Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what one or two policies you think could make the biggest difference to the U.K.?

411 replies

whatkatydid2013 · 14/09/2023 07:36

To me the big one is social housing. I feel like if we could build up a large supply of social housing at reasonable rates all over the country the benefits would be massive. It would make life affordable for many more people and lead to them being less likely to need in work benefits. The affordable rents would cover maintenance and could keep large numbers of people in stable employment doing said maintenance (as well as creating administrative roles). It would make it less challenging to staff key worker roles in more expensive areas. In the short term I appreciate it would be a massive expense but it seems like in the long term it would cost less than our current system on a going basis and it would make many people a lot more financially secure. I find it disappointing that all main parties seem so focused on home ownership in their policy statements. I know there are many important policy areas but this just always feels like one that’s very central and totally glossed over by all parties. Maybe because there isn’t a quick, easy fix?

OP posts:
SayingwhatIreallythink · 15/09/2023 13:51

Really?? Don’t think E~W makes any difference. n~ S definitely does. Bristol and Edinburgh are virtually the same as far as east and west goes anyway

Sugarfree23 · 15/09/2023 13:20

MariaVT65 · 15/09/2023 13:08

Is this common? I had a 40 min commute to school and don’t ever remember heading out to school in the dark.

When I had to leave the house at 5.30am and 6.30am for work, yes. But not for school. Interesting point though.

I still don’t think it’s great though when it’s quite dark outside at 4.30pmish

The further west you go the later it is to get light. Which is further West Edinburgh or Bristol?

GMT is the natural time in the UK.
December and January It's barely light at 8am, pitch back at 7am.
Sticking with BST all year that 7am becomes 8am - the time when many kids are leaving the house to get buses and trains to school.

Overnight the ground freezes, quite often its rainy in the mornings too. Its never as frosty at home time as it is in morning. It makes sense to make more use of the day light in morning for safety than for enjoyment in the evening.

BST came about so people get light in the evening in summer when there is more light anyway. Who cares about having daylight at 3am in mid summer people prefer to have that light at 9pm and save an hour of burning light bulbs.

MariaVT65 · 15/09/2023 13:08

Sugarfree23 · 15/09/2023 12:47

So your willing to put people in danger on the roads when it's dark and slippy so you can enjoy a stroll with your kid.

You might think differently when your kids secondary school, heading out the door on their own in the pitch black on an icy morning, at what's currently the equivalent of 7am.

Is this common? I had a 40 min commute to school and don’t ever remember heading out to school in the dark.

When I had to leave the house at 5.30am and 6.30am for work, yes. But not for school. Interesting point though.

I still don’t think it’s great though when it’s quite dark outside at 4.30pmish

user1497207191 · 15/09/2023 12:59

Sugarfree23 · 15/09/2023 12:53

@Thebestwaytoscareatory
Of the benefits recipients who are in work - what percentage are working full-time?

I'm quite cynical that a lot of benefits recipient's are caught in a trap. Working 16 hours, keeps the BA happy, but if they work much more their benefits get reduced.
So they really are stuck, can't earn enough to lift themselves completely off benefits so they plod along with their 16 hours.

Yep, that is always my first thought when I see the stats trotted out about "in work" benefits.

I think we should be concentrating on statistics showing people working full time hours who are reliant on benefits.

There's no way any average person could survive without benefits if they're only working part time, but that's not the fault of employers, it's the fault of them only working part time!

But yes, the government should do more to make it easier for people to work full time and come off benefits, by introducing wider "taper" ranges where there's always a significant benefit to working/earning more, to wean people off a life of benefit dependence.

Sugarfree23 · 15/09/2023 12:53

@Thebestwaytoscareatory
Of the benefits recipients who are in work - what percentage are working full-time?

I'm quite cynical that a lot of benefits recipient's are caught in a trap. Working 16 hours, keeps the BA happy, but if they work much more their benefits get reduced.
So they really are stuck, can't earn enough to lift themselves completely off benefits so they plod along with their 16 hours.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 15/09/2023 12:48

DatumTarum · 15/09/2023 11:29

Cut working hours.

Every city should be a ULEZ

Even St David’s?

Sugarfree23 · 15/09/2023 12:47

MariaVT65 · 15/09/2023 11:45

I would say with more flexible working introduced, fewer people are doing the typical 9-5. You also have retired people or parents kids. I depend on that hour between nursery pick up at 4 and 5 to take my son for a walk. I don’t feel safe at any time when it’s dark.

So your willing to put people in danger on the roads when it's dark and slippy so you can enjoy a stroll with your kid.

You might think differently when your kids secondary school, heading out the door on their own in the pitch black on an icy morning, at what's currently the equivalent of 7am.

Sugarfree23 · 15/09/2023 12:43

1dayatatime · 15/09/2023 11:35

@Sugarfree23

Apologies- my bad and didn't realise you were being sarcastic (I do like a bit of sarcasm myself 😀).

I'll forgive you 😉

HollaWithDaRisinSound · 15/09/2023 12:33

I think we should bring back execution for serious offenders where there is 100% proof that they have commited a serious crime

This would save the country an absolute fortune

Why waste £millions every year keeping scumbag murderers and peados alive behind bars. Get them gone.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 15/09/2023 12:15

user1497207191 · 15/09/2023 10:18

I agree, they're so stupid, the only thing they can think of as to how it's all going to be paid for is the lame "tax the rich"! They've learned nothing from history (well probably couldn't even be arsed to do any reading/research about past mistakes re taxation).

It's like the window tax all over again from a few centuries ago. They imposed taxes "per window" in an effort to tax people with bigger houses. All that happened was that "the rich" bricked up some of their windows!

Same in the 70s with the (I think 98%) tax on unearned income, which just drove authors, artists, etc and rich people living on interest/dividends, abroad.

Just because previous attempts at wealth redistribution have failed doesn't mean we should give up trying.

Wealth inequality has been increasing, not decreasing, which is a sorry state of affairs imo. The top 10% of households hold arounf 42-50% of all wealth (depending on the reports you read), while the bottom 10% hold only 9%. The top 1% hold something like 24% of all wealth alone. That's not fair, moral or sustainable.

I also see people rabbiting on about productivity on these threads, which seems to be buzz word of the month. But look at how productivity and wages have diverged over the years. Productivity has increased by 87% since the 1980s, while wages have only increased by 62%, a 25% decoupling between pay and output. Where do you think that extra cash for that extra effort went? Thats right the top 1-10%.

It's beyond ridiculous that the majority of benefit recipients in the UK are actually in work and have to recieve top ups from the state becyase their employers aren't paying them fairly, preferring to exploit their efforts for the benefits of executives and shareholders.

If you want everyone to pay a fair share into the tax system you have to pay them a fair wage in the first place, and for that to happen you have to look at stopping wealth congealing at the top.

SkankingWombat · 15/09/2023 12:15

I would invest heavily in prevention and early treatment for mental health and addiction. It would save the NHS a lot of money in the long run, increase tax revenues by helping people back into work, reduce crime, and generally make the country a much nicer place to live with happier citizens and less antisocial behaviour.

A complete overhaul of child maintenance. Either take it under HMRC's wing, or allow the department handling it full access to HMRC's annual tax records for individuals so calculations can be done using full and accurate values of all income. CM would be paid by the government to the RP, with the NRP owing the government with all the same repercussions that happen if you don't pay them the tax/NI/VAT due. There would be a minimum weekly payment that reflects the realistic cost of raising a child (deductions given for overnights, as currently), plus a %age of any income over the personal allowance. If the NRP is not earning enough to cover even the minimum weekly payment, the government will pay it on their behalf with the debt accruing similar to a student loan, that the NRP starts repaying once earning enough and follows them until repaid or NRP dies. No reductions are given for multiple DCs, as the minimum cost is just that. The government needs to have a vested interest in making sure people pay up, and the only way that will happen is if it is them that is owed the money.

HumanBurrito · 15/09/2023 12:02

BygoneDays · 14/09/2023 10:55

My English teacher, who I respected enormously, did National Service. He described the tedium, the pettiness, the bullying, the abuse, the humiliations, the capricious nastiness, and much more, in angry and excruciating detail. He described it as 2 years stolen from his life.

It doesn't have to be like that. My DH did national service (much more recently than your English teacher probably as it's not long abolished in his home country) and says it is a great social leveller that provided hugely valuable life skills to people who would otherwise have been NEETs, at a crucial stage of their journey to adulthood.

MariaVT65 · 15/09/2023 11:53

Fizzology · 14/09/2023 08:57

Inheritance tax laws so wide and deep they make it near impossible to inherit wealth and property from your parents/grandparents. Royal family included (renationalise that land and those properties).

No private schooling.

If you don’t want private schooling, the state schooling needs to improve first. Massively.

And many young people will depend on inheritance to get onto the housing ladder. Who else do you propose someone’s money goes to?

Ginmonkeyagain · 15/09/2023 11:45

@MariaVT65 Well there is a very challenging conversation to be had at some point about our "life at all costs" policy.

MariaVT65 · 15/09/2023 11:45

Sugarfree23 · 15/09/2023 10:29

How?
Most people are still at work at 5 so makes very little difference if it'd dark at 4 or not getting dark until 5

I would say with more flexible working introduced, fewer people are doing the typical 9-5. You also have retired people or parents kids. I depend on that hour between nursery pick up at 4 and 5 to take my son for a walk. I don’t feel safe at any time when it’s dark.

MariaVT65 · 15/09/2023 11:42

Legalisation of assisted death.

The prospect of me becoming severely disabled or having an illness like dementia terrifies me.

1dayatatime · 15/09/2023 11:40

@Sugarfree23

"The two biggest things that make people reduce their child numbers are access to contraception and education of females. Females who are educated are less likely to have a big family."

+++

Totally agree and foreign aid spent on female education is money well spent.

Also the single most impactful and cost effective environmental measure you can take to deal with everything from global warming, to water pollution to deforestation to micro plastics is contraception.

1dayatatime · 15/09/2023 11:35

@Sugarfree23

Apologies- my bad and didn't realise you were being sarcastic (I do like a bit of sarcasm myself 😀).

1dayatatime · 15/09/2023 11:34

@Pottedpalm

"I know! Maybe I should have said increase tax to 90% on obscenely high ‘wages"

++++

Let's work this through. So let's say you had a doctor or a lawyer on £100k pa. They were then offered a promotion at £125k per year. However this additional £25k per annum would be taxed at 90% meaning they would only receive an additional £2.5k or roughly £200 per month or £50 a week.
Logically they would accept the promotion to £125k but only on a 4 days a week basis pro rata giving them the same £100k a year salary it with a day off a week and foregoing the additional £50. If they have children and have to pay for childcare then it makes even more sense to forego the £50 and work 4 days a week.

I think the challenge with voters in the UK is an educational issue in that people like the sound bite aspirational political slogans of "yeah let's tax the rich at 90%!!". But none of them are interested / bothered in the detail of how this would actually work or the consequences of it.

Sugarfree23 · 15/09/2023 11:32

1dayatatime · 15/09/2023 11:20

@Sugarfree23

"One child policy worked really well in China."

+++

Errr I don't think so and really can't see this as ever being possible in a democracy.

To enforce the policy, China carried out massive sterilization and abortion campaigns. In 1983 alone, a year with about 21 million births in China, 14.4 million abortions, 20.7 million (predominantly female) sterilizations, and 17.8 million IUD insertions were performed. A large proportion of these procedures were involuntary.

www.brookings.edu/articles/the-end-of-chinas-one-child-policy/

Also it has caused a demographic time bomb of a rapidly ageing society:

Calm - I was being sarcastic!
It was someone else who suggested it.

DatumTarum · 15/09/2023 11:29

Cut working hours.

Every city should be a ULEZ

HumanBurrito · 15/09/2023 11:25

I can do it in 5 letters. PR and UBI.

1dayatatime · 15/09/2023 11:20

@Sugarfree23

"One child policy worked really well in China."

+++

Errr I don't think so and really can't see this as ever being possible in a democracy.

To enforce the policy, China carried out massive sterilization and abortion campaigns. In 1983 alone, a year with about 21 million births in China, 14.4 million abortions, 20.7 million (predominantly female) sterilizations, and 17.8 million IUD insertions were performed. A large proportion of these procedures were involuntary.

www.brookings.edu/articles/the-end-of-chinas-one-child-policy/

Also it has caused a demographic time bomb of a rapidly ageing society:

Sugarfree23 · 15/09/2023 10:32

HollaWithDaRisinSound · 15/09/2023 10:26

Like I said, I really do not know how we would achieve a more sustainable population - any possible way would come across as dictatoral

ie - families only allowed to have one child each
No immigration at all from anywhere

None of them come across as good options

Who knows

One child policy worked really well in China.

There are certain sections of the community who have much larger families than others.

The two biggest things that make people reduce their child numbers are access to contraception and education of females. Females who are educated are less likely to have a big family.

Sugarfree23 · 15/09/2023 10:29

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

How?
Most people are still at work at 5 so makes very little difference if it'd dark at 4 or not getting dark until 5

Swipe left for the next trending thread