Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU over boyfriends birthday?

213 replies

didntgetagift · 13/09/2023 21:40

My boyfriend and I are together a year next month so this year was our first valentines and birthdays.

We returned from holiday early last week and his birthday was last Sunday. Prior to the holiday, he told me to save my money and wait until we were home and settled before buying any presents. Now I know I didn’t mishear him because he said it more than once.

He said that he expects me to spend a minimum of £200 on him because that was his budget and specifically requested an outdoor pop-up tent and JBL speaker equating to the budget.

Based on boyfriends advice, this would mean anything I order wouldn’t arrive on time for the Sunday.

I literally started a new job where I am paid monthly and after the holiday and paying other bills, I have £30 to do me until payday and my boyfriend is completely aware of this. Sunday came and he was incredibly disappointed there were no gifts (I did bring him to the beach and paid for dinner).

I would never expect him to take care of me financially but despite knowing how strapped I am until payday, he hasn’t offered to pay for anything and instead keeps making jokes about how poor I am. He even tried to give me £5 as a joke so I couldn’t say he ‘wasn’t a good boyfriend who didn’t get me anything’…

Here’s my issue. My birthday was in June and without sounding materialistic I was incredibly disappointed with my presents and know my boyfriend completely cheaped out yet set a minimum budget for his presents.

He bought me a pair of Crocs (in the wrong size), Yankee Candles (Christmas scents), and a reed diffuser. On top of this, we went for a meal tasting (8 courses) that was £80 per person (in total £160) and my boyfriend is including the total £160 toward the money he spent on me. Now, when I take anyone out for dinner, I only factor in their portion towards total cost and completely ignore my own because that’s money I spent on myself and not them. Isn’t this normal?

Before anyone presumes I went googling the prices… My boyfriend left the delivery slips in the bags (presents weren’t wrapped and they were handed to me in packaging they arrived in) and a lot of the items were heavily discounted compared to their normal retail price.

I know it’s not what a person spends but the thought that counts, but when I tally what my boyfriend spent it was roughly £130!

AIBU?

OP posts:
Americano75 · 14/09/2023 17:27

didntgetagift · 13/09/2023 22:32

I suppose this is the first time that I’ve seen my boyfriend in this light so I’m taken back and still processing what’s actually going on. I don’t want to confide in family or friends as I prefer to keep my relationship private and I don’t want them to be aware of my current financial situation either incase they try to offer anything.

He’s also my first adult relationship so I have nothing to compare it to.

Edited

I think you haven't confided in them because you know they'll tell you to bin him.

This isn't OK, you deserve better.

serendipitea · 14/09/2023 17:11

The attempt to account for his £80 dinner as a present to you is some serious CF-ery. How can you even consider staying with him after such mendacity?

pomers · 14/09/2023 16:34

Do not finance anything. He is mean, cheap and nasty. Get rid of him now

Rufusroo · 14/09/2023 15:26

Seriously this does not sound like a good relationship. He seems to be very selfish and immature. In my opinion his behaviour is likely to get worse if he is already acting like a petulant child when you have only been dating a year! I also think he is showing narcissistic behaviours and is gas-lighting you.

Please think very seriously before committing to him.

QueenBitch666 · 14/09/2023 14:01

pinkyredrose · 14/09/2023 12:35

I'd rethink your love language. Randomly sending people £5 is actually quite patronising, I'd be agog if someone did this to me.

Think about ways to show your appreciation while keeping your wallet shut. Have a think about how others show thier appreciation for you.

This. Sending money to people is cringe worthy and patronising

QueenBitch666 · 14/09/2023 14:00

Wrap up the cheap, thoughtless presents he gave you for your birthday, give them back to him with a huge FUCK OFF
And raise your standards, he saw you coming

HalfSpoon · 14/09/2023 13:31

I think you are already aware that he's a prick. Just dump him and move on. It's for the best, really.

MadCatLady27 · 14/09/2023 13:30

Even his presents to you don't sound great unless you're into those things? Feels very last minute and that not a lot of thought went into what comes across as very generic gifts

Unless agreed before hand no I wouldn't class a meal out as part of the present budget

I absolutely would not be going into debt to buy him such expensive gifts. At most he could have the tent OR the speaker

Whatthehell1977 · 14/09/2023 13:27

So if he expects £200 spent on him for his birthday, then goodness knows how much he expects you to spend on him for Christmas!
He's dictating to you! Either stand your ground or get rid, it will only get worse!!
He probably thinks he should be made a fuss of because it was his 30th! Doesn't give him the right to tell you what he expects!
Stop being too nice and a people pleaser (I mean this in the nicest of ways because I have been where you are and you only get taken advantage of, used and abused and dropped when you're no longer needed!!)
You're young, please don't start off accepting this sort of thing in relationships, you deserve so much better!
Tell him you expect him not to dictate how much you spend on him and that he should be grateful for whatever he receives and you will be doing so within your budget. Tell him you expect him to be more understanding about your current situation with regards to changing jobs. Bet he won't like hearing that!
I would use this time to have a bit of you time, process what's going on, wind down a bit after your holiday and see if you feel like you're looking forward to seeing him when the next time comes. You might be surprised!
As for the 'free fun' comment, I'm assuming he means sex? I'd tell him to eff off personally! Good luck! x

JANEY205 · 14/09/2023 13:24

Stop buying him stuff all the time and stop buying friends coffees etc. Sorry but I agree with a previous poster that whilst you think you’re being nice (you are) to others you will come off as easy to manipulate, which is what is happening here.

Spend your money on yourself! How often do these friends do things like this back for you? Your BF definitely didn’t care about your birthday that much or get you anything decent.

Start putting that care and money into yourself or saving it!

JANEY205 · 14/09/2023 13:19

Also, when we have been low on cash my partner and I adjust what we would like accordingly or forgo gifts and do a nice experience together.

This boyfriend is gross!! Really gross!

Mix56 · 14/09/2023 13:19

Yes, Please ditch this greedy Ass.
Imagine this down the line.... Don't waste your time.

chaosmaker · 14/09/2023 13:16

All the money stuff is such a turn off, hope he's a good shag as he has to have SOMETHING going for him.....

He's have been dumped as soon as he mentioned his expectations

JANEY205 · 14/09/2023 13:16

Dump him!! This has given me the major ick just reading it. I have NEVER been told by any of my boyfriends EVER what to buy them. Adults buy stuff for themselves if they want it, they don’t demand it as a gift. My husband and I now do low key birthdays and token gifts because if we need anything during the year we sort it out.

Major major ick of this guy! The gifts he got you are so so shit! Just tat really. £200 is absurd to demand off someone. The I got you this so you owe me this is also a major no no. It’s a really horrible character trait.

The bigger issue is he’s controlling about money, tells you what to do and is really mean and disrespectful to you. Dump him!! Buy yourself a nice bday gift as he definitely didn’t!

DO NOT BUY THE TENT FOR THIS LOSER! buy yourself a nice gift OP!

ToddlerSAHM · 14/09/2023 13:12

This sounds really unhealthy :( I’ve been with my boyfriend for 3 years and I can’t even imagine him saying that he expects me to spend £200 (or any amount) on his birthday gifts… l do ask what he wants (and usually get 1-2 things he ask for and then a few surprises) but if I can’t afford it then that would be fine and he’d just pick something else 🤷‍♀️

ChateauMargaux · 14/09/2023 13:09

I didn't read all of the replies but did read the Op's posts.

Someone else said: 'It's the thought that counts, not the £££££ signs.' .. when he thought about your birthday, he thought about a meal out for himself.. and a couple of pretty low thought presents. I suggest a spa day for 2 (wowcher or virgin experiences), a £30 pop up tent and the cheapest JBL speaker.

https://www.virginexperiencedays.co.uk/product/twos-company-spa-day-with-treatments-for-two-at-bannatyne-health-clubs

https://www.amazon.co.uk/RISEPRO-automatic-Lightweight-Waterproof-Protection/dp/B089SHJ7G5/ref=sr_1_5?c=ts&keywords=Pop-Up%2BTents&qid=1694691378&s=camping-hiking&sr=1-5&ts_id=3076651031&th=1

https://www.amazon.co.uk/JBL-GO-Wireless-Bluetooth-integrated-Black/dp/B08FB2H6Y4/ref=sr_1_3?crid=10TLPBS1RT2N6&keywords=speaker+jbl&qid=1694691429&sprefix=speaker+jbl%2Caps%2C103&sr=8-3

Or save yourself the effort and ditch him.. (Mumsnet standard response!)

His comment about 'free fun' sounds a little like well if you can't afford to buy me a present, I will accept payment in the form of sex, rather than 'we can have fun together without spending money'...

And while 6 years age difference is not much, it is a big difference in terms of the amount of time you have been earning and therefore your budgeting and discretionary speeding capacity.

Two's Company Spa Day with Treatments for Two at Bannatyne Health Clubs - Virgin Experience Days

If you're looking for gift ideas then Virgin Experience can offer a wide range of different kinds of gift experiences such as Two's Company Spa Day with Treatments for Two at Bannatyne Health Clubs

https://www.virginexperiencedays.co.uk/product/twos-company-spa-day-with-treatments-for-two-at-bannatyne-health-clubs

Humidititties · 14/09/2023 13:05

Aside from your boyfriend, why are sending £5 to friends to buy coffees?

Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 14/09/2023 13:04

This whole scenario is ridiculous on both sides

EllaBella41 · 14/09/2023 13:02

If he knows you havent got much money, just say "oh well we wi have to do something belated after" and leave it at that.

If he continues to behave like this, bin him and save yourself £200.

CharlieUniformNovemberTangoYankee · 14/09/2023 12:58

YABU for using the term 'love language' 🤮

Otherwise, hell no! Fuck him and his shitty presents and horrible demeaning attitude. Tell him to get to fuck and take his fucking crocs with him.

Next time, don't settle for less than somebody who treats you with respect.

MrsJellybee · 14/09/2023 12:54

Many men see altruism as a weakness. You think your gift-giving is a kindness. But it makes you weak in his eyes. He knows he can manipulate you and get what he wants. You will use your innate altruism one day, likely on your children. That is what it is for. You are a nurturer, a giver, a pleaser. Keep it for your kids. Never be this altruistic towards a man especially when dating as you will attract what you already have - an absolute loser.

You need to hold yourself back, and in your next relationship, let the man come to you. Stop trying to woo men! Don’t give him gifts unless it’s a birthday or Christmas. And only give what you can afford. If he buys you something outside of birthdays and Christmas say thank you, but do not immediately buy him something back. This isn’t quid pro quo. Let him make himself worthy of you. Stop giving gifts.

Dating is a game, and it’s a game that’s been played for centuries. Men have to have the agency initially for it to work. They have to like you and want you more than you like and want them. They have to do the leg work else they don’t value you. It might be sexist, it probably is. But it’s also psychology and biology. A man truly in love with you only wants you. He doesn’t care for trinkets and baubles, or how much you spend on him. You are not with that man. Throw this one back and find yourself a man worthy of you.

Timeforchangeplease · 14/09/2023 12:50

I'd avoid him permanently if I were you

WitcheryDivine · 14/09/2023 12:43

Can I tell you what my partner would say if I was broke and it was his birthday? "Don't get me anything love, I know you're strapped for cash. Wait til you start your new job and take me out for dinner then." He'd be over the moon if I spent a few quid on cake ingredients to make him a birthday cake.

That's what an adult relationship should look like - treating each other when you can, but not expecting a fixed expenditure (!!!!!!) at any time let alone when the other person is struggling.

He sounds like the sort of person who makes a big gesture in order to hold it over you later - those people are manipulative tossers.

He's not behaving well here honestly, he's not the one you want xx

Lotsofthings · 14/09/2023 12:42

If you dump him before his birthday that’s two problems solved.

Curseofthenation · 14/09/2023 12:42

Ergh. Up your standards OP. This man is awful. He's probably dating you because he knows your naive. Don't buy the bloody tent, put a fiver in an envelope.

Swipe left for the next trending thread