Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what one or two policies you think could make the biggest difference to the U.K.?

411 replies

whatkatydid2013 · 14/09/2023 07:36

To me the big one is social housing. I feel like if we could build up a large supply of social housing at reasonable rates all over the country the benefits would be massive. It would make life affordable for many more people and lead to them being less likely to need in work benefits. The affordable rents would cover maintenance and could keep large numbers of people in stable employment doing said maintenance (as well as creating administrative roles). It would make it less challenging to staff key worker roles in more expensive areas. In the short term I appreciate it would be a massive expense but it seems like in the long term it would cost less than our current system on a going basis and it would make many people a lot more financially secure. I find it disappointing that all main parties seem so focused on home ownership in their policy statements. I know there are many important policy areas but this just always feels like one that’s very central and totally glossed over by all parties. Maybe because there isn’t a quick, easy fix?

OP posts:
LakieLady · 14/09/2023 12:54

Somebody mentioned upthread a couple on 80k a year having a tiny rental payment on a social house, whereas another family in the same area on lesser wages are paying the going rental for that area.

And the family paying the going rent may well be getting a good chunk of it (if not all) of it paid for by UC/HB, which in practice means the taxpayer.

The rent on my MIL's council house is £125pw. An identical house in the same road is rented out by a private landlord for £1300 a month. ie £300pw.

Some BTL landlords are effectively getting the property they own paid for by the rest of us.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 14/09/2023 12:46

Just thought of another one (which Labour has proposed but then appeared to row back from slightly) - day one employment protection rights.

I don't see why you should be sacked on a whim in the first two years. There should be protection from day one. If someone wants to get rid of you there should be a process to follow, even if it's a cut-down process during say the first six months. No sacking people because they eg got covid on day two of their employment, for example.

TheShinmeister · 14/09/2023 12:40

Pottedpalm · 14/09/2023 11:09

Cap the obscene ‘wages’ paid to footballers.

The footballers’ wages are nothing to do with government policy!!

ChristopherTalken · 14/09/2023 12:25

Housing. More social housing (houses not flats). Large taxation on second homes and penalties on empty properties. Capping the profit you can make on a rental property. More regulation on house prices - five new towers of flats have sprung up in my area of shoebox flats marketed at 500K for a two bed when the local house prices are around £300-£400K. This inflation pushes out local residents.

bombastix · 14/09/2023 12:23

@mummymeister - yes Peabody and a few other trusts did this. They also rented a few places out at market rate to bring in income.

They were good properties and it was a good system. Desirable places and well kept.,

mummymeister · 14/09/2023 12:16

@SensationalSusie in London I think it was the Peabody trust, they provided cheaper rented accommodation to people who were earning a certain percentage less than the average national wage. each year you had to declare total household income. if you exceeded the wages amount you were given 12 months grace to move out. this is how council housing should work. it should be a leg up for those that need it. but it isnt.

DivingForLove · 14/09/2023 12:15

@lavender2023 sorry should have clarified I’m a huge supporter of inheritance tax - it helps to level the playing field. My DC will still inherit more than enough - the rest should be redistributed.

SensationalSusie · 14/09/2023 12:10

Dontcallmescarface · 14/09/2023 12:05

Cracking idea that. "You want to improve your lot, well done but it will cost you your home, your job and your children's school place if there is no-where you can go locally once we've kicked you out for daring to do better for yourself". Yep you really thought that through didn't you?

@Dontcallmescarface

Obviously there should be protections in place to allow a gradual shift.

But people shouldn’t be profiteering off of social housing and allowed to stay indefinitely.

Somebody mentioned upthread a couple on 80k a year having a tiny rental payment on a social house, whereas another family in the same area on lesser wages are paying the going rental for that area.

It’s a madness.

Sarvanga38 · 14/09/2023 12:10

SorryWorry · 14/09/2023 08:29

The NHS is broken and cannot continue in its current state. All political parties need to acknowledge that it needs reform and they need to put party politics to one side to come up with a plan for the future with consultation with the public.

There needs to be a commitment to all work towards this future vision long term and not for a four year political cycle.

This. Issues that affect the whole country for the long term should not be subject to party politics, with every party afraid to take vital steps as they know it will lose them votes. (See also kicking the can down the road on pension age ...)

I'll take banning zero hours contracts for my second one - give people a fair wage so they can actually stabilise their lives.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 14/09/2023 12:10

But if I am going to cheat and have more, I would:

Ban greenfield development, bring disused houses out of disuse, and have sticks and carrots to bring holiday lets and second homes back into residential

Reform primary healthcare - many people don't need to see a GP but they need to see someone - the answer may be to have drop in centres attached to GP surgeries where you can just turn up and wait to be seen

Merge employee NI and income tax, increase income tax and make tax simpler - the tax take would be greater

Retain inheritance tax - you don't have to pay it, it's only because people hoard wealth instead of spending it earlier in their lives. Spend and enjoy your money and there will be no, or much less, tax to pay.

Extend a ULEZ type charge to SUVs regardless of age and type of fuel and invest in cycling and walking infrastructure rather than new roads

Strict controls on dogs and have dog exercise areas, dogs to be on short leads everywhere else

Reform jail sentences so the only people who go to jail are those who pose a danger; everyone else to be punished in other ways. At the moment we have too many people in jail who shouldn't be there, but there aren't any votes in making life better for criminals

Rejoin the EU (ducks)

Dontcallmescarface · 14/09/2023 12:05

SensationalSusie · 14/09/2023 11:03

@DynamicK I am with @SayingwhatIreallythink

Social housing should not be some cushy set up provided by the government to allow people to put down roots and plant gardens.

It should be an emergency situation there for people who are struggling and in dire need. There while it is required and given up when circumstances improve.

I know of someone who was socially housed when in dire need, but was never reviewed. So they stayed there throughout the completion of two degrees, when in employment and when married. Rent £300 a month, annual household income £50-60k… they got an enormous discount via right to buy and were able to buy a 300k house via this.

So again, I reiterate social housing should be needs based and reviewed every few years or you are going to have people taking the absolute piss as they are at the moment. Right to buy needs to go too.

Cracking idea that. "You want to improve your lot, well done but it will cost you your home, your job and your children's school place if there is no-where you can go locally once we've kicked you out for daring to do better for yourself". Yep you really thought that through didn't you?

shearwater · 14/09/2023 12:02

Ginmonkeyagain · 14/09/2023 11:55

@shearwater The unspoken thing about the line that "council housing used to be for everyone" is it wasn't. There were strict criteria for getting a council house - often local connections, ability to pay the rent, being of "good" character (which often mean no unmarried mothers). Vulnerable and "undesirable" people were still often left to fend for themselves in unsecure and poor housing.

Edited

Oh sure. It wasn't a perfect system and I'm sure it would have been very unfairly judgemental at one time.

MeadAndPie · 14/09/2023 12:01

I'd be massively in favour of the highest paid person in any company only ever being able to be paid X times higher than the lowest paid employee.

I wouldn't be against that but have seen even more suggestion that top company people should be in same pension schemes as lower paid workers - tends to mean better ones overall.

I think you could possibly get rent control but as same time you have to give landlords something like more protection and reduce their risks - if renters aren't paying the rent it shouldn't take 12+ months and hefty legal fees to get the property back - basically you'd have to get most landlords on board before implementation so they don't just flee the sector rather than have MN attitude of they are the enemy.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 14/09/2023 12:00

OP am I only allowed two things? I could come up with so many.

But I think I would:

ban pavement parking other than in certain areas where housing estates have been created with pavement parking in mind; and

deal with noise pollution, so have strict rules on noise at night, enforce quiet carriages on trains etc

Both of these would improve health - noise is very stressful for people, and if you make it easier to walk to places, people will.

shearwater · 14/09/2023 12:00

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 14/09/2023 11:35

By continuing to increase pension age in line with healthy lifespan, and by accepting that we’ll need to increase pay and improve conditions in health and care services to ensure a good ratio of people happy to take care of the elderly.

The Ponzi scheme of continuously increasing the population by bringing in ever-more young immigrants is a terrible alternative.

I think we need a government who is prepared to have a grown up conversation about lack of skills and how this impacts on productivity and will mean zero economic growth in the next ten years, economic growth as a desirable thing at all v population growth, immigration, housing and how this impacts on climate change - and liaising with many other countries facing the same issues in demographics, not shutting up shop and withdrawing from international co-operation while dog whistling to the tabloids on immigration and I certainly think we need to invest vastly in education and skills, which is a long term thing.

Before any talk of increasing pension age we would need to ensure we have a robust and healthy population with an increasing healthy life span, which we don't have. What we have is vast differences in life expectancy and healthy life expectancy and millions of people unable to work while they wait for basic surgery, and millions of people who live very unhealthily for many years. At te moment it would be unconscionable to ask many people to work for longer before obtaining state pension. Most people will have to anyway, as it is.

Isheabastard · 14/09/2023 11:59

Mine is one that affects many countries and I don’t think there is a solution.

Most of our really serious problems (like climate change, pollution, habitat loss, endangered species) have a common problem: too many humans.

But individually many countries need a growing young working force to pay taxes to fund their economies.

Birth rates in many places is already falling. I believe Japan is actively encouraging people to have larger families. Many western countries already have top heavy older people in their demographics. But to keep their economy working they still need to encourage more young people by birth rate or immigration.

Most people want to have children, I did myself.

I just don’t know how we square this circle.

ohfook · 14/09/2023 11:58

LastHives · 14/09/2023 08:24

Are you all willing to pay massive taxes for all of these things?

Yes
I have a friend in Sweden that earns less than me and pays more tax but pays far less mortgage, utility bills are far cheaper, has far more annual leave than me and pays the equivalent of about £36 a month for full time childcare. They definitely have a better quality of life and more available money than me although admittedly their food bill is higher.

The purpose of our government is to take the money we pay in taxes and use it to improve the life of everybody in the country. I can't remember the last time I believed a U.K. government was doing that!

1dayatatime · 14/09/2023 11:57

@sheflieswithherownwings

"Increasing wages / salaries to above inflation.. wages are low in the UK compared to other developed nations which means people are sometimes choosing, understandably, not to work because they'll lose out (e.g losing benefits if you work above a certain number of hours). Better earning power would mean people have more options with regards to housing / where to live etc.. not an simple one to fix though"

+++

But that's not how economics works.
Increasing wages above inflation or giving people better earning power would simply mean higher inflation which then leads to demands for even higher wages and even higher inflation and so on.

FoodFann · 14/09/2023 11:56

Incentives for old people to sell their massive houses and live in smaller places.

End the ‘one size fits all’ approach to education. I’d like to see lots more SEN schools, more grammars, more opportunities for vocational study etc etc

whatkatydid2013 · 14/09/2023 11:55

usernother · 14/09/2023 10:38

Stop right to buy for council properties and build more social housing. someone mentioned earlier that the rents would pay for the maintenance but this isn't the case, paying for the upkeep of social housing is very expensive. I'd also make able bodied job seekers earn their benefits.

I don’t understand how upkeep of social housing costs more than upkeep of privately rented housing + a profit for landlords. For that to be true either private housing must be universally poorly maintained, social housing must only be occupied by people who wilfully destroy it or social housing must be maintained in an incredibly inefficient way.

OP posts:
Ginmonkeyagain · 14/09/2023 11:55

@shearwater The unspoken thing about the line that "council housing used to be for everyone" is it wasn't. There were strict criteria for getting a council house - often local connections, ability to pay the rent, being of "good" character (which often mean no unmarried mothers). Vulnerable and "undesirable" people were still often left to fend for themselves in unsecure and poor housing.

SensationalSusie · 14/09/2023 11:54

shearwater · 14/09/2023 11:45

I don't have that impression at all but it can be the way, largely due to bad planning/design and policy. With things done better integrated social housing can be amazing. My grandparents had a normal terraced house which they rented from the council all their lives, brought up two children, until they retired and eventually died. My GM did part time factory work and GF worked for the electricity board. It was just a solution for people doing working class not particularly well paid jobs to be able to afford housing. No doubt people did use right to buy on the street and I expect some were privately owned. It was a perfectly nice street to live on, even with its own set of shops in the middle.

I also live in a former council house that we bought privately (not right to buy) but someone would have done RTB in the past in order for it to pass into the private sector. The houses were built for keyworkers at a local MOD site in the 1950s. Most are privately owned now but there are a number of social housing properties still on the road, mainly inhabited by young families, elderly people and people with a disability. It's not a sink estate or rough and a very nice community. It also not always apparent which houses are private and which belong to the housing association.

@shearwater I know what you’re saying; my great GP were council; my GF bought the house for his parents in the end and most of the houses in the street are privately owned now.

Our first house ex council so somebody went via RTB before us; single mother with issues to one side, family with health issues and not working on the other, man with serious mental health problems further up the street, and a range of transient/problematic people in and out over the years.

It really was not a “community nirvana” and not where I would feel safe bringing up a family.

mummymeister · 14/09/2023 11:52

Always on these threads the issue of rent controls comes up. so heres the thing. you say to a landlord you can only charge £XX a week rent. the landlord looks at the rent amount. they realise that with all the laws weighted in favour of the tenants that mean they can stay in rent free for many months before eviction. and they think, sod it. if I cant rent for an amount that covers my costs, makes this a proper business and covers the insurance against bad tenants then I am either going to leave it empty (many more choose to do this than you would realise) or start using it as a furnished holiday let. BOOM your rent controls have lost yet another property for rent out of the market. well done.

Landlords are not villaneous barons holed up in their palaces surrounded by servants counting their money made off of the backs of the poor. they are often accidental landlords - parents died and left them a house, move in with partner or have to relocate long term to somewhere else. They are a vital part of the housing mix, more so now that there are so few social houses available. yet successive govts bash them to the point where they stop letting with the net result that yes those tenants who are in properties have better protection but there are far fewer properties to rent because of this. Its bonkers. start recognising landlords for what they are: providers of accommodation for people to live in. you only have to look at whats happening in uni towns where landlords are fed up on being vilified so are just basically leaving the property empty because it costs less than the alternatives.

Gillstuck · 14/09/2023 11:50

Reform of social housing as the OP said plus voting reform. Proportional Representation and plenty of discussion and middle ground.

shearwater · 14/09/2023 11:49

ohfook · 14/09/2023 11:48

A ban on companies that pay their employees so poorly that they have to top their income up with UC.

I'd be massively in favour of the highest paid person in any company only ever being able to be paid X times higher than the lowest paid employee.

This - great stuff.