Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that gut health will become a huge focus in the next decade?

133 replies

KenAdams · 14/09/2023 00:18

I'm seeing more and more people looking for ways to improve their gut health.

I have endo and going GF has been one of the most helpful things pain wise.

AIBU to think we're on the cusp of a gut health revolution here? Fingers crossed that it will drive companies to come up with better tasting GF food as well as some of it is dreadful!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
justasking111 · 17/09/2023 11:12

Following a bug food poisoning? Nine days later I'm still bloated, gassy, nauseous. Off to buy some actimel this morning.

LittleObe · 17/09/2023 11:08

It's already a big thing. Has been in news and magazines for about a decade now with serious studies and interest.

socialdilemmawhattodo · 16/09/2023 00:41

FatandRoundBouncingontheGround · 15/09/2023 07:01

Eating gluten and dairy free is important, IF you are coeliac or allergic to dairy.

Going GF and dairy free (and stylistically vegan, using meat substitutes, for that matter) if you are not, means you are likely to be eating even more in the way of highly processed "alternatives" packed full of emulsifiers, maltodextrin, gums etc. All of which are bad for the gut.

Our understanding of "healthy" food in this country has gone completely out of the window.

Eat real food, unless you have genuine allergies. Cook from scratch as much as possible. Eat a bit less. Don't sterilise every surface multiple times a day. There is especially not need for products like "antibacterial washing powder" unless, maybe, you work as a pathologist....

Mum - is that you! Get off the internet now please! (my mum is an 88 year old biologist who despairs of her children - 1x strict vegetarian for 40 years and the other a pescatarian who has been gluten-free for 5 years and is quite obsessed by this. Luckily Granny has a normal (in HHO) GC who eats everything!). Food nutrition is a big part of our conversations.

But yes when I look at her and my dad. Both lecturers in an FE college for decades - one taught biology and the other catering and Hotel management. Currently there is such little understanding of what healthy food is, or other health practices. The "processing" is awful. But also an understanding of what causes problems. My colleague has an appropriate food certificate for providing food to the public, yet cannot understand that if their child has an infectious bug they and their child need to not be in contact with others.

larlypops · 15/09/2023 21:23

Definitely my bowel condition I take tablets and probiotics for but still have issues with food but haven’t tried eliminating things yet.
Also so many take omprezole yet acid reflux is high risk for throat cancer

Panaa · 15/09/2023 21:17

100% - your gut is your second brain.

Yep, sometimes anti-depressants are prescribed for IBS!

Panaa · 15/09/2023 21:14

KimberleyClark · 15/09/2023 07:36

Apparently for optimum gut health it’s essential to eat as wide a variety of plant foods as possible including whole grains, nuts, seeds, pulses and fruit. The keto diet is really bad for your gut microbiome.

https://www.eatingwell.com/article/291999/why-you-should-never-try-the-keto-diet-according-to-a-gut-health-expert/

Keto worked amazingly for me...and I had tried all the gut healthy food out there. I was even buying the a loaf of fermented bread made with teff flour that was €25 a loaf. Loads of people swear by it but it didn't work for me even though every single ingredient in my diet was planned for optimal nutrition at the time.

Started keto (and dirty keto at that) and it fixed all the inflammation in my body which healed my gut.

For those who are suffering from chronic inflammation sometimes keto is the only thing that seems to work.

Panaa · 15/09/2023 21:09

@Delatron

It’s certainly not going to cause anyone any harm (like certain trendy diets) to eat more variety of plants, less ultra processed foods and more fermented foods.

Some groups do have to avoid fermented foods and they can harm them.
People with compromised immune systems, candida overgrowth, histamine intolerance and some kinds of digestive issues etc.

Delatron · 15/09/2023 21:01

Puffling235 · 15/09/2023 20:58

Agree OP. Gut health isn't a fad diet. Poor gut health really is the root of the declining health in the western world, including mental health. It's not just down to diet, but clearly that's a huge factor.

of course there will be people just jumping on the bandwagon that don't really know what they are talking about. I include Tim Spector in this. He probably believes what he says, but I honestly think he's massively behind the curve, pushes a vegan agenda (dreadful for good health) and I've just learned Zoe recommends rapeseed oil 🤦‍♀️

Seeds oils are literally poison to the human body, (excess of omega 6, not enough omega 3), hence the major decline in health since their introduction.

The latest 'fad' diet is carnivore/animal based. Look at Paul Saladino MD. However it actually makes a lot of sense, follows an ancestral diet (well raised meat/eggs/fruit/raw dairy/ raw honey). This guy hates vegetables 😂 (fermented are better of course). he is a little extreme. But I think the basics are there.

See also Weston A Price foundation, and Lily Nichols RDN. Dr Nemechek 's gut health protocol.

Although there are differences of opinion, for me, there is enough agreement on certain principles ( eliminating seed oils, reducing carbs, benefits of good olive oil, benefits of animal based foods, etc) to know it isn't just a fad. The vegan movement is not great for human health. But if done without seed oils then still better than a standard modern diet.

Agree with all this. Especially Tim and his vegan agenda.

I‘ve only just discovered how bad rapeseed and other veg oils are. They are literally in everything and very bad for gut health!

Puffling235 · 15/09/2023 20:58

Agree OP. Gut health isn't a fad diet. Poor gut health really is the root of the declining health in the western world, including mental health. It's not just down to diet, but clearly that's a huge factor.

of course there will be people just jumping on the bandwagon that don't really know what they are talking about. I include Tim Spector in this. He probably believes what he says, but I honestly think he's massively behind the curve, pushes a vegan agenda (dreadful for good health) and I've just learned Zoe recommends rapeseed oil 🤦‍♀️

Seeds oils are literally poison to the human body, (excess of omega 6, not enough omega 3), hence the major decline in health since their introduction.

The latest 'fad' diet is carnivore/animal based. Look at Paul Saladino MD. However it actually makes a lot of sense, follows an ancestral diet (well raised meat/eggs/fruit/raw dairy/ raw honey). This guy hates vegetables 😂 (fermented are better of course). he is a little extreme. But I think the basics are there.

See also Weston A Price foundation, and Lily Nichols RDN. Dr Nemechek 's gut health protocol.

Although there are differences of opinion, for me, there is enough agreement on certain principles ( eliminating seed oils, reducing carbs, benefits of good olive oil, benefits of animal based foods, etc) to know it isn't just a fad. The vegan movement is not great for human health. But if done without seed oils then still better than a standard modern diet.

thebellagio · 15/09/2023 17:54

@Notlaughingalot i can give you a referral code that makes if cheaper if that helps?

but really just focus on getting 30+ different plants into your diet every week

HalfSpoon · 15/09/2023 15:58

Wanderingllama · 15/09/2023 12:59

Kefir is deiving me crazy. I ferment veg, but failed at kefir. My friend excelled in kefir, failed at sauerkraut 😂

You don't need to do anything special.

Just buy Kefir from the shops and some milk. Remove a glass of milk from the milk you just bought, pour some of the kefir you just bought into the milk bottle - wait a day. You now have lots more Kefir!

It makes the kefir you buy much better value as milk is so inexpensive by comparison:

Notlaughingalot · 15/09/2023 15:54

I'd like to try the Zoe programme but it's too expensive.

Notlaughingalot · 15/09/2023 15:52

I've started cutting out all the ultra processed food that I can, and I've lost 4lb without doing anything.

I bought a bread maker to avoid shop bought bread, and I make wholemeal bread with added seeds.

For pasta I make my own with Einkorn flour, which is apparently better than modern wheat.

I cook from scratch, or DH does as we both like cooking

If I could just crack the wine habit...

SadnapTwapples · 15/09/2023 14:40

BingBongDingDong · 15/09/2023 06:32

This is depressing. All that good gut health needs is a really simple diet of simple whole foods and fermented food like whole grains, vegetables, fruit, nuts & seeds, beans & lentils, and things like simple kefir milk, kimchi etc.

Food manufacturers jumping on the bandwagon will do completely the opposite - flooding the market with highly ultra-processed "foods" with exciting labels claiming bacteria have been added to suck people into believing they're being healthy, when in fact they'll be eating a pile of utter crap, and the process of ultra-processing will in fact have rendered any added bacteria utterly useless.

Yes

Combusting · 15/09/2023 14:30

lljkk · 14/09/2023 20:55

Meh. All I hear in recent years about gut health and wellbeing is lots of speculation, speculative correlation & speculative mechanisms leading to speculative outcomes. Precious little proof about which actions lead to specific benefits, beyond the extreme situations (eg., people who need fecal transplants).

I find it hilarious every time I hear kefir talked about as superfood. It's obvious sugary junk food to me.

What the fuck? Where’s the sugar in natural kefir?! It’s made at home with milk and kefir grains or water and kefir grains. Or bought in its natural form from shop.

are you confused? Are you perhaps getting confused with flavoured/sugary kefir type drinks sold under various brand names? Are you confusing these with actual raw kefir ?

HundredMilesAnHour · 15/09/2023 14:07

Louise303 · 15/09/2023 01:15

We use symprove a probiotic liquid and find it great it may be a coincidence but my sons immunity is great.

I also take Symprove every morning and it's made a huge improvement to my immunity (which used to be poor despite a healthy diet). Amazing stuff! Symprove is one of the only two probiotics that GPs recommend (the other one being VSL# powder).

InBedByTen · 15/09/2023 14:00

Notpooryet · 15/09/2023 12:29

I wonder if cheap stuff ever ends up being better for you

Beans,, lentils and chickpeas tend to score high for everyone.

Wanderingllama · 15/09/2023 12:59

Kefir is deiving me crazy. I ferment veg, but failed at kefir. My friend excelled in kefir, failed at sauerkraut 😂

Doggydarling · 15/09/2023 12:53

Anyone buying kefir instead of making it themselves please be careful and check what you are buying. Some commercial produced kefir is not actually fermented in the tradional manner but has probiotics added artificially. It's incredibly easy to make at home, all you need is milk, kefir grains, a glass container and a fine sieve. Most people who make it are very happy to pass on grains to anyone interested in starting. By the way it's really good for dogs particularly if they're on medication, my dogs queue up for their daily dose.

KnittedCardi · 15/09/2023 12:52

It's been around for several years actually. Lots of the doctor/health type programmes were all over it as more research came out. Also see poo transfers for C Diff, and vaginal secretions for C Section babies. I think originally it came out of Israeli research.

Notpooryet · 15/09/2023 12:29

thebellagio · 14/09/2023 21:38

@Stupendousseptember with Zoe, they monitor your blood sugar over two weeks, take a blood sample and a stool sample so they can accurately assess how your body reacts to different foods, from the perspective of blood sugar, blood fat and gut micro biomes. So everyone’s results will be different.

to make it easy to understand, foods are given a score of between 0-100. The higher the score, the better they are for your specific body,

so taking fruit as an example, you would generally think any fruit is good if your trying to eat healthily. But for me, Avocado is a score of 100, passion fruit is a score of 93, strawberries and raspberries are 83, yet a banana is 47 and watermelon is 22- huge differences,

in terms of oil, I’d been using coconut oil thinking it was a healthy choice, but that gives me a score of 26 while xtra virgin olive oil is 92.

id swapped my rice for Cous Cous, but for my body, rice is a score of 5 (yikes!) and cous cous is 25. But bulger wheat is 71. So simply by swapping my grains, I’m making better choices.

I wonder if cheap stuff ever ends up being better for you

justasking111 · 15/09/2023 12:17

Wanderingllama · 15/09/2023 11:33

It's a money maker so might be hard to find independent studies imho.
I know 3 people with gastric surgery and each has aquired food intolerances, digestive issues, vitamins and minerals deficiencies etc. Things like now cannot eat tomato based food, no spicy food, and so on. Small sample, I know, but very much made me decide that diet was the way, not surgery. I love food and spices.

Not had gastric surgery but developed all those intolerances. Thanks menopause. Now the other side of that roller coaster can tolerate a little more if cooked. But chilli off the menu permanently.

Friend had gastric band. Vitamin deficiencies, hair loss which is common. BUT having a bad diet can cause those things too.

Our surgery do a lot more blood tests these days, more comprehensive too. Found my folate deficiency.

Wanderingllama · 15/09/2023 11:33

medianewbie · 15/09/2023 11:29

I'd be interested to know ow of there is yet any research on the long term effects of gastric surgery (including 'failed' surgery where the patient regains considerable amounts of weight). Imo GS is brutal for gut health.

It's a money maker so might be hard to find independent studies imho.
I know 3 people with gastric surgery and each has aquired food intolerances, digestive issues, vitamins and minerals deficiencies etc. Things like now cannot eat tomato based food, no spicy food, and so on. Small sample, I know, but very much made me decide that diet was the way, not surgery. I love food and spices.

medianewbie · 15/09/2023 11:29

I'd be interested to know ow of there is yet any research on the long term effects of gastric surgery (including 'failed' surgery where the patient regains considerable amounts of weight). Imo GS is brutal for gut health.

sleepwhenidie · 15/09/2023 11:07

OP you are right but I agree with PP that Tim Spector has conveniently turned this into a huge money making exercise.

This is a fantastic read for anyone interested in the subject - and provides no magic solution to buy. Some of the recommendations include things like regularly kissing your partner so it’s not just about diet!

Dark Matter: The New Science of the Microbiome https://amzn.eu/d/bWj1HbG