Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask all stepparents this question?

190 replies

Zellam · 14/09/2023 21:30

Based on recent posts regarding stepparenting and many (in my opinion) judgemental responses, I am VERY curious about this, and please answer as honestly as possible: Do you love your stepchildren as much as your own?This question is targetted to parents of stepchildren and biological children, of course. I know it seems weird to be asking this and I don't mean to make you feel uncomfortable, but it's very interesting to consider if we are perhaps programmed to love 'our' children more due to biological nurture elements etc. I am sure you can love your stepchildren very deeply indeed; but would you always have love that goes deeper for your own, I wonder.

OP posts:
Namerequired · 15/09/2023 11:09

Testina · 14/09/2023 21:45

You want to claim that we might be programmed to love only our own biological children for a discussion about stepchildren, but you’re shying away from people saying what does their mean for adoptees - cos you realise it will make you look an arsehole?

It’s not the same though.
My simple answer is no I don’t. But I truly don’t believe it’s biological. My step child is not my child, whereas an adopted child is. We were actually the rp of dss (adult now) but I never felt like he was mine. He had a mother and a whole maternal family. I didn’t get to make big decisions for him, I questioned everything and everything was questioned. I felt judged in a way that I never have with my own. Felt I always had to justify everything such as discipline etc. I honestly feel I could have hit my own children (for the record I wouldn’t hit a child) and people would have went poor you they must have pushed you over the edge, but if I looked wrong at dss I was the evil stepmother. Now I know some of that was probably in my head but not all of it. I didn’t have any legal rights and would have lost him if dp and I had split. Dp got to pull rank ans it was his child. So did his mum despite her very limited time with him. I was putting my time, money and resources into him, annd frankly it was thankless. And then there’s the fact that it’s a child dp had with an ex partner. Not the biggest issue but it is one. Who wants reminders of exes.
I don’t believe stepparents love the children the same in most cases, some just hide it better. I do think it’s often easier for stepfathers to do, or if the other parent is deceased or completely absent and you are parenting as an equal parent but i don’t know. What I have realised with hindsight is that dss wasn’t the issue, it was dp, bm, extended family, society and probably my own mind. I wouldn’t do it again though.
Now I believe, though can’t possibly know, that I could love an adopted child as my own. It would actually be interesting to do a thread on this for people who have adopted and biological children.

aSofaNearYou · 15/09/2023 11:09

Take it you have your own? Do you find it hard then to not feel love for him and having him around so often? I think I would find it hard if I had the same relationship with both of them that I do with the youngest, I think having such a nice relationship with the eldest is what gets me through really, and hoping that when eldest stops being interested in sleeping over because he has his own life, that youngest will stop bothering too.

Yes I have my own. I do find it hard sometimes, because I find a lot of his behaviour really frustrating. I don't think I would if I just didn't feel the love but his behaviour was easy to deal with - I often imagine how I would feel if it was a different child whose disposition I just liked better, but it's luck of the draw really what kind of kid you get and I got one that I am not naturally inclined to enjoy the company of, the older he gets.

But it's EOW - in truth, if it was more than that, I'd have bailed by how. Hence why I never understand why people are surprised that the more committed, loving step parents are the ones that have to live with them full time and have made the decision to stick around.

milkshakebringsallthebuoystotheyard · 15/09/2023 11:02

aSofaNearYou · 15/09/2023 10:52

To answer your question OP - no not in the slightest. I wouldn't actually go so far as to say I love him at all; much like with my MIL, who not only do I not love as much as my own mum, I wouldn't actually say I "love" her, though I get on with her fine.

Take it you have your own? Do you find it hard then to not feel love for him and having him around so often? I think I would find it hard if I had the same relationship with both of them that I do with the youngest, I think having such a nice relationship with the eldest is what gets me through really, and hoping that when eldest stops being interested in sleeping over because he has his own life, that youngest will stop bothering too.

aSofaNearYou · 15/09/2023 10:52

To answer your question OP - no not in the slightest. I wouldn't actually go so far as to say I love him at all; much like with my MIL, who not only do I not love as much as my own mum, I wouldn't actually say I "love" her, though I get on with her fine.

aSofaNearYou · 15/09/2023 10:49

Holly60 · 15/09/2023 06:33

What I find interesting is that the overwhelming majority of women have come on here to say they don't love their step children/ or not as much as their own children. However those posting about their partners seem to all be saying that their partners DO love their step children (the woman's biological children).

One poster even had the two views in one post. She said she could barely tolerate her own SC but her husband loved her biological children as his own!

Either men are just much more loving than women, they are lying about it to their partners, or women are just refusing to see what is in front of them 🤷‍♀️

Men are not more loving than women. I think they probably take the question less seriously and just say "yeah sure", but the main reason it is more common for men to view their SC the same as their own is because they are usually living with them near to or completely full time, which is not the case for most step mothers. They/their partners would not stay in the situation if they were not all in emotionally, it wouldn't be enjoyable for anyone involved.

FreshStart12345 · 15/09/2023 10:38

No. I love her more like I do my niece/nephew. I think that's the best way to describe how I feel about her.

I think it depends how much time you spend together. If the mum is no longer on the seen, and your partner is the full time parent so you also become the full time parent, it's very different then if you only see your step dc EOW, and are very much in "dads new wife" territory.
I would expect my stepdc to love me the same as she does her mother, and so I don't think it's right to think I should love her the same as my own children. We are all only human at the end of the day

milkshakebringsallthebuoystotheyard · 15/09/2023 10:37

Zellam · 14/09/2023 21:30

Based on recent posts regarding stepparenting and many (in my opinion) judgemental responses, I am VERY curious about this, and please answer as honestly as possible: Do you love your stepchildren as much as your own?This question is targetted to parents of stepchildren and biological children, of course. I know it seems weird to be asking this and I don't mean to make you feel uncomfortable, but it's very interesting to consider if we are perhaps programmed to love 'our' children more due to biological nurture elements etc. I am sure you can love your stepchildren very deeply indeed; but would you always have love that goes deeper for your own, I wonder.

Tough question. I once desperately wished they didnt exist. Im now very close with the eldest, not in a motherly sense, more like a big sister (which sounds odd I guess but my little brother is 14 years younger than me so in terms of age difference, I guess thats the only relationship I can liken it to). I love him to bits, hes a great kid. I dont love him like a mum but I dont feel the need to, we have a great bond.

The youngest... Oh god. Im awful but no, I about tolerate him for the majority of the time. Sometimes fond, mostly grin and bear it, other times I just have to be away from him. He has additional needs which make him... I guess just a lot harder work, which in itself isnt an issue, but means he has no off button, zero emotional awareness, is constantly acting the fool for attention and thats all fine when you are in a good place and can mentally understand its the issue rather than him, but when its constant, god it just grates, its exhausting. He's a walking mouthpiece for his mum, not deliberately, but if shes said it, he's gonna come and tell us. We'll ask him why what hes said was even relevant to tell us and he doesnt know, its just basically word vomit. No one will have said anything at all for the last few minutes and he'll just blurt out "Mum told brother off last week for him accidentally calling her "my name" and said it was a disgusting thing to call her". Just out of nowhere, so constantly having these little bombs dropped in when we all just having a perfectly nice time. When told I miscarried, and both were asked if they had any questions for us, youngest instantly sparked up with "I bet it was weird carrying around a dead baby inside you, hurhurhur".

Im due my own next year (all being well this time) and I worry that it will highlight the issues with youngest SS further. Hes not going to take the baby having attention well. Last time he spent time with my much younger niece, someone commented on not realising how big kids are getting until they are around other younger kids, and he started crawling around on the floor saying he was still the baby.

In saying that, I'd never let any harm come to him. But I dont think I'll ever love him anything like my own.

funinthesun19 · 15/09/2023 09:54

I used to be a stepparent. And no I never loved my dsc as much as my own dc.

Biology did play a huge part, but so did the logistics of life. Dsc had their own mum who they spent half of the week with. A mum they loved like my children love me. So it never occurred to me that it was my job to love dsc like my own. Dsc didn’t need or even want that from me.
I was kind to dsc and fond of them. And brought a lot of stability in to their life that they wouldn’t have had with their dad if I wasn’t around because my ex was and is useless. So I played a massive role in dsc’s childhood. But I never loved them like I love my own.

CurlewKate · 15/09/2023 09:34

Mind you-my brother has a stepchild who ended up living with him full time from the age of 4 because of her mother's abuse. She's 34 now and I suspect that, if tortured, he would admit she's his favorite child...

CurlewKate · 15/09/2023 09:30

I would be very sceptical of anyone who said they did.

Milkkbottles · 15/09/2023 09:13

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

AmyandPhilipfan · 15/09/2023 09:13

The issue of biology is an interesting one. And actually I would imagine that a lot of adoptive parents do love biological children more than adopted ones. But it is such a taboo to say that. And I think that might prevent some adoptive parents from asking for help when they are having problems, because they don't want to be judged as a monster for not automatically loving these children, and so they limp on until things improve or, in more cases than people might realise, the adoption fails.

I haven't adopted but I am a foster carer to two children who have been with me for several years. In that time I, unexpectedly, had a birth child. Before I had her I would have said I loved my foster children as if they were my birth children. Then I had her and it became clear to me that I don't. I care deeply for them and I hope to always be in their lives in some way, but I don't love them like I love my daughter, and I actually found myself feeling a bit resentful of them in the early days, when I had to get my sleeping baby up to take them to school, and leave her crying in the pram while I tied shoelaces, found PE bags etc.

That could be because they were already children when they came to me and, had I raised them from babyhood, I could very well have loved them just as deeply as my birth child.

ASCCM · 15/09/2023 09:08

Absolutely not. I will be honest and i am not sure i even like them very much. ( this is mutual) They both cried and made at scene when we got married, telling my kids they didn't want us to marry and trying their best to ruin the day. I was very upset about this.

Their mother is the main reason tbh, her behaviours and selfish and her unreasonable approach to shared parent life is a drain on mine. My money and time gets taken up because she is so demanding , lazy and nasty. It's hard to like anyone in this situation ( she also has told them she refuses to be in a room with me etc so that's not helpful)

I also see how they treat their dad, who tries so so hard to be the best he can, sacrificing almost everything to see them. They don't care. They are lazy and when they are here ( after he has driven an unreasonable distance because their mum refuses to share drop offs) they just stare at their phone or ipad or talk about how wonderful their mum is and their other house it etc.

I know people will hate this, but you asked for honesty and the truth is, my life would be lots better without them in it, i didn't want any more kids. They bring no joy or benefit, they bring drama and stress. Even when they are here, it doesn't make their dad ( or them seemingly) happy, so what is really the point?

I think there are a lot of people in our situations doing what they believe the be the 'right thing' but without the care or enjoyment of it.

InsomniacA · 15/09/2023 09:03

Yes, but she entered my life when she was only 2. At the time, I believed I couldn’t have my own children and maybe that helped? I did eventually have a bio child, but Dsd is also my daughter and I love them equally, truly. I feel blessed to have my bonus daughter and wish I had more.

My own stepmother is a bitch who actively strove to drive a wedge between me and my dad, so growing up hating her also probably contributed to my own choices.

GrapeEscape · 15/09/2023 08:57

Euridicefortuna · 15/09/2023 08:54

I've always wondered this;is it more like love for a niece/nephew?

I would happily lay my life down for my niece and nephew ,not sure if women would for their stepchildren.

I'm sure it is for some people like a niece and nephew.

But there are plenty of step parents who would say they don't even love their step children at all. I don't, not really. I like them and I'm kind and friendly and do what's needed but I don't really feel like I love them, I'd not be upset if me and my husband split up and I never saw them again for instance.

Euridicefortuna · 15/09/2023 08:54

I've always wondered this;is it more like love for a niece/nephew?

I would happily lay my life down for my niece and nephew ,not sure if women would for their stepchildren.

Sapphire387 · 15/09/2023 08:53

Dh and I were both widowed and we have a blend with each of our own biological DC plus a DC of our own.

Do I feel the same about my DSD? No. It isn't the same. But I do love her. And our bond grows over time. And that will have to be enough.

Might be 'easier' for us as there are no other parents involved. But of course the bereavements are by no means easy.

uneffingbelievable · 15/09/2023 08:52

No I met them when they were entering teens and a v different dynamic.

Care alot about all 3 of them, even if 1 quite clearly does not like me much.

I have taken the aunt role and we generally have a balanced dynamic with the old blip. It works for us.

What you are asking is a common statement on the SM forum by angry SMs - yet have never seen someone actally say it. I care for my SKs like I do my own - same rules, food bondaries in this house. i treat them as I want my DCs treated.

GrapeEscape · 15/09/2023 08:41

OP’s post did unfortunately refer to people being programmed to love children because of biological nurture elements.

Because it is factually correct. It would be silly to suggest biology has nothing to do with the love we feel for our children. Of course it does. On an primal, hormonal instinctual level we are "programmed" to nurture our own genes.

That's not to say there is no other way to feel that though. Actively seeking out a child, being their main caregiver and mother also develops a bond, one I'm sure can be to the same "level" as a biological parent and child. But I do think adoption has its own hurdles and is likely not something just anyone could do.

SunsetsInVenice · 15/09/2023 08:41

I know someone who claims she loves her 2 adult stepdaughters and 2 stepson (both from previous relationships ) as much as her own DD.
I can't imagine that at all especially as she doesn't and hasn't ever lived with any of them full-time and apart from the youngest, hasn't been there through their childhoods.
With the youngest her partner has always persuaded her to play the mummy role from day 1 because he hates his ex. Feel sorry for the kid involved when dad is making mothers day dedications to his partner of 5 years but who doesn't live with them and only sees them of a weekend. Very odd when said kid already has a mum.

PixieLaLar · 15/09/2023 08:28

Yes I think it’s the pressure and expectations put on step mums compared to step dads that makes a big difference here. Also from my own experience and knowing other step parents, you often hear about how nasty and spiteful bio mums can be towards step
mums but I don’t hear about bio dads being the same towards step dads….

AuntieEsther · 15/09/2023 08:27

No of course I don't! I haven't raised them, I see them 2 days a week plus holidays and they have a mum who is perfectly positioned to love them more than anything in the world. All that's expected of me is to be kind to them, be fond of them and support their father in raising them as much as he asks me to.
It's completely different to adoption where you're the parent, not step parent and you're actively cultivating an attachment relationship which if all goes well will lead to the same bond you would have with a birth child. Step parents usually aren't expected or required to do any such thing (excepting those who are raising the children full time and taking the parental role)

Naunet · 15/09/2023 08:21

Holly60 · 15/09/2023 06:33

What I find interesting is that the overwhelming majority of women have come on here to say they don't love their step children/ or not as much as their own children. However those posting about their partners seem to all be saying that their partners DO love their step children (the woman's biological children).

One poster even had the two views in one post. She said she could barely tolerate her own SC but her husband loved her biological children as his own!

Either men are just much more loving than women, they are lying about it to their partners, or women are just refusing to see what is in front of them 🤷‍♀️

Men walk away from their own biological kids everyday, at a rate far, far higher than women, so I’d think carefully about that what that tells you.

GrapeEscape · 15/09/2023 08:18

To answer the OP, no I do not love my step children in any way the same as my DC. And because I don't have the same unconditional love for them I admittedly do find them harder to be around, less patience, look forward to the times they aren't here ect.

I am always a bit sceptical of those posters on here who insist their husbands or partners love their older children as much as their children together because really how would you know? It tends to be men typically who love all of these children "like their own" and I do think there is something to be said about a man's typical role in child rearing and how easy he then finds it to love (or appear to love) step children like his own. I mean tbf I'd probably find it easier to come across that way too if all was expected of me in order to do so was act like a typical bloke. I'm sure lots of posters will say their husbands are the main caregivers, do EVERYTHING for their stepchildren ect but in reality we all know its typically the women who do the house and childcare and I can't imagine that being any different in blended families.

The amount of threads on here I see of women being expected to become a nanny to her stepchildren and actually being berated by other women for not doing so is ridiculous. So yeah I can imagine there are far more step mothers who don't love their step kids than step dad's. But let's not pretend the expectations for both are typically the same.

I'm yet to see a post from a mother who says she met a bloke and then dumped her kids from a previous relationship on him constantly and merely "helped where she could" with her own children. Yet its a weekly thread here about a stepmum.

jeaux90 · 15/09/2023 08:15

MonkeyPuddle · 14/09/2023 21:44

I have DSD, DS and DD.
Without a shadow of a doubt I love DS and DD more. Nowt wrong with that. They’re my kids.
I care deeply about DSD, she is a wonderful child, my partners child.
I would happily chuck DP in front of a bus for all of them.

Grin the last bit cracked me up sorry!