Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what one or two policies you think could make the biggest difference to the U.K.?

411 replies

whatkatydid2013 · 14/09/2023 07:36

To me the big one is social housing. I feel like if we could build up a large supply of social housing at reasonable rates all over the country the benefits would be massive. It would make life affordable for many more people and lead to them being less likely to need in work benefits. The affordable rents would cover maintenance and could keep large numbers of people in stable employment doing said maintenance (as well as creating administrative roles). It would make it less challenging to staff key worker roles in more expensive areas. In the short term I appreciate it would be a massive expense but it seems like in the long term it would cost less than our current system on a going basis and it would make many people a lot more financially secure. I find it disappointing that all main parties seem so focused on home ownership in their policy statements. I know there are many important policy areas but this just always feels like one that’s very central and totally glossed over by all parties. Maybe because there isn’t a quick, easy fix?

OP posts:
shearwater · 14/09/2023 11:48

Yes, I think people should be encouraged to become MPs when they have life and work experience (particularly in blue collar sectors and SMEs) and don't come from the professional classes and do the standard PPE degree, professional adviser route.

ohfook · 14/09/2023 11:48

A ban on companies that pay their employees so poorly that they have to top their income up with UC.

I'd be massively in favour of the highest paid person in any company only ever being able to be paid X times higher than the lowest paid employee.

AmIAutumnalNow · 14/09/2023 11:47

Tougher action on "low level" crime and anti social behaviour.

These things matter to, and affect, the majority of people

ohfook · 14/09/2023 11:46

Where possible, Government ministers having a professional background in the department they are "head" of... a health minister had been a doctor or hospital administrator, a defence minister that had served in the Forces, an education minister who had been a teacher... it wouldn't always be possible, but even some would help!
*
⬆️* this suggested by another poster above all others. I fail to understand how you can successfully lead a profession or an industry with literally no knowledge of the problems the people on the ground face.

Free childcare.

A thorough review of our education system and a look at culturally similar countries that are doing better than us.

Grants or interest free loans for solar panels and electric cars and other mega expensive things that may benefit the environment.

A ban (or a limit) on cheap crap imported from China - Shein/Temu etc.

shearwater · 14/09/2023 11:45

SensationalSusie · 14/09/2023 11:30

@fearfuloffluff

being seen as for people with addiction problems, homelessness, just out of prison etc

This is basically the definition of the way social housing is seen where I am, and everyone I have ever known to live in social housing (if you add in domestic abuse victims, single mothers, asylum seekers, disabled, benefit claimants making a career out of it)

I think that’s why I don’t like the idea of an expansion of it as it enables a lifestyle that is just not healthy and problems for surrounding neighbourhoods.

If they could turn it into a lovely beacon of community pride as you describe well that would be wonderful.

But my impression is of estates ruined by drugs and deprivation… with the odd chancer wiggling in there to make money via right to buy.

I don't have that impression at all but it can be the way, largely due to bad planning/design and policy. With things done better integrated social housing can be amazing. My grandparents had a normal terraced house which they rented from the council all their lives, brought up two children, until they retired and eventually died. My GM did part time factory work and GF worked for the electricity board. It was just a solution for people doing working class not particularly well paid jobs to be able to afford housing. No doubt people did use right to buy on the street and I expect some were privately owned. It was a perfectly nice street to live on, even with its own set of shops in the middle.

I also live in a former council house that we bought privately (not right to buy) but someone would have done RTB in the past in order for it to pass into the private sector. The houses were built for keyworkers at a local MOD site in the 1950s. Most are privately owned now but there are a number of social housing properties still on the road, mainly inhabited by young families, elderly people and people with a disability. It's not a sink estate or rough and a very nice community. It also not always apparent which houses are private and which belong to the housing association.

lavender2023 · 14/09/2023 11:43

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 14/09/2023 11:40

But my policy was nothing to do with increasing GDP per capita.

I also can’t agree that there’s anything wrong with me paying my PA £90k per year, it’s a fair price for the way it frees up my time.

DH has two on a similar rate, and a team of three with the more elevated title if “business manager” who are on a lot more as they free him up to only work where he can add good value to the company.

there is nothing wrong with paying your PA £90k if you can afford it.

But it is far more than the average income in the country. It is an illustration of the inequality in the country which is what is making it poorer. The wealth is concentrated in certain industries. You can't pay a PA in a regional Midlands firm or in the NHS 90k because it just doesn't make good financial sense. You can pay a PA 90k in a hedge fund when the portfolio managers are earning millions.

loislovesstewie · 14/09/2023 11:43

If this has already been said,sorry, but I would stop the RTB on social housing.

SensationalSusie · 14/09/2023 11:42

lavender2023 · 14/09/2023 11:10

I would say social housing but realistically we would not be able to build enough of it quickly enough.

I think the government should fund cooperatives where groups of individuals buy up housing and rent it out at affordable rates earmarked to local incomes. There could be student cooperatives as well. Some of them could be for sale too. Crucially if its for sale, it should only be allowed to be resold to people on the median local income or below. This would help the government buy up those ex BTL rentals at a quicker rate (cos there would be some private funds involved in this initiative). Apparently half of landlords want to sell in the next few years so this is a good opportunity.

Edited

@lavender2023
I really like this idea. I think a cooperative and keeping out wealthy investors from elsewhere is a great idea!

Ginmonkeyagain · 14/09/2023 11:41

@shearwater no you misunderstand me. At the moment the estate owes the IHT if it is above a certain threshold. I would tax the person receiving the inheritance as income. So it would be treated like other forms of income including work bonuses.

There would be a tax free allowance of £10k or so to allow for sentimental items and small bequests. As I noted I would also have a tax free carve out for people inheriting all or part of their primary residence.

Why do I say this? Because how is it fiar that someone who earn say £100k thorugh their labour is taxed, whereas someone who ges £100k because a relative died gets the whole lot.

lavender2023 · 14/09/2023 11:40

SensationalSusie · 14/09/2023 11:13

@DivingForLove aware that in certain parts of the U.K. there are people with vast amounts of unearned wealth tied up in property - mainly as a symptom of a broken housing market and overinflated house prices, never mind luck. That wealth is not guaranteed and concrete unless you sell it and stick it in a bank.

My point is, if someone has worked, paid their taxes and purchased an asset, it is up to them what they do with that asset without it being up for a further enormous tax grab in the event of their death.

the problem with this is that if you are able to pass £1 million to your child tax free, so can far richer people which completely skews the game. So if you own the average house which is around £280k, you may feel proud about being able to pass it to your child, but then I own a £400k london flat and my DH is a third generation Londoner (his mum and grandfather all own houses in London, he will not inherit but lets just say he somehow does because there are kids like that who are only children), our future child could potentially inherit millions and this would mean that whatever most kids inherit is completely meaningless compared to this very high amount.

When rich people get richer, you get poorer, that is the reality. Cos wealth is all relative.

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 14/09/2023 11:40

lavender2023 · 14/09/2023 11:18

average age a woman has a child is already 30.

Many of the people who have children and are struggling already have skills i.e. nurses. The way to earn money nowadays is to work in commercial law, tech, finance or as a doctor. In these industries, you will earn above national average easily as a 25 year old and consider 60k a low wage (I know my DH does despite earning £75k)

With the exception of law and medicine,you don't always need a degree and if you do have a degree, it is often in something generic. What matters is often your location as such jobs are mostly located in London, manchester, edinburgh as well as your ability to perform at interviews. Not skills at least from the onset. What matters is experience which allows you to develop the skills but you need to get your foot in the door! I just read an article about a 28 year old on £70k who basically always worked in operations for an education tech company in London, so nothing glam at all or particularly high skilled.

What is the issue isn't always the skills, but the fact that outside of London and the SE, the country is closer to Eastern Europe than a Western European country so industries which rely on domestic demand and the salaries of public servants (nhs staff and civil servants) cannot pay well. Hence why you get an executive assistant for a hedge fund earning as much as £90k which is more than many doctors or highly qualified professionals in the regions. The discrepancy in salaries and gdp per capita is not going to be solved with anti-natalist policies and it isn't up to the individual either.

Edited

But my policy was nothing to do with increasing GDP per capita.

I also can’t agree that there’s anything wrong with me paying my PA £90k per year, it’s a fair price for the way it frees up my time.

DH has two on a similar rate, and a team of three with the more elevated title if “business manager” who are on a lot more as they free him up to only work where he can add good value to the company.

whatkatydid2013 · 14/09/2023 11:36

Gazelda · 14/09/2023 09:39

Combine NHS with social care and properly fund,

Address housing crisis. Both owned and rented.

There are other critical issues that need addressing (education, climate change, crime, equality etc) but I don't think any will be properly tackled until we get the basics of housing and health sorted.

Combine NHS with social care and properly fund

Yes it seems like the lack of integration with social care is one of the biggest issues for the NHS. Inspite of comments about how we can’t keep pumping money in U.K. actually spends relatively less per capita on healthcare than Scandinavia, US, Canada, Germany & others. France & Finland spend less & by all accounts have decent systems so definitely seems like it’s worth looking at what they do differently and to what extent it could work here. It’s also unsurprising there is a need to spend more with increasing life expectancy and more elderly people.

OP posts:
FirstYouGetTheMoney · 14/09/2023 11:35

shearwater · 14/09/2023 11:12

And how do you propose to resolve the demographic crisis?

The birth rate is really low in the UK and in most countries in the world.

By continuing to increase pension age in line with healthy lifespan, and by accepting that we’ll need to increase pay and improve conditions in health and care services to ensure a good ratio of people happy to take care of the elderly.

The Ponzi scheme of continuously increasing the population by bringing in ever-more young immigrants is a terrible alternative.

anniegun · 14/09/2023 11:35

Make social housing a viable option for all families. Just build the things- stop making excuses and stop selling them off

shearwater · 14/09/2023 11:34

@Ginmonkeyagain Inheritance tax already exists and falls to a lot more people than it would have previously as it hasn't been adjusted in line with property prices.

I think it's not perfect but reasonably fair as it is, I certainly wouldn't scrap it but I wouldn't increase it- and actually at 40% over a certain threshold it is greater than the income tax threshold for many people, though obviously the threshold before it gets paid is much greater.

Plus it would be political suicide, no party would propose it. And I don't think it would work in terms of releasing properties into the market instead of people inheriting them or bring in a lot more tax revenue as there are always way round these things.

A massive social housing building programme and therefore no housing shortage would affect the property market a lot more bring down prices and bring more people into IHT thresholds.

LakieLady · 14/09/2023 11:34

Have much tougher policies about Job seekers forcing more into employment or their JS allowance is stopped. This creates swathes of jobs and fills lots of job vacancies.

As someone with some experiencing of challenging work coaches' sanction decisions regarding looking for work, and with 100% success rate in such challenges, I can assure you that the policy is not only tough enough, but is often applied in a completely unreasonable way.

towriteyoumustlive · 14/09/2023 11:32

I agree with having far more social housing, but I also think private rents needs to be more in line with social housing rents with much longer tenancies offered rather than just 12 months. Lots of Europe have 3 or 5 year tenancies.

As we currently have so few social houses and very long waiting lists, I'd also increase social rents with salary. Money raised could then be used to build/buy more social housing. e.g. A friend of mine has a joint family income of £80k and pay such a tiny amount for their 2 bed social house and just one child. And yet another friend is paying over double that for private rental and yet they earn only £35k between them and struggle to afford to run a car.

I'd also make parents take more responsibility for the education and behaviour of their children. I'm always shocked at how many parents are just not interested in interacting with their kids and leave all learning and discipline to the school.

PinkRoses1245 · 14/09/2023 11:31

Pay per mile road taxation. And a very high tax on ultra processed food, used to reduce the price of non processed foods

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 14/09/2023 11:31

BygoneDays · 14/09/2023 10:55

My English teacher, who I respected enormously, did National Service. He described the tedium, the pettiness, the bullying, the abuse, the humiliations, the capricious nastiness, and much more, in angry and excruciating detail. He described it as 2 years stolen from his life.

I was certain you were going to end that with “he said it reminded him of his time in national service.”

SensationalSusie · 14/09/2023 11:30

fearfuloffluff · 14/09/2023 11:13

What you suggest has several problems @SensationalSusie

Firstly, if social housing is only for those in dire need it would increase the stigma of it and lead to it being seen as for people with addiction problems, homelessness, just out of prison etc - you'd either get sink estates or very hostile neighbours

The housing would probably also cost more to maintain as tenants would be less likely to take care of it, and tenant turnover would be quicker so less incentive to look after it

Also if someone just about got on their feet after a crisis then the minute they get to a more stable place, they're pushed back into private renting and have to move to a different area, it's fairly likely to cause hardship and many would go back into crisis before too long

What you really want is enough social housing so you can build strong communities where people are proud to live there and take care of each other, feel a bit of pride that encourages them to take up education etc

You make it sound like a probation hostel, basically

@fearfuloffluff

being seen as for people with addiction problems, homelessness, just out of prison etc

This is basically the definition of the way social housing is seen where I am, and everyone I have ever known to live in social housing (if you add in domestic abuse victims, single mothers, asylum seekers, disabled, benefit claimants making a career out of it)

I think that’s why I don’t like the idea of an expansion of it as it enables a lifestyle that is just not healthy and problems for surrounding neighbourhoods.

If they could turn it into a lovely beacon of community pride as you describe well that would be wonderful.

But my impression is of estates ruined by drugs and deprivation… with the odd chancer wiggling in there to make money via right to buy.

fearfuloffluff · 14/09/2023 11:30

Also trains renationalised and fares made reasonable, maybe priced per mile.

The cost to travel by train is ludicrous in this country! I'd love to travel more in farther flung parts of the country but it's much more expensive than flying around Europe.

lavender2023 · 14/09/2023 11:28

whatkatydid2013 · 14/09/2023 11:22

I’d be willing to pay increased tax to be ringfenced for spending on social housing, education and health services (in particular mental health/dentistry). Ultimately though with some of these things you are taking of a one off investment vs an ongoing cost. Once you had more social housing available and you stopped selling it via right to buy then you’d have it forever and have rent coming in to use to maintain it. If the occupiers were not paying the rent then it would still surely be cheaper for government to fund maintaining property vs funding those people to rent privately.

the issue is that at some point under our two party system, the tories will come back into power and they will sell it off. They hate social housing and they will market it as right to buy 2.0. They are already planning this as part of their comeback (after they lose the election next year so probably in 2029). I think they did a survey on social tenants before and something like 50% of them would prefer to own (despite having lower incomes and probably less ability to pay for things like broken boilers and roofs). This percentage would probably increase if the economy improves. I guess we all want what we can't have and its easy to underestimate the costs of owning esp when home ownership is so embedded in the British psyche.

So while I support social housing, the fact that the tories would continue to be an electoral force means we need to approach it differently. Can't put all your eggs in one basket, hence why I support independently run cooperatives. If the system is more dispersed and diverse, it is more difficult to dismantle. Make it as unravellable as possible.

LakieLady · 14/09/2023 11:28

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 14/09/2023 08:06

All essential services to be state owned and run for service not profit. Water, power, gas, rail, phone, internet etc. Utilities perhaps a state option with private companies permitted to compete alongside.

Public transport to be made frequent, cheap, capacious, and fully integrated everywhere. Swiss transport ethos comes to the UK.

I'm up for all of that! I used to work for one of the regional gas suppliers pre-privatisation. They had to get permission from the government if they wanted to increase prices above a certain threshold and if they made too big a surplus they had to pay it to the govt where it went in to the general pot. That meant they spent excess money on improving infrastructure and keeping costs down.

I also worked briefly for the "water board", which in my area was run by the council. They were also required to keep prices reasonable and were allowed to borrow cheaply from the govt when they needed to replace a treatment works and a pumping station.

It's interesting to see that so many of the suggestions on here are in favour of reinstating the arrangements that were in place in the 60s and 70s when I was a child/young adult.

Ginmonkeyagain · 14/09/2023 11:26

A proper integrated high speed rail network.

Tax inheritance as income (exemptions for someone inheriting part or all of their primary residence)

Zipps · 14/09/2023 11:25

Huge increase in public transport and tax to hell anyone in a big 4x4.
Investing in schools so that all abilities and interests are encouraged and can be successful not just those on the road to university. Less emphasis on exams and more emphasis on actual skills.