Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dog in school

134 replies

Coffeeandcatsforlife · 14/09/2023 21:20

The head teacher has a Rottweiler dog who is by nature a huge dog. He’s brought in to school a lot and the children get to play with him and look after him. Aibu feeling uneasy about this. It’s a primary school.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
drinkuptheezider · 15/09/2023 10:46

Hmmm... I've got splinters..

My DC are in their 30s. State primary, dogs in playground to meet kids was perfectly normal, no school dog though. The majority of the dogs were working dogs with country families. There was a right whooHa when a family moved to the school and complained.
DS1 went to a prep whose HM had his black labrador in school, but they lived on the premises, and boarding was still the norm. The dog would amble around. Once the novelty wore off, boys tended to just say hello as he wandered around.
DD, senior school, the headmistress had her lab in school, but it tended to stay in the office.
Neither dog ever was an issue that I was ever aware of.

I know a spaniel that goes into a school. The owner would like it to be a therapy dog, but I'm not sure if it's being specifically trained or just relying on its gentle nature and it is kept in a specific area of the admin area, I believe. The owner is the head.

I can see for allergy or phobia that it can be awkward, though, and I would hope mitigation would be in place to avoid trauma.
For some kids suffering other forms of trauma, dogs can provide comfort and a 'listening ear'

RandomButtons · 15/09/2023 10:45

I think a random pet with no specific therapy training has no place in a school, especially a large breed. If a cockapoo bites you it’s a few stitches at worse. Doberman can take a limb off.

CastlesCrumbling · 15/09/2023 10:19

rothbury · 15/09/2023 09:43

What about the rights of a child with an assistance dog to attend school?

As PP have said, we’re getting into “competing disability” territory here.

My SIL teaches at a school where the HT has an assistance dog, and so do two current pupils. I imagine if a child with a severe allergy wanted to attend that school, you would expect the other students to have to leave? And the HT? Of course that’s not going to happen.

So there is a specific need for those assistance dogs; they're presumably trained and risk assessed and the school can come up with a policy to manage the needs of the allergic child and the children and staff who need the assistance dog for their disabilities. It's a different scenario to any headteacher who feels like bringing their pet dog to work every day. A minority of people require assistance dogs so they won't be in the majority of schools and the scenario won't arise that often. People here are talking about 'school dogs', and claiming it's becoming 'the norm' for senior staff to bring in their pet dog, not a medical assistance dog, and that's what I'm objecting to.

OCDmama · 15/09/2023 10:08

Absolutely not okay for me. Many kids are afraid of dogs, allergic, etc and there are cultures which don't keep dogs as pets as they are seen as unclean.

A one-off lesson about dog safety, maybe. But no more than that, and definitely not such a large powerful dog.

Dogs are animals. Ultimately they could snap at any minute. Not many people could hold a rottweiler back.

BeignetPommes · 15/09/2023 10:04

as a child I was utterly terrified of dogs. Even knowing a dog was somewhere in the school and I could come into contact with them would have massively interrupted and probably ruined my education

Same. Didn't help that I was nipped on two separate occasions when completely minding my own business, little dog running at me through an open gate that I was walking by on a public pavement, and once on the bus as I walked by a little dog under a seat. I hadn't stepped on it.

As an adult I still don't like dogs although I'm not terrified of them any more.
I do avoid them though, especially over friendly ones who stick their noses in your crotch. I visit friends with dogs I'm familiar with who know how to leave you alone after an initial stroke, but would not be happy sitting alone in a room with a dog I'd never met before. Dogs walking by on leads don't worry me at all. They can be an awful nuisance off lead in parks and too many of them are allowed by their owners to jump up at passers by. There was an awful ruckus recently in a sandwich shop when two on lead customers dogs went for it with lots of squealing and growling and flying of fur. I made a hasty exit. There is now a sign on the door banning dogs. All that said, it's perfectly possible to go through life without having to put up with dogs providing you're firm with boundaries.
It's really not fair to force children into situations that frighten them.

rothbury · 15/09/2023 09:43

CastlesCrumbling · 15/09/2023 09:36

Because the allergic child has to attend school, has the right to attend school and will be spending six hours there as opposed to the duration of a short bus journey. Allergies limit a child's life in so many ways; please let's not add primary school to the long list. All children are legally entitled to an education; the rights of dogs to be everywhere is thankfully not yet enshrined in law.

What about the rights of a child with an assistance dog to attend school?

As PP have said, we’re getting into “competing disability” territory here.

My SIL teaches at a school where the HT has an assistance dog, and so do two current pupils. I imagine if a child with a severe allergy wanted to attend that school, you would expect the other students to have to leave? And the HT? Of course that’s not going to happen.

Pizzanight · 15/09/2023 09:39

I have dogs now and love dogs but as a child I was utterly terrified of dogs. Even knowing a dog was somewhere in the school and I could come into contact with them would have massively interrupted and probably ruined my education. One minute we are told teachers are streched beyond their means, which I fully agree with and support but the next they are claiming they have time to piss about with a bloody dog at school, they can't have it both ways!

Cosyblankets · 15/09/2023 09:38

Oysterbabe · 15/09/2023 09:27

It's something we're constantly working on, but it's difficult when progress is frequently undone by someone's untrained mutt running toward us and jumping up at her.
'Don't worry, he's friendly!'
😡

I keep mine on a lead around kids simply because all he wants is fuss and play and if a child screams he will see that as a sign that they want to play! And if they run that's an even better game! If i sit him down and they want to stroke him that's fine. The calmer the child is the calmer the dog will be. I wish it worked with my fear of wasps!

CastlesCrumbling · 15/09/2023 09:36

bluebeck · 15/09/2023 09:16

I was on a train recently when a woman told a fellow passenger (with a terrier) they would have to leave the train because their son was allergic to dogs.

As you might expect, he told her she should get off, or move to another carriage. To be honest though, every time you get on a train or bus or even a plane, there will be traces of dogs or dogs present. They are in shops, cafes, pubs, everywhere. So it’s not helpful to have an expectation that the whole world is going to accommodate your allergy. Better to have adequate medication and avoid as much as you can.

What is the point of depriving kids that would really benefit from a school dog, when an allergic child has potentially spent their bus journey to school within two feet of a dog?

Because the allergic child has to attend school, has the right to attend school and will be spending six hours there as opposed to the duration of a short bus journey. Allergies limit a child's life in so many ways; please let's not add primary school to the long list. All children are legally entitled to an education; the rights of dogs to be everywhere is thankfully not yet enshrined in law.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/09/2023 09:31

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 15/09/2023 07:19

My motti is "never trust a person who doesn't like dogs".
@topnoddy @Womencanlift

Mine is ‘never trust people who can’t be bothered to proofread’

Oysterbabe · 15/09/2023 09:27

Cosyblankets · 15/09/2023 08:46

How are you helping her to overcome her fear?

It's something we're constantly working on, but it's difficult when progress is frequently undone by someone's untrained mutt running toward us and jumping up at her.
'Don't worry, he's friendly!'
😡

CastlesCrumbling · 15/09/2023 09:21

It does need to be properly risk assessed and managed @neverbeenskiing which is why I'm really apprehensive that headteachers are seeing the trend and deciding to just bring their dog in and call it a school dog - because of course their dog is lovely and friendly and if it bites a child it's their fault for surprising it. Trained, assessed, managed dogs that are kept in agreed spaces - ok. But strong, powerful breeds give me pause. If a headteacher decides to bring in their XL bully, is everyone happy with that?

There are too many bad, naive, irresponsible dog owners out there for me to think this is ok. And too many people blithely insisting that dogs should be included everywhere and that if anyone gets hurt it's their own fault - never the dog's.

ABC123DoReMiDoeRayMe · 15/09/2023 09:21

Nice victim-blaming.

bluebeck · 15/09/2023 09:16

I was on a train recently when a woman told a fellow passenger (with a terrier) they would have to leave the train because their son was allergic to dogs.

As you might expect, he told her she should get off, or move to another carriage. To be honest though, every time you get on a train or bus or even a plane, there will be traces of dogs or dogs present. They are in shops, cafes, pubs, everywhere. So it’s not helpful to have an expectation that the whole world is going to accommodate your allergy. Better to have adequate medication and avoid as much as you can.

What is the point of depriving kids that would really benefit from a school dog, when an allergic child has potentially spent their bus journey to school within two feet of a dog?

neverbeenskiing · 15/09/2023 09:09

CastlesCrumbling · 15/09/2023 08:29

Unless the dog is confined to certain spaces where allergic children never have to go, it poses a risk to those children. Allergies and asthma are on the rise - it's not a positive thing for these children to have a dog in school.

In all the (many) schools I've worked in, or visited for work, that have dogs onsite they've been based in a certain room/office and children who benefit from interacting or reading with the dog are brought in to see them. Ocassionally the dog might be present for small group interventions, but obviously if a child in the group was allergic or fearful of dogs that wouldn't be the case. When outside they've been with their owner on a lead. I've never known a school where a dog has been roaming around, wandering in and out of classrooms. Most school dogs don't go into classrooms at all IME. If a child is so severely allergic that being in the same building or the same outside space as a dog poses a risk them then that's obviously quite an extreme situation, but it could be risk assessed and managed so they didn't come into contact, in which case the dog wouldn't have a negative impact on that child but others, often the most vulnerable children, would still benefit from being able to spend time with the dog.

I am not a dog person by the way! I don't particularly like dogs, definitely wouldn't want one myself, but I have seen first hand the benefits of animals in schools and there is a lot of evidence to support their involvement with kids with SEND and other vulnerabilities. It just needs to be properly risk assessed and managed.

Stroopwaffels · 15/09/2023 09:07

I think there is a huge difference between those PAT - pets as therapy - dogs which are selected for their temperament, trained, and which then go into hospitals, universities, schools, care homes and someone's pet which they don't want to pay a dog walker for.

TheBarbieEffect · 15/09/2023 08:53

Dullardmullard · 15/09/2023 07:51

What bollocks no you wouldn’t

Oh I would. You cannot trust a dog owner, they are blinded by the “love” they have for their animal.

Rottweilers are dangerous dogs and they do NOT belong near children and certainly not in a school. No dog does.

cartagenagina · 15/09/2023 08:51

Surely if someone is that massively allergic to dog dander/hair/whatever that they would be at risk in a room a dog had previously occupied, then they would be at risk sitting next to any child or staff member who had a dog at home?

My nieces school has a school dog, and one of the students has a therapy dog. Schools will get to the point where they are dealing with competing “disabilities “ where one student’s requirement to have an assistance dog is pitted against another child’s allergy.

I have two colleagues who regularly bring dogs into the office. One very large, one very small. My manager complained because she doesn’t like dogs. She was told she doesn’t have to come in to the office if she doesn’t want to (her contractual workplace is home)

The only downside I suppose is that we all get far less work done when the dogs are in as most of us can’t resist them!!

Cosyblankets · 15/09/2023 08:46

Oysterbabe · 15/09/2023 08:27

My DD is very afraid of dogs after some bad experiences and this would be a nightmare for her. She would be unable to relax, have fun or focus on learning if there was a dog in the same room as her. Dogs do not belong in schools.

How are you helping her to overcome her fear?

Lahdedahiam · 15/09/2023 08:45

I'd love it!

HelpIsOnTheWay · 15/09/2023 08:30

Sussandbored · 15/09/2023 07:43

Ours has a cockapoo who humps everyone's schoolbag.

😂😂😂

We have a school dog, he's very well behave and much loved by everyone.