Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

FIL smacked my bum

211 replies

wisewoman2023 · 14/09/2023 14:11

I have a frought relationship with my in laws. They have no boundaries and are what I think toxic parents to their adult children.

Anyway, last Christmas my FIL smacked my bum three times in quick succession. It hurt and I could feel it for days after. I have kept them at arms length since. I do not feel comfortable him staying in my house, and when he asked to stay over we have declined as I do not feel I received an apology.

He apologised at the time but it was defensive. My MIL has now written to me to say that it was just a "pat on the bum" and meant as a "well done". She says that I need to accept the apology with "good grace".

I don't want a relationship with them. This has come after 14 years of being treated not very well by them. How do I explain that I don't want contact with them to my DH? I want us to continue a happy marriage, and I'm happy for him to continue a relationship with them, but I don't want to be included in that. Is this possible?

OP posts:
JKRisGalileo · 16/09/2023 02:14

Agreed! You do not have to share your personal feelings with an abuser. You need only to state your boundaries. And that for you, ought to be NC. If your DH supports this abuse, he needs to change his behaviour and attitude if he wants to stay married. I wish you all the best.

Escapingafter50years · 16/09/2023 00:28

You are thinking about adoption. What does your husband think about the possibility of you having a baby girl, who you want to teach has rights over her own body, but she grows up seeing her grandfather sexually abusing her mother?

I was adopted into a dysfunctional family (alcoholic father/narc "mother") so I have strong feelings on this. Please don't bring a child into this toxicity. The lifelong damage to an innocent baby is horrific.

It is disgusting how these abusive types view an apology as simply a couple of words to be said, and then they can carry on with their abuse, and you "must" accept it because they said they were sorry. My "mother", when I tried to explain to her how her behaviour had hurt me, would actually snarl "I said I'm sorry".

I listen a lot to the excellent Insight - Exposing Narcissism podcasts, and one of the things said about apologies is that an apology without changed behaviour is nothing more than manipulation.

Growing up un this dysfunction is a mindfuck and your husband has a long road ahead should he begin to realise his family is abusive. Please be careful you don't waste years on waiting for him to come to this realisation.

Do you think he might see a therapist to discuss the current situation?

EliflurtleTripanInfinite · 15/09/2023 23:51

My Stbxh is abusive. I spent a decade pre kids thinking he was a good man and that we had a strong marriage. Sometimes you don't know a person's character till it's tried. FIL and MIL believe physical discipline is the way to raise children that behave. Stbxh inherited this view, it did him no harm apparently. Except for the fact he grew into an adult that thinks smacking and pinching children isnt harmful and is acceptable behaviour. I can't imagine FIL would ever cross this line, even Stbxh would consider him crossing that line wrong.

Your DH has disordered thinking because of his childhood. Unless he is prepared to work on addressing that preferably with a psychologist nothing will change. You can't fix this or make your marriage right again, you could compromise your boundaries and try to bury this, but that will hurt you in the long run and probably destroy your marriage anyway. You could try laying it all out with I statements (takes away blame nature) ie when your Dad smacked me I felt violated/scared and so on. You could lay it down as an ultimatum, I won't be seeing your parents again and if you keep pushing this it will ruin our marriage. You could say you need to have counselling together. You can't make him see, or make him understand, ultimately that part is down to him.

Newnamefor23 · 15/09/2023 23:40

Maybe put this to your SIL. What would she have done.….

Breaktime coffee queue in staffroom. Ron (50yo deputy head) is behind 25 yo Ms. A.N.Other waiting to be served. First thing the other staff knew was a great shout of F… Off Ron. Every one stopped.

He’d been twanging her bra strap. This was in the days before grievance procedures etc etc. Ron was just being Ron.

How would your SIL deal with this - both as a victim and as a senior member of staff having to sort out the mess, accusations etc.

She may think that sort of attention is ok. Most do not.

Escapetofrance · 15/09/2023 23:32

Why on earth did your fil smack you? What possible reason did he say he had to do that? It sounds absolutely mad.
I really hope you feel better soon & get over this awful incident. I certainly wouldn’t visit without an apology and a promise to never behave in that way again to anyone.

wisewoman2023 · 15/09/2023 22:59

Yes I know the Spanish case has been in the press, but my in laws are so righteous that they are unlikely to draw any parallels. MIL loves holding her head up high in her local parish. You know the type.

You are spot on about DH growing up in a household where he had to diffuse the situation. He has told me many times that MIL and FIL would argue and he hated it as a child and has as a result become very non-confrontational.

I want to educate both my DH and my SIL because they both work in the public sector and of all people I feel they should know that touching bums without consent is not ok. SIL is a secondary school teacher and has taken her dads side, saying he didn’t mean it etc. She also said to my DH my email expressing my discontent at the situation was unpleasant. I feel they have made me out to be unstable for criticising him.

Thankfully I’ve spoken to my own blood siblings and parents as well as a few friends who have all supported my going NC with FIL, MIL and SIL. They are sad though as they know I have a good strong marriage with my DH and are worried this is going to cause a strain. I’m worried about this too obviously. Hope we can get through it.

OP posts:
Newnamefor23 · 15/09/2023 22:11

Isn’t there a man in court in Spain for a similar sort of non-consensual sexual assault?

Whilst not defending your husband he may have grown up having to defuse/ignore inappropriate behaviour from his father? His lessening of his fathers behaviour to you may be part of this?

It will be easier if you can get your OH re-educated so that you decide as a couple how to deal with your FIL. A serious sit down talk. But it may be that you end up having to act alone.

Do you have children? Esp daughters. Where are they in all of this?

Morgysmum · 15/09/2023 22:00

Yes, it is possible, to avoid him. I don't get on with my FI, nothing like this. But he treats his wife like crap and is not a nice person to be around. Big baby at times.
I avoid get togethers, by saying I am working, most of the time I am. My Oh, goes to see his parents with our son.
We went Christmas time the other year, as he was told, due to poor health he might only have 2 years. Well he totally ruined Christmas, by demanding tablets, that the doctor had told his wife, he was getting taken off, but no it was his wifes fault. So demanded more, which ment a hospital visit for him Christmas morning. Hospital advised my partner and MIL, that it could be a long wait, so they came home to do presents. FIL sulked all day.
Long story short, even his daughter, hasn't visited her parents much after Christmas fiasco. She only lives 3 houses away. But he ruined the kids Christmas.
My partner doesn't push for me to be there, as I don't push him to be around my parents either.

OddlyFramed · 15/09/2023 21:53

@wisewoman2023 you will never be able to reason or explain to them. The more you email or ask or explain the more they’ll use it to show you are unhinged. Which you are not.

Tell your DH what would happen if he did this to a female colleague I the work place, or a random woman in the shop. How he feels that is wrong is the same as his father.

Dont explain or ask for any more apologies. Just tell your DH he can have contact but you won’t. Unless it’s a family event like a wedding or something

OhcantthInkofaname · 15/09/2023 21:12

Toomuchtrouble4me · 15/09/2023 20:34

I’m sorry this happened but no way was it sore for three bloody days afterwards! Drama Llama much? He’d have to smack your arse with a cricket bat to feel
it 3 days later.

How do you know how her body responds to an injury? You don't -- you are just another keyboard KIA.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 15/09/2023 20:34

I’m sorry this happened but no way was it sore for three bloody days afterwards! Drama Llama much? He’d have to smack your arse with a cricket bat to feel
it 3 days later.

LaDamaDeElche · 15/09/2023 20:08

Your husband is a grown man who shouldn’t need to be educated on this. I’m astounded that he hasn’t fallen out with his father massively over this. I just can’t get my head round your FIL doing this and your DH pressuring you to have any relationship with him that you aren’t comfortable with. The whole thing is fucked up and gross. Was he drunk? I just can’t get my head around it.

Anniegetyourgun · 15/09/2023 19:54

Your husband doesn't reckon it's assault? It wasn't his bum, was it? So he can fuck right off with that minimising crap.

I got smooched by a pervy old uncle on my wedding day and XH never forgave ME for it! I did ask why he didn't come to my rescue. He said it looked as though I was enjoying it. Arse.

Bogeyes · 15/09/2023 19:44

Sexual assault is not a way of saying well done. How dare your mil suggest this. I am sure if it happened to your mil it would be a different story. By the way don't swallow that nonsense that bullies come out with where they say you are too sensitive. They are toxic.

Foggyfoggyfoggy · 15/09/2023 19:36

Ask dh if you had a dd would he want a male relative groping her?

Marcipex · 15/09/2023 19:19

What @DuploTrain said is perfect.

PotatoLove · 15/09/2023 19:17

I cannot stand these type of creepy old men! The way people try and normalise this behaviour pisses me off as well.

leesmum · 15/09/2023 19:14

Seriously I actually can't believe that this sort of thing might be happening in 2023,

Please have some respect for yourself and pack your effing bags, you've been let down and humiliated by too many people.... you deserve better 😞

ihadamarveloustime · 15/09/2023 19:10

He hit you. 3x. He hit you.

And there were sexual undertones to it as he smacked you on the bottom. 3 times.

and your husband wants you to move on?

Perhaps he should move back in with his father if he thinks this is ok and you have to put up with an insincere apology and a whitewashing of their continued poor treatment of you.

Please don't have children with him.

whynotwhatknot · 15/09/2023 19:08

You dont need an apology you need to stay the hell away from them

vingraitte · 15/09/2023 19:03

Do you have children OP? This is horrible.

SylvieB74 · 15/09/2023 18:55

Jesus Christ, just rinse and repeat what an absolute weirdo. I haven’t read through or anything but if you have kids I wouldn’t want them anywhere near him, if your husband’s still having a relationship with them. It sounds like he’s got the potential to be a total nonce.

IReallyStillCantBeBothered · 15/09/2023 18:48

Catza · 15/09/2023 09:43

This is a slightly tricky matter as under the British law an assault is "any act by which a person intentionally or recklessly causes another to suffer or apprehend immediate unlawful violence". So your husband may argue that since the intent wasn't violence, this would not constitute an assault.
There is clearly a case of "unwanted touch" which may or may not fall under sexual assault.
The bottom line is, your FIL's behaviour is inappropriate whatever you call it. And this is what your husband needs to get on board with, not how it is defined legally. I would be concerned that if your husband lets it slide, it may be highly likely he considers physical punishment and controlling behaviour towards children appropriate also. And this would definitely be an assault. I think you need to discuss this seriously before committing to an adoption.
Either way, he should not be forcing you to have a relationship with your family as this is also controlling behaviour. Whichever way you look at it, the situation sucks.

Unwanted touching and fondling is sexual assault under British law.

sharonarnott · 15/09/2023 18:40

It's a good job for him that it was your backside he slapped and not mine. He wouldn't have got up off of the floor for a week. Sorry but I wouldn't go anywhere near him again ever whether it upset my husband or not

JMSA · 15/09/2023 18:30

Crikey, what a horrible old perv.

YANBU Flowers