Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what one or two policies you think could make the biggest difference to the U.K.?

411 replies

whatkatydid2013 · 14/09/2023 07:36

To me the big one is social housing. I feel like if we could build up a large supply of social housing at reasonable rates all over the country the benefits would be massive. It would make life affordable for many more people and lead to them being less likely to need in work benefits. The affordable rents would cover maintenance and could keep large numbers of people in stable employment doing said maintenance (as well as creating administrative roles). It would make it less challenging to staff key worker roles in more expensive areas. In the short term I appreciate it would be a massive expense but it seems like in the long term it would cost less than our current system on a going basis and it would make many people a lot more financially secure. I find it disappointing that all main parties seem so focused on home ownership in their policy statements. I know there are many important policy areas but this just always feels like one that’s very central and totally glossed over by all parties. Maybe because there isn’t a quick, easy fix?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Grapefruitsquash · 17/09/2023 10:03

FirstYouGetTheMoney · 14/09/2023 11:35

By continuing to increase pension age in line with healthy lifespan, and by accepting that we’ll need to increase pay and improve conditions in health and care services to ensure a good ratio of people happy to take care of the elderly.

The Ponzi scheme of continuously increasing the population by bringing in ever-more young immigrants is a terrible alternative.

The pension age is already 67. I'm 64. My job is very physical. I'm on my feet for the whole of my shift and often walk around 15k steps. I am already exhausted. How long should I work? And don't say change jobs. I'm highly experienced in what do. I'vebeeninthe same industry since I was 20. No one will hire a mid 60s age person in an industry I've never worked in before.

whatkatydid2013 · 17/09/2023 07:22

1dayatatime · 16/09/2023 23:16

I don't think anyone would disagree with the concept that "those with the most pay out the most," and indeed that is how the current income tax system works with the top 1% of income earners paying 30% of all income tax revenues 48% paying no income tax because they don't earn enough and the remaining 51% paying 70% of income tax revenue.

If your suggestion is to tax the top 1% even more then you really have to hike it to make any difference in tax revenues because mathematically there are so few of them (1in a 100). Year f you make this the top 10% then the hike has to be less so and so on.

I'm curious because I don't often see on these threads that the answer is to the rich more but nobody ever defines what "rich" is. Is it the top 20%, 10%, 1% or 0.1% for f income earners?

I think it’s not income earners or at least not salaried ones that many people mean when they say this. As someone posted upthread more taxes linked to wealth and less to income might be beneficial. If I personally were choosing to restructure I think I would also want to understand where we stood to make the biggest tax gains. Just targeting the very wealthy doesn’t necessarily raise that much compared to everyone paying a little bit more. As an example reducing the personal allowance to £10k would raise billions across the whole workforce and would cost someone on lowest rate of tax about £40 a month. To raise the same amount by targeting the top 5% you’d be costing those people about £800 a month. Even on a high salary that’s a big difference. Yes for some people £40 is also a significant difference but for many of them it would be quickly offset if that money was invested in things like social housing for more affordable homes, NHS dentistry, better public transport etc. If everyone paid more tax rather than just the top 5% you’d have enough to provide better services and those better services would likely most benefit those in lower incomes proportionate to the cost.

I would like to see NI & tax combined and everyone paying same rate on earned and unearned income, marginal rates abolished (personal allowance for all or none at all and replaces with a lower rate on first slice of income), IHT thresholds abolished with only estates not liable to tax being those left to a partner whose main residence was with you (Tax should be payable at point the estates assets are sold capped to a timescale of a number of years to give anyone else living in parents/relatives house time to identify alternative arrangements with the part of the estate they will inherit), capital gains thresholds to be eliminated.

Tax free schemes exist to incentivise people to save/invest even outside pensions (share schemes in work place, ISAs, separate allowance for interest on savings). Is this a desirable behaviour or would spending benefit the overall economy more? If the latter then eliminate the schemes.

I think top earner in a company only being able to earn a maximum of a multiplier of bottom earner is nice in theory but in practice might lead to minimum wage/low wage type jobs being subcontracted so they were officially in a different company or high earners moving to being part owners of the business with a lower salary and rest made via their stake in the company.

We don’t pay higher rate tax currently as, being borderline, it’s better for us personally to invest more in pensions and keep our child allowance. Unless and until we need what we earn above the threshold we will just keep putting more in pensions for next 10 years. It’ll help us retire earlier if we want and leaves us better off overall. If we would keep the child benefit regardless we likely would spend at least some of that money. I can well imagine those on around £100k have a similar approach to avoid the marginal rate.

OP posts:
1dayatatime · 16/09/2023 23:16

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 16/09/2023 21:52

@1dayatatime one can either look at how to ensure those with the most pay out the most, or one can look for problems in doing it. Depends where one's sympathies lie, really. I'm sure that, with a will, it's achievable.

I don't think anyone would disagree with the concept that "those with the most pay out the most," and indeed that is how the current income tax system works with the top 1% of income earners paying 30% of all income tax revenues 48% paying no income tax because they don't earn enough and the remaining 51% paying 70% of income tax revenue.

If your suggestion is to tax the top 1% even more then you really have to hike it to make any difference in tax revenues because mathematically there are so few of them (1in a 100). Year f you make this the top 10% then the hike has to be less so and so on.

I'm curious because I don't often see on these threads that the answer is to the rich more but nobody ever defines what "rich" is. Is it the top 20%, 10%, 1% or 0.1% for f income earners?

Stupendousseptember · 16/09/2023 22:49

'* ie stop focusing on grammar and private school and sort out the issues in state

Stupendousseptember · 16/09/2023 22:48

Getting teachers, nursery staff, and people involved with dc all up in sen, how it presents, stragety to deal with it and more Ed psychs, dyslexia assement and so on in nursery and primary school... Sorting out sen will break cycles of illiteracy in families.. It will stop damaging young dc and causing low self esteem.
It will feed back into society with more people actually able to reach their true potential, less drug and addiction issues, less peooleIn prison

Sugarfree23 · 16/09/2023 22:01

@marmaladeandpeanutbutter
Taxing the 'rich' really means middle income - the handful of super rich have accountants to exploit every loophole and use offshore if they need to.

The employed high earners are already being squeezed to the point of why bother working full-time, consider moving elsewhere, I'll not bother going for the next promotion.

We need more people being net contributors to the system not a few paying a hefty burden.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 16/09/2023 21:52

@1dayatatime one can either look at how to ensure those with the most pay out the most, or one can look for problems in doing it. Depends where one's sympathies lie, really. I'm sure that, with a will, it's achievable.

1dayatatime · 16/09/2023 20:50

@marmaladeandpeanutbutter

And who would you define as rich?

The top 20% of earners, the top 10%, the top 1%?

The problem is that once you get to a small percentage of earners then you have to make a massive increase in taxes in order to raise any significant tax revenue and the moment you do that then they either reduce their hours or move abroad.

As for increasing company taxes then they either just add the cost in to prices leading to higher inflation or they also register abroad like Amazon does.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 16/09/2023 09:26

I would also tax the rich more. Amd companies.

Sugarfree23 · 16/09/2023 09:13

I don't know the ins and outs but it must be similar. I know too many people working a couple of days or 3 hrs a day for 5 days Who don't want to work more because it affects their benefits.

NameChangedToProtectInnocentSmoothie · 16/09/2023 08:39

Sugarfree23 · 15/09/2023 12:53

@Thebestwaytoscareatory
Of the benefits recipients who are in work - what percentage are working full-time?

I'm quite cynical that a lot of benefits recipient's are caught in a trap. Working 16 hours, keeps the BA happy, but if they work much more their benefits get reduced.
So they really are stuck, can't earn enough to lift themselves completely off benefits so they plod along with their 16 hours.

I think this was the case under the old benefit system, but not with Universal Credit. I did not support all of the benefits reforms but I reluctantly hand it to the Tories on that one.
You could argue the taper rate is too high - once you're earning a certain amount benefits get reduced by 55p for every £1 you earn, but there's no longer the sudden withdrawal of benefits at 16 hours.

NameChangedToProtectInnocentSmoothie · 16/09/2023 08:28

Sugarfree23 · 15/09/2023 13:20

The further west you go the later it is to get light. Which is further West Edinburgh or Bristol?

GMT is the natural time in the UK.
December and January It's barely light at 8am, pitch back at 7am.
Sticking with BST all year that 7am becomes 8am - the time when many kids are leaving the house to get buses and trains to school.

Overnight the ground freezes, quite often its rainy in the mornings too. Its never as frosty at home time as it is in morning. It makes sense to make more use of the day light in morning for safety than for enjoyment in the evening.

BST came about so people get light in the evening in summer when there is more light anyway. Who cares about having daylight at 3am in mid summer people prefer to have that light at 9pm and save an hour of burning light bulbs.

I'm not sure about this.
I live in the north of England and there's a large and noticeable difference between sunset/sunrise times compared to the south. (In midsummer it technically doesn't go beyond twilight here, and isn't darkest until after 11pm). An extra hour in the summer evenings makes little difference here but it's horrendous in the autumn when the clocks change and suddenly the "daytime" daylight is cut short, in exchange for an extra hour in the morning when you're still at home getting ready. Later in the winter it's still dark on the way to school anyway, but also afterwards on the way home, which it wouldn't be if we left the time on summer time. I remember coming home from school by bus in the dark, hated it.

It just makes more sense to have the hour of light during the daytime rather than at the beginning of the day - it's really off-kilter atm, with the mid-point of the daylight coming much earlier than the mid-point of the hours when we're awake/active (in general). So you end up feeling like it's getting towards bedtime at 3.30 in the afternoon when there's still hours and hours of activity left!

Presumably it's regional, but it also is far more likely to rain later in the day here too, with mornings usually clear, so I'm not convinced about that argument either.

Either way, it's the changing of the clocks that is particularly disruptive. Perhaps we could split the difference and settle on a half-hour compromise? (Nod to India who are 5.5 hours ahead of GMT.)

1dayatatime · 15/09/2023 21:02

@Pottedpalm

"I would hope that the senior medics and consultants ate able to earn well over £100k; it’s a pretty standard salary on Mumsnet."

++++

£100k may or may not be a pretty standard salary on Mumsnet but it sure as hell isn't in the wider UK society.

The UK median salary is £27,756 and a salary of £59,200 plus puts you in the top 10% and a salary of £180k plus puts you in the top 1%.

However many of those earning say £60k wouldn't see themselves as in the richest 10% and would object to paying higher taxes. Equally the same would apply to those earning over £180k plus there is a lot less of them so you would have to really hike their taxes to make any meaningful increase in tax revenue.

The unpalatable truth is that if voters want more Government spending on various areas then that money will have to come from all income groups.

Vegetus · 15/09/2023 19:43

Pottedpalm · 15/09/2023 19:12

@1dayatatime when you said
”I didn’t realise that by ‘obscenely high wages’ you meant more than 200k a week rather than over £100k a year which some would view as obscene but others such as yourself slightly rude “, I really don’t understand what you are trying to say.
I would hope that the senior medics and consultants ate able to earn well over £100k; it’s a pretty standard salary on Mumsnet.

People claim to feed a family of 4 with a single chicken for a whole week, I wouldn't take much notice of what people say on here.

Pottedpalm · 15/09/2023 19:12

@1dayatatime when you said
”I didn’t realise that by ‘obscenely high wages’ you meant more than 200k a week rather than over £100k a year which some would view as obscene but others such as yourself slightly rude “, I really don’t understand what you are trying to say.
I would hope that the senior medics and consultants ate able to earn well over £100k; it’s a pretty standard salary on Mumsnet.

1dayatatime · 15/09/2023 18:13

@Fightyouforthatpie

"You have a lot to say about income tax. The tax that really wealthy people either hardly pay or don't pay at all"

+++

Firstly I thoroughly agree with moving the tax burden away from income and towards wealth:

But let's look at the practicality of this. Income from an employer is fairly easy to determine whereas how much wealth someone has is much harder. For example do you include as wealth things like fancy gold and diamond jewellery or a sports car or fine art and secondly how do you even know the individual has these things.

Indeed the only wealth items that are easy to identify and value are: housing, investments, share holdings and cash.

By all means tax these but there will be squeals from little old ladies living in million pound house saying that they don't have the pension income to pay the wealth tax etc.

1dayatatime · 15/09/2023 18:04

@Pottedpalm

"
I did say ‘obscenely high “wages”’, which was in reference to footballers ‘earning’ hundreds of thousands a week, not consultants/barristers etc"

+++

Sorry I didn't realise that by "obscenely high wages" you meant more than 200k a week rather than over £100k per year which some would view as obscene but others such as yourself as slightly rude.

Now that's clarified this idea is even dumber.

So again let's work this through shall we? Currently there are only 22 football players in the UK earning over 200k a week of which les than 10 are UK nationals.

www.givemesport.com/1788011-ronaldo-pogba-grealish-salaries-for-top-50-premier-league-players-ranked/

So if you tax football players are even say City Bankers at 90% then they absolutely will not come to work in the UK. So instead of the Government getting a tax income of 50% from 200k you actually get nothing because the player has chosen to work in Spain or Italy instead.

A 90% taxation rate would actually bring in less tax revenue, all it would achieve is to be seen as punishing such high earners out of envy.

HumanBurrito · 15/09/2023 17:42

living at home and attending your local uni is par for the course in much of Europe.

GreyhpundGirl · 15/09/2023 16:56

Social.housing is so important. Where I live, there is house building wherever you go two orr three miles out of the city centre, but they are all identikit new build estates,no affordable housing. I'm not sure how it would work though- central government would have to fund it surely?

SharonEllis · 15/09/2023 16:54

Royanne · 14/09/2023 07:51

Live at home and attend a uni locally?

God this is such an awful idea. Getting away is so essential to develop independence and meeting new people and opening up peoples worlds. And having adult kids at home could be really disruptive to some families. I would have seriously fallen out with my mother if Id stayed home. As it was we had an excellent realtionship at a distance. And then by just staying local course options would be so limited.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 15/09/2023 16:43

Sort out all of the empty and abandoned buildings for housing use before building by on any more green space and the continued turning of villages into urban sprawls ditto make it easier to build on brownfield sites

Fightyouforthatpie · 15/09/2023 16:43

user1497207191 · 15/09/2023 12:59

Yep, that is always my first thought when I see the stats trotted out about "in work" benefits.

I think we should be concentrating on statistics showing people working full time hours who are reliant on benefits.

There's no way any average person could survive without benefits if they're only working part time, but that's not the fault of employers, it's the fault of them only working part time!

But yes, the government should do more to make it easier for people to work full time and come off benefits, by introducing wider "taper" ranges where there's always a significant benefit to working/earning more, to wean people off a life of benefit dependence.

Don't forget the costs of childcare are often more than the entire extra wages where people would like to work full time but would be worse off.

Fightyouforthatpie · 15/09/2023 16:40

Princessandthepea0 · 14/09/2023 17:52

Half of the population are now net takers. We have a broken system that is ever reliant on a small number of people on PAYE - they are bang on. Source: the office of national statistics.

36 MILLION people get more from the state than they pay in. That is 54.2% of adults. Highest on record.

83% of income tax is paid by 40% of British adults. The top 10% of earners now pay over half of all income tax (these are the ones now beginning to stop that by changing behaviour or leaving). The top 10% of earners only earn 35% of pre tax income but pay 60% of all income tax. Marginal rates of 70-100% in cases.

None of that is sustainable.

You have a lot to say about income tax. The tax that really wealthy people either hardly pay or don't pay at all.

Sugarfree23 · 15/09/2023 16:36

Footballers have a relatively short career. 10 years of earning that sort of silly money tops.

Mean while they create a shed load of jobs for other people, catering staff, ground stewards, ticket sellers, top sales and other merchandise.

If you tax them at stupid levels they will up sticks and leave, causing the UK football industry to fall down.

The same with most people earning seriously big bucks they create work for other people.

Pottedpalm · 15/09/2023 15:50

1dayatatime · 15/09/2023 11:34

@Pottedpalm

"I know! Maybe I should have said increase tax to 90% on obscenely high ‘wages"

++++

Let's work this through. So let's say you had a doctor or a lawyer on £100k pa. They were then offered a promotion at £125k per year. However this additional £25k per annum would be taxed at 90% meaning they would only receive an additional £2.5k or roughly £200 per month or £50 a week.
Logically they would accept the promotion to £125k but only on a 4 days a week basis pro rata giving them the same £100k a year salary it with a day off a week and foregoing the additional £50. If they have children and have to pay for childcare then it makes even more sense to forego the £50 and work 4 days a week.

I think the challenge with voters in the UK is an educational issue in that people like the sound bite aspirational political slogans of "yeah let's tax the rich at 90%!!". But none of them are interested / bothered in the detail of how this would actually work or the consequences of it.

I did say ‘obscenely high “wages”’, which was in reference to footballers ‘earning’ hundreds of thousands a week, not consultants/barristers etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread