the money order, at her instruction, and sign it.

"But how do I know it's you", she said. Good thing I used my own name, eh.

You wrote your name etc, sure, but how does she know that the name you're rwriting down IS in fact you? It doesn't seem weird to ask for ID int hat situation. And I imagine she has to confirm she's seen it, or even take a copy?

SavBlancTonight · 18/09/2023 11:00

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 17/09/2023 22:43

Called John Lewis to chase up an order, had to confirm name, address and phone number. Fine.
I asked about a different order and she asked me to confirm the above again.
Literally same call, same person.
Next day, turns out not sorted, so called again and of course no record of my 25 minute call the day before and nothing actioned.

Third time's the charm I thought....so three days of chasing up the same thing and having to confirm my identity twice each time......

I think this is because they have to input the security questions in order to access the order info.

I keep having similar ridiculous questions with the company managing our house insurance claim for subsidence. They ring me to book an appointment but we have to go through security every time, tedious but fine. The questions are a randomised set of questions based on the data they hold on me. It's always amusing when one of the questions they ask me is, "what is your phone number"... having just called me, on the exact number they're now asking me for!

user1497207191 · 18/09/2023 10:35

CanadianJohn · 18/09/2023 04:31

Some years ago, I had to send someone a postal money order, which I bought at the local post office. It turned out, I didn't need to send the money order.

So, I went back to the post office, the same clerk, and asked if I could get a refund, or something. She said that the easiest thing to do was just to make out the money order to myself, and then she could cash it.

Okay, so I borrowed her pen, made out the money order to myself, and ... now you have to sign it, she said. So I did that.

Then she asked me for i.d. Why? So she could verify I was the person the money order was made out to. I protested that she had just seen me print my own name on the money order, at her instruction, and sign it.

"But how do I know it's you", she said. Good thing I used my own name, eh.

That's almost certainly a requirement of their system though, not the person being stupid. Their system probably has a tick box for ID, with a drop down box to select what kind of ID has been seen, some even require input of the reference number from the document. All financial services are now heavily regulated/policed, so they may have been disciplined (or even prosecuted) if the transaction turned out to be fraudulent, or the system may not have allowed them to proceed (i.e. open the till drawer) until the boxes had been completed. What seems innocent to you, may well be replicated by criminal gangs, i.e. with stolen blank postal orders, etc.

budgetingnovice1993 · 18/09/2023 05:29

@Nutterjacks I didn't understand your pair. Once you left a review that triggered a refund? Couldn't you show EBay the item had been delivered?

CanadianJohn · 18/09/2023 04:31

Some years ago, I had to send someone a postal money order, which I bought at the local post office. It turned out, I didn't need to send the money order.

So, I went back to the post office, the same clerk, and asked if I could get a refund, or something. She said that the easiest thing to do was just to make out the money order to myself, and then she could cash it.

Okay, so I borrowed her pen, made out the money order to myself, and ... now you have to sign it, she said. So I did that.

Then she asked me for i.d. Why? So she could verify I was the person the money order was made out to. I protested that she had just seen me print my own name on the money order, at her instruction, and sign it.

"But how do I know it's you", she said. Good thing I used my own name, eh.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 18/09/2023 04:19

Talking of reviews, Somone posted on the John Lewis website about their extandable clothes drier that it was miniature and not fit for purpose.
She had the photo of it next to a regular household item to compare size and prove her point.
It's meant for small storage spaces and says both on the site and packaging that it's extendable. All she had to do was ypu know, exrend it! Shame you can't post replies to point it out.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 17/09/2023 22:43

Called John Lewis to chase up an order, had to confirm name, address and phone number. Fine.
I asked about a different order and she asked me to confirm the above again.
Literally same call, same person.
Next day, turns out not sorted, so called again and of course no record of my 25 minute call the day before and nothing actioned.

Third time's the charm I thought....so three days of chasing up the same thing and having to confirm my identity twice each time......

Slowlylosingmymind101 · 17/09/2023 11:56

Sometimes I wander how civilization and human kind has made it to the year 2023.

ScottBakula · 17/09/2023 11:40

LuciaPillson · 17/09/2023 07:24

"As the first tinges of autumn hit our shores, I found myself bundled up against a crisp breeze, teeth a-gleam, perfect breasts nestled in pumpkin cashmere, my mind filled with an aching reminiscence of swedes and parsnip; memories of forcing soup upon hungover flatmates at uni, who gave me an opportunity to observe that the soup, later, looked much the same coming out as it had going in.... I saw myself yet again in after years holding my famous soup parties in which happy, happy guests partook of my velvety, sinuous concoctions coupled with a just-right glass of smoky Pouilly-Fumé. Even the humble act of peeling a root vegetable can be a sensuously tactile reminder of the cyclical rite of the seasons (don't worry though, no need to do the whole heap, you can get the maid to finish up). Finally, here on my foodie-blog Carilla's Cutest Culinary Creations, I can share with YOU my special reader, how to make sweet parsnip magic, compelling swede passion, that will transform your friendless, unjoyous existence and bring the soup-thirsty masses to your door." (etc.)

Edited

This was very well wrote , ⭐⭐⭐⭐, I would of giving it 5 stars but the writer did not use the word unctuous so I can not tell if i would like the soup .

😁😂😂

housethatbuiltme · 17/09/2023 10:26

Dogon · 17/09/2023 06:15

Also, the reviews that are rated 1 star because the delivery company failed to deliver, or something like that. 1 star because it didn't turn up etc. It's a review of the product, not the service!!

I disagree, I tend to look for a review of the SERVICE... lots of things are market places now and have scammers.

If theres 8 reviews and 5 says it never arrived thats far more important than what the other 3 say.

housethatbuiltme · 17/09/2023 10:21

inappropriateraspberry · 17/09/2023 06:06

I think they probably mean only tried on, rather than worn for an actual wedding!

They often post pictures of them AT their wedding in it as the photos of the dress, usually with something like 'only worn for 8 hours' and 'small marks on the train' etc... in the description.

It's very common.

GreyCarpet · 17/09/2023 10:01

LovedFedAndNoonesDead · 16/09/2023 06:38

I was once on a medication that was prescribed exclusively to people who were obese. In the patient information leaflet one of the warnings was that people on this medication were at higher risk of stroke or heart attack than the general population - given it was a drug only for people with a BMI above 40, those prescribed the drug were already at higher risk of stroke or heart attack even if not prescribed it; the added risk of taking it compared to the risk of having a bmi over 40 was something like 1/50,000 so it really wasn’t a big added risk in comparison. And far lower than the risk of experiencing some of the side effects of the only alternative drug prescribed at the time.

My understanding is that, when trialling drugs, people have to report every potential side effect. So if they experience something whilst taking the drug, it has to he reported.

Which is, I suppose, you find things like 'depession' as a possible side effect on anti depressants.

I often look at possible side effects and think it looks a lot more like correlation than causation!

Nutterjacks · 17/09/2023 09:22

CharlotteBog · 14/09/2023 22:17

I ordered something from Ebay today. Strangely enough it hasn't arrived yet.
I've already received an email asking to review my Ebay experience.
Daftness indeed.

I got scammed on eBay. Sold a few items to one buyer who immediately left me a really good review then bugged me constantly for a return review. I gave in, tracking said parcel had been delivered, then the buyer claimed he hadn't received items and got refunded in full.
Not falling for that one again! 😡

IrresponsiblyCertainAboutSexualDimorphism · 17/09/2023 08:27

Once when looking for a hotel in Paris I came across a one star review (amongst other positive reviews) for a hotel in a very old building opposite the Gare du Lyon. Apparently the lift was far too small and could only accommodate two people with suitcases, the corridors were very narrow, and the server at breakfast spoke no English.

We booked it anyway, and I can confirm it was an accurate review. I gave it 5 stars.

FormerlyPathologicallyHappy · 17/09/2023 08:26

This is true, gotta be 1500 words with high quality original images and choc full of keywords.

Luckily blogs often have a jump to recipe button now.

CassandraClassic · 17/09/2023 08:09

Tukmgru · 17/09/2023 06:19

The one that aggravates me more than it should is when you find what looks like a recipe you want to try, and it ends up being some mum
blog with a thesis of an intro about their personal lives as it pertains to the meal, where they first ‘encountered’ the dish, how their husbands/kids/dogs feel about it. They very carefully nestle the actual recipe about half way through sometimes so you can’t just scroll to the end.

i. Just. Want. The. Recipe. I. Don’t. Care. About. Your. Self. Aggrandisement.

It doesn't make it any less annoying, but this is done for search engines wanting "high quality webpages" with "well written content", and a straightforward recipe gets ranked down for being a simple list.

So that's an idiotic thing Google has done and that's why you have to read utter nonsense about their 'childhood morns on the farm' prefacing poached eggs.

Hardbackwriter · 17/09/2023 08:07

Leggytigberk · 15/09/2023 10:06

I wish our doctor would hold back on their "satisfaction survey"

Questions like how likely are you to use us again?
Ans) You are the only Practice for about 10 miles and there are no buses!

Are you likely to recommend us to your family?
We are already all signed up.

Who analyses these results? Sounds a cushy little part time job!

I got one of these for labour ward - not even the general maternity service, specifically for labour ward - which was clearly a hospital wide policy they couldn't change, but which was a bit baffling in context. I hope I am very unlikely to use your service again as I dont want any more children; I would be very unlikely to recommend it to my family and friends, unless they were in labour in which case I would indeed suggest it might be a good idea; my issue was indeed resolved during the course of my visit if we assume that 'my issue' was being halfway through having a baby...

eastegg · 17/09/2023 08:04

TokyoSushi · 14/09/2023 23:04

It doesn't quite fit, but I need to let it out somewhere! Why in Aldi, and it only seems to be in Aldi (I do my food shop there every week, no Aldi snobbery here!) do people not understand how the bloody check out belt works. There I am with my trolley piled high with the weekly family shop, I start putting it onto the belt, maybe halfway along after somebody else has finished, and somebody comes straight up behind you and starts unloading their shopping, giving me about 30cm to fit in 50+ items, every bloody time!! USE YOUR EYES AND YOUR BRAIN!!!!! Argh!!!

Edited

I could have written this post word for word! I find my shop takes up almost the full length of the belt, but there is definitely a reluctance to accept that!

NotSayingItsTheMasonsBut · 17/09/2023 08:00

One of those posts on Facebook where someone is trying to find their missing parcel with the delivery photo.
Only DPD had photographed the parcel next to a plain agricultural fence post, absolutely no identifying features around it just an ordinary, get in every field, dwelling, farm suppliers fence post.
I live in a rural community, we have millions of them.
Made everyone laugh though, including the poster of the the post.

CurlewKate · 17/09/2023 07:26

I loved a 1 star review on a Seasalt skirt "I'm 6ft and it was too short for me."

LuciaPillson · 17/09/2023 07:24

Tukmgru · 17/09/2023 06:19

The one that aggravates me more than it should is when you find what looks like a recipe you want to try, and it ends up being some mum
blog with a thesis of an intro about their personal lives as it pertains to the meal, where they first ‘encountered’ the dish, how their husbands/kids/dogs feel about it. They very carefully nestle the actual recipe about half way through sometimes so you can’t just scroll to the end.

i. Just. Want. The. Recipe. I. Don’t. Care. About. Your. Self. Aggrandisement.

"As the first tinges of autumn hit our shores, I found myself bundled up against a crisp breeze, teeth a-gleam, perfect breasts nestled in pumpkin cashmere, my mind filled with an aching reminiscence of swedes and parsnip; memories of forcing soup upon hungover flatmates at uni, who gave me an opportunity to observe that the soup, later, looked much the same coming out as it had going in.... I saw myself yet again in after years holding my famous soup parties in which happy, happy guests partook of my velvety, sinuous concoctions coupled with a just-right glass of smoky Pouilly-Fumé. Even the humble act of peeling a root vegetable can be a sensuously tactile reminder of the cyclical rite of the seasons (don't worry though, no need to do the whole heap, you can get the maid to finish up). Finally, here on my foodie-blog Carilla's Cutest Culinary Creations, I can share with YOU my special reader, how to make sweet parsnip magic, compelling swede passion, that will transform your friendless, unjoyous existence and bring the soup-thirsty masses to your door." (etc.)

Swipe left for the next trending thread