Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think all parents yell

171 replies

fit2023 · 14/09/2023 11:02

I am a 'gentle' parent (in quotation marks because the word means different things to different people) and I have yelled at my dc.

I always talk about it later with them. I take responsibility for my yelling, and tell them it's not their fault I have used my 'scary' voice.

When I feel like all is good (we have a strong connection again), I try and understand why they did/ said what they did before I lost it and suggest better ways for them to react next time I.e. correct their behaviour that way, with calm authority.

Posting this as often when a parent says 'I yelled at dc' they're being attacked on here.
We are all human and there's often many things going on for us. As long as we try and fix things as we go, think how to do things differently next time, we are doing parenting right.

OP posts:
LeavesOnTrees · 14/09/2023 12:10

I've yelled when they've absolutely had to stop something for their own safety, like running in the road, near water, playing with plugs / electricity etc.
I also yell when they start fighting with each other and a calm 'don't hit your sibling' is ignored.
It's always very specific and to stop a certain situation.

Otherwise they get my stern voice if the first few nicer attempts are ignored eg. 'you need to brush your teeth now'.

I will also yell from another room 'you need to turn the tv off, dinner's ready etc.

I don't think I know any parents who never yell. There's out of control yelling and there's 'you need to understand I'm being serious' yelling.

If they've been naughty I try to talk to them to explain why they've been naughty and hear their side of the story, which I think is much more effective.
In general my DC are well behaved so I think we're doing ok.

VelvetUndergrounds · 14/09/2023 12:08

Devilsmommy · 14/09/2023 12:07

Aaah the look😆 I remember that from my dad so well😁

I think I learnt it from my Dad!! 😂

BackToOklahoma · 14/09/2023 12:08

I don’t yell at my children or anyone else. I’ve only ever really shouted at a couple of people, who were abusive, and they’re not in my life now.

My first child was quite ‘spirited’, 😬so I obviously had to speak to him in a serious tone but I didn’t shout at him. My second child was always well behaved, did as we asked etc so has never needed it. She hates raised voices.

So no, I don’t think everyone yells. People are different, we’re just not a ‘shouty’ family.

My parents shouted constantly and I hated it.

Devilsmommy · 14/09/2023 12:07

VelvetUndergrounds · 14/09/2023 11:20

You'll get varying responses, I guess. My husband has never yelled at our children once (10yrs and 20yrs). Or raised his voice really. I can't say that I have 'yelled', I like to use 'the look' or some choice words. But I think both of our children very much don't like to get in trouble. Mind you, our daughter is just entering into the realm of pre-teenager-ness so is starting to push back a bit. The next few years will be interesting!

Aaah the look😆 I remember that from my dad so well😁

ManateeFair · 14/09/2023 12:06

TheBarbieEffect · 14/09/2023 11:23

Well no, I’ve never shouted or yelled at my child. I’ve never been that out of control.

Biscuit
SunRainStorm · 14/09/2023 12:06

My parents never yelled at me.

I've never yelled at my children.

I've used a stern voice, and I've definitely sounded crosser/more exasperated than I would have liked.

Yelling is abusive IMO. Especially to someone smaller than you.

fearfuloffluff · 14/09/2023 12:05

So what do you non-shouty perfect parents do when, for example, a child is being defiant of a punishment? Or in danger like running in front of a swing? Or pulling their sibling's hair? Or doing something gross and potentially unsafe?

You just stand there saying 'come on now let's stop that?'

CatamaranViper · 14/09/2023 12:04

I yell.

Yesterday I yelled at DS because he kept juggling his socks while I was repeatedly asking him to get ready for bed. It now takes him over half an hour to get changed in to pyjamas, brush his teeth and wash his face. I asked three times and other than going in and getting him ready myself (which is what he wants), I raised my voice and told him I was getting cross. Once I'm cross he loses a toy for a day.

I consider yelling to be raising your voice at all. I don't stand there screaming at him, I don't shout things that he shouldn't hear, I don't use bad language or call him names or put him down, I don't withhold love or affection. I always ask him why he does X, Y and Z and if he understand why it's frustrating etc. But he's 6. He's at home where he feel more comfortable pushing boundaries so of course he will. To me yelling is just showing that he is pushing it.

MaybeSeven · 14/09/2023 12:03

I hear you OP. I thought I'd be an endlessly patient parent; turns out I'm not. I'm mostly calm, but when I'm stressed and struggling on a range of fronts, sometimes something that happens at home just tips me over the edge and there is some shouting. It's not often, but it has happened. I do the best I can to reconnect afterwards and make sure they know it was a me problem not a them problem. I'm generally regarded as a soft touch (pushover) by the DC - they aren't scared of me or my reactions and that's how I want it to be.

SaltyandSweet · 14/09/2023 12:00

I do shout very occasionally but I am quick to apologise and talk about it with the kids. I think that if an infrequent shout isn't accompanied by nasty words and there is a conversation afterwards, it doesn't harm the kids (obvs not with regard to little ones). My own parents never shouted but my mother routinely said awful, belittling things in a perfectly normal tone of voice. That damaged me and our relationship significantly. I think the content of what's said is much more important than the volume (with the caveats above of course).

Brightandshining · 14/09/2023 12:00

People have different definitions of the word yell so its hard to tell.
Ice certainly never screamed in my kids faces but I've definitely raised my voice when its the fourth time I've told them to brush their teeth and they've just been messing about in the bathroom for 30mins instead.
I've got a 3rd on the way... its occasionally chaos
I imagine if you were a wealthy sahp to a NT well behaved only child its possible you may have never raised your voice ever and only ever used a gentle pleasant tone... but for most people I would agree we all at some point will have lost our rag and shouted.
Again tho people have different definitions of what constitutes shouting or yelling.
I've never scared my kids to the point of tears, or been absolutely screaming at them etc.. which might be some peoples definition of yelling. But I've said 'WHAT IS GOING ON HERE THIS IS ABSOLUTELY NOT ACCEPTABLE' in a very loud cross voice. Which I do define as shouting.
Neither me nor my husband are full on scream yelling people when we get upset though. I can count on my hand the times hes raised his voice in 11 years.. and I tend to cry when upset rather than shout.

N4ish · 14/09/2023 11:59

Snowpaw · 14/09/2023 11:43

"I try and understand why they did/ said what they did before I lost it and suggest better ways for them to react next time I.e. correct their behaviour that way, with calm authority".

The reflection with the children shouldn't be on what they did to cause you to yell. It should be on how you reached that point of loss of control and how you can avoid doing that next time.

I agree with this. Sounds like you’re blaming them for your loss of control.

Blackblueandgold · 14/09/2023 11:56

I've never yelled and neither did my parents.

fit2023 · 14/09/2023 11:56

Snowpaw · 14/09/2023 11:43

"I try and understand why they did/ said what they did before I lost it and suggest better ways for them to react next time I.e. correct their behaviour that way, with calm authority".

The reflection with the children shouldn't be on what they did to cause you to yell. It should be on how you reached that point of loss of control and how you can avoid doing that next time.

Yes. I intentionally didn't say they caused my yelling. It's not their fault and I say it to them. I apologise and say I'm working on that.

I probably had some piled up frustration already and, say, their refusal to do something which I saw as urgent at time time would make me go for my loud voice.

When we are both happy and calm I'll discuss their behaviour (unconnected to my yelling), starting with understanding from what's their feeling behind it to start with.

OP posts:
Moltenpink · 14/09/2023 11:55

I’ve never yelled. My parents never yelled at me. One look from my mother was all that was needed, I’m not that strict but definitely not a yeller

I had to shout for help a couple of years ago and it felt so odd, it was literally the only time I could remember raising my voice that much. I almost didn’t know how to do it!

readbooksdrinktea · 14/09/2023 11:55

I think raising your voice now and again is a healthy thing, the parents I know who never yell actually have this creepy passive aggressive barely-contained frustration thing going on.

I see this with gentle-parenting friends. They're beyond frustrated.

Having said that, my parents never yelled. One look from them was enough. We knew there was a line.

felisha54 · 14/09/2023 11:54

I've never yelled or shouted at my dd(12). I have been stern with her but never felt so cross that I've had to raise my voice. There still time though ...

Hollyhead · 14/09/2023 11:54

I had to ask my 12 year old to brush his teeth 7 times last night, I then found him tickling his brother without his brother’s consent (no, stop, stop tickling me etc) instead of doing his teeth. How does anyone not lose their shit in that situation?! And although I did apologise, I personally think he has to take some responsibility too!

SaySomethingMan · 14/09/2023 11:53

I’m sure i’ve yelled at dc at some point. I don’t remember when.

i don’t know if all parents yell but it’ll be uncommon for men to do so generally because women carry the burden of parenting in many households.

I have a colleague whose dad would wait for his mum to come home and give him consequences if he behaved badly while she was out …

Desecratedcoconut · 14/09/2023 11:53

I've shouted when shouting was necessary - to get attention from far away or to convey danger - "stop running with those scissors!" type thing. I've never yelled at them when they were right next to me and they weren't about to come to harm...I've never yelled at them to put them in place, if that's what you mean?

Howtohideasausage · 14/09/2023 11:53

I don’t have time to for long ‘Oscar, mummy wants you to think about what you’re doing’. Sometimes a quick ‘stop it’ is all it needs.

Howtohideasausage · 14/09/2023 11:52

I yelled at my five year old this morning as he wandered into the road.

My mum used to shout at me, long shouty rants berating me for ages.

Those are two different things. I talk very sternly to my kids (eldest is 11) if I need to (ex teacher). I don’t rant at them. Sometimes I shout ‘put you shoes on!’ If it’s the 8th time of asking. I don’t do tirades.

MissInterpretation · 14/09/2023 11:50

I've never had to yell at anyone until last week when I saw some bullying going in a grassed area near a busy road where I was stuck in traffic. I shouted in my loudest ever voice across several lanes of traffic and to my shock the bigger boy stopped hurting the smaller boy and off they went. I shocked myself as I have never had to even raise my voice with my kids, so this was a first!

I think I'm really lucky to have very laid back kids who seem to want to stay out of trouble. I also think that yelling can be really counterproductive if you do it too much. One of my neighbours is constantly yelling at his kids, and they are genuinely doing nothing wrong, just playing, but he wears their names out and you can see them just switching off. Kids who are constantly shouted out soon learn to tune out of it. But if you're usually quite chilled out, as soon as you do have to say no or give them 'the look,' they know you mean it.

fearfuloffluff · 14/09/2023 11:50

I think raising your voice now and again is a healthy thing, the parents I know who never yell actually have this creepy passive aggressive barely-contained frustration thing going on.

Kid throws something at your head when they're of an age to understand that's a shitty thing to do. Entirely reasonable to yell at them.

I also think it's culturally specific, UK/US gentle parenting stuff makes being always super calm a goal to achieve - other cultures would see this as a bit cold and stiff, letting it all hang out is arguably emotionally healthier. I know Italian, Portuguese, South African parents who all voice anger spontaneously, does the kids no harm. Kids are smart enough to tell a parent who is frustrated and annoyed from one who is aggressive and out of control.

Likeaburstcouch · 14/09/2023 11:49

Unfortunately I have a short temper so I do sometimes lose control and shout when stressed eg getting them both out of the house in the morning. I really try not to.