Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what one or two policies you think could make the biggest difference to the U.K.?

411 replies

whatkatydid2013 · 14/09/2023 07:36

To me the big one is social housing. I feel like if we could build up a large supply of social housing at reasonable rates all over the country the benefits would be massive. It would make life affordable for many more people and lead to them being less likely to need in work benefits. The affordable rents would cover maintenance and could keep large numbers of people in stable employment doing said maintenance (as well as creating administrative roles). It would make it less challenging to staff key worker roles in more expensive areas. In the short term I appreciate it would be a massive expense but it seems like in the long term it would cost less than our current system on a going basis and it would make many people a lot more financially secure. I find it disappointing that all main parties seem so focused on home ownership in their policy statements. I know there are many important policy areas but this just always feels like one that’s very central and totally glossed over by all parties. Maybe because there isn’t a quick, easy fix?

OP posts:
shearwater · 14/09/2023 11:25

National service is a good idea but should be entirely voluntary, can be done at any age from say 14 to 25 and encompass a wide range of roles which benefits society and not just the military. And they should be paid for it.

I certainly wouldn't have wanted to interrupt two years of my life and stop studying and working and certainly not for military service. Being the oldest in the school year I was already 19 when I went to university, I did a four year degree, worked FT for a couple of years, went back to university for a year FT while working PT, did two years of workplace training and finally qualified at 28.

So I think it might be a very good idea indeed, particular for those who are disenchanted with school, and particularly if it is seen as a really positive thing to do on you CV. But it has to be voluntary, people have different life paths and I'd want to add to young people's options not make them do things that I would have hated.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 14/09/2023 11:24

BygoneDays · 14/09/2023 10:55

My English teacher, who I respected enormously, did National Service. He described the tedium, the pettiness, the bullying, the abuse, the humiliations, the capricious nastiness, and much more, in angry and excruciating detail. He described it as 2 years stolen from his life.

My late Dad did it and described it much the same way, including the suicide of the ones who couldn’t take it.
As for enforcing it - we have pretty much zero enforcement of anything but the most serious crimes now, it’s fanciful to imagine we could make the feral youth comply.

whatkatydid2013 · 14/09/2023 11:22

LastHives · 14/09/2023 08:24

Are you all willing to pay massive taxes for all of these things?

I’d be willing to pay increased tax to be ringfenced for spending on social housing, education and health services (in particular mental health/dentistry). Ultimately though with some of these things you are taking of a one off investment vs an ongoing cost. Once you had more social housing available and you stopped selling it via right to buy then you’d have it forever and have rent coming in to use to maintain it. If the occupiers were not paying the rent then it would still surely be cheaper for government to fund maintaining property vs funding those people to rent privately.

OP posts:
sheflieswithherownwings · 14/09/2023 11:19

Increasing wages / salaries to above inflation.. wages are low in the UK compared to other developed nations which means people are sometimes choosing, understandably, not to work because they'll lose out (e.g losing benefits if you work above a certain number of hours). Better earning power would mean people have more options with regards to housing / where to live etc.. not an simple one to fix though.

Also, schools.. there needs to be a huge re-think on how schools are run - it really is failing many children. I would love to see more options open up for kids who need a more relaxed approach to learning eg homeschool type hubs that are State-funded, or apprentice/hands on-type education from a younger age, rather than expecting ALL children to conform to a very rigid idea of what education should be. I'm not saying do away with formal learning, (it definitely suits some kids, my DS included) but it is not one size fits all, which is what this and many other governments seem to believe. Don't see this happening any time soon though.

lavender2023 · 14/09/2023 11:18

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 14/09/2023 11:11

I’d say reduce the population over coming decades by 10-20% (and no, not by killing people…)

The population density in the UK is too high, and the quality of life for all would be improved were it smaller.

Incentivise people without medical issues to not have children in their twenties, to only have two, and to gain the skills first that will allow them to support them well.

average age a woman has a child is already 30.

Many of the people who have children and are struggling already have skills i.e. nurses. The way to earn money nowadays is to work in commercial law, tech, finance or as a doctor. In these industries, you will earn above national average easily as a 25 year old and consider 60k a low wage (I know my DH does despite earning £75k)

With the exception of law and medicine,you don't always need a degree and if you do have a degree, it is often in something generic. What matters is often your location as such jobs are mostly located in London, manchester, edinburgh as well as your ability to perform at interviews. Not skills at least from the onset. What matters is experience which allows you to develop the skills but you need to get your foot in the door! I just read an article about a 28 year old on £70k who basically always worked in operations for an education tech company in London, so nothing glam at all or particularly high skilled.

What is the issue isn't always the skills, but the fact that outside of London and the SE, the country is closer to Eastern Europe than a Western European country so industries which rely on domestic demand and the salaries of public servants (nhs staff and civil servants) cannot pay well. Hence why you get an executive assistant for a hedge fund earning as much as £90k which is more than many doctors or highly qualified professionals in the regions. The discrepancy in salaries and gdp per capita is not going to be solved with anti-natalist policies and it isn't up to the individual either.

SensationalSusie · 14/09/2023 11:18

shearwater · 14/09/2023 11:10

I know of someone who was socially housed when in dire need, but was never reviewed. So they stayed there throughout the completion of two degrees, when in employment and when married. Rent £300 a month, annual household income £50-60k… they got an enormous discount via right to buy and were able to buy a 300k house via this.

Good for them, they became well educated and got a good job. I don't agree with Right to Buy, certainly not when the social housing asset is not replaced, but I wouldn't begrudge anyone their good fortune in this way. Society should not have to be a race to the bottom.

@shearwater it is not begrudging - they got the same student loans/grants and had a part time job just like everyone else. But their housing was subsidised by the government for no reason for over a decade. And they were essentially given a five figure deposit from the government via right to buy, again for no reason. I do think the system is wrong. A family in need could have been in the house.

LakieLady · 14/09/2023 11:18

Imtoooldforallthis · 14/09/2023 08:16

Government run care homes to the standard of private ones.

Central or local government?

Care homes used to be run by councils, who paid staff a fair wage for caring for them and they had decent conditions of service. Not like now, when many homes are now running a 2-shift system so staff have to do 12 hour shifts, get the legal minimum leave, pisspoor pensions and about 20p an hour above NMW.

I would merge adult social care and the NHS.

At present, there's a disincentive for ASC to be prompt in carrying out assessments and making provision for people ready to be discharged from hospital. The minute they're discharged ASC has to meet their needs in terms of care, whether it's provided in the community or in a residential setting. The longer the council can delay assessing their needs and making the necessary provision for discharge from hospital, the less it costs them and the more it costs the NHS.

With some people waiting several weeks before they can be discharged from hospital because of delays in assessment and making provision, the cost to the NHS must be significant and it has a knock-on effect on waiting lists because of bed-blocking.

If it was all under one roof, so to speak, I bet that discharge planning and getting care plans in place would be much quicker.

whatkatydid2013 · 14/09/2023 11:16

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 14/09/2023 07:56

I think social housing is a good call. I would look at policies around integrated public transport across the country. I am in London and for all it’s faults TFL (Transport for London) does bring a degree of coordination and integration to the system eg The same season tickets / weekly and monthly fare caps apply across multiple modes of transport. So if I catch a bus, TFL Rail and the Tube in the same day each journey counts towards the daily fare cap and one the cap is reached you stop paying.
There are bus stops outside Tube stations, area not covered by Tube or TFL rail will often have good bus routes. There are interchange stations between tube lines and also between tube and TFL rail.

If you want people to drive less, first improve public transport

I love this idea. You definitely need a carrot to change behaviour on using other forms of transport. Just making it harder/more expensive to drive with no alternative doesn’t help

OP posts:
SayingwhatIreallythink · 14/09/2023 11:14

BygoneDays · 14/09/2023 10:55

My English teacher, who I respected enormously, did National Service. He described the tedium, the pettiness, the bullying, the abuse, the humiliations, the capricious nastiness, and much more, in angry and excruciating detail. He described it as 2 years stolen from his life.

But if it’s an alternative to education or work then it’s aimed at those who would otherwise drop out of society.

SensationalSusie · 14/09/2023 11:13

shearwater · 14/09/2023 11:02

Hear hear!

@DivingForLove aware that in certain parts of the U.K. there are people with vast amounts of unearned wealth tied up in property - mainly as a symptom of a broken housing market and overinflated house prices, never mind luck. That wealth is not guaranteed and concrete unless you sell it and stick it in a bank.

My point is, if someone has worked, paid their taxes and purchased an asset, it is up to them what they do with that asset without it being up for a further enormous tax grab in the event of their death.

fearfuloffluff · 14/09/2023 11:13

SensationalSusie · 14/09/2023 11:03

@DynamicK I am with @SayingwhatIreallythink

Social housing should not be some cushy set up provided by the government to allow people to put down roots and plant gardens.

It should be an emergency situation there for people who are struggling and in dire need. There while it is required and given up when circumstances improve.

I know of someone who was socially housed when in dire need, but was never reviewed. So they stayed there throughout the completion of two degrees, when in employment and when married. Rent £300 a month, annual household income £50-60k… they got an enormous discount via right to buy and were able to buy a 300k house via this.

So again, I reiterate social housing should be needs based and reviewed every few years or you are going to have people taking the absolute piss as they are at the moment. Right to buy needs to go too.

What you suggest has several problems @SensationalSusie

Firstly, if social housing is only for those in dire need it would increase the stigma of it and lead to it being seen as for people with addiction problems, homelessness, just out of prison etc - you'd either get sink estates or very hostile neighbours

The housing would probably also cost more to maintain as tenants would be less likely to take care of it, and tenant turnover would be quicker so less incentive to look after it

Also if someone just about got on their feet after a crisis then the minute they get to a more stable place, they're pushed back into private renting and have to move to a different area, it's fairly likely to cause hardship and many would go back into crisis before too long

What you really want is enough social housing so you can build strong communities where people are proud to live there and take care of each other, feel a bit of pride that encourages them to take up education etc

You make it sound like a probation hostel, basically

shearwater · 14/09/2023 11:12

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 14/09/2023 11:11

I’d say reduce the population over coming decades by 10-20% (and no, not by killing people…)

The population density in the UK is too high, and the quality of life for all would be improved were it smaller.

Incentivise people without medical issues to not have children in their twenties, to only have two, and to gain the skills first that will allow them to support them well.

And how do you propose to resolve the demographic crisis?

The birth rate is really low in the UK and in most countries in the world.

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 14/09/2023 11:11

I’d say reduce the population over coming decades by 10-20% (and no, not by killing people…)

The population density in the UK is too high, and the quality of life for all would be improved were it smaller.

Incentivise people without medical issues to not have children in their twenties, to only have two, and to gain the skills first that will allow them to support them well.

lavender2023 · 14/09/2023 11:10

I would say social housing but realistically we would not be able to build enough of it quickly enough.

I think the government should fund cooperatives where groups of individuals buy up housing and rent it out at affordable rates earmarked to local incomes. There could be student cooperatives as well. Some of them could be for sale too. Crucially if its for sale, it should only be allowed to be resold to people on the median local income or below. This would help the government buy up those ex BTL rentals at a quicker rate (cos there would be some private funds involved in this initiative). Apparently half of landlords want to sell in the next few years so this is a good opportunity.

shearwater · 14/09/2023 11:10

I know of someone who was socially housed when in dire need, but was never reviewed. So they stayed there throughout the completion of two degrees, when in employment and when married. Rent £300 a month, annual household income £50-60k… they got an enormous discount via right to buy and were able to buy a 300k house via this.

Good for them, they became well educated and got a good job. I don't agree with Right to Buy, certainly not when the social housing asset is not replaced, but I wouldn't begrudge anyone their good fortune in this way. Society should not have to be a race to the bottom.

Pottedpalm · 14/09/2023 11:09

Cap the obscene ‘wages’ paid to footballers.

shearwater · 14/09/2023 11:06

SensationalSusie · 14/09/2023 11:03

@DynamicK I am with @SayingwhatIreallythink

Social housing should not be some cushy set up provided by the government to allow people to put down roots and plant gardens.

It should be an emergency situation there for people who are struggling and in dire need. There while it is required and given up when circumstances improve.

I know of someone who was socially housed when in dire need, but was never reviewed. So they stayed there throughout the completion of two degrees, when in employment and when married. Rent £300 a month, annual household income £50-60k… they got an enormous discount via right to buy and were able to buy a 300k house via this.

So again, I reiterate social housing should be needs based and reviewed every few years or you are going to have people taking the absolute piss as they are at the moment. Right to buy needs to go too.

I completely disagree. Social housing should be part of the fabric of society and should definitely not just be for emergencies. That's certainly not how the system was created and I think it should be available to anyone within a certain range of lower paid but much required jobs.

LakieLady · 14/09/2023 11:05

hattie43 · 14/09/2023 07:47

To make every able bodied person make a positive contribution. We definitely aren't all in it together .

Eradicate crime and anti social behaviour.

What about those who are able-bodied but have learning disabilities, ASCs or MH issues that would make it difficult or make their issues worse if they had to make a "contribution"?

Sounds horribly like "workfare" to me.

SensationalSusie · 14/09/2023 11:03

DynamicK · 14/09/2023 10:51

People need security and stability. They make friends and have a community. Their home has memories. They many have invested financially and established a garden.
A home isn't just 4 walls.

@DynamicK I am with @SayingwhatIreallythink

Social housing should not be some cushy set up provided by the government to allow people to put down roots and plant gardens.

It should be an emergency situation there for people who are struggling and in dire need. There while it is required and given up when circumstances improve.

I know of someone who was socially housed when in dire need, but was never reviewed. So they stayed there throughout the completion of two degrees, when in employment and when married. Rent £300 a month, annual household income £50-60k… they got an enormous discount via right to buy and were able to buy a 300k house via this.

So again, I reiterate social housing should be needs based and reviewed every few years or you are going to have people taking the absolute piss as they are at the moment. Right to buy needs to go too.

shearwater · 14/09/2023 11:02

DivingForLove · 14/09/2023 11:00

@SensationalSusie can we stop with the correlation between “hard work” and wealth. It is utter bullshit. We have a house that’s worth over £1 million not because we’ve worked harder than our friends but because we made some savvy choices about house purchases and got lucky.

There are many millions of people in this country sat on huge wealth - and many millions who aren’t. It’s not because they worked harder - it’s partly down to life choices and partly down to luck.

This government has played the narrative for years that those with ££ are hard working and those without are lazy. It makes me so fucking angry.

Hear hear!

shearwater · 14/09/2023 11:02

Education - massive change to the state education system as Finland did, should be one of the top priorities.

DivingForLove · 14/09/2023 11:00

@SensationalSusie can we stop with the correlation between “hard work” and wealth. It is utter bullshit. We have a house that’s worth over £1 million not because we’ve worked harder than our friends but because we made some savvy choices about house purchases and got lucky.

There are many millions of people in this country sat on huge wealth - and many millions who aren’t. It’s not because they worked harder - it’s partly down to life choices and partly down to luck.

This government has played the narrative for years that those with ££ are hard working and those without are lazy. It makes me so fucking angry.

BygoneDays · 14/09/2023 10:58

1dayatatime · 14/09/2023 10:50

@CapEBarra

"Make politicians accountable for their lies.

Make newspapers fact check their stories.

Drain the swamp and restore trust the press and politics. I don’t have to like them, but I should be able to believe them."

+++

But politicians have to lie because if they didn't then no one would vote for them and they would simply have been a candidate rather than a politician.

Look let's say there are two candidates:
Candidate A promises more spending on popular areas eg NHS but it will mean higher taxes for everyone.
Candidate B promises more spending on popular areas but says (ie lies) that they will get the money from some ill defined concept such as "cutting waste", ""closing tax loopholes " or "growing the economy " - but definitely not increasing taxes.

Guess which one gets voted in? It's not the politicians fault for lying but the electorate for voting for "the cake and eat it".

And the biggest liars get the most votes.
Boris Johnson.

BygoneDays · 14/09/2023 10:55

LizardLizard · 14/09/2023 09:02

I’m not saying I necessarily support military service, but I’m intrigued as to why you consider it to be ridiculous and unenforceable? Other countries do it, as did the UK at one time.

My English teacher, who I respected enormously, did National Service. He described the tedium, the pettiness, the bullying, the abuse, the humiliations, the capricious nastiness, and much more, in angry and excruciating detail. He described it as 2 years stolen from his life.

SensationalSusie · 14/09/2023 10:53

rumnraisinrocks · 14/09/2023 10:40

Increase inheritance tax and bring in legislation to stop the various ways people, usually the incredibly wealthy, avoid it

It should be paid to some extent from anything above about £10k.
Something like:
£10k to £100k at 10‰
$100k to £200k at 20%
200k to 400k at 30%
400k to 1.5m at 40‰
1.5m up at 50%

Make it easier for the tax to be paid once property is sold, rather than people having to find the money for IHT before they can release the proceeds. It could be settled from the proceeds before solicitors release the funds.

@rumnraisinrocks I really don’t agree with this, you’re asking for things to be taxed twice.

ie. Say the inheritance is a house, the money that paid for it came from income that had been taxed. Then you’re wanting it to be taxed again, highly, upon the death of the person. It is their money and they should be able to do as they wish; they have worked hard and paid tax.

There could also be more problems with settlement of estates, deficits, and homelessness caused by this so I don’t think it’s a good call and punishes people for working hard to build wealth.

Swipe left for the next trending thread